Had the best lunch at Saylor. The ambience/food was great and our server Ally was amazing! 10/10 experience definitely recommend!

Kayleigh was amazing!!! Food was very solid and the vibe is perfect :) Saylor is perfect summer stop!

Good and service and good. Ally was excellent and was very attentive. View is great as well.

This was our first trip to Greenport and didn't quite know what to expect... As we pulled in and parked it was the gorgeous arch filled with Ivy and lemons that caught her attention... As you walked into the restaurant, the Water view literally made you feel like you were in Greece with mansions here and their tucked in the hills across the water... But in the end, the biggest thing that we can rave about is the food! A few years ago we were lucky enough to travel to Greece. Their original version of a Greek salad has been almost bastardized (lol) in the US. It's wholesome and fresh cucumbers with fresh tomatoes and a block of feta on top. Drenched in a crisp dressing. SAYLOR brought us back!! The Greek salad, The calamari, the zucchini chips.... Mouthwatering !!!!!!!! Don't even get me started on the drinks. A basil vodka drink yummm and an old fashioned made with a refreshing twist!!! For sure this is a go to place for your visit!!! The owners, the managers, Rob the bartender all cared about your experience as much as we did. read more

Saylor Beach House - Mediterranean Near Me - Greenport, New York

I've said this plenty of times, and I'll die on this hill: you cannot be a restaurant that has both outstanding food and a great, lively atmosphere. This restaurant is proof of that. We came for lunch on Friday of Fourth of July weekend after being told they were fully booked for dinner. Even during the day, the restaurant was packed, which definitely speaks to its popularity. The menu is Mediterranean, which is one of my favorite cuisines, so I was excited to try it. Unfortunately, the food was just average. We started with the fried calamari and the Greek salad. The Greek salad was probably the best thing we ordered--fresh, flavorful, and well-balanced. The calamari, however, was disappointing. It was mostly chunks of fried breading with very little actual calamari. At one point, we picked up what looked like a piece of calamari only to realize it was just a tightly packed cluster of fried tentacles about the size of a golf ball. It was served with an aioli that was extremely rich and overpowering. A little went a very long way, and I found the dish difficult to finish. For our entrées, my fiancé ordered the skirt steak based on our waitress's recommendation, and I had the chicken kebabs. They certainly didn't skimp on the portion size for the kebobs, but the chicken pieces were enormous and unfortunately very dry. I only managed to eat a few bites before giving up. One thing that was surprisingly frustrating was the drinks. I ordered a Sprite and was served seltzer instead. Assuming it was just a mistake, I ordered another when my glass was empty--but I was brought seltzer again. It wasn't a huge issue, but it was odd that it happened twice. The service started off well. Our waitress was friendly, attentive, and personable. However, once she went on break, it felt like we were forgotten. At one point, I dropped my fork and waited nearly 10 minutes for someone to pass by so I could ask for another. Eventually, I ended up grabbing one from the empty table next to us because no one came around. Overall, this is a fun place with a poppin' atmosphere, and I imagine it's even better in the evening around sunset. That said, it's not somewhere I'd recommend for the food. I'd suggest coming for drinks, the ambiance, and the overall vibe rather than expecting an exceptional meal. The food wasn't bad--it just wasn't memorable, and it certainly didn't justify the prices. For me, it was simply OK. read more

We had a wonderful dinner for two at Saylor's we sat by the dock. The vibe and energy was amazing . We loved the view Our server William was so attentive and provided excellent service. We definitely wanna come back and hope William is our server again. We shared the Greek salad and we had the shrimp skewers and a whole Branzino. It was perfect . We finished the meal with baklava. We will definitely be back read more

See all

Oh Saylor! Such a cute spot and definitely gave Mediterranean feels all over. I ordered the chicken kebab with pita, and potatoes. Very delicious and shareable. Our server was attentive and nice. Our food did take a while to come out but once it did, it was worth it. I do wish the place had a mocktail menu. They also had no NA beers. The best part of Saylor for me was the DJ. I kept on being impressed on his transitions from song to song, it was great! Oh and also the entrance was definitely instagramable, lots of females taking photos lol read more

Saylor Beach House - Mediterranean Near Me - Greenport, New York

I had the best dinner at Saylor Beach House! Ask for Julia G -- she's the sweetest, most attentive server and made our night. The food was incredible, vibes were perfect and the service was unmatched. I'll definitely be back. read more

See all

This place was amazing the food was top notch. The highlight of the night was the Branzino. Grilled to perfection with a crispy skin and so much flavor. Oysters was so sweet and even tho I'm use to adding different ingredients on my oyster this was fine without it. The waiter Tyler consistently checked on us to see if we needed anything. He paid attention to detail and how I wanted food prepared. The scenery was very nice great ocean views. I will definitely be coming back again to try more things on the menu read more

See all

Wow. To say this place was a disappointment would be an understatement. The potential here is through the roof, but the most important part just was not executed. First and foremost, salt and pepper go a LONG way. Unfortunately, there was none on any of the plates. We started with apps. Fried calamari and baked feta. Best thing we ate here, was the baked feta. It was creamy, crispy, good. Solid app. The fried calamari however, shouldn't have been called fried. It was not fried long enough, the breading just fell off into the plate and was mush. It was served with a cup of mayo. Literally. It is supposed to be a "lemon aioli" no. No lemon, no flavor, just mayo. Second were our main courses. I had gotten the Mediterranean pasta with grilled chicken. As described on menu, butter, white wine, capers. All things that would give great flavor but there was none. Just extremely bland. Even the added grilled chicken, just tasted like nothing. My wife ordered the steak. Ordered medium rare, the steak was cooked beautifully. However, again just no flavor. No salt, no pepper nothing. Great cook on steak but what's the point if it has zero flavor. It had a "chimichurri" on the steak as well, which somehow tasted like nothing. Extremely disappointed. We also got lemon potatoes, which were ok. The one thing on the table that had a tiny bit of flavor. They were tender potatoes, nice lemon kick, they were good. Wife's steak came with a fried rice and broccoli. Fried rice with steak? Interesting. Was not fresh fried rice. Boxed, no flavor, broccoli had no salt pepper or garlic on it so it was very very bland. We had cocktails, they were ok. Can't complain too much about those. After the tasteless meal, we decided to skip dessert. Had a feeling we would just be disappointed. Two stars were for the view ( which is beautiful ) the refreshing cocktails, and the potential. But they must learn how to season food. Especially if they're charging what they're charging. Mind you, seemed the surrounding tables had problems with the food and service as well. But that's just hear say. I wouldn't go here until they work out the kinks with flavoring. read more

See all

We just had dinner at the Saylor, this place is gorgeous and has a great atmosphere. Our server Tyler was a great waiter very professional. My only complaint was our fried calamari was a bit soggy and not crispy. Besides that the bake feta and skirt steak was delicious and our server was fantastic. Definitely recommend to try this lovely spot for yourself! read more

Amazing food and ambience. Very good service. Tyler, our waiter was very attentive and professional.

Came for lunch - first time since the new venue...Great views, friendly and helpful service... Alie recommended the crispy Baked feta - yum! read more

Saylor Beach House - Baked Feta - Mediterranean Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

Ali was the absolute best. This place is magical, food amazing, drinks amazing, ocean amazing, ahhhh

Saylor looks like the kind of place you want to love before you even sit down. It has the view, the music, the coastal decor, the whole "lunch that accidentally turns into sunset drinks" fantasy. Which makes it all the more frustrating when a restaurant with this much going for it somehow manages to feel less like Greenport's next great waterfront spot and more like a beautiful missed opportunity. We went on Sunday for lunch to try Saylor, and the setting really is lovely. The views are wonderful, the playlist worked, and the decor has that relaxed, beach-club elegance that made me think of Comporta in Portugal. That is where the good news mostly ends. We started by asking for a cocktail that was not sweet and were steered toward the Mykonos margarita. It was bad enough that we sent it back and decided not to order anything else from the bar. It had a strange aftertaste and was still sweet, which felt especially disappointing because the place is begging for a serious bar program. With that view and vibe, this should be the home of a great bergamot spritz, a crisp white Negroni, a clarified milk punch, something bright and coastal and memorable. Instead, it felt like a big missed chance. The Greek salad was fine. Nothing wrong with it, nothing exciting about it. Exactly what you expect a Greek salad to be. The shrimp skewers, though, were mushy. My guess is they had been over-marinated in acid and were basically "cooked" before they ever touched the grill. The fried calamari was passable, though a little salty. Again, not terrible, but not something I would go out of my way for. The bigger issue is that I still do not really know what Saylor is trying to be. It has the view, the room, the music, and the bones of a great Greenport destination. But the food and drinks do not yet live up to the setting. I would come back for a tap beer and an app, but for now Saylor feels like one very pretty missed opportunity. read more

Julia, nice job! Good food, great service. Nod to Alix from Romania, nice job! The cocktails were on point.

Just seems like another seasonal spot that doesn't care what product they put out because they think the great location can carry any short comings. I understand these seasonal spots have just a few months to make their money. I don't care if something is expensive, but if you're going to charge premiums, please put out a nice product. Mezze Board(really a tower) for $42 offers 3 tiny ramekins of dips with pita. Presentation and portions were sad. Fried calamari was so greasy and the breading was falling off. Drinks served in hard plastic cups. Unsure why there wasn't glass . Ambiance was nice but not worth it for the food. Service was okay. I have to assume it's difficult to get staffing on the north fork of Long Island but if so, maybe spend more time training them so they offer your guest an elevated experience for your location. Giving 3 stars because I'm hoping they improve . read more

Insanely overpriced. Tacky decor...this place is in the heart of the North Fork, an agricultural treasure of fruit, flower, and vegetables....and yet the entrance is tunnel of FAKE lemon vines ..tacky and ridiculous. Wife and I sat at bar, the seats were low and uncomfortable, likely to help turnover to serve more and sell more. Cocktails for $18, many served in plastic cups. Tap beer served in plastic cup for $10. Ridiculous. Calamari appetizer, $28. Annoying loud beat music served by a DJ. The place is in a beautiful harbor setting, so why spoil the vibe with thumping beat music? Neither of the 2 bartenders acknowledged us, so, after 5 minutes waiting for a simple " hello, be with you in a minute" we left. Was INFINITELY better as Crabby Jerry's...no pretentions, reasonable value. read more

Beautiful ambience- best baked clams!! Our waitress Julia was excellent!! Could use more N/A choices

Too bad. The renovation is lovely. The location can't be beat. But if you're looking to actually speak to each other, forget it. The DJ had the volume turned up so high we had scream across the table to be heard. Never again. read more

New gem on the North Fork. Went to Saylor Beach House in Greenport on a Sunday, we took the ferry over from Sag and so easy to get to. Stunning views on the water and the food was great. Have a DJ and great vibe. Our server Tyler is great and Chris one of the managers checked in and spent some time with us to make sure our experience was amazing. Will be back soon!! read more

Saylor Beach House - Mediterranean Near Me - Greenport, New York

See all

I dined here with a large group and I would not go back again. the service was terrible, we waited 45 mins for drinks which didn't all come out at once, then our mains weren't out after 1 hour and 20 mins which after I complained I was told they are coming out maybe in 20 mins? the mains were shrimp which should not take that long. multiple other tables were complaining as well and then we said cancel all the food we want to leave and they gave us the bill with the comped food on it and my friend credit card was charged for the full amount. read more

YANET BEST WAITRESS, so accommodating, friendly, and nice! So nice to chat and thank you for your recommendations! the best!!!!!!

Such a fun vibe - vibey dj and felt tropical. The shrimp skewers were nice and service was great - Julia was fantastic!

Angel, our server, was amazing! The vibes were definitely vibing, the food was top-tier, and the atmosphere was perfect on such a beautiful sunny day. We had an incredible experience and can't wait to come back. Highly recommend! read more

Great experience, such a beautiful venue right on the water. Alli is the best server!!! The frozen lemonade drinks are elite

Vibe is wonderful, food was great, and our service was exceptional! Scott was warm, friendly, and very helpful!

While visiting the Hamptons, we took the ferry over to this hidden gem and I'm so glad we did! First, the atmosphere is absolutely stunning. Set right on the water, the restaurant feels like you've been transported to the Amalfi Coast, complete with gorgeous yellow European-style furnishings and breathtaking waterfront views. Since it's entirely outdoors, it's only open seasonally, so be sure to visit before they close for the year. As for the food, everything was fantastic. We started with the mezze platter featuring an assortment of Mediterranean dips and warm pita bread. The standout for me was the spicy feta dip--absolutely incredible and packed with flavor. We also ordered the whole branzino, which was cooked to perfection (major compliments to the chef), and the chicken skewers, which were tender, flavorful, and paired beautifully with their homemade tzatziki. Whoever is behind the dip recipes deserves special recognition because every single one was outstanding. Another standout for our group...a whole fresh lemon, hollowed out and filled with a refreshing frozen lemon slush made from real lemon juice. The owner, Celeste, stopped by our table to check on us and shared that they'll be adding DJs on Saturdays and Sundays, which will make the already lively atmosphere even more fun. We loved this place so much that we came back a second time before leaving the Hamptons, and the food was just as exceptional as our first visit. If you're visiting the Hamptons, this is an absolute must. Beautiful setting, delicious food, warm hospitality, and a vibe that makes you want to stay all day. read more

Saylor beach house was a fun experience , I pulled up with my boat .. the food was really good & staff lovely , I would totally go back

Energy was good. Food was fine. Appetizers were best. Super fun place with water views. Julia, our server was amazing!

Valentino took care of our section of the restaurant effortlessly. We happened to be there during a beautiful rainstorm, and despite the weather, the staff made everything feel seamless. It turned what could have been a challenge into an absolutely wonderful dining experience. read more

Ambiance was good and Kayleigh, our server was fantastic. Menu is small and well executed.

Julia was great ! We came for lunch and drinks all was delicious. We have fries and a meditterenean boat.

Such a nice and relaxing spot! Drinks and food were good! Our server Allie was awesome!

Food, drinks, and location are amazing! Scott was the best server who came with the best food and bev recs.

Food delicious. Atmosphere beautiful. Service and Waitress Allie was so sweet. Helped us decide on a few menu options for the table. We will definitely return. read more

The staff was lovely drinks were amazing and you cannot beat the ambiance and the views! Cannot wait to return. read more

See all

Beautiful space, genuinely -- that's the only positive I can offer. The kitchen was a disaster from start to finish. We sat for almost 30 minutes before anyone even acknowledged our table. Once we finally ordered, it took another 40 minutes for a single appetizer to arrive. Two hours in, we still hadn't been served our entrées. Two hours. We asked staff to send the manager over. He/She never came. After two hours with no dinner, we paid for the one app we'd gotten and left hungry. We left our house excited to be on a Friday night "date night." Ended up just frustrated and mad. At these prices, you expect at minimum to be fed in a reasonable timeframe. Whatever's happening in that kitchen or with staffing, it's not close to acceptable. Can't recommend, and I won't be back to give it another shot. If you're not ready for a weekend on the NOFO in June, you're closed by Labor Day. read more

Do not come here unless you want to leave angry and hungry. Came on a Saturday night as a party of 7. Took over 40 minutes to receive our first cocktail and 2 people's took longer to arrive. Appetizers arrived before their first cocktail did. Some cocktails tasted like watery soap. Never had enough of anything and had to keep asking for it (water, water cups, utensils). No one cleared our appetizers, so after waiting long enough we removed the plates/obnoxious dip pirate ship ourselves. (if you're going to serve dips in a big wooden ship, give people enough pitas). Our mains (a few orders of shrimp and chicken skewers) never arrived. After 1 hour and 30 minutes we had enough and told the server to just cancel our mains (he couldnt give us a solid update on kitchen timing, guessed it would be another 20 minutes or more). Another table was also complaining about the same things and cancelled their food order after waiting just as long. Server was doing his best but seemed like he was dealing with alot of upset people, not just us. The music was so loud that you couldnt hear the person next to you, the server could barely hear us when we were ordering. To top it off, they charged our credit card almost twice the amount of our bill. It was such an unenjoyable experience it was laughable. We actually started laughing because there was nothing else to do (eat, drink, or talk). The location is the only redeeming quality. read more

An afternoon at saylor beach house is like being transported to a lunch on the Mediterranean. Beautiful ambiance surrounded by the water. The food was excellent. Especially the zucchini chips, chicken skewers, and hummus; as well as the basil cocktail. All of the staff were super friendly and attentive. They were great to my dog as well. read more