Delicious pizza delicious service I got the turkey pepperoni, it came hot and ready like Caesars little Caesars five dollar special you know, but I walked in while I was doing a test drive nearby of a jeep Wrangler... I was like what is the Santino's place? The ambience was awesome. They have the Grinch theme for the holidays and I tried the pizza before I left burnt my mouth, but it was so good good so fresh. I put red pepper and pepperonis on mine. read more

My dad always loves to try local pizza shops and since he was in town we decided to check out this place. They were decked out for Halloween and decorated on a whole other level than any other place (other than a haunted house). The service was okay. The guy at the front desk was friendly, but seemed to not provide direction. I had to ask if we could sit down or if it was a takeout restaurant only. The pizza also took over 30 minutes to prepare which I felt was a long time for two personal pan sized pizzas. The pepperoni was really greasy and something we wouldn't order again. But the grilled chicken was awesome. It was surprisingly flavorful and perfectly cookies, it complemented the white pizza and fresh tomatoes well. I'd definitely go back and order this one again. Overall I'd say the experience was good, but for the price and service I felt more was desired. I wish they were more upfront that it's less of a sit down restaurant and more self-serve type of style. read more

Santino's Pizzeria - White pizza with grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

As usual me and my boyfriend got our cheese pizza which is ALWAYS amazing. Come to find out they have mac and cheese bites now. Let me tell you these mac and cheese bites were phenomenal, 10/10 will definitely get more soon. The service there is always immaculate and the workers are always so welcoming when we come in to order too. read more

Ordered pizza for delivery at 8:15. Was supposed to be delivered at 9:00. At 9:30 still no pizza so I drove to Santinos. They were closed. Signs say open until 11:00. They charged my credit card. Don't think they will stay in business with service like this. They better reverse the charge on my credit card. TERRIBLE!!! read more

Not sure if I ordered from here on an off night, but I tried this place out recently with a pizza delivery order and honestly didn't get the best first impression of the food. While the pep and cheese pizza I got was pretty standard and tasted decent, I cannot describe it as anything but a grease bomb. The crust was so soaked wet with grease you could not hold a slice up without everything just falling apart or sliding off. Once the pizza cooled down, there was a physically tangible thick, waxy, layer of congealed grease coating the bottom-side crust that made leftovers totally inedible. I know it's pizza, it's always greasy, but this was like "I could only eat this while blackout drunk" level greasy. On the positive side, our delivery driver was really fantastic - so nice and friendly, and I appreciate the sense of humor the company has (ie. the recent "now hiring - non-stupid people" sign fiasco in the headlines). I hate to critique a local business so harshly, but, dang it, Santino! read more

I'm actually just super pumped that they do not hire stupid people. It's a relief to see a business out there with standards. For the record: they, and I, are talking about stupidity as a self-inflicted wound. Most manifested stupidity is preventable, but the one manifesting it just doesn't bother. Great pizza, great service, great value, would return again any day of the week. read more

Odd taste, few topping and crust was not done enough. Will not order again.

More than just a meme; it's really good pizza. Got a 16" hand tossed pepperoni pie delivered. Tons of cheese and tiny "cup" pepperonis with tasty sauce and a thick outer crust that was perfect for dipping (the garlic sauce is good) Only downside is the large slices were sloppy with most of the front falling off. Needed a fork but tasted fantastic read more

Placed an order, went to pick it up and they were closed. I have called to get a refund repeatedly, and was told a manager has to help me, yet there never seems to be a manager there. Every time they say they will leave a message with the manager. It's been over a week and I have not received a call back or refund. read more

Good pizza, great customer service. Kudos for funny "now hiring" poster :D neat & simple interior.

Good food and great service .. one of best in the neighborhood . Would recommend people to try it ..

excellent service and very tasty food. They also DO NOT hire STUPID PPL read more

After receiving a menu at home I decided to try Santino's out. They do have online ordering but it was kind of a pain to use. I ended up calling my order in for pickup. Based on the menu and their prices I expected the Pizzeria to be fancy. Walking in, it definitely wasn't that. It is a small space with limited seating. There was nothing really fancy that stood out. I got my pizza and chicken wings and left. The chicken wings were alright. The pizza was really good but it was expensive. Based on the prices compared to what you get (good pizza but small portions unless you pay more) it is not a place I will go to often. read more

awesome place and i love that they are hiring non-stupid people.. what a bonus! and the pizza was delicious of course!

I love this place. I feel it may be my favorite in town. I just love the pepperoni they use on this pizza. The cheese is very nice as well as the sauce. If you dine in, it's very cozy. Comfortable booth style seats with chairs and tables in the center. The subs are excellent as well. The customer service is great!!!! read more

The food here seems good but the service is awful. I ordered two subs on three separate occasions and was told 15-20 only to wait 45-50 minutes each time! When I call about them they just say they are working on it. I was told last time that they were closed for four days and didn't have anything ready. Then why open if you can't serve? There are too many other places to try to keep wasting our time and money here. $26 for two subs is way overpriced anyway. read more

Came in from a recommendation from a good friend. New to the area and looking for a solid pizza place. Was greeted rudely after waiting for ten minutes. Order was incorrect, took another 25 minutes to fix. The place looks good but other than looks I don't have any positives. Would not recommend. read more

I work very close to santinos and since i love pizza and subs like no other its about time i try this joint out. The 3 stars is for the sub. Although the 6 inch is very small it packed a punch. So small by the time i got to the first traffic light it was gone. I guess its the selection of meats and toasted bun made the difference. As for the pizza goes, ill pass on it next time. If u like CHEF BOY R D pizza sauce u will love this place. I dont. Ill go back for an italian sub but ill order a 12 inch next time read more

Santino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Ordered small pizza, cheese sticks, pasta salad and wings well done. got correct pizza but everything else was completely wrong. not sure what the disconnect is bc we called in and placed the order directly with an associate. will never go back read more

This was my second time ordering from here and I had another great experience! I ordered a large pizza with their original crust with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions. My boyfriend and I devoured the pizza! It was really delicious and I will continue ordering from them!! The delivery order was on time as well. read more

Santino's Pizzeria - Large pizza-original crust, with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

It's okay pizza. Not good not bad just okay. The sub was pretty pathetic. Harley any meat at all and as far as dressing it was laughable. Go to dominos probably better read more

I love the updated decor and bar. I hate that they only do personal pizzas now. They just aren't as good. Service is wonderful and some of the pasta dishes are good. But please bring back the larger pizzas..the smaller ones are just now done as well. read more

The Italian sub was excellent. Antipasto salsa plentiful, tasty and spot on. Ordering was easy and customer service was attentive and friendly. Pizza sub was delicious and tasty. The food is really good and portions are plentiful. Nice job ! read more

Top notch service and great food! Wouldn't expect anything less from people who are not stupid! Love it!

First time with this restaurant. I ordered the fettuccine alfredo with chicken and mozzarella sticks on the side. When I got home, there was no chicken in the fettuccine alfredo. The mozzarella sticks were ok. Very disappointed. read more

Great food. Fun clean atmosphere. Food is definitely fresh and top grade ingredients.

We are so glad we found this place! The thin crust pizzas are excellent! My husband had the Fettuccine Alfredo, and loved it! We will be back to try the subs and anti pasta salad! Already planning my next visit here! Tonight my husband had spaghetti! Awesome and the meatball was huge and delicious. read more

Darn, what a disappointment. I was really hoping that this place would be my next go-to pizza joint on the west-side, but service, quality, and product just fell completely short. First issue--We stopped by, the place wasn't busy. It has an interesting décor of naval and maritime. A little different, but heck, if Flyers can have planes, why can't another pizza joint have boats? However, the décor wasn't really an issue by any means.... The fact we entered, and had three teenagers gawking at a computer screen, instead of acknowledging they had customers.... Issue. In fact, we were greeted by someone in the back of the house who happened to peer from behind the wall. We ordered at the counter, were told to sit and they'd get our drinks, which translated to.... Please sit down, and I will hand you a Styrofoam cup and you can get your own damn drinks. This place has some cool games like chess, checkers, etc to entertain while you're here, and you'll need it. It took our order a VERY long time to be made, and we were the only diners.... Didn't really hear a lot of delivery orders, so I didn't know if perhaps that was the hold up. The product was finally delivered, but extremely disappointing. Due to hunger, we ingested, but were neither pleased, nor excited. The pizza is floppy, greasy, and tastes like pizza you'd pick up at one of those pizza vendors at the fair. We ordered mozzarella sticks, which were baked, but not well... they were floppy, and covered in seasoning, while the breading just flaked off. Come on y'all, you can at least invest in a small fry daddy. That's just cheap and not providing any quality with your product. Another thing that kinda irked me was the fact they were complaining about a previous customer ( a bad customer I would agree), but that's not good conversation to be immersed it, when you have people in your dining room. It just comes off as unprofessional... keep it for the back of the house, or at home. A family run place from what I could hear, which is a shame they could not deliver well. I'm always for supporting local above chains, but these guys have some MAJOR work still. Cannot recommend. read more

Santino's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

i ride by this place almost everyday and thought I'd give them a try. I ordered an Italian Sub & Potatoe Skins and I wasn't impressed with either, the skins were undercooked. I also noticed an employee making a pepperoni pizza and he didn't have any gloves on. Will never go back, much better options in the area. read more

Tried this place on a whim and wanting to try a new place. Man, they are soooo good. Especially the wings, my husband never eats chicken but tried their wings and fell in love. I had the bbq wings and the sauce was amazing!!! The pizza was perfect and we got classic cheese with half pepperoni. I can't wait to try the rest of the menu. Everything was a hit. Such good prices and super fast for pizza. This is my favorite pizza shop now. read more

Where to start took nearly 2 hrs to get my food when I did get it driver was not wearing a mask it was luke warm at best and burnt my 4 yr old daughter ate pepperoni and cheese off her pizza cause the crust was so hard she wouldnt even eat her normal bacon pizza because the bacon hurt her teeth it was too hard my sub was decent I feel like if it was hot it had potential to be really good not sure about spaghetti wife hasn't tried it yet... managers response " I'm sorry it's your first night on a Friday night" yea first and last time I ever order from santinos I worked at pizza hut over 8 yrs and never put out product like this nor treated costumers that way read more

See all

We absolutely love their Hot Brown Pizza! After living in Louisville, KY years ago, we were very surprised to find it here. Thank you for making it Santinos! read more

Santino's is SO good. The pizza is very reasonably priced and it is worth every dollar when you taste it. The quality is fresh and the staff is so nice. I love supporting locally owned places and encourage you too as well. I don't post at all on here but felt this was necessary :) read more

Santino's Pizzeria - Santinos is always SO GOOD. The price is very reasonable for being locally owned and it's value comes out in the taste. So worth it! - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Really like their pizza! Flavorful sauce that is there enough to tastes, not sparse as if they spread a single drop around, right amount of toppings. If you like sausage they have great tasting meatballs on there. Then there is the crust...probably considered thin but great flavor, tastes fresh and the bottom has a crispness to it and has never been burnt and yet a soft freshness. I used to go to Zamerellis but the service and crazy wait times made me try Santinos and glad I did, enjoy the quality and the customer service is WAY better. If you haven't had it, try it. Subs aren't bad either but I stick to the pep mushroom and sausage read more

It worked. Ok pizza. Good staff and didn't charge for extra sauce. If you are wanting really good pizza don't go here. But if you need to get the job done go for it . I was a bit drunk so I can't remember if it was a good value. read more

I tried their pizza for the first time today and I loved it!! It is actually different and they use real pepperoni!! So good! Also, I'm not normally a crust guy and usually leave it at the end, but I really liked their crust and I ate every bite. Next time I am bringing my dad because he loves pizza with real pepperoni. He refuses to eat anything else!! Also, just want to say that this is the one in Columbus, Ohio. read more

Absolutely the worst customer service ever! We've ordered from them on a regular basis and have let several wrong orders slide by because they aren't a chain and we didn't want to be "Karen's". Well after last night I just have to!!! Ordered a basic pepperoni pizza and was quoted 30 minutes. Husband shows up at that time, after working a 14 hour shift at work, and was told it would be 8 more minutes. Great, he has a seat and waits. He was then informed that they needed to go to the storage to get a box for our pizza because they had none?! You wait till a pizza is out of the oven past the 30 minutes quoted to realize there are zero boxes to put it in?!?! He continues to wait while the trip to get a box is made. Once the girl returns with a box she is laughing and saying how she had to stop to help someone get their lawnmower unstuck and that's what took so long. At this point we are at an hour and 10 minutes for this pizza. She was then going to proceed to box this same pizza that had been sitting there this whole time getting cold and stale, while she's out helping someone on a lawnmower. Called the business to speak with the owner and the guy who answered the phone was very rude and told me to write a letter and send it to the owner since I have the address. This establishment never looks busy and now I understand why! We won't be going back and apparently not many others do either. read more

The BEST local place for handmade pizzas and sub sandwiches! A definite favorite of my whole family. read more

See all

Haven't been here since they opened, although for no particular reason. I remembered the pizza was good so thought we'd have it for something different than our usual. Fresh hot pizza... Good tasting ingredients on the sausage and pepperoni and the mozzarella cheese was 'authentic' tasting. I would've liked a little more sausage but that may just be the meat lover in me speaking. Very nice service even though was about 10 minutes longer than the 20 minutes I was told. 12 inch Italian sub was very good. I will be back and I recommend that you at least try it and decide for yourself! read more

Really good pizza. Nice thick cheese, crispy crust, not too doughy, only thing that kept it from a five star was it could use a little bit more sauce then it would be perfect!! I'll just have to ask for extra next time cause I'll for sure go back! Originally a 4 star so a Few months later got extra sauce and it was really good! read more