Best cheese steak I've found outside the city. Cooper sharp cheese, fresh baked sesame roll toasted to perfection, onions perfectly cooked. 10/10. Have to revisit for pizza read more

Johnny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

My brother and I picked up a few pies for the family while visiting. This place is a hidden gem. My brother and I often complain we can't find a good pizza place like we had growing up in New York. This was it.. We had a margarita, a Sicilian and a half cheese/half pepperoni. Let's just say amongst the 8 of us there were no leftovers. Everyone was praising the food, it was perfectly crispy and tasted amazing. I was really surprised when my brother was boasting about this place. I sure am glad we found it. read more

Cheesesteak was one of the best in the area and has a pretty decent claim to the throne. Roll had a good crunch but super light. Pizza looked and smelled great but flavor was a bit to be desired. Would try again. read more

The best pizza in the area no doubt. Great owners, very passionate staff! I come here all of the time. Garlic knots may be best everrrrrrr read more

Johnny's Pizza - The best - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

Service with a smile. These guys are hustlers in a small sweat shop with great food coming out hot and fresh. I got the pizza fries, which were hands down the best I've eaten. FRESH BASIL a lot of cheese and sauce covering CRISPY fries. Y'all it's a banger! read more

Johnny's Pizza - PIZZA FRIES - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

By far the best cheesesteak I've had in years and possibly ever. Incredibly long wait- we waited 41 minutes for our food. Their flattop stove is way too small for the amount of volume they make. They get packed as soon as they open. Call and order ahead rather than ordering there and waiting if you're able. They open at 11 and weren't taking phone orders. Cheese steak- worth the wait. One of the best I've ever had. Great seasoning and flavor of the steak. Very cheesy Crunchy roll, doesn't get too soggy fast. Square pizza- was meh ok, not anything to rave about. Tons of seasoning which flavors are a bit overpowering. Small seating section in the back- small and dark. Dirty dive bar feeling. The girl at the front was very friendly and helpful. read more

See all

This pizza is so good i can't stop thinking about it. Great dough, perfect sauce to cheese ratio, great guys work there . We've had it a few times now, also their cheese steaks are outstanding as well. I suggest eating in the no frills place, it's so good out of the oven. It's a must have pizza. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Johnnys Pizza. unreal - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

I went back and tried the cheesesteak. There is a reason it's not called Johnny's cheesesteaks. The steak was tender, onions, cooper sharp. Just not as good as the pizza. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Johnny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

Pepperoni square pizza is bomb!! Standard 20 ish minute wait for the pizza cooked fresh. Whether ardmore or Wayne is your local shop both are worth trying. read more

I LOVE a great pizza spot that also slings out great cheesesteaks. A gem that doesn't need the all those advertisements that others depend on. Johnny's has been doing it right ever since they took over the old Pizzi Pizza. Picture this kiddies, fresh sliced rib-eye waiting to be thrown on that grill. Perfect marbleized cut after cut of that rib-eye will give you that great flavor with every bite. Now that I gave you somewhat of a visual of the quality type of meat to expect , lets go a little further. What makes a great sammy? Some say it's the ingredients and prep work. Others say its the establishment and traditions behind it. My friends it is all about that bread, the foundation behind it. That is where you start this masterpiece, and Johnny's has it my friends. Yes the tradition is important, and they follow it to the "T" but it starts with the choice of bread. Now onto that pizza that has me screaming obscenities', literally I'd smack a nun in the mouth for this. Obviously I'd put powdered sugar in my hand to give her that sweet blissful experience. A square pie , simple , easy, throw some sausage on there, and yea this is winning all day. So. Frigging. Good. Add a sesame seed crust with that hot honey drizzle over it, and I'm telling you you'll be moaning. Soft, subtle euphoric moans as your taste buds are going crazy. Ok , as you can see from the other Yelpers we're not lying about this. Sooo just stop reading this, and get in there. read more

See all

I've heard about this place for about a year now, but made my way there a few times. From pizza to cheesesteaks, I've had it all and it's all worth it. It's a place I've brought plenty of co-workers and even my wife. On one occasion, we got there too late and they ran out of those amazing rolls from Merzbachers... So we got an amazing pizza instead. So good, done right. The cheesesteaks are among the best I've ever had and I'll say my favorite, because it's easier to get to than Philly. The roll helps to make it, but the key here is all of the ingredients. They are better ingredients than other places. We should all be fans of places that run out of food. You know you are getting quality when that happens. You can't just have amazing dough laying around. Who wants a roll from a few days ago? Better quality ingredients that take care. It's a guarantee that whatever you have will be fresh and taste better than anything else. read more

Had their pizza and steak sandwich tonight with my grandsons. We all agree that the food was great. The steak sandwich had a really great meaty taste, not like the usual steak sandwich. The pizza has a terrific crust and sauce. The staff were very friendly and helpful. The sandwiches are very big (even the smaller size) so think about sharing. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

We got takeout from here a few weeks ago and wow were we impressed! The cheesesteak was hands down one of the best we've ever had. The portion sizes were huge. We also got the pepperoni pizza which was phenomenal. Wish it was closer and easier to order but we will definitely make a trip back! read more

During a work trip, I decided I wanted to try a Philly cheese steak, after doing some research I decided to check out Johnny's pizza. Service was great! They were very helpful when I asked questions and didn't make me feel like a total rube for not knowing much about cheese steaks. I ended up having a delicious cheese steak and pop! I also liked checking out all of the "art" on the walls. Check this place out if you are in the area, the food is delicious! read more

See all

There are many pizza places in the Bryn Mawr area. This was our first time trying Johnny's. It's located on Lancaster Ave with metered street parking and a municipal lot nearby. They have Coke products. We planned to eat there. We ordered at the counter which overlooks the bustling kitchen area with several people making pizzas and cheesesteaks. There is a seating area in the back. By the time our order was ready, we decided to just take it home. We split a regular size cheesesteak with Cooper sharp cheese. The bread is outstanding- good crunch, not too thick or doughy, and sesame seeds. The meat to cheese ratio is excellent as is the filling to bun. We also tried the round white pizza (without carmelized onions). The crust is thin with a good crunch. They put sesame seeds on the pizza crust, too, which I really like. Both the cheesesteak and pizza were delicious. I highly recommend Johnny's. read more

See all

Five star cheesesteak, three star pizza. I've read a ton of reviews for the grandma style pizzas here--I'm unsure exactly what the fuss is about. It was fine but there are so many good pizza places around, why pick the one you have to call 18 hours in advance? It's difficult to order from here. Most times they'll tell you they're booked solid or it's a 4 hour wait. I called at opening and had a very difficult time getting the person on the phone to understand me. Cost of a pizza + cheesesteak was $46. Best of luck to the business owner, I hope he succeeds, but I'll be going to Felicia's, Crust, and Pica's. read more

Stopped in on Saturday of Dad's day weekend right after opening time. Ordered a round pie with pepperoni. Also added a cheesesteak with Cooper sharp and onions. Now, onto the main event - the pizza! I opted for a round pepperoni , and it did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of char from the oven. The tomato sauce was rich and flavorful, topped with generous slices of fresh mozzarella and fragrant basil leaves. Each bite was a delightful combination of tangy tomato, creamy cheese, and herbal notes. Clearly the best pizza in Western 'burbs. The cheesesteak is similarly phenomenal. Loaded and tangy with that sharp American cheese and seeded roll. I don't eat as many cheesesteaks as I might have at another time, for comparison, but this is near the tippy top. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Round pie with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

Pizza is good but this place has been "sold out" the last three times I've tried to get food here. Really turns me off to coming back.

OK, I have finally had Johnny's at a friend's party. Although not fresh out of the oven the Pizza and Cheese Steaks were very good. The Steaks were a bit different than most local purveyors but different in a good way. I would like to go and try it in person to see how much better it is when I visit. (I hear that getting an order to go is difficult but as I did not order I have no idea if that is true.) read more

After lots of chatter on the Facebook groups about how good this place is, I finally found myself in the area and was able to try it. Called 10:45am on Sunday morning I got through right away and place an order for large square pepperoni and cheesesteak. It was kinda tough to hear over the phone as some loud punk rock playing but ultimately was able to get the order through. I arrived 25 minutes later and paid cash close to $40. Food met every expectation I had. Was delicious and along the lines of power players in the pizza industry: Crust (Havertown), Goats Beard, Pizza Jawn, L'Angola, and Pizzeria Beddia. Expensive in price but highly recommend. You are paying for quality. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Cheesesteak 8" $13 - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

What went well??? EVERYTHING!! Square pizza was amazing and the cheesesteak sandwich was one of the best I've ever had read more

Johnny's Pizza - Square cheese pie - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Have not been back for pizza, but have had the cheesesteak on multiple occasions now and it is amazing! I get the 16", which is about $25 but will easily feed 2-3 people. The seeded roll is lightly toasted, the fried onions cooked perfectly, copper sharp, and a nice chop on enough fresh ribeye that it will have a nice heft when you pick it up. Service has been great every time, the counter and grill people are always quick and kind. Plenty of seating in the back if you want to eat in. I have to try the pizza again but the cheesesteak is so good I have trouble trying anything else. Only issue is the parking. You can sometimes get a lucky street spot or try the lot across the street by the tin lizard. read more

Johnny's Pizza - 16" cheesesteak with Cooper sharp and fried onions. - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Pretty awesome cheesesteak! The meat is seasoned well, the cheese is perfect and the bread is great!! I've only had one other that I thought was better. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

Really yummy cheesesteak! The buffalo chicken pizza was really good too, but the cheesesteak was so good that I'd go straight for that next time. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

The crunchy seeded roll is the best thing about their cheesesteak. Too much meat and too much cheese. Overall a nice flavor, though very salty, and a bit too much cheese. At about $18 - totally ridiculous. Perhaps I'll try again requesting light cheese, less meat and split with a friend. read more

Cheese steak with onions, mushrooms and cooper sharp! First time there on Tuesday 10/16/24. On my way home to Chester Springs, always wanted to stop and try so I did...Glad I Did. Cheese steak Guru's on Facebook have mentioned this spot on several occasions and took some of their (bloggers) advice. If you blink you drive right by and parking can be dicey! But it's worth the trip. Steak chopped but not mush, onions caramelized for nice sweet taste and mushrooms added a bit of earthiness. The cooper sharp just rounds out the flavor of the toasted roll and sesame seeds. 10 inch seeded roll, plenty of meat and it made the 35 minute trip home and was still warm and delicious. My pictures don't do the sandwich justice but it was spot on! Wish I lived closer. I have Gazzos, Gentili's and Pudges near by so I am content! Check them out for sure!! read more

Johnny's Pizza - Mushroom, onion and Cooper Sharp chz steak - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

Johnny's Pizza does not do slices they do not do hoagies. Very good pizza if you're hungry enough for a whole pie really great cheesesteaks.

THE BEST!!! The pizza is seriously amazing and the cheesesteak is the best around. There's nothing in the area that even compares. Get Johnnys! read more

If you are in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania and craving a cheesesteak, Johnny's Pizza offers a solid cheesesteak. The pizza is also very good (it is after all, a pizza place. The name kind of gives that away). Walking up to the simple building, I just knew that I was in for a treat at Johnny's Pizza. It has that old-school vibe and from the outside you can see that this place is the real deal. The staff at Johnny's Pizza is friendly and professional. This is always a plus and the team at Johnny's Pizza helped make the overall experience a better one. I went with a cheesesteak with Cooper Sharp and fried onions. If you are unfamiliar with Cooper Sharp cheese, it is a great melting cheese and a staple in the Philadelphia, Pennsylvania area in general. It is my preferred cheese for cheesesteaks and this cheesesteak certainly did not let me down. This cheesesteak hits you in a primal way. You know you are eating something pretty incredible and savoring every bite. Eating this cheesesteak shows how a cheesesteak can be a culinary wonder. I was very impressed with the cheesesteak at Johnny's Pizza. If you are in the area, this can save a trip to Philadelphia and still enjoy an amazing cheesesteak. Cheesesteaks are something amazing and no trip to this part of the world would be complete without enjoying a cheesesteak. If you are in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, Johnny's Pizza can save you a trip to Philadelphia and you can still get your cheesesteak fix. I love a great cheesesteak and Johnny's Pizza definitely delivers a great cheesesteak. The pizza is definitely good, as well. Go check out Johnny's Pizza for yourself, I am confident that you will be impressed. I give Johnny's Pizza five stars overall. read more

Pizza is delicious. The thin crust is rolled and tossed out just right. They have seating to sit in and eat but it's set up better for to go orders. The hot wings were fried crispy before being tossed in the sauce which made them really good. I wish they had more beverage options but the bottled root beer I had was tasty. The seating area is adorned with signatures and messages from patrons on the wall. It's a cute concept for the space. Overall a good experience but if you're eating in the parking can be tricky!! read more

Johnny's Pizza - In the seating area of Johnny's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

ordered $145. worth of steak sandwiches and one pizza.l, and fries. Pizza was ok. Definitely an adult style pizza. It was a larger order so the nice girl on the phone read it back to me. They totally screwed up my order putting hot peppers on everything that I asked for on the side. Even when removing them, sandwich was too hot for the family of 4 kids. What I did ask for was onions. Where there any, nope! and when my wife asked for an extra bag because the french fries dripping with grease soaked through the bag. You would have thought I put a gun to his face! He gave us a horrible nasty look! Are you kidding me? never again- you guys blew it big time! read more

I HAD to check out what all of the foodies were posting about on social media. I did my research beforehand and called my order in early. They kindly told me my square would be done in about an hour (on a Tuesday evening). Slid thru to pick up and it's your normal pizza spot. The cashiers were really nice and the price wasn't half bad. I got a square pizza half cheese half sausage w/ hot honey. You can definitely taste the fresh ingredients and the lovin in the dough. They were skimpy on the sausages and the cheese so it messed up the vibe. Now that I see they're good for cheesesteaks I'll try that next time. read more

Neighborhood place that makes it feel like home in a new city. Cheesesteaks are wonderful - fresh, soft/crispy seeded role, perfect long hots and onions, steak is superb. Similarly, pizza is fresh and filling. Tough to beat combo. Highly recommend. read more

Wow. Forget the overhyped spots in the city, Johnny's is the place to go for all your cheesesteak and pizza needs. I was first introduced to their pizza through a pizza bracket party that I hosted, where Johnny's made it to the semifinals and probably could have won had it not been for crust pizza (Havertown), another heavy hitter. But the pizza was delicious, with a crisp, tasty crust and great sauce and ingredients, so I knew I had to go there and try more. I was feeling more cheesesteaky today, so went and followed reviewers' advice and got the cooper sharp cheese and fried onions, and when I say this was one of the best cheesesteaks I've had, I really mean it! The sesame roll is crisp and lightly toasted, thick but not too thick, and the meat is the perfect texture, thoroughly coated in their delicious cheese. At other places, I often add ketchup because their steaks are a little bland, but no ketchup was needed in this case--the flavors shined on their own! The quality of the cheesesteak and its individual ingredients was impressive. If I ever have friends visiting from out of town, I will recommend this place to them! None of those tourist traps. Service was friendly and pretty fast (I ordered in person right when they opened on a weekday). There's some seating and a smallish bathroom and crayon/marker all over the walls, and one old school fighting arcade game, so if you wanna sit and eat, you can, but you probably wouldn't go for the ambiance. The food and service though? Absolutely. read more

Johnny's Pizza - Cheesesteak (look at that bread!) - Pizza Near Me - Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania

See all

We enjoyed this, a great spot for our cheesesteak tour while in the area for the We Run The World flag football tourney..

You will taste the quality ingredients in your first bite! Johnnys is the real deal!! I can say without reservation that it is one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had, so no need to travel into Philly if Johnny's is within reach. Flavor filled ribeye steak sliced to perfection (and void of any gristle), blended with smooth and creamy Cooper Sharp Cheese and perfectly grilled onions...surrounded by a fresh baked and ever so slightly chewy seeded roll... will have you thanking God for the founding fathers and the inventor of the Philly cheesesteak! One bite of the pizza and you'll be wondering if it wasn't delivered through the back door by a little old lady straight off a boat from Italy! The sauce is so fresh and perfectly balanced that you'll find yourself wanting more of it... to eat it with a spoon. Cheers to Johnny and "pizza master" Jason for serving up top shelf quality food that you won't soon forget! read more

Walked in to get a to-go order at the predicted time. When we got there they said it would be just a moment. They then served 2 other customers who came in after us and 20min later said "what order are you waiting for again?" And it turns out the food has been sitting on top the oven the whole time and was cold when we got home. I'm ok with mistakes but this was just ridiculous given the $100 price for 2 pies and a side. read more

Best cheesesteak I've ever had, no question. The smoked cooper sharp version is spectacular!

Elite pizza, elite cheesesteak. Best of both on the Main Line. Pizza is maybe a little pricy but totally worth it. Clearly homemade and has the perfect set of ingredients and textures. Crust is crispy, maybe a little overdone for some people but that's the way I like it. The cheesesteak is phenomenal, even for Philly. This place has a small, dingy, college like interior, so maybe not for everyone, but you're not here for anything other than the food. The small size means they sometimes sell out or are far too busy and can't take orders, so make sure you plan ahead if you want to eat here. There's a reason it's busy! read more

The pizza unbelievable & the cheesesteak was to die for! Give them a try- just delicious!