If you're grabbing a slice, skip the special. 1 slice will fill you up. And never mind with the pepperoni. Bland and average. The sauce and cheese, however, good stuff. read more

This is my favorite local place to grab a slice. They're quick and relatively cheap (slice of cheese & slice of roni came to $4.90 today). The roni is a little spicier than other place, so i I dig it. Last time I came here I was meeting a friend at City Feed and I texted her to tell her I'd be late and she asked where I was to which I responded "same old place'. Heh heh heh. I do wish JP had late night pizza options though. read more

Fast delicious generous and convenient. They have mozzarella sticks and great Sicilian. what more do you need?

Love this place! Super yummy pizza and fries! Super friendly people who work here! I caught a situation where a man came in to use the bathroom not realizing its a bathroom for customers only. One of the people who worked there kindly mentioned it to him and then turned that situation into a friendly one asking him if he had caught any fish ( having come from Jamaica pond) and joking around with the man and wishing him to have a nice day! How friendly was that! Overall, I really enjoy coming here into a friendly environment and great food! read more

Just not the cheapest or best tasting pizza/food around. With that said, they have the best staff. The younger guys working there are awesome people and have become personal friends. So, you shouldn't feel bad about going here. And if you do, drop these guys a tip, they work long hours and are always smiling. read more

Me? I love pizza in all shapes and forms! I particularly love thin crust pizza, cooked well, with delicious sauce and cheese blends--and the Same Old Place keeps that love alive for me without even working hard at it. It true that I may be biased because my family has been getting pizza and subs from here for as long as I can recall. The food is tasty, well-portioned, quickly prepared, and always reliable. A staple at our parties--their fried eggplant pizza is ridiculously yummy and uncomplicated. Subs and dinners are your standard sub shop fare but the ambience and authenticity of your local sub shop experience is only rivaled by JP House of Pizza a few blocks down. I give the Same Old Place 5 stars for it's consistently delicious food, simplicity, and value--and I encourage you to give it a try with a drop-in-slice! read more

They have great pizza and great subs. I'm from New York, pizza is better there. It's a fact of life. But as far as Boston goes, I'm pleased to say that this is a suitable substitute. I really like their sausage parm and veal cutlet parm. Also, the fact that they're super close to me is a huge plus. read more

Best Pizza in JP. Only Pizzaria Regina can beat it. Subs are oj, but it is the pizza that makes this place so special. FOrget the slices. Order a pie and enjoy! PS-Service is VERY good, and that says something about a pizza joint! read more

I am originally from New York, and certainly ate my share of pizza growing up. I love Same Old Place. Thin crust, sweet sauce, cheese that is salty enough without overdoing it. Atmosphere is utterly casual - I used to go with friends to split a pie and watch Jeopardy. Good times. Been going here for close to 15 years, and I'll continue going for as long as I live in Boston. The only thing that might beat it is my hometown fave, Junior's Pizza in Huntington, NY. Until they move here, you can find me at SOP. read more

These guys are a gem. Anyone who knows their history, knows that. They are just a great bunch of people. And the food is about as good as you can get from a take-out Italian place. The pizza, though a bit variable, is generally excellent and rivals some of the best in the city. It's not gourmet, but if you're looking for a good New York-style pie, this is as good a place as any. Always a pleasure. The only thing that keeps me from giving them four stars is the prices. When you have so many other decent pizza places in the area, it pays to be competitive. Why would I pay $17 for a two topping pizza from SOP when I can get one for $11 from Zesto's just up the street? The pizza isn't as good at Zesto's, but we're talking almost 50% more in price for SOP. What gives? That and they don't do normal sized calzones. It's large (and $16) or nothing. For shame. I truly hope that some day I can bump this review to four stars and happily eat here at least a couple days a week. Fingers crossed. In the mean time, their price per slice is pretty good, so I'll just stick with that. read more

Useless. I'd understand the slight disregard for customers if they offered amazing food or a unique experience, but they offer an okay slice of pizza and shitty service. If you like being ignored at the counter, don't want your call picked up, or like to sit on hold endlessly in your attempts to support local business... go here. If you want a decent slice of pizza and to be a valued customer go elsewhere. At this point even Dominos is better. read more

They have a very tempting menu, but I have to admit that I've only had the pizza thus far. And that is because it is delicious. read more

Great Food! The only thing is they need to order more steak tips on a regular basis! But if you get the chance to try them, you'll never stop getting them! The pizza is phenomenal! read more

Some of the best pizza in the Boston area, and the steak sub is addicting. As good as you can expect from a neighborhood pizza joint. read more

Great for luch break time- located right on center street... MBTA accessible I love their pizza by the slice, for some strange reason it tastes better than the whole pie?!?!? *** breakfast there is fast, cheap, and delicious too! (ONLY TILL 11AM) Tito is awesome they know me there as Gijo---- tell them gijo sent you! read more

This is the best pizza in town. Do not go there because you want to be impressed by the service. Go there if you want a mean slice for cheap. You can also wash your pizza down with $2-$4 beers. I can't say anything about the rest of their menu. Every time I go there I get an immediate craving for pizza. read more

There's a sign that days, 'Order Pizzas here' but unlike most places, you also pay there too. So you need to be prepared to order and wait at the same place. Great cheese pizza slices. read more

Same Old Place - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts

Exactly what you expect to find in every neighborhood: a dependable sub shop. Great for hangovers or guilty pleasures. Nothing they make is perfect, but it's not trash either. The portions fit right in line with the price as well. The large sub is nearly 18" long! And the large pizza is massive. My go-to's are the steak & cheese sub (with onion, always get it with onion. In fact, if you're ordering a steak & cheese and not getting onion, then you're doing it wrong. Trust me on this) and the super pizza. My only gripes are that they sometimes miss the little things (hots on the side, pizza got a little lopsided). To sum up: don't order from this place when you want to impress your visiting mother. Order when you and your significant other are focusing on more important things and you want to feed yourselves quickly. read more

Got the steak and cheese calzone. It was pretty good. Judge for yourself. The eggplant parm sub was also pretty good. The blue cheese dressing was sub par but still overall a 4 star experience. read more

The pizza at Same Old Place is incredibly excellent and they definitely have the best ones in Jamaica Plain! You will not be disappointed, particularly if you get one of their specialty pizzas. My all-time favorite is the Veggie Special with added roasted chicken - absolutely delicious!! :-) read more

I think Same Old Place's pizza is just great. I am also from New York (where the pizza is better) but in as far as Boston Pizza goes, I'll eat here. I found the pizza is repeatedly better than Ideal, Zesto's, Cappy's, Boston's House of Pizza, Uno, Bella Luna and Penguin. I liked Il Mondo, but since I only went there once I can't rate it yet. I have also had the Greek salad here which was very good, but a little pricey. I think my number 1 reason for giving this place 5 stars is the cold beer on tap. I am not used to dive places having anything more than bottles. This really sets them apart. If you are in the area, stop in and try it out. I haven't ordered take out yet so I can't rate that. read more

Great pizza, fast delivery service, no complaints. Their Italian sub, which I've eaten at the establishment, is also pretty good. I agree with other reviewers though that the place could use a little bit of an upgrade. read more

Hands down the closest you'll ever get to a mouthwatering, thin and crispy crust topped with perfectly balanced sauce and cheese without trekking all the way to Manhattan, where pizza like this is sold at $1 or $2 a slice at places dotted around the island like Dunkin' Donuts in Boston. Simple, straightforward, generous slices that aren't dripping with grease. Are you hungry yet? I've never had anything but the pizza here, mostly because their vast menu is somewhat overwhelming considering the small kitchen they have. The place could use a bit of an update, but then again you're here for the pizza, not for the elegant dining experience. They keep the place clean and prep areas look respectably clean from in front of the counter. I live a block away right now, but I'm happy to call Same Old Place my go-to place for pizza no matter where I find myself living in Boston if/when I move from here. read more

Wow, I've been walking and driving past this place for years, but only thought to try their pizza last night, and I was amazed. This is just like the pizza I knew and loved in New York as a kid. The crust was light, yet crisp, with a perfect combination of tomato sauce and cheese. It was perfection. I found myself thinking about that slice of pizza I'd had all day, and just came back this evening with my girlfriend and once again: perfect pizza! My girlfriend ordered the Gluten-free Pizza, and agrees--this pizza definitely warrants 5 stars! read more

See all

I've lived in Jamaica Plain my whole life and Same Old Place is the ONLY place I ever come for pizza. My fave is to get the 2 slice special with a small drink. The pizza crust is cruspy and thin, cheese is gooey with just the righty amount of sauce. Love love love! read more

Ordered Buffalo tenders and a Greek salad. The salad is wilted and the "tenders" are paper thin pieces of chicken with soggy breading--5% chicken and 95% breading. I would avoid this abomination if at all possible. Might as well head to your local dumpster to see what's in there--it would be better than this garbage. read more

The food here is overall pretty good. And now they serve beer, yaay! Some of the pizza guys have pretty stinky attitudes. Maybe it's the extreme heat of the ovens, I don't know. I remember one day I was waiting to order a "slice special" and one of the guys there asked me if I had an "eye problem". He looked like he was ready to deck me. Then pizza guy #2 apologized to me and said "sorry he's having a rough day". So, I'll be careful about how I make eye contact next time, else I'll be "sleeping with the fishes". read more

This is a perfect pizza joint! - $7 pitchers of cheap beer (their pitchers serve 3.5 glasses) - $9 pitchers of yummy beer (my first Oktoberfest of the season, baby!) - DELICIOUS pizza. Its thin and floppy with a perfect cheese to sauce ratio! - Awesome staff* - they're really nice and have a good sense of humor. Any time we ask if they have something, if we can mix and match, etc. the answer is something to the effect of "Yeah, we can make that work" with a warm grin. The downside for me is that this place is two bus rides away from my place, but if I'm in JP, I'm going here! *While the staff rocks, they seem to be incredible OVERstaffed. Every time we go here there are usually only a few other people in the place, but they consistently have 10 people behind the counter. But hey, do your thang Same Old Place:) read more

Sandwiches here are kinda just ok. Pretty servicable and cheap pizza, definitely a place to pop in for a slice if you're in the vicinity and you're craving a cheap bite. I've had pizza here enough to know if I like it or not, notably once or twice from the optimal departure point of pizza criticism, the fresh out-of-the-oven slice pie. It was good but it was merely that. If you're willing a trek up to hyde square, Slice O Pie has this place beat for pizza. If not, stop in. Tradition and history of this establishment shows they won't be tinkering with the formula too much, if at all. And by all means choosing this over Domino's or Papa John's goes without question. read more

The reasons for giving same old place three stars? Well, first off, it takes so much time before the pizza get prepared, Secondly, the place is always crowded, so there's barely any place to sit down. Thirdly, the pizza has so much grease, it makes you want to pass out. Fourth, and sadly lastly, you should only go to same old place if your craving is to get a stomach pump to suck out all that grease, or if you're on the streets, and you're lucky enough to buy something warm, otherwise, Papa Gino's is your best bet for to die for pizza. Should be ok for kids under 14. read more

Giving 4 stars because it's exactly what you would expect from first glance and smell. Pretty cheap decent food that does not disappoint or surprise in any way. Not everything on yelp needs to be "amazing" but in no way do I dislike SOP. Their more conventional options are much better than their contemporary additions (wraps, etc). read more

I LOVE SAME OLD PLACE! It's the BEST Pizza in boston! Everyone who works there is so nice and friendly! you can tell it's a neighborhood hang out when I walk in I feel like I'm part of the neighborhood. The best pizza! Let me say that again the best pizza! I've been treating myself to the 2 slice of cheese pizza and can of soda for $5 dollar special for the past 3 years. Tonight I tried grub hub for the 1st time( super easy)...I ordered buffalo chicken fingers(amazing) and of course because Same old place is so busy that my dressing was forgotten(I understand, it happens) When I called they were so nice and apologetic and I really appreciate that they brought me another one because I know they're having a busy night. I love same old place and I know you will too!! read more

Ordered a cheese burger sub with Curley fries & a cheese burger. The dries burger I ever had. Very disappointed. First time ordering & last read more

Same Old Place - Vermont burger with Curley fries - Pizza Near Me - Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts

Same old place is my favorite pizza. I moved to JP in 1984 from New York and Same Old Place's pizza kept me from being homesick. The sauce is delicious! The crust is New York style and delicious! The cheese.... you got it...delicious! It's the best neighborhood pizza joint in town! read more

The name pretty much says it all it's the same old flavor, same old dough, and same old slow delivery service. I ordered a half cheese half hamburger and it was blah with too much red sauce, a salad and Italian sub everything is just a little less than average. The prices are fair and they give napkins. At least they don't set your expectations too high it's just the same olde place in every way! read more

I really want to get take out from Same old Place, but every time I walk by one or more staff are visible from the sidewalk and not wearing a mask. I really like their pizza but I am not taking the risk. read more

I love the breakfast burrito here. It's super cheap and fills you up nicely. The pizza is good as well, as are the sandwiches. I think the best part though is the price of everything. I seriously think this place competes for having the cheapest pint of Sam in Boston. read more

Best slice comparison to a NY slice. Crust is very good, a dealbreaker for me. Perfectly flaky without being buttery, fold this shit up, and it fills me up quick. Just wish they had free refills, but their overall-low prices warrant that. read more

The place is kind of a cool hole-in-the-wall. I got a combo with two slices of cheese pizza and a soda for less than seven bucks. The pizza is your typical east-coast-style fair - thin, light sauce, chewy, foldable, and greasy. It gets four stars for the value. read more

I took my daughter here for breakfast one Saturday morning. The breakfast was a well done, standard American breakfast. But the owner was a total a-hole. He was super rude to his staff, grimaced a lot and kept addressing the old lady patrons with things like 'look lady' and 'hey lady'. So even though I liked the food, I don't want to give money to the owner. read more