Sciulli's is a classic Pittsburgh pizza shop. As a Pittsburgh local for all of my life, I sincerely believe that this was one of the best pizza places I have ever been to. However, it also caters to my personal preferences for pizza, a thick crust, and plenty of cheese. I got a mini personal cheese, made on the spot, and it was great. What really made me write about this place was the atmosphere though. This place had every bit of the warm Pittsburgh nostalgia and spirit that makes me feel at home, and I was sad to leave. Hope to come by again! read more

This is my go to spot for tasty pizza and subs when in Oakland. Very fresh and they deliver!

Great pizza and even better staff!!! Everyone is always super friendly and welcoming!!!! Best pizza in Oakland

consistently good food. I recently tried the chicken parm meal and loved it. I also get the half sub combo often. but there is no better bank for your buck than the $8 cheesy bread. easily enough for 2 people. read more

I ordered an online order @ 10:30am for our office lunch to be delivered at 12:00pm. I called the establishment at 12:15pm and was told my order was out for delivery, my office is one block from the pizza shop. I called again at 12:30pm because now everyone's lunchtime is over. This time I am told it would be another 15 min. I said I did not want to pay for these because lunch is over by then. She put on the manager, Tim who stated you will either pay for these pizza's and I will give you a discount or cancel your order, I then asked for his name and he got very angry and said you do not need that, this order is canceled and then hung up on me. Not only did I order well in advance, but I also paid by card AND gave a 20% tip, when they also charge for delivery. I called back to ask when my payment was going to be refunded since it was already taken out of my checking, I was told 24 - 48 hrs, so I told them I would be done for the cash today. About an hour later I got a call from the pizza shop that they will not give me the cash and I would have to wait the 24 - 48 hrs. Do not patronize this establishment they have very poor management. read more

Sorry but not good at all. Way thick heavy crust. Not light and there's not enough sauce to make it work. I hate giving bad reviews but there's so much better square slices in town don't do this one. read more

Best hospitality and service maybe anywhere in Pittsburgh. Without a doubt, this is Oakland's "hidden" gem!

Sicilian pizza was cold and picked up prior to time given and cheese was not even melted. I told them no black olives in the salad and the salad had black olives. Chicken Parmesan was good. read more

We decided to eat medium pepperoni pizza and 6 garlic parm wings. Both were delicious. The service was polite and very accommodating. I didn't realize at first there are 2 rooms for your dining needs. Many options to accommodate a group of different palates -- salads, hoagies, pizza, pizza rolls, wings, etc.. You cannot beat fresh made dough.. so good and we love the sauce- very hint of sweet.. fantastic!! Hope to find my way back here in the future!! read more

Sciulli's Pizza - 8 cut pepperoni pizza.. yum - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Sciullis never disappoints. When in the 'Burgh, you owe it to yourself to experience great food, great family friendly atmosphere and a great staff to make sure everything is just right! read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Today's luncheon special. - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

The food was okay. I read other reviews saying the pizza and pepperoni roll and in my opinion it's just okay. I probably won't order from again but it's okay for the price. read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Pepperoni Roll - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizza was great and service was even better. Friendly and quick!!! Plus prices were fair.

Amazing food and service! We were visiting the area and found this little local place. The Sicilian pizza, hot sausage sub, and Turner iced tea were spot on! read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Old school place! - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Been coming here for years. An Oakland staple. Legendary for their incredible pizza and hoagies. Affordable. Love the sauce on the pie. Super tasty. Italian hoagies are old school yum. Take away right now during pandemic and they're doing a stellar job with safety. read more

I checked this joint out after watching number 1 pizza in Pittsburgh although it wasn't number 1they were still said to have great pizza I'm sorry to say I was very disappointed the only thing good about the pizza is the cheese the hoagies are very dry and the wings severely undercooked the are indeed of new chefs the people and service was superb read more

Kind service, great sauce, the crust was amazing!! Other local patrons were easy to talk with and gave it the added family atmosphere

Great pizza join in Pittsburgh that my family had while we were in town. I love Pittsburgh and I love pizza so this is a win win for me. We got a large pizza and a few drinks and it was excellent. This is a must try read more

See all

My husband and I were in town visiting and based on Yelp we decided to give Sciulli's a try. Thanks Yelpers!! You've done it again! The staff was friendly, the pizza was tasty and the ingredients tasted sooooooo freaking fresh people!!!!!! Give them a try, you won't be disappointed. We got a junior pizza, 1/2 sausage & meatball, 1/2 pepperoni & green peppers. Needless to say, it looked so good we started eating before I remembered to take the pic. read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Junior 1/2 sausage & meatballs, 1/2 pepperoni & green peppers - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Very nice, both taste and service. It's the best pizza restaurant in Pittsburgh I would say. read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Decent pizza. Quick and friendly service. Convenient location. Crust was just a little too thick and crumbly. It may just be that Sicilian pizza is not my cup of tea. read more

A little removed from the Pitt Campus but worth the trip! Lots of seating and take-out available. Craft beer and many excellent choices for pizza, hoagies and sides. Lunchtime specials gets you lots of food for less than $10. Best pizza in Oakland! read more

Best pizza in the burg clean area lots of space excellent service staff is friendly prompt service I been coming to this place since for about 30 years and it's still good everything good as hell good work fellas read more

I love this place! I have tried various pizzas, the Italian sub and today the pepperoni roll! All have been excellent! The pepperoni roll really surprised me how large it was! I think it's the dough for an entire small pizza! Cannot beat the service either! Everyone there has been great! If you are looking for a good pizza shop, good service and good prices, no need to look any further than right here! read more

This is THEE BEST pizza, hoagie, salad, fries and chicken spot there is!!! I don't drink beer but they sell beer now too and finally after all these years they take card! I don't know when they started taking cards but I LOVE IT! Me and my gram (RIP) have been coming here for years and the quality has not changed and the prices haven't too much! I live close to them and it sucks they don't deliver to my house but I will catch the bus in a heart beat to enjoy pizza night! No place comes close. They recognize my voice- know what I want and are so kind and on point with their food they should have more awards than they already do! Fresh veggies! Perfect sauces! AND THEY SELL BARQS ROOTBEER I love this place and I hope they never close! My name is Ash and I recommend the Family Special Large 1 topping, whole hoagie and 2 liter for under $25!! A steak salad with fries is like $9. They put boiled eggs in their salad, I never liked boiled eggs before but I do now. In my salad! Keep up the AMAZING work Sciulli Pizza read more

Best Pizza in Oakland!!! I cannot stress this enough!! The real deal!! Great guys!! Old school vibes!!! Must try!!!

I went to pitt years ago and I loved this spot I have to be honest I checked it out recently and the food is shitty still showing love but these guys can't cook for shit I mean I probably never order a Sicilian pizza again fell off that bad I don't know what happened but it's not the same read more

Had them deliver to a job site I was on, got 5 large pizzas for all the workers. Pizza was great!

Pizza crust was good and fluffy. The sauce was pretty sweet but not to my liking and there was way too much cheese compared to crust. Pickup time was very good at 20-25 minutes - overall 6.5/10 read more

Feels like the neighborhood pizzeria it is. Excellent homey vibe. Honest spot on recommendations. Absolutely cannot beat the value with fresh ingredients perfect crispy crust (I ordered the regular thin but they have 2 other crust options) nice sauce flavor and volume and good quality cheese. No greasy or soggy pizza here! Portions are amazing. The 4 slice option was more than enough for 1 person. I ordered a salad to go with chicken and it was huge. I really like that each pizza is your own creation. There are no set pizza combinations. Eating here for the first time feels like I've been coming here for years. The environment is friendly relaxed and small town neighborhood chic. Just go. I can't imagine anyone not having a great experience and great food at the absolutely best value I have experienced anywhere in the country. Hands down. Think I'm exaggerating? I travel across the country every week and have been for 10 years. That's how serious I am about my recommendations. read more

Sciulli's Pizza - 4 piece pizza option mushrooms spinach onion pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Came in for a quick lunch (by myself) during a recent weekday. The service was prompt after placing my order at the counter. They have a few very reasonably priced lunch specials...I oped for the personal pepperoni pizza and a can of pop, but I also ordered a side salad. The side salad came out first. It was huge with decent ranch dressing. covering the lettuce and veggies. Then the pizza came out. Unfortunately for me, it had a fairly sweet tomato-based sauce and that is just not my style (I prefer a more tangy, vinegary-based sauce). The crust was cooked just right, but the sauce just did not do it for me. This spot is incredibly convenient if you are across the street at UPMC Presbyterian / Montefiore so if you want a low-cost meal option close by...just remember to bring your wallet as they only take cash, no credit cards. read more

See all

Ordered the Italian hoagie and pan Sicilian pizza. The pizza was great. But the hoagie was a bit disappointing. High quality meats and bread were ruined when for some reason they put mayonnaise on an Italian hoagie. Why I have no idea read more

Have been going here for years and missed a few when I was traveling for work. But back in Oakland for past couple of years and Sciulli's is my go-to for pizza for myself, family and to treat my work peeps, I think COVID may have lessened the amount of cheese, but happily pay for extra. Authentic, not stamped out and delicious! Friday special was a large 2 topping with free decadent breadsticks. Yummmmmmm, extra cheese and mushrooms for a take home dinner that was a great Friday Lenten meal and welcome change from fish. The rest goes into the freezer for another dinner. Thanks, Sciulli's!! read more

A very slim slice of a pizza shop! Friendly staff who had many regulars. A slice of pizza was not my favorite. The crust was much more crumbly vs bread like I'm used to in a Sicilian slice. The sauce and cheese were tasty though. The iced tea was very sweet, too sweet for me. Maybe a next visit, we will try a chicken parm read more

See all

Best Sicilian pizza ever! Crust has the perfect balance of crunch and pillowy softness. Sauce is a perfect balance of salty and sweet. Make this a must stop when you are in the area! read more

Food was excellent and staff very friendly. We would come more often if we lived closer!

The staff is super friendly and helpful. The interior of the restaurant is amazing: a step back in time that I wouldn't change at all. The pizza is strong: doughy crust but still light, good sauce, right amount of cheese. Love it!! read more

Was in Pittsburgh to visit my son and really wanted some pizza. He had never tried this place, but it's close to his house and he had heard it was good. IT WAS SO GOOD!!! He's mad he hadn't tried it before because he's leaving Pittsburgh in a week. So delicious!!! read more

Our silician pizza was huge. Meat lovers was packed with meat and so good. I recommend the pepperoni roll for sure. So soft and savory with garlic butter in top. Just visiting bbit if I lived close I'd be back for sure. read more

Sciulli's Pizza - Pepperoni roll - Pizza Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Came in from Florida for a short two day work trip, asked the gentlemen at the hotel desk where we could get some good pizza and he recommended Sciulli's. We took a very short walk from the hotel and located this little gem of a hole in the wall, we asked them how their pizza was and they stated "good enough to stay in business for over 40 years. My travel partner and I both ordered a medium pie and to sat it was amazing would be an understatement (we considered eating there every day before we left). The staff was awesome and very friendly, and did I mention the pizza was absolutely amazing! I highly recommend this place and will more than likely go back tomorrow night! read more

In my second order, I got the special with a large 3-topping pizza + free breadsticks for $20. For that price, I got an amazing, tasty (and a somewhat oily) pizza that didn't skimp on the toppings that I paid a bit for. Breadsticks with the pizza sauce make for a great snack as well. I think this pizza place nails the sauce/cheese ratio the best around Oakland (perhaps in all of Pitt). Will almost certainly order pizza from here again! Edit: Regarding my first order, I got the shrimp basket special prior to the pizza for a quick and cheap meal for lunch before work. The shrimp didn't really taste that great, and the fries lacked a bit of salt. The cocktail sauce was not original (packaged by Kraft) nor did it taste good with the shrimp/fries. Wouldn't order this again, but that doesn't change the fact that their pizza is really good. read more