Some classic NY slices in here right in the heart of town. I really enjoyed my Sicilian slices. They had plenty of seating both indoors and outdoors along with plenty of slice options. The staff were friendly and quick. I would definitely return next time I'm in the area. read more

Umbertos - Pizza selection - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Local fave spot for solid Italian food. We are regulars. Service is great and love sitting outside when the weather gets nice. The salmon special is always my go to and gelato too !!! read more

Umbertos - Vodka personal pizza - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

For the past few years now this place has really come along way. Foods great and the manager Mike is such a great guy. Pizza is always on point and there resturant food is also very good. I recommend the mussles, meatballs, chicken parm, and chicken franchise personally. They have a decent size resturant and a small 3 booth pizza side. The bar is also very nice and perfect for a cocktail. Definitely recommend if your in town. read more

Umbertos - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Received the most obnoxious behavior from the front staff. We had a reservation on OpenTable for 530 and arrived at the restaurant at 5:40 to be told that they gave away our table and we would go on a waiting list likely 45 minutes. OpenTable has our telephone number and They did not even have the decency to call to see if we were on our way. I have never been treated like this in a restaurant over only nine minutes late! We will never be back and will make sure we tell everyone!! read more

The manager and his daughters were the best host and hostesses I have had in a long time Food fabulous read more

Hadn't been here for a while, because we are always searching for new places to try. So today we had an early pizza dinner, and were reminded. Umberto's of Massapequa Park has the best Grandma Pizza around. Perfect crust, perfect sauce. We also love the deep dish, another best ever. Ya gotta remember, there are a lot of pizza joints in the area, but not a lot of Great Pizza. Umberto's is the best, and I say this after returning from vacation in Italy. And by the way, the Afogato for dessert is a hard to find and also excellent. We'll be back!!! read more

We had chicken cacciatore and chicken with breadcrumbs and sides of baby potatoes, asparagus, and broccoli. Delicious flavorful sauce and hot sauce. We were surrounded by delicious looking pizza and pasta. Nice servers and manager kept checking on us. read more

Umbertos - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

This Umburtos located in the small village of Massapequa Park has take out Pizzeria food. They also have bar for dining in.. In warm weather they have outside dining with table service. Some popular items are salads, pasta & Margherita Pizza - which they do reliably well. A good place for an easy night out with wine and casual Italian food.. read more

Recently ate lunch here with my son-in-law and grandson. Consistently good pizza and such a treat to have when in town from CA. It's pretty easy to find authentic Italian pizza in NYC or on Long Island what with so many Italians knowing what to do. We happen to love this pizza from Umberto's and get it every visit to NY. read more

See all

Always get a delicious pizza and dinner at Umbertos. Since we live close, Umbertos is our go to place for dinner after a long work week.

An Italian place that offers "panini's" but doesn't even know what a panini is. Ordered a grilled chicken panini and was served a cold sandwich on a roll. Called back after picking up the order and was told that they don't press their "panini's" and there isn't anything they can offer to fix it. Bad place, not true Italians read more

Umbertos - This is not a panini - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Food is phenomenal. Service is great. Prices are reasonable. The grandma pie is exceptional. I had it made with vodka sauce. And it did not disappoint. Place is situated in a cute town. read more

Umbertos - Grandma Vodka pie - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Let's start with the service. They were very attentive and so nice. Entertain my son as he watch them make a pizza pie from scratch. Place is very updated, clean with modern chairs and benches, but with actual clean organize containers with all types of toppings. The pizza slice and the Sicilian pie OMG IT WAS AMAZING! Hate to compare with other places but CLOSE TO PRINCE ST PIZZA taste FROM SOHO. I was amazed and DEFINITELY order and coming again to this place which is 30 mins away from my house. read more

Something changed this place is completely disorganized and not the same. Too many people behind the counter they have no clue whose pie really belongs to which order. With so many pizza options go elsewhere. read more

New to Massapequa. I found Umberto on Park ave. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and very active. Plenty of welcoming staff. Even the manager is welcoming and active in all aspects of the operation. We found our appetizers and salad to be delicious. Our entrees were also extremely delicious. It's a great place to return to. There's also outside seating ! read more

Ordered at 4:30 for a 7:00 delivery. It got here at 8:10. Horrible service. Never again. When you call they don't even pretend to care

I have a love hate with umbertos. Honestly, I tried the new guys down the block with the bleach-free and no bromates roman pies. Very clean food. But I still prefer umbertos over them despite some bad experiences here. Umbertos has been decent lately. read more

We had a birthday party for my father-in-law (85th) at Umberto's Massapequa Park on a Saturday in late March. We had about 40 pp which was set into two very long tables. The establishment was very clean organized with cloth table covers and a personal preference, wrapped utensils, clean b&b plates stemed water glasses etc. The food I will admit that it was good, actually very good. We opted for the grandma pizza and fried calamari. The calamari was spot on, fresh, ( but probably frozen previously) crispy but not over cooked which made it very good and not chewy as some places I have eaten, even at high end restaurants. Never trying previously the grandma pizza at Umberto's was absolutely delicious. The ingredients were of good quality. We have since ordered take out and the grandma pizza was great again. I believe consistency is key to success. We had our event in the afternoon. Decorating the area was assisted by an eager, friendly staff. The manager was on site and keeping an eye on all. We were able to successfully surprise the the birthday man and he was overjoyed. I spoke to all our guests to ask how they were enjoying everything. There were no bad reviews or comments given, rather they raved about the food even the chicken parmesan, eggplant rolatine, shrimp scampi, salad and bread was all favorable. The price was right for what we received. They did not leave us hungry with plenty of offerings. They even packed up the leftovers for us. In addition to the service they cut the cake for us but the cake we purchased at a local well known Italian bakery was of very poor quality as it crumbled uncontrollably. We made the best of it. That review to follow. All said and done, we completely enjoyed the friendly staff and manager made our day a great one. I have just recently started leaving reviews about my travels and observations. I have the time now to write these reviews with an open mind. I give credit to credit due and honest opinions about how it can be. Umberto's is a established Italian restaurant that's gets 4 stars from me. Well done operators, we will be back. read more

The food (being a huuuuge fan of Umbertos I guess I over expected! The service, only aspect salvageable! Food was just God awful! I would NEVER return! The Lasagne was like a pie that was crash accident. I wasn't impressed! read more

Known for their Grandma pie, it's always a must when ordering. Got two pies and both were amazing. Quick delivery and kind driver. Massapequa has a plethora of pizza places, but this is one of the best! Constantly great! read more

Umbertos - Grandma pie, Classico pie on the right. - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

So disorganized. The young girl at the counter was overwhelmed and the other girl, who usually is at the register, needs to get another job. She is rude and has a pissed off look on her face all the time. She's in a service business and needs to act as such. A customer came in after ordering a pie and waited quite a while for it. Instead of apologizing for the delay or offering some kind of discount, she just shoves the box at her read more

I went to this place with my baby cousin. Everyone was SO NICE to us. I had a pasta and it tasted amazing. This place has amazing service and the food come out pretty quick. I've been here twice. The first time it was PACKED. The second time it was very quiet. A amazing place. read more

The Umberto Calamari is fried and has a little spice which gives it a tasty kick if you are into that. I could just eat the appetizers and be full. The manager comes out to either seat other parties or say hi, gives it a welcoming family feel. I had great meal and a good time here. Outdoor seating on Park Ave is a nice touch. You can RSVP via OpenTable for points. When making RSVP, it is only for inside seating, if you have to ask if outdoor seating is available to take. Lastly there's a 3.5% cash discount. Good: -White Mussels -Calamari (Umberto) was great! -Gnocci Bolongese was delicious! -Portobello Salad was filling. -Parking in the rear lot -RSVP on OpenTable for points Bad: -I had to ask for the complimentary bread read more

See all

Food was not impressive no flavor . Waiter forgot the cheese & forgot the ice. The only two things I asked for. he was either on his phone or watching the baseball game. read more

Never going back here!! We ordered the pizza to be cooked light because they typically overcook it. The bottom of the pie was still blackened. We ordered Calamari with regular sauce and got super hot/spicy sauce. They overcharge for everything on top of not doing it well. $48 for a pizza & calamari. It's horrible to go there to get your food, come home to enjoy it, and it's bad. When I read more

Umbertos - The blackened bottom of the pizza crust. We ordered it to be cooked light. It was gross! - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

First time here. The pizza was delicious. I had a regular cheese slice and a sicilian slice. Both were cooked to perfection, not burnt and the crust was crunchy and seasoned well. Thanks read more

Our go to Italian place about once a week. Pizza is really good obviously but their entrees are delicious too. Big portions, always come out fast, and they have a full bar. Staff super nice, the main guy that's always there is great with our toddler and getting the order in fast. My husband loves their chicken franchese and the draft Peroni. Plenty of parking and fair priced! read more

Umbertos - Spaghetti bolognese and Penne Alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

In comparison to the other locations, this one could use a little work but overall was good! Was hoping the pizza would be a little less doughy but nonetheless it's better than most pizzerias out here in the long island. The only person they're competing with is themselves lol! read more

I have eaten from this location before but now done after yesterday. Margherita pizza 26 dollars burnt on bottom and dry. Do I really have to check the bottom of the pie before I leave the restaurant? For that money for a stupid pizza soneone ought to be doing quality control. Go elsewhere for pizza at least. read more

They have a name, give it a try. I tried the Massapequa Park store and ordered chicken cutlet Parm dinner with penne Alfredo. Now, I've been a chef for nearly 35 years went to school work the industry and I've never tasted an Alfredo sauce with so much nutmeg in it it was overpowering and un edible. The chicken cutlet Parm the chicken was so tough I've never had chicken so tough in my life. I don't know what they did with it but it was like rubber. So this is based on the food I've never eaten there inside per se. But as far as the food. Sorry guys need some quality control over there with some one oversee food going out. read more

They should be embarrassed to write "since 1965" on the box because if you can't perfect your recipe in 57 years, you should close up shop. Ordered a Sicilian with vodka sauce and fried chicken. Looks like a grandma to me based on the thinness. That's the least of the concern. Pizza was burnt on the bottom, hard, chewy, bitter from being burnt, and dry. The regular pie was barely cooked, doughy, chewy, and the sauce tasted like something you get out of isle 5 at the supermarket. $60 for two pies and they were both trash. Don't send out garbage and hope people aren't going to say anything about it. Have some standards. Needless to say I won't be returning. read more

Umbertos - Burnt - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

I was shopping in Massapequa and stopped by Umberto's for lunch! WOW the food was excellent we ordered not one BUT 2 orders of Baked Clams they were so delicious we also had salmon piccata it was super fresh and tasted delicious and beautiful glass of sangria. BUT what also make this place absolutely the best, is the team that works there ,Peter the chef came to say hello, Carlos the manager super friendly, Antonio our waiter was exceptional same as the girls they all were very attentive, quick, and kind. Looking forward to go back soon again. Definitely a wonderful place to eat. read more

Umbertos - Baked clams - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

Been here twice while visiting in from Texas. The food here is soo authentic and fresh. They have the best chicken bacon ranch pizza I've ever tasted. The Caesar salad is delicious. The mozzarella sticks were nice and hot and paired perfect with the marinara sauce. Highly recommend!! read more

See all

Food is good, but give your order twice because they don't listen. Ordered my sandwich with toasted bread....said toasted bread on receipt....no toasted bread read more

This place has gone downhill fast! Food is subpar. It used to be a nice Italian place where you knew what you were getting. Now the portions are smaller, prices are higher, and the quality of the food isn't there. Meatballs are dry and lack flavor, sauce is sour, and the pasta is of poor quality. The service is notably slow, with staff appearing more engaged in conversation than checking on customers. Server knowledge of the food is limited, offering favorable descriptions of dishes that differ from what you get. Now, the pizza side is a different story. Excellent pizza and excellent service. Unfortunately, I allowed this establishment three additional opportunities to meet my expectations. Regrettably, these attempts were unsuccessful. Consequently, I am willing to pay more at Baccaro's, which is conveniently located across the street. read more

The pizzas and salads are delicious! Staff is always friendly and welcoming. Ambiance is always busy but people are super nice!

Pizza's great, but had a Greek salad there with chicken. Not a fan. Not enough feta, and the greens itself didn't really taste fresh. Maybe I caught an "off" day, because everything I've eaten there I've really enjoyed. I like the ambiance a lot. read more

The pizza was pretty good. I enjoyed my slice but the dark haired girl behind the pizza counter is not friendly or personable. She looks angry and doesn't smile. Maybe hire a friendly face who makes customers feel welcome. I was here on a Friday at 2:30 pm. That is all. read more

Pizza overall is a 3.5. Surprisingly only ok, considering how much press and success this group has had. Maybe I'm missing out on their entrees... Their grandma pie, while reliably delicious, has gone on a diet and gotten more expensive - approaching eggflation. Their other pies are consistent though on par with others in the area. +their garlic knots are a good pickup. +their staff are professional +you can order and sit down on your own or be waited on. Still one of the better pies around, which will keep me coming back. read more

Quite literally the worst meatball "hero" I've ever had. It's not even hero bread?! Very unusual to not announce that. Wings are good. Maybe make a legit hero not with deli rolls read more