Having Rosa's Pizza in Long Island and only 5 mins from my house is a dream come true! This is my favorite pizza period. The sauce is the best I ever had. My favorites are the red slice, grandma slice, eggplant slice and you can never go wrong with the Sicilian. I also enjoy the meatball plate, cheese ravioli and eggplant parm. You really can't go wrong ordering from here. read more

Pizza is great but staff is rude as hell! Sick of it! Umm without customers you have no business so how about some customer service! Id rather have shitty pizza with nice people serving it! So done! read more

Nice to see Rosa's in our neighborhood. They have a good amount of selection of pizzas to choose from. We usually order a pie from them when we feel like a pizza day. The crust is thin and crisp crust. The place is small. There are a few tables for dining in, but we usually order out since we live in the area. The pizzeria is also on Too Good To Go, so you can get a decent meal for a fraction of the price as long as you don't mind what you may get. Overall a great pizza spot and nice folks. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

9/24/25 - We didn't feel like going out, but hubby went to pick up yummy, small pizza and a side of Meatballs.It was just enough. Service was quick as he called in the order. You can get a 10% diff you order through the app, but hubby doesn't like apps, and 10% is not enough incentive. Ambiance is basic. The pizzas in the case offer great choices. The whole meal was almost $20. We pay more than that when we go out for breakfast! FYI, they're on the Too Good to Go app. read more

See all

I walked in. I looked at a very appetizing pie. I asked for a slice, and the man behind the counter started explaining something to me about why he could not give me a slice from that pie. I didn't understand him so I walked out. it's very difficult to buy a piece of pizza these days what happened to the nice little corner pizzeria where we could understand the dude, he was Italian and you could buy any slice you wanted of any pie?! read more

Wow is all I can say!! From the pizza to the staff, the wait for opening day was worth it! Being a Brooklyn girl, I LOVED their grandma slice... chef's kiss! Perfect amount of sauce with a hint of saltiness and sweetness that really shines through. The family could not have been more amazing and welcoming to everyone that stopped by. Carmelina is an angel and as busy as she was, she took the time to talk to me. I am so happy this place has finally opened up not too far from me! I'll definitely be back! read more

See all

Really good pizza and nice staff. There's a few tables to eat, but it's a little more suited for take out, like most pizza spots. I've had the BBQ chicken slice and my wife s enjoyed the Caesar salad chicken slice. I look forward to trying more of their specialty slices soon. Good stuff! read more

The upside down Sicilian Pizza Is Amazing. No one else comes close. Friendly service, same great pizza as the Rosa's in Maspeth read more

The Sicilian upsidedown slice is outstanding, Their regular slice is very nice and very good quality. Their pizza slice are nice size what pizza used to be. Aslo is tasty. All theur food is excellent i havent had a bad experience as of yet and yes i do recommend them. Is a small place so is bet to do take out. read more

A welcome addition to the neighborhood! Finally, a city slice and so much more! Waiting to try their hot food and hero's in the near future however I can predict they will be great and this will be my local go to now. read more

See all

Great pizza, quick and not too busy. We ate in, everything was very fresh. A nice fast food pizzeria. It smells amazing inside!

Reealllllly good pizza. Best around levittown and comes super fast and hot from uber eats.

My first impression Pizza it looks like average New York City pizza, it does have a nice undercarriage there is a good amount of flop. The cheese is very stringy. The sauce is a little bit sweet. Dough is light crust is crispy. Pizza scale is a 5.5 out of 10. 6 garlic knots nothing brag about.. average knots.. side sauce tastes very similar to jar sauce and not fresh. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Two reg slices, 6 knots side of sauce - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

Absolutely one of the best slices of pizza I have had in a long time. This out does any other pizzeria in the North Bellmore, North Merrick area. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - This speaks for itself! - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

I went there on the day of the grand opening but the line was too long so I went by a couple of days later I really enjoyed a regular slice and an upside down slice it took me 4 days to eat them but it was really good lol read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

See all

Sent their upside down Sicilian on a plane for a buddy in FLA. He missed it that much. I used to drive out of my way to get it in Maspeth. Excited to be this close to a Rosa's now. Welcome to the neighborhood. Got their grandma on opening day. Great quality even during the rush. Hope this place stays for a while. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

My taste buds are still jumping. WOW!!! Holy Mozzarella!!! Queens quality pizza on Long Island. Burned the roof of my mouth, that's how fresh it was! Tiny place with only a few tables but the kind of pizza that you would jog miles for read more

Not really a fan of this place unfortunately. Could be just bad luck but anytime i order the pizza, it's always over loaded with cheese which makes it soggy and not enjoyable. But that's just me, worth a shot to try I guess, but I gave it already a few chances and it's just not for me. read more

Ordered the "special" for lunch (Pizza, garlic knots and a soda) and I feel like I overpaid. They advertised 20oz soda with the special but they did not have 20oz or half liter bottles. They gave me 1 16.9fl oz bottle instead. Most pizzeria specials give you a 2 liter bottle. Also $6 for one rice ball? No marinara sauce for dipping either. I can see 2 rice balls for that price. However, the quality of the pizza (cheese, sauce, pepperoni) was delicious. My wife enjoyed the rice ball, as much as I enjoyed the garlic knots. Still, the $40 I paid may seem like a good deal to some, and not for others like me. So, if you don't mind the price, and not getting a little more from what you can get at other places, this an overall good pizza place. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Rosa's Special - Cheese Pizza, 6 garlic knots, and 20oz soda (actually 16.9fl oz) plus 1 $6 Rice Ball (no marinara sauce) - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

See all

Simply the best of the best! My brother took me to the original location in Maspeth years ago and it just hit every spot Now, there's a location down the block and each slice tastes exactly the same! You can't beat a good old Queens slice! The place is a bit small but it's filled with the best hospitality and you feel right at home Sunday dinner done right with Rosa's I give this 20/10 Madones read more

Stopped in today and was pleasantly surprised. First, the gentleman behind the counter was very welcoming and friendly. I ordered a mushroom slice and a vodka ravioli slice. Both were delicious, but the vodka ravioli slice was outstanding. The slices were huge too. There are a couple of tables for dining in. I go to the hair salon in that shopping center, so I will definitely be back! read more

Stopped by at 7:30pm on opening day. After hearing great reviews, we knew we wanted to try it. Ordered a Sicilian and a regular pie. They were delicious. Line was organized, and we made friends with those on line with us. The employees were so welcoming and the DJ made the wait worth it. The pizza was great! Will definitely be back! Best of luck in Bellmore! read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Upside down Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

See all

First Time there last night . Very clean , attractive display of fresh pizza at 8:00, whereas other neighborhood places have slim pickings at that time . Buff slice was huge as well as their chicken Caesar slice . Both were above average . Their upside down slice is what they are famous for from Maspeth queens . It did not disappoint. On par compared to taking a ride to Brooklyn. Staff was very friendly . This place is going to be very popular soon , get there now. . read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Buffalo slice , caeser slice , upside down , vodka slice , mozzarella sticks , pepperoni roll - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

Best sausage and peppers hero on Long Island. So delicious!!! Portions are huge and prices are spectacular. And food is really amazing. Without a doubt, my favorite pizzeria on LI. Oh and their eggplant rollatini is to die for. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Penne ala vodka - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

See all

Once again, items missing from my order. This is a pattern with this place. Seems like every time I order, they put my order together incomplete and then do nothing to make things right. Don't expect much here. read more

The pizza was very good but not outstanding. It was slightly above others. I wouldn't go out f my way for it but I will stop in again when I'm in the neighborhood read more

Love having them out here. Just recently moving from Queens we loved picking up from Rosa's. So seeing Rosa's pizzeria out here made our day and they didn't disappoint. Everything was delicious and we can't wait to go back. read more

Stopped in and ordered cheese calzone and a couple of slices to go. Well first off I I grew up on great pizza and calzones,my calzone was huge which I thought was a good thing until I tasted it,It was dry Ricotta cheese and way too sweet almost cheese like from a cheese danish cheese,terrible. I mean who puts pastry cheese in a calzone,it was really bad,threw it away. The round slice was no better than mediocre and the square Sicilian was like dry cardboard,it's fairly priced but IMO it's not the authentic Rosa's from Maspeth. I won't be returning. read more

I live locally and wanted to give Rosa's a try hoping to make it my families new spot for family parties. Ordered from them Monday over the phone, over a $250 order... I was surprised when I got there that the prices on their website (Rosaspizzabellmore.com) weren't honored. The gentleman working told me their website and that pricing is separate from in store/phone orders.. seems to me like that needs to be fixed if that's your website and you don't plan to honor that pricing. Didn't feel great about the interaction and I expected the cost online to match what I was expected to pay. Be aware of this discrepancy. Probably won't be back because of this. read more

Forgot my order and got annoyed when ask where my food was. Slice was bearly warm and chewy when took a bite. Questionable slice and business practices. read more

Pizza was surprising really good considering the location. But the service was horrible! They guys behind the counter were not to friendly when you use coupons. read more

Tried it out for the first time today. Really great eggplant slice. Great crust! I'll definitely be back!

This is the second time I ordered from this pizzeria. The first time I got the margarita, which was really good. This time. I got the Sicilian. Looked good but It was disappointing. After waiting 40 min, (it was not crowded) the dough tasted undercooked very little cheese it also advertises that you get a free liter of soda with the order which I did not get. I'm ordering on Long Island Strong night so I'm hoping that the five dollars goes to the donation for the fundraiser for the West Babylon families in the crash. read more

Rosa’s Pizza - Pizza from Rosa's - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

The regular pizza crust is always crisp without being burnt and the sauce has great flavor and just the right amount. So far we love the plain - vodka Grandma and the eggplant. Wife loves the upside down Sicilian ... too much sauce for me but I can see why she loves it. read more

Favorite square pie, greatest panini grilled chicken, my family loves anything from Rosas

I tried Rosa's pizza for the first time yesterday and I am thrilled there is a local option for great pizza as there aren't many places that have great pizza (I am very picky about pizza and Italian food). The sauce was delicious and you can tell they use the best ingredients. I ordered the personal pizza with meatballs along with a variety of slices so we could sample a bit of everything. The meatballs were flavorful and delicious. The eggplant slice was HUGE and the eggplant was crispy and delicious. The grandma slice was perfect (this is only the 2nd place I tried that knows how to make a great Grandma slice). I also had the spinach roll which was stuffed with spinach. The parking is convenient. The prices are very fair and better than most places. Looking forward to having leftovers for lunch! This is definitely my new pizza spot. read more

My mom and I went to Rosa's to try it out and it was amazing! The man at the counter was so kind and the pizza was great! 10/10

This place had promise but sadly is just a big let down. We discovered this place the night before its grand opening, on a soft open. I was familiar with the Maspeth location and was super excited to learn this was the same family. The pizza that night was spectacular; delicious, tasty, wonderful sauce, thin crust and everything a Queen's pie is. The day of the grand opening we were on that long line, waiting to get that yummy pizza. We got home and the pizza was tasty but the dough was just too thick. We shrugged it off as opening day rushing because the place was that busy! We had it a few more times, today being the last time. Don't get me wrong, the taste is still there but the dough is just too thick. If I wanted a Sicilian slice, I would order that because at least it would be airy. The regular pizza dough is so thick and gummy that it overshadows the goodness of the flavor. read more

Great pizza brought me back to queens pizza is fresh service very good and staff friendly price good

I called to place a decent size order. Hero, pizza slices etc. I call and the guy on the phone said I can't order slices on the phone and need to come in cuz he's "too busy". 10 other pizza places in town that are happy to have my business. Happy to go elsewhere. Don't know what the hype is with this place anyway. read more