Great pizza! Best we have had in that area. It's a little loud because it wide open but the pizza makes up for that. The service was great.

Kept putting off a visit because every time I looked at the lot it was PACKED. Finally, decided to give it a go for a late lunch. When we arrived we realized that they are probably NEVER packed, most of the parking is likely folks visiting the plumbing store next door. So, find a parking spot and give it a go. The waitress and cashier were super nice. The food was pretty quick and pretty reasonable. I ordered the cheese sticks & marinara because another table did the same. No regrets there. It was very tasty but could have been left in the frier longer as it was a rubbery bounce rather than a chewy gooey. For lunch I had the meatball sub. I ordered the small and got what I ordered: small. Pro-tip: order the large. I will next time. The meatball sub was very delicious. I only wish I would have split fries with my lunch partner as it was a bit lonely. But, that was on me. Definitely a spot I'll try more of the menu of. read more

Sal's Italian Pizza - Small Meatball & Cheese sub. Tasted great! Order large - trust me. - Italian Near Me - Kilmarnock, Virginia

See all

We haven't been to Sals for a couple years because we had moved out of town. We're back in town and my wife, who has eliminated pizza from her diet decided treat herself with pizza. So we picked Sals, and were glad we did. They were not busy so we were waited on quickly.The pizza took a little longer than usual, but that was because it slightly overcooked. I would of sent it back but I decided to taste it first. Personally I throughly enjoyed it, and told my wife that if I could do 4.5 stars, I would, but I can't. So 4 stars on the pizza. My wife said that she thought it was 3 stars, she said it was good but she could taste the burnt, then she turned a piece showed the burnt bottom. But we both did enjoy it, just one of us more than the other. Personally I don't enjoy most pizzas places, but Sals makes a great pizza and when you get 4 stars or even 3 for that matter on a burnt pizza, the pizza must be pretty dang good. Yes I could of complained and they would of made another and probably discounted it. But we enjoyed it. I will let them know the next time to play attention to our pizza. read more

Sal's Italian Pizza - Large pizza, pepperoni, onions, black olives, Canadian bacon, mushrooms, and half with pineapple - Italian Near Me - Kilmarnock, Virginia

Very nice people, but just too much dough and not enough toppings on pizza. I just personally prefer a thinner crust.

Ordered a Philly cheesesteak with onions and tomatoes. For takeout. Got home and there's no cheese on the cheese steak. Called them back and they said I only ordered onions and tomatoes. I said I ordered a Philly cheesesteak with onions and tomatoes they argued with me on the phone and would not provide any compensation or discount for another visit. I guess when you order a Philly cheesesteak and they ask you what you want on it you gotta make sure you say you want cheese. Ordering a cheesesteak does not mean you'll get cheese at this location. Skip this place zero customer service. read more

So yummy!!! Nice vibes!! Fun games! Great juke box! Lovely service! Best pizza around!

Sal's pizza was ok. The crust was a little thick for my liking but the pepperoni pizza was good. The combination wasn't that great and I would avoid that. I would go back to eat it but not to take it home again. read more

Please, people said this pizza was great. I read the reviews. 21.00 for a pizza that the website says is 18.50 to begin, canned mushrooms sparsely sprinkled on an already so so pizza. safe yourself the trouble. I strongly disagree. I love pizza but not Sals pizza. place sux. one star because I can't put ZERO. BAM! read more

Dont bother. The service is slow. They mess up the orders more often than they get them right and you are in for a disappointment.

Been going there since I was a kid. Pizza is really good. Drive at least once a month from Mathews for it.

We use to like this place for pizza. The last couple times the pizza was terrible, too much crust and little ingredients. I called to inquire and asked to speak to the manager and was promptly asked why?, then I was told she was busy. I asked if the recipe had changed recently and I received a very rude response. Will not be returning and will let others know............... read more

We really like Sal's... best pizza in the area, by far and fairly priced. Nice yeasty crust and tasty sauce, just add your choice of toppings. Our fav is Sal's combo. Try it! read more

Just visiting the Northern Neck and wanted take-out pizza. Found Sal's with a web search. Ordered two pizzas-really outstanding! The crust is just right - not too thin, not too thick, and cooked perfectly. Good balance of sauce and cheese, and good toppings. Really delicious! Ready in 20 minutes. I highly recommend them! read more

Great Pizza. Ordered a large pepperoni. Love the abundance of flour on the bottom of crust.

Stopped in here after a little shopping trip. Turned out to be a nice local restaurant with really friendly service. We shared a pizza - I give it a 5 stars and hubby rates it a 3 because he didn't think the balance of ingredients was what it should be. All fresh ingredients and a homemade crust - really good! If you're looking for a good solid local restaurant, give Sal's a try! read more

Sal's Italian Pizza - All mushroom and green peppers; half sausage and half onion. - Italian Near Me - Kilmarnock, Virginia

We think this is the best pizza joint in Kilmarnock, highly recommend! Extra cheese for the win!

Sals pizza never disappoints! The crust is my favorite. The service is excellent and everything is good.

IF YOU'RE NOT A LOCAL, AVOID THIS PLACE!!! Wife and I rented a house a couple miles away and decided to grab a pizza to go the other night. Placed the order and was told it would be 30 mins. No problem, I put $5 in the tip jar. More people came in and ordered and got their pizzas while I waited. No biggie I thought, they seem to know everyone that comes in. After an hour I was told it was almost done. At an hour and a half, I kid you not, they told me they were out of pepperoni and asked what else I'd like. Now I didn't care about the pepperoni, but when other folks come in and order pepperoni pizzas AFTER me, and get their pizzas while I'm waiting, they obviously could care less about the out of town guy's pizza. Keep in mind that I asked three times for an update and was always told it was almost done. Finally asked for a refund, went to Dominos a block away, and had pizza in 20 mins. Hindsight is 20/20 and so are restaurant reviews. read more

Ordered Philly cheesesteak with hot peppers and mushrooms. Told to wait 40 min to pick it up then waited an additional 25 min once arrived. Order was missing CHEESE and hot peppers for which we were charged extra plus the onion straws were very cold. read more

When it comes to pizza in Lancaster County there's not too many choices. Yet thats no excuse why Sal's has to have so many issues with its pizza. Again, all my reviews are to explain what can be *improved*. Problems: The sauce - Either its not being seasoned or is canned, it tastes like tomato soup. Pizza sauce should not taste like soup. Improving the sauce would definitely improve it the most The dough - One time I had a pizza from Sal's that had raw dough in the crust end. It looks like they need to cook it longer Greasy - I'm not the biggest fan of NY Style pizza, but even I know the pizza shouldn't be swimming in its own grease. Something needs to be done about this as myself and most people I know like pizza to be crisp, not soggy. I'll be in town again soon, and I'll be happy to try this place again and follow up my review if needed. read more

Sal's is exactly the way you remember it, looks just like an 80's pizza spot inside. We have never eaten inside, we ALWAYS get take out. The pizza is solidly good. Ordered two pizzas, ham and pineapple and pepperoni. Both were solid, nice soft dough, not a crazy amount of cheese, plentiful toppings. One was a bit overcooked but still tasty. Hand tossed crust, not too thin or too thick. It did take longer for our order to be ready that they quoted but the holidays are very busy. Sal's is a solid choice for pizza, perfect take out spot. If you are looking for a romantic Italian spot, Sal's doesn't aim for that. It's a simple pizza joint, period. read more

This place is amazing!! Great food and really friendly staff!! Just a great old school style Italian restaurant! We will definitely be back and suggest this place to anyone! read more

I've been coming to sals since I was a kid and it never gets old eating here and worked here as a teen!! The atmosphere and staff are always awesome and the owners are awesome!! read more

My go to place for pizza in Kilmarnock. You can get a meat lovers (with full slices of bacon) for $20! And the staff is so nice.

Nice pie, had a combo salami and peppers (red and green). Staff was extremely nice and it was fast.

Only two pizza places in this town, so I tried the one that was the oldest and most established ...big mistake. The place is very dirty and neglected. Should have been a sign for us to leave , but we tried the pizza and it was far from a good pizza . The other pizza place In town was much better but that's not saying much. I miss Frank Pepe's in CT. read more

High prices for tiny subs. My ham had 1 slice of ham, very little lettuce or anything else. Save your money. You will leave hungry. Go elsewhere,! read more

The best pizza in Kilmarnick. Very family friendly, kids are more than welcome. Everything on the menu is very reasonably priced and Lisa is incredible! We try and eat there once a week to help support our local economy. Wednesday night is BOGO! read more

Sals is a family favorite of ours! Our trips down here to our family farm is never complete until we come to sale. The owners are wonderful and it's our families favorite place for pizza anywhere! Their subs are awesome too!! read more

Sals is absolutely awful and a waste of money. The pizza we had was soggy dough, would of been better off getting pizza from Walmart. Also our waitress forgot about our drinks and also forgot one of our meals all together. She didn't come check on us and we had to wave her down multiple times. When they sat us down the table was still dirty and they didn't clean it for 5 minutes so we just stared at dirty dishes. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

This place is small and friendly restaurant with excellent fresh pizza. Toppings, cheese and sauce are all delicious and and the crust is amazing. Salads aren't too good here but definitely some of the best local pizza I've had. Service wasn't great when it was a crowded Sunday, it was very slow and it could have just been under-staffed. read more

When we visited Kilmarnock, my wife wanted Italian one night (pasta particularly) so we decided to order take out form Sal's. It was honestly the worst mistake we made on our trip. Not only did they not write down the order when we made it over the phone, but they took an additional thirty minutes to produce spaghetti and meat sauce for her. She is not a picky eater when it comes to spaghetti but she told me it was cold and very bland. Very upset she told me she wished she had stopped by Walmart and gotten some spaghetti from the frozen food section. Save yourself the trouble, get something frozen and heat it up in the oven or microwave. I can't imagine if they mess up spaghetti that anything else they make can be better. read more

Sorry to say that this is a prime example of a much needed "Restaurant Makeover" No wonder people like take outs. My Aunt Rosie and cousin Nicoletta would be ashamed to sit in the shabby booths no matter how good the food was. read more

Pizza is great. Toppings were fresh and crust just right. Server was friendly and provided wonderful service.

Great pizza and subs... Been eating at sals since I was in a high chair... Now at 31 it's still my go to for great pizza! They give you great big fountain sodas too! read more

Their steak and cheese is the gold standard to which we rate all other steak and cheese subs. The pizza is hand tossed, definitely fresh and made to order with whatever you want. We tried the Stromboli for the first time today and we think we've found another item to go back for. Families, politicians and the police all go there. It's not a franchise and definitely worth driving past Pizza Hut and Subway for! read more