Ordered $100+ delivery from location and my short rib gravy fries were littered with mushrooms on it! Why?! It's not listed on the menu and I didn't request mushrooms on my fries!! Was so glad Santuccis was out on the mainline when I moved from Philly. The old management of the Paoli location, while not perfect was 100x's better. Numerous orders under this new management have been incorrect or of lesser quality. I'm done read more

Santucci's Original Square Pizza - short rib gravy fries - with tons of mushrooms added for NO REASON - Pizza Near Me - Paoli, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered personal 4 topping pizza and 12 wings. Told 25 minutes. Arrived at the 15-20 minute mark. Surprised it was ready. Grabbed it and headed home, which is about 5minutes away. Sauce on pizza was warm at best. I thought there wasn't any cheese but I guess it was on bottom. Taste was fine. Topping seems light. All in all it was just ok. Wings were also more warm than hot. Flavor was good. Admittedly we ordered them well done but they seemed old and were tough. Again just ok. Maybe it was us, maybe it was on them but probably won't go back. read more

We ordered a large pizza and 8 wings. The large cheese pizza was fine. However, the wings were hard and difficult to eat. Very disappointing. I called the store and explained, what I was told was that that's how they come. The wings were hard and dry. Not worth it. I'm just warning others. read more

Just moved to the Berwyn area and have been trying to lock down a solid spot for pizza and steaks. I've had Santucci's before so I knew the pizza was good, but this review is for the cheesesteak. It came on a seeded roll which I love, but the flavor of the steak is what sold me. I got fried onions and American (no cooper sharp) and everything was blended so well together flavor/texture wise. I cannot stand when a place melts the cheese on the roll and doesn't mix it with the steak, but not the case here. This will probably be my spot for cheesesteaks now. I also got chicken tenders and mozz sticks. The mozz sticks needed a little reheating which was no big deal but were good! They are breaded not battered which I love. Santucci's sauce on their pizza and just for dipping the sticks is so good. The chicken tenders I was not a fan of. I had seen pictures of what looked more like a homemade breaded cutlet/tender advertised on door dash and review sites, however these were just a basic frozen battered looking chicken tender that needed more time in the fryer. That being said, solid choice for pizza and a steak! read more

See all

The food is good but service can be rude. The last two times I went, the person at the front seemed really annoyed. Not sure I would really go back there. Pizza is good but not that good to put up with the attitude. read more

Having been to the Broad Street and Roxborough Locations multiple times, we decided to give the Paoli location a shot as it was closer to home. Unfortunately this was a mistake. We ate in as we were out running errands. The service wasn't great, but it appeared to be a one man show: taking orders, making food and serving it. I felt bad for the guy working. Our go to is the Chicken Parm Sandwich on Garlic Bread, the Caesar Salad and the Small Pizza. We went with our usual and it was a disappointment. Same price as the locations in the city, but the portion sizes were smaller. No fries or chips included with the sandwich. No water brought to the table or offered. It was pretty clear; they aren't set up for a dine in experience. No worries on dine in if the food matched the quality of the other locations. It's a good attempt at the originals, but we'll stick with other local pizza options. read more

Haven't tried the pizza. Ordered a chicken cheesesteak based on staff member's rec. I asked if it is (pre-done) "chunks" of chicken b/c I think that's gross; back when I made chicken cheesesteaks, we whacked away at chicken on the grill just as you do with steak. He said no to my question, added that it's chicken breast chopped up on the grill. We were not on the same page apparently. Because they were nasty, RUBBERY, tasteless chunks of chicken that clearly had been made into chunks well ahead of time (possibly frozen/thawed, yuck) and tossed onto the roll. Also, "do you want everything on it" and "yes" resulted in nothing being on it other than cheese and chicken. Cheesesteak was better, though still didn't even get onions. Oh well. The rolls are tasty, however. read more

The person in the phone was actually laughing at my order. The pizza was delivered without a ring on the bell or a text saying it was delivered The pizza it self was lame I could have made a better pizza myself. Never again will I purchase a pizza from this place read more

First time trying Santucci's and we did take out. We got the bbq chicken pizza and a margarita. Both were great. Not too heavy and not too light. I don't love chunk chicken normally but I'd get this again. Definitely will be trying more pies from here! read more

Santucci's Original Square Pizza - Bbq chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Paoli, Pennsylvania

See all

Had a great experience with Santucci's for a catered business lunch at my office! Jillian - the manager was soo delightful to work with to coordinate our catered lunch, she went above and beyond! Food was delicious and service was great! I highly recommend Santucci's!! read more

The owner was very responsive to my requests. I was not satisfied with a particular product and he replaced it and called to assure me that it would never be a problem again. read more

Wasn't a fan when they first opened. However, after some trial & error, here's how we got a really good pie: 1) Order pick up. Delivery takes too long and sauce on the top pizza gets killed by the box more so than traditional pizza. 2) Prop the box open a bit on the way home. 3) Order the pie xtra, xtra well done. It makes the bottom super crispy and gives the pizza a better depth of flavor. Take that advise and the pie is one of the better ones in the area. read more

We used to have one near our old place in the city, so glad to see it come to the burbs. For those who don't know, they make a square upside down pizza with a zesty sauce. A bit on the pricey side, but worth it for the occasional fix. read more

I'm always in search of tasty pizza and am impressed and delighted by Santucci's square pizza. It has a delicious chewy texture and both the sausage and the pepperoni hit the right spice level for me. read more

Average pie. Nothing special and not bad. Kind of pricey. Reminds me of Picas in Upper Darby just not as good. Only question I have is why do you charge a fee for using my card? I get it if my order was under a certain amount but my total was 34 bucks? Seems like you guys are trying to sneak in extra fees without telling people. Kind of shady if you ask me. Was a 3 star but took one off for the credit card fee. read more

I recently saw the sign for Santucci and was pleased as we used to visit another location further away. My husband grew up eating the original pizza on O street and can confirm it's the same recipe. The pizza is delicious and the staff is friendly. Highly recommend and excited they are in the area. read more

New pizzeria in the area, I was so excited! Meh. Very disappointed. They do only square pizza, and you can customize your order. We ordered the standard for the cheese and the Margherita. Minimal cheese, generous amount of tomato sauce but quite bland and lacking garlic and spices. Some found it was kind of like eating cooked dough with canned unflavored tomato sauce. There were mixed opinions on the bread/crust, which was somewhere between thin and regular thickness. Some found it satisfactory; I found it not chewy and airy enough, as has now become the norm for pizza, and rather a bit soggy and lacking crispness. Basil on the Margherita were just tiny shreds and not the big chunky leaves I was accustomed to. While eating, I kept thinking I could have done better eating the Motor City Pizza from Wegman's I had in my freezer. To top it off, it came at a premium price, $20 for regular, $25 for the Margherita. Kind of felt ripped off. At least they delivered, and promptly. Even so, Nevermore! Did a little internet research afterwards and apparently they have multiple stores throughout Philadelphia and is apparently somewhat legendary, at least according to a Y--T--- video. Like, really?! Located right next to Paoli CVS. read more

Good service even better pizza and hoagies. Recommend to anyone looking for a great lunch.