One of the best pies on LI! Comes out in 15 minutes fresh and hot, my go to spot for anyone craving…read morea NY slice. Prices fairly reasonable too.

I was visiting my cousin in Port Washington NY and I was Jonesing for a good NY thin crust pizza…read more In Arizona good NY style pizza is hard to find. The crust was good but I should have asked to have it in the oven another minute or two. It had ample amounts of cheese and after adding extra garlic, shake on Parmesan cheese and oregano. The pizza was perfection. I definitely recommend Carlos pizza when you are in the Port Washington area.

Great little brick oven pizza spot right by a local marina…read more Pizza was fantastic and they have a few sandwiches and salads also. They have a small store also where you can get cured meats, cheeses, and some other small italian grocery items. Service was helpful and they have a small outdoor seating area. Definitely recommend.

Excellent. Don't miss Serra Provisions…read more -Location : right by the marina. Nice environment. Space itself very open and welcoming -Food : I've only had sandwiches and pizza from here. Both are 10/10. Foccia baked to perfection. Pizza made in a coal oven out back. Ingredients are top notch -Service : friendly, helpful kind staff Sort of feels like you're in Brooklyn. Can't wait to come here for drinks eventually.

MOST NYC-LIKE PIZZA IN PORT WASHINGTON!!!…read more I'm a NYC foodie and have tasted the best slices in NYC, so I can say this is the BEST slice in Port Washington. The slices are delicious, not soggy, not over-sauced. And the crust.....THE CRUST!!! I can't praise it enough! It's so buttery, crunchy, bubbly and SOOO DAMN GOOD! Gino's and Carlo's are overrated. This place is the real deal! Management, please adversise your pizza more!!!

Attempted to get some pizza here today (6-21-25). Sign on the door states it's permanently closed…read moreafter 15 years in business. Definitely a shame when the Mom and Pop small business' shut their doors for good.

Stopped in for lunch on our way out of state. Very welcoming greeting. We went for the Stromboli…read moreand based on house recommendation, also got a Margherita pie. Both were the best we had on our trip to New York. The walls have dozens of pictures of the restaurant staff and previous visitors, giving it a very inviting atmosphere. If you're in Port Washington, stop in and see them. You won't regret it.

The North Shore is not where you typically have a craving for pizza, but we somehow did while we…read morewere in the area during dinner time. Being the city folks that we are, and not carrying a lot of cash, we gave them a ring beforehand and asked if they accepted Zelle or Venmo. Much to our surprise, they answered yes and had been expecting us when we showed up. The three of us got a small, half-white, half-red pie (6 slices total) and a Pasta Verdure. We got pepperoni topping for the red pie, and while I wasn't too thrilled since the likes of Pizza Hut and awful school pizza ruined pepperoni for me at a young age, I was taken back by the superb quality. This isn't your typical commercial pepperoni. I'm no expert when it comes to cured meats, but I'm sure even a child can tell that the large size, the cuts, the color, and the texture are significantly higher quality than what's served at your typical pizza joints. On the other hand, I wasn't a fan of the white pizza as much--it was decent, but hard to top the saucier, more flavorful red counterpart. We carb-loaded more with an order of the Pasta Verdure, an all-veggie penne, which was the pinnacle of getting us to a state of bloatness. I wanted to write this review more to praise the staff than the food itself (which we would totally come back for, too), but they somehow made an exception for us to pay with a credit card on their POS system, which didn't have the option of choosing a tip. They were so kind and didn't even mention this to us and were just gonna let us be on our way after paying for our food only until we asked. We felt terrible and pooled together some cash that, while it wasn't enough to cover the meal, was a decent amount for a tip. They were very grateful that we went back to make it right for them. Absolute class and such humility shown by the staff that we would come back over and over again when we're in the area.

Because we don't get real New York-style Italian in LA, I request Gino's when I visit my sister in…read morePort Washington. It reminds me of the old-school pizza joints I haunted growing up on Long Island. During a recent trip back east I opted for the next best thing to a slice -- eggplant parm! They pile it up with lots of sauce and cheese. And for starters, we dug into their famous pizza dough rolls, sprinkled lightly with spices and slightly brown on top. Highly recommended.

6-16-25. My first time here. Popped in for a quick late…read morelunch. Ordered a salad slice and a marinara slice. Salad slice was okay, but the marinara slice was fantastic. Sauce was nice and chunky with a great flavor that was on the sweet side. Very good selection of specialty pies and stuffed meat/veggie rolls. You can tell they use good quality ingredients. Prices are a little high, but I guess so is everything else nowadays. Staff was friendly and service was good. Comfortable atmosphere with a decent amount of seating.

Always great food. A bit pricey but worth it. Love the ambiance and the staff. It's a very…read moreenjoyable way to spend your evening!

Excellent Italian food and wines. service was great and the restaurant has a lively atmosphere…read more with NY Italian restaurant vibes.

My favorite pizza. I grew up and live in NYC and the pizza has been lacking in the city the last…read morefive years. We visit Port Washington often and I always make sure we get a slice at Almalfi's. Thin crust, cheesy and no excess sauce near the top crust, it's just delicious.

Good food and good service. Anthony does it right! great choice of food and service is fine!read more

The best Italian restaurant in Port Washington. Freddy the…read moreowner of Toscanini,his very nice and friendly to all of his customers. The Ambiance is the most beautiful place, Service and the food are excellent.

It's 2 blocks west of the Landmark Theater on Main Street, has a small parking lot, but there's…read moresome metered street parking. We were seeing a show at 7:30 PM, so had a reservation for 6:00 PM, but we didn't need it (on this Thursday). It's a small-medium sized restaurant. Service from both our waiter and the owner ("Freddie") was in good spirits. We told them we had a show at 7:30. They had nice choices of wine by the glass (including Montepulciano & Chianti) and beers. Two of my buddies ordered bourbon and vodka. We sat at a round table in a corner by the front window and above us was a chalk board with the special dishes of the day. There was a complimentary Italian bread basket with butter. I skipped appetizers and ordered the Veal Romano (medallions with chopped tomatoes & artichokes in a lemon, white wine & garlic sauce, that came with a side of spinach (oil and garlic sauce) (other side choices were escarole, broccoli or pasta). Delicious - well cooked. On the low side of moderately priced. Bathroom was clean. We were out by 7:10 ... perfect. I'll be back.

Great pizza. Period. I came here when they were just operating out of the food truck but they now…read morehave an inside location. If you are looking for simple dining and just great pizza this is your place!!

Good quality pizza. Very cozy atmosphere and the owner and staff are very friendly. I would…read moredefinitely recommend for Neapolitan pizza

Food always tastes great the service was amazing ,very inviting decor…read more The only downside was super noisy when full couldn't even have a conversation without speaking loudly. A suggestion is to change the ceilings with noise reduction. Absolutely love this restaurant.

What a remarkable find!! Dinner experience was very special. Look at the menu to see what you…read morewould enjoy and order it and expect it will be exactly to your liking. They won't disappoint. I ordered the filet of sole Francese. It's how I judge the restaurant's expertise. It was THE BEST I have ever been served. No special instructions, none needed. All of the food ordered was above par. I don't believe there are any dishes that would disappoint. The other diners surrounding our table, appeared as satisfied as we were. Smiles abounded. The wait staff were very attentive and on point! Looking forward to my next visit!