Sabatinos is a great well rounded pizza shop. Their pizza sauce is not overly sweet which is something I look for in a pizza. Thin crust, fresh toppings. They have one if the most well crafted Strombolis I have ever seen, it's a long smaller diameter shape with the filling spread out evenly and there is not a whole bunch of left over crust at the end like you find when a Stromboli is the half circle shape. The cheesesteak is solid, and the price for a cheesesteak and fries is a great deal for how much food you get. On a busy night delivery might be upwards of an hour, so I have gotten in the habit of asking the delivery time before I order and pick up if it's any more than 30 minutes. Bottom line, I think this is one of the best pizzas in west Chester. read more

foods always cold overpriced and they whom answer the phones arent speaking or understanding english well at all. high prices and foods bad and then owners are nasty when u let them know!!!! sloppy food too! read more

The food was very good and reasonable priced. The staff was very attentive!! We had the pizza which was very good. We got a blackened chicken salad. That came with a large portion of chicken and was very good. read more

Great pizza, apps, and sandwiches! The food is ready super fast and is always fresh! Highly recommend the eggplant parm sandwich! I order from here regularly and always enjoy the food! read more

My previous review was for the Sabatino's on Paoli Pike. This Sabatino's (West Chester Pike) is excellent. I love the 4 Gusti Pizza best, but have never been disappointed by anything I've ordered. read more

I ordered take-out from this place as my husband and I moved in down the street. We heard great things about it! We ordered one cheese, one sausage, and one white pizza for our friends and family who helped us move in, and we all loved it! read more

ordered the gluten free pizza which was $20 and was one of the worse gf pizzas I've ever had. Been gluten free for 3 years now and the other terrible experience ive had was the one I got from sea world which they just baked frozen from some company. Far too expensive and far too disappointed. Heard their pizza is really good but hopefully the gluten free pizzas get taken off the menu or gets improved. highly doubt it's fresh whatsoever. read more

Such a great place. So very friendly & kind. Great selection of slices. I love their sausage & Hawaiian style a lot. The lunch specials are great. Recommend read more

I've ordered 3 times and have had pizza, a cheesesteak and a chicken cheesesteak. Everything has been delicious, hot, and a great value. I live close by and totally forgot they were just down the street. Decided to give them a try and now it's my go to place! read more

Excellent pizza! Sauce is homemade and crust is perfect! Owners are great and place is convenient to surrounding highways.

So today I ordered two large pizza from the store I'm a contractor and was doing some work and decided to get lunch for the crew. The pizza was very delicious btw. My issue was the delivery woman that delivered our food she was about 50 years old driving a black mini suv. I gave her a $3 tip she got a attitude and gave us the middle finger. I called the store and put in a complaint and told them a tip is optional not mandatory. Very unprofessional be on the look out for her she might tamper with your food. They ask on the phone if want want to tip so just imagine if I said no and she delivered our food she probably would've spit on it. read more

I ordered food tru uber eats and my food was left out I. The cold I never received a call from the driver and when the restaurant called me saying that the driver left it outside at the address I provided that it's not there responsibility to put the food in my hands I explained to the manager that no one had called me that it was a hotel and the right thing to do was delivery it to the front desk but he told me to fuck off so do t buy from this place read more

Sabatino's Grill - Food - Pizza Near Me - West Chester, Pennsylvania

I have NEVER received such horrible service. After receiving 3/3 wrong parts of our order I called and politely told them the order was incorrect. In response, I was transferred to the store owner who barrated me over the phone about how it was my fault. HORRIBLE service. Will not go back. read more

Got a cheese steak with onions and fries. Wasnt crazy about the canned cheese they used. The rest of the food is decent.

Let me just start by saying I was born and raised in the NYC area, so I have pizza issues. We moved to PA 22 years ago and I had found "my place" when we lived in Wayne. We moved to WC a little over a year ago and I've been on the hunt for good pizza since. I have finally found it! Great thin, lightly crispy crust with a nice chew and flavor, wonderfully balanced sauce, and a near perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Withholding one star until I've been back a few times and can attest to consistency. read more

Friday June 11, 2021 I went to their website to online order and saw that it is done through a third party called Slice. It said pickup in 20 minutes but when i went to checkout, i was asked to log in through my gmail account. Not a fan of using my credit card in conjunction with gmail, so i called in the order. The woman i spoke with quoted me 50 minutes. I questioned the wait time and before i could even finish she yelled at me saying that "it's Friday night." I explained what it said online and she said "there's no way, it's Friday night." I cancelled my order and called Jumbo. They had it ready in 20 minutes. 50 minutes to pickup a half plain/half pepperoni is insane, even on a Friday night. read more

Quaint, family owned restaurant. Friendly staff, clean restaurant, plenty of outdoor seating.

I've been a customer for at least 8 years. When it comes to pizza, I have simple tastes - large cheese. I top it with my own herbs and spices at home. And Sabatino's is my go to place - thin crisp crust, delicious sauce, tasty cheese, and still delicious when I heat it up the next day in my toaster oven. read more

Awesome chicken caesar. Great service. You wont find much better anywhere. Owner operator cares about quality.

Love there cheese steaks and they come with fries. And Mozzarella sticks. Not to keen on there sauce. read more

See all

Always have a good experience with take out. Their pizza is well done and they have a nice diverse Italian menu. We frequently order and it's usually our go to read more

we have enjoyed the food here for years. the staff is friendly and they are always contributing to great local and international causes (homeless, Ukraine). Today I had the homemade pizzelles, which were incredible! I ate the entire bag in one sitting:). and the profits benefit the homeless in Chester County...win-win! read more

Highly recommend their Western Fries which are loaded in ranch, cheese, and bacon. They are one of a kind and I order them every time we go! Great place. read more

It was Sunday and didn't feel like throwing lunch together since dinner took some effort getting in the Crock Pot. Called Sabitinos for some of my favorite food - a pizza. I saw the place had decent reviews and they delivered so took a chance. The friendly person on the line informed me a large half pepperoni pie would take about 40 minutes. Cost with delivery was $15.77. Seemed reasonable. Arrived exactly in that time frame as expected. As I do around these parts, I requested more to the well done side and they obliged. The crust was tasty. Cooked right as requested. One bummer is the slice fell away from the crust as you folded it. That's a pizza fail in my book. Sauce was good as was the cheese. You could tell the dough was made fresh and the owners take pride in what they cook. On my delco judging scale, I give it 3 out of 5. Not the best, not the worse but decent. read more

We ordered from here for the first time tonight. Food was good. Loved the cheese with broccoli pizza! Garlic knots were great too! The mozzarella fries were okay but nothing special. The delivery guy was super nice and the food got here so quick!!!! We will def order from here again!! read more

My Aunt and I ordered cheesesteaks from Sabatinos and were excited to try them. When we arrived to pick up our food, the man that was running food out to cars was very nice and he told us that our food was almost ready. We waited 45 minutes for our food plus the 25 minutes that we waited in the parking lot. At this point we were starving. About 5 cars that pulled up after we had, got their food immediately and we were still waiting. Eventually we got the food and were off to home but we were starved. People were nice but service was less than suitable. read more

First time customer tonight and we LOVED it! Sabatino's could easily charge more and I'd pay it. Phenomenal, fresh, authentic Italian food paired with the friendliest staff anywhere! Don't leave without trying the cannoli! A++++! We found our new Italian place! read more

Pizza is great, especially white chicken bacon ranch. The pasta is amazing, especially the gnocchi in red roasted pepper sauce!

I love the food. It makes me feel at home. The staff is always so friendly. They even call me by my name and treat me with respect. Five stars from me! read more

We been ordering from here since Anna and her family took over this establishment. It's been absolutely delicious. We are always remembered when we come each time. The pizza is fabulous. Anna is the best and makes you feel like part of her family. read more

Really nice guy who delivered the pizza. They're only doing curbside. The cheese was super greasy and wouldn't stay on the pizza. There was no seasoning of any type of basil oregano present. It was very disappointing. It had the consistency of a volcano that had erupted it and just slid off. read more

Pizza is the best around!! We always get a large plain, well-done. Its perfect every time!

They have great pizza and wonderful pasta dishes with generous portions. The curbside service is wonderful. Looking forward to ordering from them again! read more

This is the best pizza place on West Chester Pike. I just moved here from Jersey and had to try all the local pizza places. This one is by far the best. The daily specials are a super deal and their tomato pie is a super cheap dinner option. While I appreciate the perfectly made traditional pizza, I also love their wide selection of white pizzas. And they have perfectly sauced buffalo wings - not too wet, but not quite a dry rub either. read more

I ordered a steak Stromboli and it was awesome. One of the best I have ever had. Their dough is what makes it so good. My kids get their pizza and they love it. I tried it and it's very good. read more

Awesome Italian food, good choices for your money. Good seating and great service and everyone is friendly there.Prices are good too.

We like the wings from here. Like mild wings but can never find the "right" mild? When you order tell the waitress you want the mildest mild. Sounds weird but it seems to magic!! read more

Great pizza shop! We specifically went there because they were the only pizza place doing only curbside and delivery during the COVID19 pandemic. The had the system down unlike other places, everyone had masks and gloves and prepaid on the phone and they brought it right to the car, and no one was allowed in. The pizza was excellent, specifically we loved the crust and sauce. Can't wait to go back in the future! read more

We have been looking for great local pizza for awhile now, and finally found it!! We ordered a large pizza and calamari. Both were fantastic! The pizza sauce is not overly sweet and there was a perfect amount of cheese. The calamari was tender and not drowning in breading. They packed it on top of some lettuce so it wasn't covered in grease either, which is a nice change around here. We will be back here many times. read more

Joe the owner is the man! I'm moving into the area from South Jersey with my husband and baby bump in a couple of months. My family came to check out our new home and we stopped for a bite to eat. We ordered a large plain pie and it was so delicious! Joe the owner was super friendly and even hooked us up with some tasty canoli on the house! That means EVERYTHING to a pregnant woman in her third trimester! The ambiance was lovely and we will totally be back for more! Thanks Joe! read more