We had heard great things about Malatestas and wanted to try it out. We were disappointed that we were only able to get square red and round red. He had high hopes and we were disappointed. The round pie tasted fine but found it a bit chewy and burnt. The square pie didn't have a lot of flavor read more

Tried another new-ish local pizza shop today. It is take-out & online ordering ONLY.There is no on site dining at the shop. They have a fairly large menu,but I just tried the one basic pizza for starters.Ordered a Square/Rectangular Pepperoni Pizza with half Black Olives..it only comes in one size.Approximately 12" x 15" or so, and it's a bit pricey at $33 out the door ($25 +Tax+Fee&Tip) .Their ordering portal/website adds an online service charge and tip automatically.Not so sure I like that,I'll be more than happy to tip for a great pizza but don't make it mandatory,ok? Sauce was a bit sweet but quite tasty,plenty of it too. Cheese fans might want to order extra cheese for their pizzas,though.There wasn't an abundance of cheese on top of the sauce and toppings.They put the cheese on the bottom and dust it with some grated cheese on top,so it doesn't seem to have much on it..if you follow me. Toppings themselves were plentiful.No complaints there.Crust was firm and a bit crunchy/chewy.Not bad at all. They cut the pizza in rectangular strips,not squares.Kind of unusual. Anyway,it was a solid 4 out of 5 but was overpriced for what you get in the large 17" box.Might try their 'Bar Pie' next time,I think those are a proper full sized 16" or 18" round pizza ,not sure because their site's menu doesn't list the pizza's actual sizes. read more

Malatesta's Italian American Pizza - Rectangular pepperoni pizza with half black olives (1 size only) Approx $30 - Pizza Near Me - Newtown Square, Pennsylvania

Delco, this isn't your average pizza - it is unique. They opened mid-July and I have seen many raving FaceBook accolades, so I had to give it a try. The staff, both on the phone and in person, were friendly and helpful. I tried the round bar pizza. It was Saturday and they just opened a week ago and are very busy, so they (for now) are only making no topping pizzas to keep up with demand; mid-week you can order toppings. Once they get going a little longer, I am sure this will change On to the wonderful pizza. It has a sweet sauce that is *amazing*. There is cheese layered under the sauce, then finished with a topping of pecorino romano. It had lightly crispy edges and the sourdough crust was thin (think a couple of tortillas size). The pizza was light and had a tasty chew to it. Parking in this shopping center can be difficult - pro tip: if it's after bank hours, park in the Wells Fargo lot. What would I improve? I liked to see additional toppings offered - but hey, they are the experts, not me. read more

Knocked it out of the ballpark with the cheese steak. Out of this world great. Might just be the best one in Delco!!!! I will be back. read more

We tried the square pizza, half plain, half fried onions. Pretty bad. Very little cheese, cardboard crust. Sorry...

Pizza was just ok and for $30 fr a pepperoni pizza I need better than just ok. Also ordered delivery service and pizza box wasn't sealed at all. Would not order again read more

Not gonna lie the grandma pie LOOKED amazing. Fell flat though. Mo one else was there and my pie was ready quick- too quick - wasn't cooked the cheese wasn't melted - dough tasted like it was frozen previously, flat all around taste wise. I don't normally leave reviews unless they are stellar - but I'm hoping this kicks the owners in tha ass - you guys almost have a killer product but this won't last unless you step it up. read more

Malatesta's Italian American Pizza - Grandma Red Pie - Pizza Near Me - Newtown Square, Pennsylvania

We ordered on a weeknight so we could try the expanded selection. The thin crust bar pie was the best out of the three we ordered. The white balsamic was bland, and the pepperoni just ok. We were really looking forward to a new place in town, but it's all hype and no substance. read more

The square grandma cheese pie is simple and fantastic. One of the best pizza's you can find. Grated parm on top is killer. Was ready on time, easy pick-up. Can't wait to get it again. read more

Friendly staff, great pizza! Crispy edged with a nice char and fresh ingredients. Will be back to try the special pizzas. read more

Malatesta's Italian American Pizza - Bar pie - Pizza Near Me - Newtown Square, Pennsylvania

Within a short period of opening it is already top tier in the area. Don't believe there is better pizza in the suburbs. The buff chicken cheesesteak is also elite. Really changed the game for me as far as local options go. read more

Have tried both the round and square. The square we had, half pepperoni, half sausage, is a family Pizza Quest winner! Great crust and very good sausage and pepperoni. It's delicious out of the box but also reheats well. A very welcome addition to the pizza landscape in Newtown Square. read more

Excellent pizza, prepared on time and ready for pickup, crispy crust, good flavor and not greasy. Wish they served it in Casey's.

We had pizza there twice that we ordered and both times it really tasted like aliens and tried different kinds. It appeared that it didn't take long to get the pizza so the wait time was short, but they both seem frozen and all they're doing is heating them up. No other choices about putting toppings on, etc.. I think there's a limited amount on the weekends to pick from. read more

Pizza is really good! We had the bar pie, thin crust with pepperoni. Sauce is really tasty, mildly sweet. Lots of pepperonis. Wish they had breadsticks or a salad or something else. We look forward to coming back! read more

Highly recommend this pizzaria. The Pizza was delicious. The Staff was very accommodating. Reasonably priced. We will definitely return soon. read more

I tried to order a pepperoni pizza on Saturday. They told me they don't do toppings on the weekends. I ordered their red square pi instead boy did it need toppings it was completely flavorless and expensive last time I will be ordering from them read more

Had high hopes but was greatly disappointed. Called ahead, arrived in 10 minutes to pick up and pizza was cold. Definitely reheated, taste was bland. Once and done! read more

Pizza was burnt and flavorless. Tasted like a frozen crust. Too little cheese. Crust had to be pressed to be that think.