Great place!! The Italian food at his restaurant is one of the best in town. The service is really great also. I highly recommend Sal's Italian Restaurant. Edward Jones read more

I waited a while to write this.. I got MAJOR food sickness from this place in February. I got the ricotta/alfredo pizza. When I tell you I was vomiting and having diarrhea AT THE SAME TIME bc of this pizza.. I was unable to get out of bed for 48 hours unless I was running to the bathroom. I vomited so much that my abs and jaws hurt the next day. I wish I hadn't had this experience. read more

If there was an option for zero stars this would get it. Rude from the get go. We asked for our food (after waiting for 25 min) and watching others get served. All we got was more incredibly rude behavior. He asked if we were from Florida. No reason for the level of rudeness we encountered. Would NOT recommend EVER going to this place. We were a group of 6 ladies out for an afternoon. We were not rude and not sure why he would think we were from Florida and what that had to do with anything at all. read more

We are from Long Island we know great pizza and let me tell Sal's Brooklyn pizza is Fantastic perfect crust and very delicious read more

Sal's Brooklyn Pizza - Great pizza - Pizza Near Me - Murphy, North Carolina

Sal is a miserable jerk!! We were a big party, and he continuously either yelled at us or insulted us. The calzone was horrible (all ricotta cheese) with no flavor, and only a tiny cup of marinara. read more

This place serves five star pizza. The sauce tastes fresh and is not loaded with salt, allowing you to taste the cheese and crispy crust even more. They serve one of the best pizzas we've ever had. In my lifetime I've come across a few places that were as good, but none were better. This place rocks! read more

Rude service. Went there with friends for lunch. We ordered- during that time the owner/waiter was condescending and behaved as though he did not want to be bothered with us patronizing his business. After waiting for an hour to receive our chicken sandwich we decided to leave. As we started toward the door we were told that the cops we would be called if we did not pay for the food that we ordered as he was going to be bringing it out to us. To avoid any additional rudeness and drama we sit back down. Food was average. read more

Pizza good but unfortunately service is just rude. I've called in to go pizza orders and every time there's been a rude comment on how I order. I've decided the pizza is no longer worth it and will take my business elsewhere. If there is new ownership, then I'll give another chance in the future. Until then pizza is not worth the incredibly rude behavior. read more

Awesome pizza!! Always fresh, hot and delicious! Eat in or take out!! Mr. Rich will always do you right!

Not very nice people. They treat you like you are an inconvenience. This has happen on multiple occasions. I just stopped going.

I have been going to Sals for quite some time..each time the food is great. Consistency says it all!

The pizza and antipasto are excellent. Have been there several times and it is consistently good.. always clean. A hometown favorite place to eat. read more

Have to upgrade my review the first time I went there it wasn't friendly and it was very expensive. Gave him a second try order a pizza and I have to tell you it's one of the best pizzas in the Murphy area, but he still little on a high price, but you get what you pay for. read more

Best pizza in the entire United States. Even better than in New York. The service is great and the restaurant is impeccable.

Someone said this is the best pizza in town. Wrong. It's the best pizza I've had in three southern states (Georgia, NC, and TN). As a transplanted Pennsylvania girl, I've missed authentic NY style pizza and I have been on a mission to find it. Some have come close but Sal's is spot on. The service was great. The prices were great, but the pizza. Dang, it reminds me of home. read more

This guy makes a five star pizza. Other restaurants brag about fresh ingredients, but he really uses fresh ingredients. We visit 1-2 times a year and always stop here. It's a required stop. I didn't think to take a picture until I took the last bite of the last piece so you get the idea. read more

Sal's Brooklyn Pizza - Best pizza anywhere!! - Pizza Near Me - Murphy, North Carolina

The best pizza I have had in some time! The staff were so friendly and the prices were very budget friendly! We got a ton of food and very full bellies! read more

Never misses! the best pizza. And the calzones are delicious, full of Ricotta my fave. Sal is a warm face, always a friendly atmosphere when dining in or picking up. read more

Alas my search is finally over! I have actually found REAL NY Style Pizza here in the Southern Hemisphere!!! I am delighted to report that this Pizza fits every requirement that this NJ born Pizza snob has on her list of requirements that a Northeast Style Pie should!!! From crust to cheese pull and everything in between to the most excellent foldable quality of the thin but crisp crust, this is a fine example that should be tried by all who are yearning for that pizza from back home or want to taste what pizza should taste like! The owner was wonderful and very personable and the service was top notch! The ingredients are quality and the pies are huge! We also had the fried raviolis and garlic knots which were on point! I think any dish you order here will be truly amazing!!! This pizzeria should be on the top of anyone's list of places of someone who would like a true NY Style pizza experience! read more

Sal's Brooklyn Pizza - Aunt Helen's White Pizza (Soooo Good!!!!) - Pizza Near Me - Murphy, North Carolina

See all

Just had the white pizza for the first time! Why did I wait so long? It was amazing. The light fresh garlic is so good.

Loved Sals! The pizza was amazing and the staff was so friendly. Wish we lived closer but we will definitely be back when we are in the area! read more

Five stars all the way! Started with a very friendly lady who answered the phone and took our order. Confirming the order and amount of time until it was ready! Perfect timing as when we walked through the door it was coming out of the oven. Cut, boxed, paid and out the door! The gentleman cooking seemed to be chief cook and bottle washer and cashier! Very friendly and definitely knew how to make a pizza. Pizza was absolutely delicious, still hot with an amazing flavor crust and fresh toppings. Was a Cuzziono's fan but they were closed so Sal's was our choice! Bye-Bye Cuzzino's HELLO SAL'S! One suggestion would be a great antipasto salad, since you only offer a plain side salad and you have everything for subs etc! Otherwise perfect in every way! read more

Visiting the area for the weekend. Fantastic pizza! Not fast food but this is NOT an insult. Made fresh to order. The very best pizza crust I have ever had and I have had pizza in many different places across the U.S. that claim an authentic Italian experience. It's not just that we would visit here again next time we are in the area, we are trying to decide if we are going to eat here again twice in the same day! It's that good! read more

25 minutes to make two sandwiches in the middle of the day. Go to Cuzzinos down the street

My name is Charlotte Wolfe and I was employed At Sals Brooklyn pizza for the last year . on Friday three days ago, I walked off the job because the owner Richard Amato is the most unethical person I've ever met. He's a criminal! He attack on a dollar without the customer ever suspecting a thing to each and every person's ticket price! He never lets them know a thing and they don't notice an extra dollar is added. It's unethical it's stealing!! He also charges the customer without telling them for a cup of ice or a cup of water or a straw or a napkin! If the customer does notice it on their ticket price, he screams at them usually profanities and says "look this isn't a hobby!" he's extremely rude and unprofessional and literally manhandle me three days ago for giving a customer a refill on their drink when they paid $2.75 for it! After he put his hands on me, I walked off the job! Do not go here if you don't want to be ripped off! read more

Best pizza around here. If you're looking for a New York style pizza this is the best place to go. The pizza, garlic knots and cheese sticks are all top quality. You will not be disappointed. read more

Dough fresh made in store. Authentic New York Italian diner. Pizza isn't all they offer. Sal is very nice and friendly.

I love Sal's Brooklyn Pizza.I've been a regular for a decade.From the pizza to the calzones,garlic rolls and desserts ,I've never had a problem with an order.The staff is friendly and the owner is a delight, he does care about his customers unlike many business owners in the area.I've been to plenty of Ny pizzerias but this place has won me over with their fresh ingredients and the dough is fresh and airy compared to other pizza places.The dining area is clean and it can accommodate more than 20 people.Thank you for your hospitality and great food Sal's! read more

Very good pizza and dessert. Staff is very friendly. Liked that we could buy pizza buy the slice!

Disappointed for the price. Very few fresh veggies at all for a supreme. Also manufactured sausage in slices, when you would expect full chunks of real sausage. We did takeout . We will look elsewhere. read more

The pizza from Sal's is so good! I grabbed some pizzas for our family for the day after Thanksgiving. The service was great and efficient. The slices were big and delicious! I'll gladly order pizza from Sal's anytime I'm visiting Murphy from now on. read more

Great thin crust pizza, subs and other selections are very good also. Friendly service and clean dining area.

Great pizza and awesome staff that have customer service skills that are second to none. Food is always fresh and plentiful.

Hidden gem in Murphy, NC. The best pizza in the USA. The crust was amazing and the cheese and pepperoni were espectacular. We have tried pizza all over the US, never had pizza like Sals Brooklyn pizza. Congratulations and thank you, we will be back! JC & Odette. read more

Great pizza, great customer service. Always busy! Sals special delicious, Italian sub is spot on. read more

See all

First time stopping at Sal's. Decided to get the sub. Best sub I've had and we've had many in Georgia. Jersey Mike's was our favorite until now. We can't wait to try the pizza next time. read more

This was such a great pizza! We stopped by during the day and ordered a takeout pizza with garlic knots! We decided to try the aunt Helen's White pizza with added fresh garlic. This pizza has cheese and ricotta cheese. The gentleman who took our order was friendly and was efficient. This pizza was hand tossed and in our hands in about 15 minutes! The pizza was absolutely delicious!!!! I highly recommend this pizza to anyone!! The garlic knots were delicious but were a bit smaller than expected! They even provided us the plates and napkins! We loved it and will return! read more

Reviews are all over the place about Sal's. Let me tell you it's the best pizza in the area. We had a cheese pizza with ricotta and it's awesome. An abundance of toppings. The only thing I want more of is the red sauce. read more

A week ago I ordered & picked up a meatball sub from Sals...when I got home, this is what they gave me! I called right away & spoke to the lady that made the sandwich...she said she knew it was burnt & owed me a free one...I called yesterday to collect the free one & the owner said he knew all about it & refused a free one,only offered a discount! That's rediculous & a terrible way to do business...hes lost at least 1 customer over a cheap sandwich most likely many more potential customers...guess he just doesn't care. read more

Sal's Brooklyn Pizza - Burnt meatball sub from Sals... - Pizza Near Me - Murphy, North Carolina

We are visiting NC from NYC due to Covid and checked this place out. I will say it tastes better than most pizza joints in the city. I highly recommend it. Good fresh ingredients. Much better than Pizza Hut next to it which we almost considered. read more

Sal's Brooklyn Pizza - two pizzas on a table - Pizza Near Me - Murphy, North Carolina