Do not go here. After they failed to properly inspect my car following an accident, they became hostile when I questioned them. I paid approximately $9,000 for body work on a car worth about $14,000, and they kept the vehicle for a month while repeatedly failing to return my calls about its status. When I finally received the car back, it immediately had multiple warning lights, including a low-coolant warning. I called them as soon as I got the car back and was told that they had filled all of the fluids. The car later stopped running completely, and I had to have it towed back to their shop. Instead of investigating why the car stopped running shortly after being in their possession for a month, they told me, "You need to get this car out of here," and claimed the problem was unrelated to the accident, even though I had specifically told them that there was liquid all over the ground when the car was hit. They claim to be a full-service body shop, yet they did not even write or provide a repair order documenting what they supposedly determined was wrong with the car or why they believed it was unrelated to the accident. Apparently, this completely separate problem just mysteriously happened at the exact same time. Even more concerning, after the car was towed back, the fluid warning lights that had been illuminated were mysteriously no longer showing. This came after the owner had already told me that he "just wanted to get paid" and did not want the car there, despite receiving a cashier's check for the full bill approximately one week after the vehicle first arrived because I offered to source the used part that he supposedly could not get for a month (and charged me for a new part). I was also told that I would receive a check for my trouble, but when I later mentioned it, they denied ever saying that and accused me of making it up. When I questioned the condition of the car, that they knew would be coming back, and told me I could have it sent in, and then told me "get it out there" upon prompt pick up and questioning why they talk to people the way they do, an absolute animal of a man I had never spoken to before called me rude, told me he knows me and then told me that he knew where I lived. Whether that statement was intended to intimidate me or simply creep me out, congratulations you're as unprofessional, angry, and classless as they come, I guess threatening women is easier than doing your job and standing behind your work. No customer should pay thousands of dollars, receive a car that is not in working condition, and then be made to feel unsafe for asking questions and expecting the vehicle to be properly checked. The car will now have to be properly diagnosed and fixed by another shop. I highly doubt had we went through the insurance company that this would have been the case. read more

For some reason my Tesla Model 3 has been a magnet for other drivers to rear end at traffic lights and stop signs, including making tight turns when I'm parked and they lock their rear wheel well with my front bumper in parking lots. This was before this year's assaults on Cyber Trucks and various Teslas believe it or not. At Sagamore Collision, a Tesla certified shop, Charlie is the lead where Tesla's are concerned. His friendly, stellar, professional performance is the reason I continue to return after every unfortunate mishap. Eddie has been great as well in addressing my concerns when Charlie has been busy. The staff is also incredibly friendly, professional and reliable. I cannot recommend Sagamore enough for your auto body needs whether it's a Tesla or any other brand. Although they've been great, I'd appreciate a break before seeing them again. Thanks again guys. read more

I want to Thank Gary for an excellent job on not just one but 2 of my families auto collision repairs ... it looks like it Never Happened!! Also at a more than reasonable price considering all the work and materials that hus experts put into the job. If you live in the king island area don't let anyone else touch your car but the professionals at Sagamore Collission ! Tell them Phil Adamo sent you. read more

To Eddie & Everyone at Sagamore, I want to thank you for such a wonderful job performed on my white Ford F-150 Limited. I treat my vehicles with the upmost pride, even this one which is my daily driver. You can't tell any work was done to it, which is what you want from a collision shop. But you went above and beyond. You detailed my truck and left 2 containers of touch up paint in the cup holder. When it started raining, the water beaded on all the paint, which means it was waxed during the detailing. I never asked for the detailing, but you definitely take pride in what you are sending back out to the customer. I noticed it and felt compelled to thank you. read more

Sagamore Collision - Body Shops Near Me - Oyster Bay, New York

It may have taken more time to make my car whole again, than i thought it would...but now that it is back in my possession I realize it was worth the wait! Thank you Gary and Joe......and the rest of your professional team! read more

See all

Was involved in minor accident in a parking lot. Westbury Toyota referred me to Sagamore. They took such wonderful care of me and my car. When I arrived, I was in awe of the workmanship. I hope to never need a repair again, but if I do, they have me as a customer for life. read more

My car had a minor problem but Eddie took the time to make sure everything was okay. He was so patient and kind and the problem quickly resolved. I also reach out to Eddie when my 10 year old car has problems that no other mechanic can diagnose or correct. Eddie is wonderful. read more

Hands down the best auto body shop on Long Island. Chris the service manager at Oyster Bay BMW recommended the shop and I couldn't be happier. The shops very professional and accommodating. I called to set up an appointment and, Nicole told me all I have to do is fill out some paper work and my rental will be ready! She kept her word it was a painless experience I gave the shop permission to deal with the insurance company and from that point they took total control. I didn't have to do a thing. For Eddie and Joe they are the best! They promised me the car will look better then the day I got it! They kept there word you couldn't tell the entire driver passenger side quarter panel was smashed in, they also repainted my entire rear bumper which had two license plate marks on it! So now the car looks perfect! It took them two days to detail the car inside and out now the paint just pops you see the metallic crystals even from a distance! Im so happy with the service I've received from them! Thank you very much! Side note: Rental company's on site and they give you a small container of touch up paint! They also put my insurance card in a little sleeve! read more

See all

Sagamore Collision has been beyond accommodating over the years. From minor dents and scratches, to bigger auto body work or needing my car towed, they have always been able to help without hesitation and are professional. read more

Vehicle was towed to Sagamore collision with a Broken passenger side axle. Driver dragged my vehicle onto the flat bed in park never put the car in neutral which of course broke the driver side axle and a lot of other components and stole items out of vehicle. Sagamore collision refused to take responsibility but ask if I have collision insurance so my insurance would fix their mistakes.I don't think so read more

I had a terrific experience with Sagamore. They were professional, honest, reasonably priced, nice to deal with, and responsive. The work was very high quality and done in a timely manner. read more

Sagamore collision has been there for me more than once. Each and every time they deliver exceptional service and always with a smile! Today, Eddie helped me sort out questions regarding a repair on my moms car as she was rear ended in a sort of hit and run. He gave me invaluable advice and without making a cent off of the time he spent helping me. It is things like this that make Sagamore Collision the only place I trust for quality service. Thank you very much for all you do for our community!! read more

I've been going to Sagamore for about 6 years now, and they absolutely never fail to disappoint. Super reliable, the staff are incredibly kind and accommodating, and they make you feel right at home. They treat customers like family and that's hard to come by these days. I sent my car in after an accident and my car came back looking better than when I had originally bought it. Parts were fixed and my car was finely detailed. I couldn't be happier! read more

stay far far far away from this lala land of a bodyshop i took my tesla in for some light bodywork and they ended up taking 4 days to give me an extimate the owner gary was a rude obnoxioius arrogant individual who said to me if you dont want to do the work i dont need it i have plenty of money what an _________. if you gave me a decent price i wouldnt have questioned why the double price charge then he swore to me he will use the best materials only to use a cheap aftermarket clear paint that peeled off after 7 months when i went back to show him that it was coming off he said his warranty would not cover it cause he doesnt remember the car a lying crook he will charge you top dollar and use cheap materials then he will yell at you and as he does with his employees and his secretary be safe and stay away from this scammmmmmmmmmmmmmmm scammmmmmmmm read more

I got into a small accident, but it was my classic car and meant a lot to me. I wanted to stay local and saw a recommendation for Sagamore by Dr. Gulbransen, and figured if I can trust him with my kids, I can trust him for a body shop. He was right. Really good guys, excellent job and they made it very easy. One small thing needed to be fixed afterward, and they did it quickly and happily. Collision repair is an ugly business, but these guys are the real deal. They have my business from now on. read more

I wouldn't trust my truck anyplace else. Everyone is super nice. Attention to detail is beyond unbelievable. They work magic. I recommend them to everyone. read more

I park our Porsche Cayenne in a garage in Manhattan. They scratched the you know what out of the side. I checked around and took it to Sagamore Collision as well as another, Porsche certified, body shop. I met with Gary and I had a great experience. I got a loaner while they had the car and when we went to pick it up, it looked just like it did when it was new!! I couldn't be more satisfied. I highly recommend them. They are professional and easy to work with. Kevin B read more

They are the best of the best. Will make your car look like new if you got into an accident. Happy with the repairs they have done and dents they have gotten out. read more

This business should not be operating. I got water in my car and needed it towed early in the morning. Unfortunately I called these crooks and they were more then happy to tow my car but then tried to claim my car was totaled and would not be able to be repaired. They wanted me to abandon the car to them and were very pushy to do so, trying to give me an 1100 dollar bill for two tows and a week of storage which I confronted as dishonest and was met by the excuse that "two bills got mixed up." They act as if you are an idiot, as unfortunately my insurance did not have any interest in the claim. Upon hearing this they tried to force me to leave the car there with them by giving me an extremely high bill. They attempted to fool me in order to steal my car, luckily I was able to realize that the car wasn't irreparably damaged and payed 880 dollars to get it out of there. My mechanic was able to get the engine to start in a day, leading me to believe that they knew they could easily fix my car but instead tried to take advantage of me. read more

This place is the number one place to get your car fixed. I had my car fixed here two times after 2 accidents and both times looks better than when I 1st purchased it. Garry and Eddie are very understanding. They listen attentively and address every single need. They are the best #1. Excellent service! Highly recommend.! read more

Ive been dealing with Eddie for several years now, from car detailing to major accidents. I don't trust anyone else to work on my car. They are honest, caring and do the best work. I have to drive 1/2 hour to go to them so that tells you they are worth it. read more

Gary and Eddie always take such good care of us. I trust them, they actually do what they say they'll do. Someone hit my fiancée's bumper in a parking lot and they fixed it all within that same week. They're the best around. read more

I've had 3 cars serviced by Gary and Eddie -- they do fantastic work, exactly to the price they estimate, in exactly the amount of time they tell you it's going to be done. Auto body shops are like barbers, sometimes you get a bad cut; however, if these guys cut my hair every time, I'd be on the cover of GQ. Highly recommended, local business, and earnest, accommodating staff. read more

BEWARE!!! Very shady auto body shop. Pushy reps who love to milk your car insurance for lots of $$$$. They towed my car after an accident and would not release it to another body shop for repairs. My car insurance had to pay $2000 "storage fee" to get my car out. They insisted on getting a rental car for me when I didn't even need it. CROOKS!!! Don't bring your car there. read more

I just had my car repaired by Sagamore after it being hit in the food store parking lot while I was food shopping. What an amazing job they did! My Mustang is gorgeous again!!! Such a shame it is to cold to put the top down and go for a nice cruise!! The car is now cleaner than it has been in a while, even the inside is spotless!! They really did such a beautiful job I cannot say thank you enough!! You would never know she got a dinged by looking at her!! She was ready right on schedule too! Thank you, thank you, thank you!! read more

I read the reviews and was a little apprehensive to bring my car there, but then noticed only 3 poor reviews and I see hundreds of cars coming and going from this place, if so bad why is it still there. The place is close to where I do some business, so I brought my Audi 6 there for a touch up, get out some minor dents, repair a damaged grill and re-powder coat the rims. The work was done on time and as promised, no cost over runs. If I need work done in the future, I will certainly use these guys again. read more

Just got my car done at Sagamore Auto Body. Very friendly people, but don't be fooled. They milk the insurance company like no other. Had minor damage to my car but wrote up a super high bill for the insurance company. They didn't even replace/fix 70% of the stuff they billed for. Car takes forever to be completed. Each time you call them for an update "car is in paint and going to be reassembled", when the car is clearly sitting on their lot, untouched. They think you are a fool and don't know whats going on. I would stay away from them for their dishonesty. read more

I have to tell you all these guys are great! I dealt with Gary and his assistant Nicole who were both very helpful. I dropped off my car they had a rental waiting for me and had my car done in a little over a week. they came in under the estimate and when I picked up my car it looked like it just came out of the showroom! They even fixed a few scratches I had on my car that had nothing to do with the accident. I hopefully will never have another accident but if I do there is only one place I would ever bring my car Sagamore Collision. They are the best !! read more