Chatham location opened in 1995 with other locations in Tribeca and Montville, NJ. It's in a 1740s farmhouse offering Northern Italian style dishes. I first heard about it from a friend and nearly missed it because the place looks like a private home on Main Street. I love that they offer a 4 course prix fixe menu for $72 which really differentiates itself & offers genuine authentic Italian meals without the Italian American twist so many places lean on. The service was also amazing. AMAZING spot for a family dinner or to impress the parents. read more

See all

Romantic Italian Dinner spot with a 5 course pre-fixed menu of delicious selections. The small spot boasts various awards, although many from over 20 years ago, but still lives up to a unique experience for small parties and date nights. The price point matches the exquisite service, ambiance, and menu items that will impress any dinner party or date. Dishes such as the Butternut Agnolotti are unique and flavorfully crafted for this experience and I highly recommend. I will find time to be back! read more

See all

Came here for dinner for a birthday dinner. Valet parking (which is unnecessary for this place). Not sure how to describe the decor, mix between an Italian grandma's living room and French. It's a $72, for course dinner. A single piece of shrimp in a mustard dressing to start, paradelle with veal as an appetizer, snapper for main, and ricotta cake for dessert. Our waiter was nice and knowledgeable. They were a bit confused when it came to service. They served the wrong dishes for some courses or served another tables dishes instead of ours. The waiter could have checked in a bit more in between dishes. The shrimp was interesting, it had a tangy creamy taste. My favorite dish was the veal paradelle, the veal was soft and buttery. The snapper was disappointing and lacked any flavor. The dessert was ok, but nothing memorable read more

See all

This is a first class restaurant. The ambiance is charming and warm. Feels you are at home. The service was excellent. Our waiters recommendations were prefect. The food was delicious. I never order pork chops at a restaurant. I am glad I ordered it here. It was delicious. read more

Scalini Fedeli - Lightly Pounded Parmigiano Crusted Rib Pork Chop - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

Courses are amazing Service could not be better Value is there Ambiance is rather formal, which I was ill prepared for meeting my father for dinner. Food was one of the best meals I've had roaming around north jersey. This place has elegance and soul that is not overbearing or out of place. The menu is methodical and orchestrated to the final bite. I will be coming back, perhaps in more than just jeans, but coming back nonetheless. read more

See all

Went with friends. Great food on the menu, and great romantic atmosphere for our date night!

I hadn't been here in a few years. My wife and I decided to celebrate Valentine's Day a week early and boy are we glad we chose this restaurant! Their five course prefix menu has absolutely something for everyone and the presentation and exquisite quality of food. makes it one of the finest Italian restaurants in New Jersey. They have incredible cocktails probably the best old-fashioned we've ever had, a wonderful wine list, including wines by the glass and also half bottles which I love. Our server, Gus was not only very knowledgeable about the menu and accommodating. He was also simply a warm, friendly and funny person. Also the beautifully decorated restaurant and dining room makes it for a wonderful romantic evening. We cannot wait to go back! read more

This was my first time back in almost 15 years and not much has changed; and that is a good thing. Formal dining venue located in an old house in Chatham, parking in the back. Charming dining room with an old school feel. Food and service are very solid and if you are looking for a formal meal with delectable flavors and portions then look no further. The soft egg yolk ravioli and the mushroom risotto to start was a pleasant surprise with the portions on the larger side. Veal Milanese and the salmon special was mouth watering and delicious, didn't want to leave a bite behind. Dessert was impressive and helped capped a memorable and delicious meal. If you are looking for an old school dining experience to celebrate an event or a formal date night put this on the list. read more

See all

Came for dinner and had a good meal. The ambiance inside is like a nicely decorated home and the service was great, very attentive. You pick one appetizer, one entree and one dessert. The bread they brought to the table was decent, sliced baguette or equivalent and a white bread with seeds in it (similar to rye), but honestly it could be better. Neither was as soft as I hoped, but that is minor. They start by bringing out the Ecuadorian shrimp as a bite (one shrimp) which was good. I ordered the parpadelle as my starter and it was a decent size. My only complaint was the primary flavor in the dish was rosemary and I was hoping for more than one strong flavor. The pasta and ragu were cooked nicely. For entrees we split the short rib and the branzino, both a good sized serving. The short rib was cooked well, but was exactly how you expected short rib to be served, over mashed potatoes with jus. There is nothing wrong with that, I was just hoping for something a bit more unique or creative. I feel you could get that dish at many other restaurants, that it would not be reason to come here on its own and did not justify the supplemental charge. The branzino however was divine. Perfectly cooked with lots of flavor. Easily the best dish of the night. They bring out sorbet before dessert, not my favorite but others at the table liked it. We got the banana tart and hazelnut and pistachio cookies which everyone seemed to enjoy (though the banana tart had alot of caramel on it). Overall a nice meal with good service. read more

The food was great. The service was attentive. However I will say that the bread they served Was stale :/ but the primary food was delicious. The restaurant atmosphere was romantic and intimate. I would go back again. read more

This was an elegant location with a vaulted interior and loud atmosphere. The menu was fixed pricing ($72 for four courses) along with a couple extra costs depending on what was ordered. It was odd that the menu had no titles for items, just descriptions of different dishes. The service was appreciated in the beginning but fell off towards the end with our check and dessert taking a while to arrive. To start off the meal, multiple types of bread were given. My favorite was the sourdough. The rye was just alright. The bread was ideal for future dishes though. The first course was an Ecuadorian shrimp. It came in a mustard sauce with vegetables. This was a nice start to the meal. The shrimp was perfectly cooked, and the mustard sauce was tasty too. It was a nice compliment to the shrimp. For my second course, I chose the pappardelle. It came in a braised veal shank and marrow sauce with minced cherry pepper and Italian mascarpone. This was definitely the best dish of the night for me. The pasta was fresh and cooked to my liking while the veal shank and marrow sauce was great. It was a perfect blend of so many flavors coming together. I did not really taste the cherry pepper, but it did not matter because of how good this dish was. I also tried the butternut agnolotti. It came with a sage brown butter and buffalo mozzarella. This was nicely done as well. The pasta again was cooked perfectly, and the sage brown butter was a nice compliment. It was very rich but paired nicely with the butternut flavor. The entrée portion, I had the veal scallopini. It was three pieces of veal with prosciutto, fontina, and eggplant in a wine sauce with hearts of broccoli. This was okay. The veal was tender and very thin, but it lacked seasoning. The sauce was pleasant as well as the cook on the broccoli, but the lack of enough seasoning really threw me off. I also tried the pignoli crusted faroe island salmon that was over roasted eggplants, peppers, onions, and currants with a wine lemon and basil sauce. This was solid. The salmon had a ton of pignoli crusted to it and the cook on the salmon was ideal. The sauce was good as well. The intermezzo consisted of lime sorbet with pineapple and coconut. This was a nice palate cleanser, and the coconut appeared extremely fresh just from the smell alone. It was nicely done. For the dessert course, the crispy banana tart was ordered. It was sprinkled with hazelnut praline and drizzled with caramel sauce along with a side of caramel gelato. This was not too heavy, and the caramel obviously went well with the banana slices here along with the tart. The tart was very crispy and paired nicely with the caramel gelato Again, everything appeared very fresh. I also tried the chocolate soufflé. It was served with pistachio and straticella gelato. The pistachio was alright while the straticella was my preferred choice. I would have liked to see more of a pistachio taste. The chocolate souffle was done right. It was soft and came out warm with it being paired nicely with the gelatos. Will I go back? I believe so. read more

See all

This is our favorite restaurant to celebrate life events. The food and service are impeccable.

Definitely a Five Star restaurant! Prix Fixe menu. Four courses. Had excellent burrata and lobster. Complimentary bread selection and lemon ice for palette . Phenomenal service in a hi-end surroundings. read more

See all

Service was impeccable. Ambience was excellent. Food was good. What was not good was the inflexibility of the menu. For example, for my appetizer I wished to have the beet salad what was forced to order pasta because the next course did not include any pasta. I would've preferred to have pasta for my main entrée rather than meat. I did not like the inflexibility of this restaurant. They should accommodate people for what they want. The price is astronomical. And even if you do not adhere to the menu, you still get charged full price of $72. Very unhappy with this inflexibility. Will not go back. read more

Food was beyond good! Pricey but they give you a lot in addition to the 4 course. Can't see anything being bad. Service was quick. Ambiance was cute in there it is set up like a little house. read more

Scalini Fedeli - Destroyed chocolate soufflé and berry dessert - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

It has been several years since we have been here, and we thought it was time to come back. I have been coming here since they opened in the mid-1990's. They had no liquor license back then (great times), and the food and service were amazing from day one. Fast forward to Saturday night...we had reservations for my birthday. The request on the reservation was for a table by the window. It was also stated on the reservation that it was my birthday. Upon arrival, the woman at the host stand was oblivious to the fact that we requested a window seat. After we insisted she look at the reservation, she finally gave us a window seat. ( There are a couple of tables for two that are less than desirable, near the columns in the middle of the room - we always want to avoid those tables.) We were seated, and service started wonderfully - just as we remember it. We started looking at the menu, got the wine list, and picked out a Pinot Noir. There were a couple of food specials, but neither appealed. Our waiter came back to take our order, and that was going well....until he actually made us order our dessert when we ordered our appetizers and entrees. I asked why we had to do that, and he said it was because it was "prix fixe". Ummm...WHAT? It's been prix fixe since day one, and we never had to order dessert the same time as our meals. It was upsetting at the time, but even moreso once we finished our dinner and realized we didn't really want the desserts we ordered. We were really full, and definitely would NOT have ordered the Italian Ricotta Donuts (surcharge) the the very dense, very rich chocolate tart. The amuse bouche - surprisingly - was exactly the same as it always was! It might be time for a change....lol The apps and entrees were amazing. Even the sorbet was perfect. Both entrees had surcharges - they weren't anything that should have warranted $8 and $10 surcharges. The little tray of extra dessert they brought out was out of place in a restaurant like this. A few biscotti and some toffee?!?! Seriously? What happened to the cute little pastries - the little tarts, cookies, etc? They should just bring out a small plate of biscotti and keep the candy. Oh, during dinner, our waiter came over and asked what name our reservation was under...lol. Clearly someone screwed up somewhere. Service throughout was attentive. No birthday candle, no acknowledgement, nothing. It's likely we'll come back - the food is excellent. We definitely will NOT be forced into ordering dessert at the beginning of our meal - ever again. If that is indeed a requirement, we'll walk out and never return. read more

See all

There is no better date night then dinner at Scalini Fidelity. Service is impeccable and the food is off the charts. If you haven't tried it you are missing out Yay yourself, you only live once better enjoy it read more

See all

Thoroughly enjoyable evening, food terrific, staff professional. It was like walking into a euro-style ambiance, and elegance. Unexpected!!

Overall ambience and service was very pleasant minus 1-2 people on staff. Our actual waiter was very accommodating and entertaining. Food hits all the marks one expects in a Jersey Italian restaurant, but small things were lacking that just made it fine but not memorable. Dinner is a 4 course pre fixe with a starter and palate cleanser. I had a chicken special as my main course - it felt more like a southern or typical American dish with just chicken, pile of mashed potatoes and gravy everywhere on the dish. The chicken was cooked well but not much there in terms of enjoyable flavors. The dish was also supposed to have prosciutto but I got maybe two tiny bits that could have been bacon. The chicken dish on their regular menu sounded pretty great and more typical Italian but I figured the special would have a bit more oompf(I was wrong) On to issue with 1-2 staff members- they seem to change the vibe as they look to provide Parmesan or black pepper but forcefully provide bare minimum and move on without allowing you to decide if it's enough or you need more. The dessert was very okay. I truly enjoyed the palate cleanser (lemon sorbet) much more than the actual dessert (the chocolate cake). It felts too dense and the cherry sauce just didn't add to the dish and overwhelmed the overall flavor. Other diners I was with enjoyed their respective dishes but also felt each item felt short of memorable. read more

Truly a wonderful dining experience!! The atmosphere inside is beautiful. Each course of food was amazing!! From the bread on the table upon arrival through dessert. My only complaint was the service at the end of our meal. We had a 630 Tuesday reservation for a group of 6 (business dinner). At 830, the servers took everything off the table (the glasses, the flowers, the candle) and put their coats on and stood off to the side staring at us. It was a poor ending to a really wonderful dinner that left us with a bad taste, hence the 4 stars. I expect better from a restaurant like this. read more

Had a big family dinner here! After our reservation for 9 people was in the system for the next day, the staff quickly acted and were able to accommodate us in a big table and then a table for two. Price fixe menu includes an appetizer, main course and dessert. The space is pretty, dimly lit and intimate feeling. The staff was attentive to us and the food was good. Side note -- don't enter from the main road! Haha the door is on the side. Also they do offer valet parking. read more

The food was just so so The service was so so The ambiance was ok Food. Not great. Too much sauce Quality was not good I paid extra for shrimp and lobster. Not of the highest quality I won't be back read more

Overall a decent dining experience. The mushroom ravioli and veal Milanese a enjoyable while the great service and hospitality are the winners here. read more

Scalini Fedeli - Boneless Veal Chop Milanese - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

See all

PROS: This place is by far one of the greatest Italian restaurants around. Atmosphere, food, and menu variety were amazing! The staff was very nice and the food was fresh and came out on time. CONS: For dinner they only do a 4 course $72 option rather than ala cart style. OVERALL: As long as you don't mind paying a fixed price this place is one of the best places to visit. You also have valet parking which has it's ups and downs depending on how you view it read more

See all

Unique and flavorful food in a romantic and cozy setting. Service was friendly and attentive. Overall a lovely way to spend my dad's birthday! read more

Scalini Fedeli - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

I liked the dining room and they gave us a very nice table for a 5pm reservation on a Fri night. Service was very good also. For evening, it's a $72 price fixe menu. They start you off with complimentary bread - 3 ways plus an amuse bouche of ecuadorian shrimp. The shrimp was fine but I find it alittle strange to have ecuadorian shrimp in an Italian restaurant. If it was amazing, then I get it, but why feature a dish that is "fine". I had the Soft egg yolk raviolo which was cooked perfectly and had nice amount of sage butter sauce. My husband had Tagliatelle and said it was good and just would have liked alittle more ricotta. For main, I had potato crusted redfish and my husband had veal scallopini. For redfish, the crust was soggy so it almost felt like why have it. Taste was good though. My husband said his veal scallopini was fine. For dessert, I had the banana tart and this did beat my expectations. It was delicious. My husband had the chocolate souffle which looked more like a chocolate lava cake - just cooked more. He said it was fine. Overall, it was a nice dinner but for $72 per person, I expected more from the food. I would pare down the menu to try to make the dishes fantastic vs. fine. read more

Delizioso! This is my first time at this restaurant and so I had high expectations. I heard lots of good things about it and have been told that the food was amazing. The place blends in with the neighborhood and I almost missed it. Thank goodness there is valet parking. The decor is a little dated but it's cozy. The service was great with attentive staff. This is the first restaurant that I have been to with only a pre fixe menu. I reviewed the menu before going so I knew what I wanted however they offered a small list of specials. We ordered from the specials list with a small surcharge. I'm looking forward to coming back. read more

Very special place and great owners. Very attentive to details. The meal was simply fantastic read more

Scalini Fedeli - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey

I have passed this restaurant so many times, its deceptive in that it looks like a house. Its located on the outskirts of Chatham on Main street. Parking: Parking lot with Valet. Restaurant ambiance: old school Italian - Tuscany. Great for small gatherings, dates etc. It is on the smaller side and gets busy so reservations are a MUST. When we went the restaurant was packed. Menu: Extensive menu with plenty of seafood and meat options. Loved the porcini ravioli and snapper. Not BYOB but extensive wine list. Cost: $60 prefix for 4 courses. Which is worth every single penny and for the quality of food is a steal. Service: exceptional. Glass was never empty, plates were cleared quickly and courses were brought out in a timely manner. COVID: tables were a little close but all servers and staff wore masks. Will definitely be coming back and be bringing my family. Parents, grandparents will love this place! read more

The food was awesome! We had some great Brunellos. To top off the perfect evening we had Gus. He was an amazing waiter! Can't wait to go back! read more

Scalini Fedeli has two locations with one being in lower Manhattan and the other in Chatham. They pride themselves on being authentic and upscale fine dining Italian. This review is for the location in Chatham. NOTE: The menu is PRIX FIXE meaning that it is a fixed menu for one price. You choose one starter dish, one main dish, and one dessert, NOTE II: I emailed Scaleni Fedeli about two weeks informing them that I was a vegan and needed to know if they would accommodate me and never received a response. The location in Chatham is a 260-year-old New Jersey farmhouse and it features high vaulted ceilings, antique pine floors, and a sense of Tuscan appeal. The upper floor is where the restrooms are located as well as additional storage. NOTE III: There is limited lighting inside and attempting to look at the menu may require you to use the flashlight option on your mobile device. TIP I: It was easier to view the menu from their website on your mobile device than using the flashlight to look at the menu. Our group had six diners and our waiter provided us with the specials of the day when it was my turn to place my order, I explained that I am vegan, and I do not eat meat, fish, chicken, or animal by-products. There was some confusion as he didn't seem to understand what by-products were, so I explained, milk, cheese, and eggs. My colleagues' dishes from start to end were a flaming train wreck. There were multiple instances of a communication breakdown and each plate added to the building rage in my colleague. My colleague chose the Sauteed Shrimp with saffron oil, seasoned with Italia parsley and fresh rosemary in a sherry plum tomato sauce with cannellini beans. It did not appear that way when presented. It seemed to me that the shrimp was smothered in a crème sauce. My colleague's second dish choice from the Piatti Di Mezzo was the Ecuadorian Shrimp sauteed in a sherry wine and garlic sauce over pecorino and sweat pea puree. His dessert choice was the souffle but more about that later. Fortunately, my dishes were vegan but lacked flavor and any type of creativity. I must believe that the kitchen must have been fully equipped with all sorts of fresh herbs but my Roasted Beet Salad minus the mozzarella was uninspiring even though it came with sundried tomatoes dressed with a pistachio vinaigrette. The kitchen team converted the Penne with Sausage and wild mushrooms in a delicate tomato and basil sauce into a Penne pasta dish with vegetables and enough water to sink the Titanic. It was not surprising as I had consulted the reviews on Yelp and several other sites and noted that Scalini Fedeli is for those who want a fixed menu experience and can order from the options available without modifications. This is not a restaurant that cannot accommodate vegans, gluten-free, as well as dietary restrictions and allergies easily. I honestly felt trapped since the moment that I knew I was invited, and my colleague was locked into dish after dish of disappointment. We've all seen the movie scene where all the diner's tops and forks go down, and the heads turn to the troubled table. That troubled table was where I was seated, and it went like this. My colleague had ordered the souffle but did not get a souffle in lieu, he received something else. It looked like a chocolate ganache smear with berries. He called the waiter over to the table and my colleague who has had issues with the two previous plates was at this boiling point. The waiter came, checked his notes, and remarked very stately that my colleague did not order the souffle. The banter between the two escalated to the point where the waiter offered to bring a souffle within ten minutes and my colleague said, forget about it with some more descriptive vocabulary. It was at this point that everyone's forks went down, heads turned, and the dining room was silent. I never thought I would be sitting at that table. My colleague was correct and the continual errors solely on his plates seemed strangely connected. I received my dessert which was berries but had a huge dollop of Zabaglione with crushed amaretti cookies It was presented phenomenally but I had no explanation to confirm if my plate with the Zabaglione was made without egg yolk. No one ever came and said, 'Sir, the Zabaglione was made with nutritional yeast or another egg replacement. Unfortunately, not one staff member said anything even when my untouched plate was picked up. I want to be very clear that Scalini Fedeli is a remarkable location, and I am sure that the dishes are amazing as told by many reviewers from across all platforms. It's just unfortunate that we were at the wrong restaurant having the wrong dining experience read more

Can't go wrong with this place. Comfortable friendly laid back and delicious. Deep dishes out the goodness and graciousness of Chicago!

My husband and I went for our anniversary. Let me start off by saying restaurant (though dated and older) is very nice, romantic. We loved where our seat was it was intimate and we could still people watch. The food was very good, we didnt mind the pri -fix menu and the drinks were also good. What bothered me, was the utensils, drinking glasses and plates all had a funny odor, keep of like raw chicken or egg. My husband who usually makes fun of me for my strong sense of smell agreed, and having worked in the food industry said it was probably from the dishwasher. I would go back, to try it again, and hopefully the smell is gone. read more

Consistently good for at least once a year visit. Professional wait staff and extensive menu options. The decor is getting old / stale but still very nice. read more

ALWAYS amazing. Take a moment from everything going on around you at the table and taste your first bite. You will begin to understand what food should really taste like. And the service will not disappoint either! Busy nights they have a free valet which is a real bit of luxury for their parking lot :) read more

Everything was great ! Food was delicious and service was very good. Just wish the captain was a little more .... Into the night ! read more

See all

The second best meal I have ever had in my entire life. And I have eaten in thousands of places. In 48 states and abroad. Service was exceptional from the moment we walked in until the valet brought us our car. The prefix meal was worth every penny. Turned out to be 5 courses. Masterly prepared, piping hot, beautiful presentation and absolutely delicious. The perfect fine dining experience. Will certainly be back as often as possible. Highly recommend! In case you're wondering my best meal was the River Cafe under the Brooklyn Bridge. read more

See all

Suppose I would say my experience was almost four stars. Price Fixe menu option was a good concept. The dining room is "historical" or maybe hysterical, unless you really like downright old stuff. The food was ok, but at the prices were not worth it to me at least. The egg yolk ravioli as a starter was sloppy - poorly made large ravioli, and dowsed in brown butter / truffle oil butter. The truffle oil ruined it, and it's hard to tell if there was any yolk in the ravioli I could have made at home - the brown butter truffle oil was a waste. As an entree, went with the short ribs. Too much food. The demi glacé added nice favor. read more

Formerly Great, now simply average. We went for a special dinner recently - the food was undercooked or overcooked. The waiter was nothing short of aggressive, hovering over my daughter in law as she perused the menu, telling her she "had to" pick what he recommended. I'd never go back. For the price, a complete ripoff read more

Scalini Fedeli, the original Chatham, NJ location, is by far the best Italian restaurant in the State. Like it's New York City younger sibiling, it is pricey but far cheaper than a flight to Milan or Florence. The food from start to finish is always amazing. Scalini Fedeli also has an excellent wine list and good service. read more

Scalini Fedeli - Italian Near Me - Chatham, New Jersey