Pasta primavera that is so good it keeps even Grandma coming back ;) the staff is fantastic - great place all around. Cute dining area with private event space Quaint yet modern feel read more

Been coming here many years now. They are famous for the generous basket of breads that comes out when you are looking at the menu. My wife appreciates the cauliflower crust pizza. I dream of the fetuccini Alfredo. Easy parking here read more

See all

We stopped by on a weekday night after a late appointment. It's in the King Kullen parking lot on Sunrise Highway with plentiful parking. We'd been there many years ago, when our kids were little, mostly for pizza, and I once stopped there for lunch on my own. At the next table were three generations of a family celebrating a birthday. The food was plentiful, very reasonably priced, and the menu offered many choices. My wife suggested splitting the antipasto side salad and eggplant parmigiana... good call! Our waiter was helpful and experienced, and the kitchen was fairly prompt. There was also some quirky ambience, for example, a motorcycle hanging on the wall. All things considered, a very good choice for traditional southern Italian cuisine at a family oriented neighborhood pizza/restaurant. read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Was here for a good sized birthday party, which was held in the back room & which had more than enough space for all 40 or so guests. Service was excellent, personalized, servers were actively involved & very attentive & super efficient. Food was excellent, plentiful & presented beautifully. Will happily return here for any occasion. read more

Food is delicious!! Always a wait, but staff is friendly and you can hang out at the bar (where I was for a bit). Bartender refilled my drink at no charge which was very generous! It's a very welcoming restaurant where you get an amazing bread basket to start. They have a great salad/antipasto dish with every entree. The chicken is always delicious and juicy and the fish is always fresh. The portions are plentiful and I'm so glad this place is not that far so I can go back often! read more

The food is absolutely delicious. Their pizza bread baskets are always amazing. I always come here for the margaritas and the penne ala vodka with peas! Everyone here is always so kind helpful and patient. Definitely go here. read more

Very nice place. Staff was great. I had a party for my mom. They were very accommodating. We will b back

Shrimp sambuca Presentation was awesome. Flavors delicious. Priced perfect. I would recommend it to anybody that wanted a meal that was that good read more

The food, The Pizza, and The service is very good The food is normal,, no frills, just done right 1 of 3 places near here that we consider going to for Pizza and more. read more

Made reservations for NYE online from Piccolo's website well in advance. I received several texts asking me to confirm, which I did. I received a reminder of our upcoming reservation the day before. Suddenly, the night before I happen to see an email saying that our reservation was canceled. No phone call. I called the restaurant immediately, assuming it was a mistake. A girl answered and I explained that my reservation was canceled and asked for her to reinstate it. She told me to hold on. She did not put me on hold. She yelled for Frankie and told him that I was screaming at her (I was not upset, since I assumed this was just an innocent mistake and would be fixed). Frankie gets on the phone and tells me that OpenTable never should have allowed me to make the reservation. OpenTable is the way their website allows you to make reservations! Nonetheless, I asked why I didn't receive a phone call since this was very last minute, leaving our party little time to find an alternative plan. Frankie said we never even had a reservation - despite my emails and texts telling me different. Frankie was not apologetic. He repeatedly said this had nothing to do with his restaurant (again, the link to make reservations via OT is ON THEIR RESTAURANT'S WEBSITE). He said this was an OT mistake that he had nothing to do with. I asked if they could accommodate our party at an earlier time. He said no and hung up. It sounds to me that Piccolo's did not update their OpenTable reservations and continued to take reservations that did not exist. Then instead of owning up to their mistake, they are letting patrons believe it is their mistake. I suspect people will show up tonight and be surprised when their table does not exist. Regardless of where the blame falls, the least Frankie could have at least been courteous, offered an apology, and been polite. We did, in fact, plan our evening around this dinner and so having it canceled without even a phone call is just bad business. We will not return to this restaurant. read more

Came here for dinner on Sunday and cannot say enough wonderful things about the service. There are many restaurants on Long Island who have good food but service it what really makes a place stand out. Our server Theresa was beyond exceptional. She was attentive, charismatic and truly made our already good experience with the food a memorable one for how she treated us. We can't wait to come back and will make sure if she is working to ask for her. It's not often you go out to eat and get service that really goes over the top and truly makes you leave feeling special. Thank you Piccolo and Theresa for a wonderful dinner. read more

I was in with a group of people after a funeral on Monday, June 9, 2025. from start to finish everything was amazing. The food was delicious and plentiful. Our server, Mindy, was attentive, friendly and had a great sense of humor. Going out after an emotional service is hard. Mindy made it comfortable and welcoming. I recommend this restaurant for any occasion!! Thank you!! read more

All I can say is amazing! Food, service, and patrons! Sat at the bar and had drinks and food with friends and Jen the bartender is excellent! She's hysterical and makes amazing signature cocktails! Everyone here is so friendly. My new favorite spot for a drink! Ask for Jen! read more

Friendly efficient service. Mediocre meal is being generous. I ordered the chicken eggplant combo and it was not fresh. The eggplant was very dry, over breaded and flavorless. The chicken cutlet was thin, dry, salty but edible. The salad and breadbasket were the best part of the meal. The pasta was ok. I don't recommend ordering entrees. I should have taken the waitresses advice and ordered an individual pizza. read more

Great Food and Service! I dinned there with my daughter and a few friends. Stephanie behind the bar was amazing and the drinks were so good. I Recommend the espresso martini, watermelon Margarita and the low Sugar spiked lemonade. I have diabetes so the new low sugar drinks are prefect for me! Food was impeccable, I ordered the Linguine with garlic and oil with shrimp and deff something I would be ordering again! Pasta Comes with a side salad and bread, first there was 2 types of bread, one typical italian with butter spread so good with the pasta and another was more like cheesy bread sticks with sauce and I ate all of it! The salad was fresh and their homemade vinaigrette is a soo good I would order just a large house salad next time! Generous amount of pasta and shrimp had to take some home for later! My daughter and her friend got pizza and mozzarella sticks and they ate it all and had fun, nice family spot and welcoming to kids. Dessert was great too ice cream and an Oreo cheese cake to die for! Another generous amount we took half the cheesecake home. 5 stars going to make this place my regular spot! read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Spiked Low sugar lemonade - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Food was tasteless. Would not recommend. Lack of attention to detail Sauces lacked proper flavor

Our trusted Italian restaurant for over 45 years. A standout for dining in, taking out, in house or home catered meals. We have done it all with Piccolo and have no complaints ever their staff is super friendly. The owner is amazing and the food excels. read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Ravioli with meatballs & sausage - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

A local favorite. Staff is friendly & attentive . House salad lacked nothing, had everything Friday night Eggplant special was amazing.A delish lobster sauce you wanted a bowl of. Triple play of ravioli, eggplant, rollitini & lasagna with a delicious sauce 5 star dinner read more

My second time in this restaurant wasn't as good as my first time. The bread crumbs over the pasta was burn and the pasta wasn't tasty and very chewy. It tasted to me like was heated def Not as fresh. We didn't mention anything. I asked to rap to go. When we got the bill we notice a $90 extra charge in our bill. Luckily I always check. Ones I got home I had to spend some time in the bathroom right away. You know what I mean. So I should have listen to my intuition and returned that pasta w sausage w breadcrumbs right back. I trow it out my leftovers and won't be returning. So many more places to go without the inconvenience off getting sick. Sad couse I'm from Huntington. But is out of my list. read more

Decent neighborhood restaurant. My combo baked pasta dish: lasagna, eggplant, manicotti seemed to have melted into each other. Prob could have been cooked less. Baked clams were good. Good service. read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

It was lunch hour and we found ourselves here, the place is nice the staff was friendly and the food ok. The piccolo garlic bread was good ,the calamari was definitely interesting and tasty, the panini and soup were ok. read more

See all

Stopped in for a slice. More restaurant than a slice shop but it was a decent slice. Served it on a real plate. No flop. Good undercarriage. Real cheese read more

I came in to Piccolo's on Friday night with a friend and we sat at the bar. Mindy was our bartender. Not only did she make our drinks ( Espresso martinis) perfect she was also super friendly and attentive. This was our first time here and we definitely will be back! read more

I had a baby shower for my daughter on 1/18 at Piccolo. everyone had a great time and there was plenty of food and it was delicious. Samantha and Sophia were excellent and very courteous servers and did whatever it was asked . A big thank you to them and the rest of the staff. Annie was amazing! Frank as well. I requested a specific cake with a jungle and animal theme, it more than exceeded my expectation, just like the invitation. My daughter was so happy with it. I definitely recommend Piccolo restaurant in Bellmore! Thanks Frank, much appreciated. read more

We are a group of 4 couples who frequently dine out together. Piccolo is one of our favorites. We were never disappointed with the food or service. We always asked for separate checks. The last time we dined there the separate checks became an issue. We were told there was a new system that would only bill the table. They do a great business so apparently they could care less if they lost us as customers. We haven't been back since. Vincent R read more

Had my daughter's party here a few weeks ago. It honestly was a terrible experience. We came into the room and nothing was set up. We dropped decor, seating chart/cards, and balloons off at 10am for a 1pm party. We ended up finishing early at church so we all arrived at 12:45pm. Nothing. Was. Done. Still in the basket that I brought it in; placed on the table. I had to verbally tell people where their tables were as well as run around like a chicken without a head to put decoration around/untangle balloons. Pretty disappointed as well with management/owner, Tommy. When we booked this event, we purposely booked here for the family style menu. Everything was served family style other than the main course (Chicken Parm, Chicken Francese, Eggplant Rollatini, Salmon, etc) When I asked the waiter about it being family style he said the kitchen is under prepared for it to be family style, he's not sure. So I grabbed Frank & Tommy to ask about it. Tommy came off beyond aggressive saying "it's not on the contract... I don't remember it.... it's not written down". BUT if you look at the contract it doesn't say family style for pasta or dessert as well but yet that was served family style. So why is the entree served differently? Frank saw we were visibly upset and offered to have the cake be free. Well, good thing because they served the cake on hot plates fresh from the dishwasher (glad they were clean at least) This made the whipped cream melt and foam like. Food could have tasted better...Not really impressed then to have service be the way it was, just made a bad taste in my mouth. A few days later a woman called asking about my experience with the party. I told her exactly what is said above and she said Tommy (owner) would get back to me -- 3 weeks later and he still hasn't. read more

This place is absolutely amazing, the food is incredible and everyone is so friendly, and the place is a nice size so your not cramped up , it's perfect read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

We had a bridal shower at Piccolo. Frank was wonderful to help plan the event and Sueann and the servers were great. They even made personalized menus. The food was amazing and the space was perfect. read more

Okay pizza tastes decent ,the service underlining not feeling the vibes it was an older women who took my order not feeling her vibez the ambiance looked old school that's all the question is would I come here Not really read more

Piccolo Ristorante - 2 Grandma Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

We had our 50th anniversary catered by Piccolo's, in Bellmore. The food and service, by Anastasia, was excellent. Most of the guests commented on how delicious the food was. Thanks again, Tommy. read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Italian Restaurant In Bellmore - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Came here because they were open till 10pm. I honestly felt like i was in an episode of kitchen nightmares. Long story short, the atmosphere was odd, service was eh, and I was talked out of my appetizer. The food was just ok, but def microwaved and not freshly prepared. I have had worse and def better. I came here before and it was much better and I doubt i will ever go back as there are so many better options for fast italian nearby. read more

I just in to grab a pie to bring home . Service is friendly as are other customers at the bar where i waited . I had a lovely glass of shiraz which was full bodied and dry . The seating area is large with good lighting . It's a casual come as you are type vibe . Family friendly. Pizza is thin crust and crispy ! I have also had their chopped salads which are also crispy , fresh and perfectly dressed I always reheat pizza when i get home ! what about you ? read more

See all

If you like a plate full of breadcrumbs covered with sauce and lumps of cheese, this is the place for you. The salad was good but the rest was awful. I ordered a combo plate which was supposed to be 3 shrimp, eggplant rollatini and lasagna. After digging around and scraping off layers of soggy breading I found 1 1/2 shrimps. The eggplant was not rollatini but wayward bits also covered in breadcrumbs and less than stellar sauce. The lasagna was a weird circle of a tiny bit of pasta encircling something pink that resembled cat food. Just nasty. read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Combination plate allegedly containing 3 shrimp, eggplant rollatini and lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

this was our go to with the kids forever - the food is always good and consistent (vip) the staff is great and it just very comfortable here - You're never rushed - I high recommend it here read more

We have been to Piccolo many times, for different holidays, occasions and for a bite to eat. The food has always been delicious. Planning a party there is easy and the food is plentiful for the price. The servers are friendly and attentive. It's casual and there is a side room for larger groups of people. read more

The food is okay. It's a typical Italian place. As a black woman, it's pretty noticeable that my guest and I were the only people of color in the place for the duration of our mean at rush time; which was a bit uncomfy for us. Ambiance is relative, right? I think for the average Long Islander it's just fine read more

Had dinner today, food was terrible, We had shrimp scampi loaded with bread crumbs, and Veal Rotini had no taste, My wife said the wine was no good even the Italian Cheescake was bad it tasted like a fruit cake, told fhe waiter but we were charged full price. Do not recommend Piccolos at all ?? Bill & Carmen K read more

Is Piccolo Ristorante the best Italian restaurant on Long Island? For me, the answer is: yes! And the reason is: consistency. I've simply never had a bad meal, poor interaction, or negative experience. The food is fresh and delicious. Their staff clearly cares about their guests. The restaurant is immaculately clean. Everyone from Baldwin to Amityville should make this their go-to for Italian food. It's that good. Piccolo is so good that we booked my son's baptism party here for this upcoming June and we just know we won't be disappointed. I can't wait to write an updated review with details and pics. Thank you, Piccolo, for your great food and pristine service! read more

Stopped in for a slice! Way back but recall the traditional New York style of pizza I miss! You go into the thin alley like cozy NY hang in the strip mall and smell and see that long warm oven housing your lunch! . The staple selection of your favorite combinations await. It's been a long time as my brother lives not far and I don't go visit as often as I did years ago!( He got divorced)-. I liked this place enough to keep the business card I posted a pic of and the address is still correct so clearly they have been going strong for decades!! Good job guy's ! read more

Piccolo Ristorante - Had this card for 15 years!! - Pizza Near Me - Bellmore, New York

We had a great time at the bar. Food was excellent and so was the service. Everyone was super friendly.