Cancel

Open app

Search

Scrappy's Pizza

3.7 (125 reviews)
Closed • Closed
Updated a few days ago

Order Scrappy's Pizza Takeout or Delivery

Scrappy's Pizza Photos

Business Info

SCRAPPY'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Outdoor seating
Dogs allowed
Happy hour specials

You might also consider

More like Scrappy's Pizza

Recommended Reviews - Scrappy's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

So good I ate it before the picture

Best food / pizza I have had in Colorado. Super affordable and the sweet Thai chili wings were the best wings I have had in my life. We also ate the fried ravioli, pizza by the slice and the margarita pizza and everything was phenomenal! You better come here !

Scooby Doo themed with games for kids
Sarah L.

Scrappy's was yummy pizza with superior service! The staff went above and beyond to take care of us! They have games in the dinning area for kids if they still have energy after skiing all day! The Margaritaville pizza was the family favorite!

Cindy L.

Scrappy wasn't here today but I did get to meet Helen. I would of loved to have given this place a five but it barely gets three. Really sad because I did love Helen and the place is cute. Pizza wasn't cooked very well, toppings were poor, hardly any sauce and it wasn't cut, argh! YOU ALL NEED TO KICK IT UP A NOTCH!

BBQ chicken 14" pizza
Carly B.

Great service! Friendly staff, and checked in on us several times. The small Italian chop salad was yummy, and big enough to share. We also really enjoyed the BBQ chicken pizza. 14" can feed 3-4 depending on hunger level. Crust was just right thickness and plenty of toppings. Great meal before our concert at the amphitheater!

Inside
Joe R.

Ordered the gluten free cauliflower pizza with pepperoni. I thought there could have been more topping on it. Crust was good but the rest was kinda limp. Also ordered the house salad which comes already made up with tomatoes, iceberg lettuce, and croutons. There are fountain sodas and bottles to choose from. Inside and outside dining is available. Staff is friendly and helpful.

Clare C.

Came here for pizza on a Monday night around 6 pm. Lots of room in the parking lot and many open tables. The lady behind the counter was friendly and welcoming. We ordered a small bbq cheese pizza for ~$27. The pizza was pretty big and average. Not the worst pizza but not my favorite. I thought it was a little expensive and wish the pizzas came in different sizes. I probably should've just ordered slices individually. The pizza was very filling.

BBQ Chicken!!!

See all

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Best pizza in summit county. I've been waiting years for this. Super amazing New York style pizza. Reminds me of home

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

great pizza and great service!! love it, have been going there for 7 years straight on our ski trips

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 4 of 4

Ask the Community - Scrappy's Pizza

You might also consider

Cheba Hut Toasted Subs

Cheba Hut Toasted Subs

4.2(238 reviews)
0.8 mi
•$$
Kitchen open late
Full bar

Searching for a place to watch MMA fights from The White House, I failed in two (2) other joints…read more One recommended the last place I'd have looked, a sandwich shop/ head store for ski bums. One TV over the bar delivered, but so did the delightfully engaging bartenders. Colby is the best. Great bar service made excellent suggestions from the menu (ask for the "secret " menu). Toasted sandwich was a fantastic combination of flavors and texture. One really cannot go wrong, but I recommend anything with the fresh jalapeños in au jus.

We were traveling through Silverthorne and decided to stop at Cheba Hut while passing through…read more Overall, it was a good experience, but there were a few things that kept it from being a 5-star visit. We ordered the White Widow, Kali Mist, Garlic Cheese Bread, and the Bowl O' Balls for the little ones. The Kali Mist was easily our favorite great flavor and we'd absolutely order it again. The White Widow was good, just not as memorable. The garlic cheese bread was a solid side, and the Bowl O' Balls was perfect for the kids. The pricing was very reasonable. We spent around $54 for everything, and for the quality and portion sizes, it felt fair. We liked that they offer 4", 8", and 12" sandwiches, and the 8-inch subs were a great value. The drink selection was also nice, although the ice machine wasn't producing ice during our visit. The reason for 4 stars really comes down to the customer service. Noah was friendly and helped us choose between a couple of sandwiches when we asked for his opinion, which we appreciated. However, the experience lacked the hospitality and attention to detail that turns a good visit into a great one. After paying, there was no offer of a receipt I actually had to go back and ask for one. When our food was brought out to go, the bag was accidentally dropped into my arms and almost hit the ground. There wasn't any follow-up afterward no "Here's your order," "Enjoy your meal," or "Can I get you anything else?" We also didn't realize until we got back to the Hilton that there were no napkins or condiments included with our order, even though we tipped 18%. The restaurant has a fun, unique atmosphere, but the dining area could have been cleaner. The trash bins were overflowing, and while there was a steady flow of customers, it didn't seem overly busy or like they were in the middle of a rush. It felt like there was enough downtime to stay on top of basic housekeeping. Overall, the food was good, the prices were fair, and we'd stop by again if we're ever back in Silverthorne. I think the biggest opportunity for improvement is simply customer service and hospitality small things like offering a receipt, checking that the order is complete, including napkins and condiments, and ending the interaction with a friendly send-off would go a long way. Those little details are what turn a good meal into a great customer experience.

Photos
Cheba Hut Toasted Subs
Cheba Hut Toasted Subs
Cheba Hut Toasted Subs

See all

Which Wich - Chicken salad

Which Wich

2.9(106 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$

Stopped in today and got a chicken salad sub. Chicken salad is generous and fresh. The bread is…read moresoft. Toppings were fresh as well. Service was good and quick. Place is clean and bright. What more do you want besides maybe some chips &a soda

Which Wich? Not this one…read more I walk in, look around -- no employees. One other customer looks lost, he waits, then walks away. I ask what size the regular sandwich is, the teen answers 10" -- it was 6" for $10. I ask if mayo would be good on my sandwich, the employee mumbles, "I don't know I haven't had it." I end up telling him I don't want mayo. Fast forward 30 minutes and a lot of awkward silence with the two boys scampering around the back, there was mayo on the sandwich. Half way through the preparation of my sandwich a boy walks in (there was only one present up to this point). The teenage boy coughs into his armpit and then proceeds to put on gloves, at no point did he wash his hands. What makes this worse is the first boy hands my sandwich off to the second. I am not sure what the first had been doing up that point because it took another ~15 minutes for it to be done, keep in mind it was a turkey sandwich, nothing special. My family went to Chipotle, ordered for five at the same time I entered Which Wich and finished their food before I had received my one sandwich. It also smelled horribly. And was dirty. And above all, no greeting, no apology, and no explanation. I'm not the first to say this but GO TO THE CHIPOTLE NEXT DOOR INSTEAD! Horrible experience, worse service thanks to complete lack of competence of the employees and lack or manager or supervision. If I had a restaurant and wanted to put it out of business I wouldn't change a thing.

Photos
Which Wich
Which Wich
Which Wich - A worker making my sandwich

See all

A worker making my sandwich

Scrappy's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...