I saw the great reviews of this place. We were starving. It was open late after a day at the Pines…read moreon a Tuesday. It was close to the train. It's a classic bar/pub with that smell of cigarettes and buck heads on the wall. Surprisingly great food! The wings were tender and crunchy on the outside. The burger was messy. More like a smash burger. But the fries - I think they may have been my favorite fries in a long time? Somewhat like steak fries but fresh/right out of the frier. So so so good.

Sayville Athletic Club is a dive bar pure and simple. The caveat is the terrific food they pump…read moreout of the kitchen and great selection of local beers. My two go to faves are the Philly cheese steak and wings. They are known for the brisket and other bbq'd meats. The bartenders here are friendly and welcoming. They are attentive and know how to serve a customer. The SAC, as it's known, has a sports pub feel to it, lots of TV's and sports pics. It's a great place to catch a game with friends, family or just bellying up by yourself. I use the SAC for home parties and other events both at the SAC and my house. The owner Dave is great and really knows the business.

Sal is THE MAN, first of all, all I ask is we lose the sweater vest, coming here and seeing the…read morebartender is a sweater vest and button makes him seem older than I would guess he is... let the bartender dress himself he shows his skill level in personality and performance and he's a good one! Regardless, love this place and happy I get to frequent! Def recommend for the good dive bar feel and vide variety of beer, take a look at their sponsors on the ceiling (sick) and let me tell you, the tequila mule he mixes up for me is phenomenal every time!!!

Great little spot for a beer and fun but warm atmosphere. "Where everybody knows your name.."…read moreshould be the theme song!

amazing bartenders, amazing drinks, amazing atmosphere. The DJ on Saturday nights is great with a…read morewide range of all music, and the vibe is just an overall good time

From the owner: Your new favorite sports bar in West Sayville :) Come enjoy…read moreour laid back casual atmosphere with great drinks and small bites. We have 8 tvs to watch any game, quick draw and darts

Color me impressed! From the outside and the location pulling in, I didn't quite know what to…read moreexpect but they exceeded all expectations. The lot was very full on this Football Sunday and we were sat right away. Our server was nice enough and took good care of us. We had to try the wings after seeing some pics and they were fantastic. Piping hot and crispy without asking. Garlic parm and awesome flavor. Meaty too. For my meal I had the Grilled Chicken Caesar wrap and it was massive and delicious. More of a macro selection for craft beer but I found a local IPA to enjoy with my meal. The GM or owner, Chuck came over to check on us too. Nice guy! I'll be back sooner than later.

Jenn and Sarah are so nice! My friends and I went in for some food and drinks. Food is very good…read moreand even better service. Jenn was so fun and made us feel super welcome. 10/10 recommend

Great friendly service, welcomed at the door. Asked where we would like to sit. That's a great…read moreoption to allow the patron to sit where they are most comfortable. MJ and I started off with Bloody Mary's, Delicious! We opted for appetizers. We enjoyed mozzarella sticks, spinach and artichoke dip, and Irish Dream Rolls. Everything cooked perfectly.

This place would get a 3.5, but I'm rounding down for reasons I will say in the review…read more I started off by seeing this place by searching for fish and chips. Seeing they had a Wednesday special, I decided to put off my adventure from Roslyn to Ronkonkoma from Monday to Wednesday. I also found a bunch of things I was interested in to pad my experience and make the drive worth it. The waitress came quickly, got our drink orders, took a few minutes, and we started our order. I started off by getting the Fire Island Fries, the Flanagan's Nachos minus Jalapenos and Chipotle Ranch, sub the chicken in, the Fish and Chips special with additional pay for French Onion Soup and Curry sauce, and my friend got the Penne Alla Vodka add chicken. I asked how the Mozzarella sticks were and she said they were very popular so I got those as well. We'll start with my addition. The mozzarella sticks are good. Fried properly, not raw, not burnt, you get I believe 9 in an order. I greatly enjoyed them, however I would never pay more than a buck for a small brick of cheese. They were great, but not that great. The nachos were very barebones, something getting them at full capacity wouldn't have done much for. The queso is gross, and put me off from eating too much. The avocado was a single, sliced avocado which is fine, but pretty hard to eat with chips. The chicken was a bit of an issue, not tasting great. The fire island fries were good, I enjoyed the flavor change, but I feel like some cheddar would have made them from "good" to "amazing". Adding cheddar to my leftovers later confirmed that. The french onion soup was the shiniest turd I've had the experience of eating. It is the best of the worst, in every way. The cheese tastes a bit off, the broth did't have much flavor or salt, the onions were sour, and overall it looks tremendous, proper quality, but tasted like I was eating expired progresso with some sour cheese melted over it. I love proper French Onion soup, but this was very difficult to force myself to eat. The penne alla vodka was fine, but they could have added more salt, it just felt a little bland. The chicken was hard and dry. It didn't work with the dish itself, it felt like eating two different things at once, neither of them tasting as good as they should. The fish and chips were the real star. The fish was as crunchy as you expect, the chips were proper chips. The curry was hot but delicious, everything was absolutely fantastic. If I was reviewing on the fish and chips alone, this place would absolutely get five dtars. But they need to work on the other areas of their menu, they're heavily dragging this place down. I also got the donut with ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce. A donut from dunkin would have been better in my opinion, and you would save $10 assembling everything yourself. Finally, the service. It was very here and there. At first, we were getting checked up on often, but at the end, there was a good 20 minute stint where they wouldn't show up at our table and we had to flag them over to get our check. I'm not rating this against them, but I would have liked a little more observation. It was a one and done place, with excellent fish and chips this side of the pond. If I was closer, this would be a Wednesday night thing, but I'm too far to justify that.

Cute little Irish pub. It's a stand alone building with plenty of on site parking. It was very…read morequiet around lunch time. The bartender was our server, we were seated immediately and took our drink orders upon seating. Our food came out pretty quickly and was delicious. I got the chicken noodle soup (tastes like grams used to make!) and the oh hell-thy wrap. So good! Def recommend

Came here today on St Patrick's Day. My friend got there at 6:30pm and was not acknowledged by the…read morehost. There was a person waiting also before her and told my friend that she was waiting for a while. When the host grabbed the other person for their table, the host didn't say anything to us. We stood there for another 20 minutes without being acknowledged by the host. At 6:55pm, I stopped a waitress and asked if we could get a table that was emptied and cleared off. She said she would grab the host, and the host never came but dropped off beer at the table right next to us and just stared at my group of 4. It's St. Patrick's Day- have more staff working for this holiday since you're an Irish pub and acknowledge your customers. We would have been more patient if she acknowledged our existence. Found it extremely rude!

We love our Cavanaugh's! This place still hits. We went with the fam on a busy Sunday because it's…read more2 for 1 wings during football season. We ask for them to be extra crispy and they hit like they do every time. We also get them mild because the sauce is also that good. It doesn't need the heat. My moon burger was a work of art and after all those wing, I had to take most home. It's ok because my burger made for a great dinner. It's a real local spot with a bunch regulars there. It's a place where everyone knows your name and I hope it stays for many years to come.

First time visiting this local Irish pub. Immediately on entering, I knew the ambiance was…read moresomething special. Every inch of the walls are covered in history, developing over years of service and customer loyalty. Service was great with a kind and attentive staff. The food was very good! I enjoyed the mini tacos appetizer. My entree, while more of a roast beef sandwich than a proper Philly Cheesesteak, was quite tasty. The big standout, however, was the incredible Bailey's Cheesecake for dessert. Super tasty, highly recommend!

This is the sport bar for the those looking for a cold drink and tasty bites. There are TVs…read moreeverywhere so you will always have a good view and the decor is so cute! Everywhere you look there something interesting. Pro tip! If you're looking for a more relaxed vibe, I went around 10pm post dinner drinks

Smash burger was better than a typical bar burger but with smash burger just down the block, I have…read moreto say smashburger is better. Surprisingly the pasta was really good. I do have to ask for sauce on the side because my pasta didn't come with extra sauce for the garlic bread. I ordered the pasta with crispy chicken and the chicken was whatever. But the pasta sauce and the garlic bread was solid!

My friend, and bestest friend at that because I wouldn't do this for just anyone, asked me to do a…read morecookie decorating class. So here I am at the back of Jameson's. Which is a super cute, rustic bar with a great space in the back for hosting. For a Wednesday it was pretty rowdy. And for where it is, off Old Willets, well I hadn't been down there in forever and not much has changed except this cool spot. Or maybe it's been here for forever and I didn't know. Either way, because of this cookie class, I now know of it and wanna try having dinner here soon. Shirley temples and Mozz sticks were had while we decorated cookies. It's was a fun time in a great atmosphere even if it was a tad loud.

Very lively and loud place great place to socialize and hangout. Lots of TVs places decorated…read morenicely. The food was just ok. Had a side salad great dressing and plenty of veggies on salad. The waiter was very friendly. But service and drink refills slow. The steak sandwich was way to dry for my taste and way too much garlicky taste if there is such a thing Maybe some sinus or medium on steak might would have made it better. Will try a different meal next time

Joey is such a cool bartender and always has something going on at the bar during his shifts..from…read moreopen mic to karaoke.Beers are cold and the glasses are always clean.Stol in and say hi to my buddy!

So let me tell you about "Someplace Else". This is a bar that accepts credit cards as payment and…read morehad it's own parking lot located in the rear. As you enter, you'll notice that the bar is positioned in the right side of the entrance. They have no beers on tap, but they have plenty of bottled beer, canned beer, hard liquors, and wine in stock. They also have a limited selection of food to pick from, such as Chips, Personal Pizza, Burrito, Corn Dogs, BBQ Rib or Chicken Sandwich, and a Grilled Chicken Sandwich. They offer an ATM, Arcade Game such as Cards, Dart Board, Happy Hour, Multiple TV's, Pool Table, and Touchtunes, with separate restrooms for men and women. There's even a backyard with tables, for those who like to smoke. This place has a fun atmosphere about it and is worth checking out. Thanks to Angela, who was The Bartender today.