I have had meals at Seaville Pizza and everything has been excellent. The waitstaff are all so very nice and everything is just the way you ordered. read more

I ordered a wrap and fries on a Thursday night over the 4th of July weekend, so I completely understand that they were probably busier than usual and I'm willing to give some benefit of the doubt. However, I was told on the phone that my order would be ready in about 45 minutes. When I arrived 45 minutes later, I was told they hadn't even started making it because they were so backed up. I completely understand being busy, especially on a holiday weekend, but I would have much rather been given an accurate wait time from the beginning. I ended up waiting almost an hour and a half for a wrap and fries. Super disappointing experience, especially when the expectations could have easily been set differently over the phone. read more

Super gluten free options. There are hardly any gluten free places down shore and they can make most entrees gluten free which is great. Prices are fair for the shore and staff is great too. Huge fan and I recommend everyone go and support this family owned business. read more

Did you ever think a Pizza Joint served Breakfast? Well this is the place Good food, nice portions and a friendly server "Noah" read more

Seaville Pizza - Italian omelet with hash browns and rye toast - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

Most overpriced wings of all time. Literally. Almost $18 for an order of wings w tax. You can get them at the tavern across the street for $12 and just about every other place that sells them. I don't get it. Kinda shocking. They weren't bad. Just overpriced. read more

I'm giving this place four stars because of the impeccable cleanliness of the restaurant & the open kitchen. There were a lot of people in there, ordering food and sitting down at tables, so the other things on the menu must be decent; however we ordered the Chicago style pizza that somebody on yelp said was good and it was basic at best. You can get a better one at Domino's and I am a pizza critic. The dough wasn't great. It definitely tasted like tomato paste versus marinara sauce and the cheese seemed cheap. It did not stretch at all. We would not get that again. The Caesar salad was fresh with homemade croutons. That was good. I would get that again. We definitely will try them for our regular circle pizza in the future. I thought about giving three stars because I really didn't think that Chicago Pizza was great, but I'm gonna be nice. On the off-season you can't find anything open on the island so we are strategically trying all the places outside of Sea Isle & Avalon for take out. read more

Seaville Pizza - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

See all

Service and Food was quality top notch, hidden gem. Dont miss out they also serve breakfast,lunch and dinners! read more

Seaville Pizza - Bacon Blue Burger - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

I had a Plain slice. It was delicious. I'm picky since I used to work at a pizzeria! Looking forward to trying something else

I went with my two cousins and Aunt we had a wonderful family meal. The food was absolutely fantastic and the service even better. I had the taco special and they were terrific. The other meals and the soup were all great and the salad A+. Prices were good and the staff is really friendly. Nice clean atmosphere and newly renovated. Will definitely go there again. read more

Seaville Pizza - Salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

See all

There are so many things to like at Seaville Pizza from the atmosphere to the food. Some of our favorites are the Traditional Pizza and the breakfast offerings. Seating is plentiful. The restaurant is very clean. The waitstaff is excellent. Home delivery is always quick and correct. We love it here. read more

We had breakfast at Seaville Pizza. Everything was delicious. The eggs were perfectly cooked. The service was outstanding. So glad to have a great place to eat cloaked to home. read more

Seaville Pizza - Eggs over easy with Scrapple - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

See all

The food was delicious. Our waitress was able to recommend items that were to our liking. It has booths as well as tables to accommodate different sized gatherings. Plenty of parking and also offers take out. read more

Dominic was the best server I have ever had in my life very attentive and the food was very good. buffalo chicken egg rolls were amazing.

So good this is now our regular spot!!!! It was wonderful and Awesome food at a great price read more

See all

food was very good and everything was fresh! Atmosphere was ok. lighting was too bright.

Decided to try dinning inside of seaville pizza, the food was mid at best and the staffs staring killed the vibe

This place is unbelievable, everything is outstanding! The place is clean friendly and delicious! The chef is unbelievable and if he was not married and I was not married I would marry him him for his talent! Nice people and ditch your pizzeria and go here. If you are headed to the shore,order and get on the garden State parkway and have a delicious meal when you arrive !I do not review often only the best or worse. These people are the best!! read more

Ordered a hoagie tray and everything was fresh and very good. They normally cut the hoagies four times but I wanted them cut into three's. Did go into business to order. I will be ordering from this establishment again. Very friendly and they were very accommodating. read more

Been there about 5 or 6 times including a few deliveries. Pizza's good. Haven't tried other foods yet. They make one of the best burgers in town. Then need to get a web site that you can order on line. I actually order from another pizza shop down the road because it's easier. read more

I kept hearing about the new "restaurant" that opened in the Acme shopping center. I saw on FB that they opened as well. (Located where Mama Mia's used to be) I thought that it was just a typical pizza takeout so I didn't go in. They opened in October, 2024 and I just went in last week for the first time. My loss of great food for 4 months. Upon walking in, it was bright, clean and open. We sat down at a booth and the waiter greeted us. Very friendly. My daughter ordered breakfast (they serve it all day) and I ordered a Chicago style pizza. Pictures attached! The menu was large with offerings for breakfast and lunch and they also had a dinner menu. This is a BYOB as well. The only thing that I would say as a negative was the wait time once the order was placed. In their defense, there were several other tables there as well. And we didn't mind. Once the food arrived, it was well worth the wait. My pizza was one of the best I have ever had. The crunch of the crust and quality of the cheese and sauce were top notch. My daughter had the western omelet with hash browns, that she requested to be well done, and toast. The serving size was enough to pack it up for breakfast the next morning. I would highly suggest trying Seaville Pizza. Just give yourself enough time and enjoy. read more

Seaville Pizza - Chicago style pizza half plain and half pepperoni. Medium size. - Sandwiches Near Me - Ocean View, New Jersey

See all

They did a great job with the place. Pizza n knots were good. Love that you can also get breakfast - like a nice little pizza diner. Look forward to trying taco Tuesday. read more

Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza period! Large Fresh salads! Welcome home.... Great specials throughout the week

We had Prosciutto Pizza and a side of Meatballs Every thing was delicious. Has delivery service Will definitely order from them again Thank you for a delicious meal read more

Their grandma pizza was the worst pizza I have ever eaten. It was like tomato paste on top of dough.

It's great to have a restaurant back in the spot of the original Mamma Mia's in the ACME parking lot. After trying it several times, it has definitely become a family favorite. The Miguel's Popular Pizza is our favorite pizza yet. The breakfasts are delicious and plentiful, especially the cream chipped beef on toast. Service has been great each time we have gone. Definitely a must try. read more

Went last night for dinner. As soon as we got there we were told no pizza or anything that cooks in the oven. This is the norm lately from the reviews. Not a good way to start a business. Got hoagie and the wives got dinners which they said were good. Hoagie were good but not enough meat.plenty of lettuce on roll. Place is very nice inside but very disappointed with the fact we couldn't get a pizza.Edit...we went today and got a pizza at 4:00.It was good. Price is good and really enjoyed it. Still wish we could've got one last night. I guess when the newness wears off. We can get one for dinner. read more