The pizza is delicious! But thats not all.. the workers are kind and welcoming. Especially Leo and Tony who made me feel very welcome. Grazie! read more

I can always count on Taglio Pizza to have unique pizza options. I went with the buffalo chicken, barbeque chicken, burrata and sausage and pepper. I was hesitant to try sausage and pepper on pizza, but you won't regret it. So many delicious flavors at the same time. The best part is the light and crisp crust, so good. It does get crowded on weekends but I never have to wait that long. read more

See all

Welp, I guess I'm not going to try their food. I called to place an order for 3 specialty pizzas, 3 salads & 2 heros. I was told they dont take phone orders and the woman sent me a link to order online. Now I had to pull over, figure out where everything I needed to order was, ok not bad. Now I have to create an account to place the order. THAT is when I shut the site down, and ordered elsewhere. 10 minutes wasted on the side of the road. ***You had me on the phone !!! Take my damn money. UR LOSS. read more

I was skeptical because I haven't found anything close to Roman pizza here. Well now I have! You walk in and they have a ton of different options, some authentic and some their own spin on it. I purposely picked what I have had in Rome , and settled on a funghi and mortadella e pistacchio piece. The second I took a bite I knew this was different. It was light and airy and crispy , exactly as it should be. The ingredients are clearly fresh and high quality. I found the guys behind the counter to be extremely helpful and nice . They are also quite funny , especially Leo. I have been back already more than once and it is consistent. Very well done , can't wait to continue to come back and try other things. read more

See all

Taglio Pizza is hands down the best pizza on Long Island. The space is roomy with nice decor, making it a great spot to hang out. The BBQ chicken is my personal favorite, but you really can't go wrong with any slice. I've tried the buffalo chicken, Margherita, buffalo, and Bianca - every single one was incredible. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

There are so many great places to eat in Massapequa Park near the train tracks. Taglio's is one of the best! My son's friend recommended it and then we found out it's highly rated as the best pizza in the U.S. I had a pepperoni slice and you can taste the difference fresh ingredients make! It was flavorful and delicious with the perfect crust. The kids said the BBQ chicken slice beats any of our local places for flavor and freshness. It was moderately crowded on a Saturday night but we found a table and got our food very quickly. The music and decor gives this pizza place a unique vibe - great place to grab a slice before or after drinks at one of the local area bars. They also have an extensive mixed drink menu and amazing gelato, which we were too full to try! Will be back again and again! read more

See all

I ordered a regular slice, taking the recommendation of my Yelp Elite friend "Dan's Grub Adventures". It was above average compared to the crap that I have eaten in NY of late. I grew up eating in pizza shops owned by Italian immigrants, and nothing will ever compare! I drank a bottle of Menabrea beer with it. It is a blonde Italian beer with a moderate amount of bitterness, according to its website birramenabrea.com. It is too bitter for me. I prefer Peroni, the best-selling Italian beer that only has a mild amount of bitterness. I joined Taglio's Rewards program and received 35 points on toasttab.com. The service was average, and the place was clean and tidy. I highly recommend. read more

See all

I really love Taglio & the crew/staff who always make my experience positive. In the warmer months, I typically come for a slice at least once a week because their location is in perfect view of the train station, which my 18 month old son loves to look at. A few months ago, my son wasn't eating pizza yet, and Rob always gives my son a little bread if he wants which is super nice. Let's talk about the pizza and vibe now. I really love the upbeat music, the artwork on the walls is super creative and the restaurant is clean. Their fountain drinks are self serve, and there are high chairs if you need. I have never had a bad slice at Taglio. Pizza is consistently delicious and their salads are very good too. My go to's are anything with pepperoni on it & their chicken parm hero. If you are looking for a good vibe, friendly staff, great pizza with indoor and outdoor seating- give Taglio a try. read more

Taglio Pizza - Outdoor area very accommodating for kids and strollers & a perfect view of people watching & trains - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

I discovered this place on TikTok and was pleasantly surprised to learn it was only a few minutes from my home in Massapequa. As soon as I walked in, the staff greeted me right away and let me know I could seat myself either inside or outside. They also have a separate side entrance if you're just heading to the bar. The interior has a really cool vibe, with artwork on the walls inspired by Roman and Greek gods, and TVs throughout so you can catch the game while you eat. All the different pizza varieties are displayed in a glass case, making it easy to see your options before they pop your slice back in the oven. The pizza was phenomenal. It is packed with flavor and the perfect amount of crunch. I'll definitely be bringing friends and family here whenever I have visitors in town. If you're on Long Island and looking to try some of the best pizza around, I highly recommend stopping by Taglio Pizza. They also have another location in Mineola. As a bonus, they offer a military discount, which is always appreciated for those of us who serve. read more

See all

Damned good, actually. A friend turned us on to Taglio and for our first try, we ordered the Roman with pesto, cheese, pepperono and vodka sauce. Delish!!! The menu looks amazing, and we saw several things we want to try. We'll be back! read more

Finally made it here for lunch. My mom and I were in the area and I suggested coming here. Upon walking in I saw the display case with all the different pizzas! So many choices and everything looked delicious. I asked the staff member behind the counter what certain slices were. I settled on Mortadella Pistacio and Prosciutto Arugula. My mom and I split the slices. They were absolutely delicious! Both unique in flavors and not something I've had before. Staff behind the counter was very friendly and it was clean inside. I would absolutely return! Wish one was closer to me in Patchogue. read more

Taglio Pizza - Left- Mortadella Pistacio Right- Prosciutto Arugula - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Great pizza ! Definitely one of the best on Long Island. Offering both regular and Roman style pizza. Definitely worth the price with offered toppings. A have to try pizzeria. read more

Absolutely hands down 10 out of 10! It's absolutely delicious and the sauce is not overly sweet just how a pizza should be the Roman style is my absolute favor! I will definitely be back for more read more

Taglio Pizza location popped into one of my foodie feeds with great news that they rated #3 nationwide in 2025. So I couldn't miss an opportunity to see what the successful buzz really yielded. Not to mention living in Nassau county LI, why I hadn't heard of them before. This isn't the first time either according to article I read that they were getting rated high nationwide. That said went in with no information other than their stellar ranking. Walked in via back door since we parked in back open municipal lot to a narrow hallway with few small tables that exploded onto a very large clean, covered glass counter with all their offerings. I came to find that the majority of there slices were square/rectangle in shape. So not your traditional NY triangle wedged slice. A bit thrown off and being on a time crunch I couldn't simply decide on one of their specialty looking slices...there were at least 10 different fresh kinds. So for the sake of getting a feel for their red sauce and crust, my Mr and I just ordered up 1 plain Cheese Slice and 1 Pepperoni Slice $10 (cash price). Note the slices went into oven for less than 5 minutes and came out pipping HOT!! So watch out on that first bite. My husband and I thought, alright a decent slice, not the best or worse had here in NY. I figure, I really need to go back and pick one of their Square designer slices to probably get the real award winning feel of this location. After the pop in last night I decided to research a bit on a Roman slice, and found out the name of location now makes sense, along with what the majority of slices looked like ;) A Roman-styled pizza was defined as "pizza al taglio", and this a type of pizza that originated in Rome. It is characterized by a rectangular or square shape with a thin crust . The dough is typically made with higher hydration and allowed to ferment for an extended period, resulting in a light, airy, and crisp crust. That now known, will definitely be going back to see what I truly missed, and hopefully give them that 5th star for what's truly #3 in the nation. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pepperoni ~7.7.25 - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

I'm not really a big pizza girl but my friend wanted a slice so we came here over the weekend. I do agree with others reviews about the attitude of those behind the counter. Why do they all look so mad? The pizza itself has a ton of choices which I liked, I got the Serra to start, I don't normally like pesto sauce but all the sauces together worked insanely well. I decided to take 2 slices home. The spinach and artichoke slice which I'll have tonight for dinner and the prosciutto arugula slice which was also delicious. I'd def try a salad or hero here. The food is definitely good read more

See all

Not sure how this place is rated so low, it blows all the pizza in the area out of the water and was probably the best square pizza I've had in a very long time. SO. MANY. VARIETIES. I wanted like 6 of them! Wound up going with the Diavola and the potato, caramelized onion, rosemary one. Both were so good, but the Diavola was exceptional. The perfect ratio of sweet to spicy with pepperoni and cheese and fresh basil. I went back up for a second slice. These are dangerous!! Crust was so good, light, airy, not greasy, and CRUNCHY! The base held up under all those toppings. I know I'll be back to try the salads, sandwiches, and platters. Everything looked so good! read more

See all

We had a great experience trying Taglio Pizza for the first time! So many pizza choices to pick from. We got a bit of everything (buffalo chicken, bbq chicken, burrata slice, tri slice). My favorite was the buffalo chicken & burrata slice. I highly recommend. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

**FANTASTIC ROMAN & REGULAR STYLE PIZZA** **CRAZY GOOD HEROS & PARMIGIANA PLATES** WHAT'S WRONG WITH LONG ISLAND PIZZA? Just about everyone likes to indulge in a nice slice of pizza. And because of this, countless pizzeria restaurants can be found throughout any Long Island town. But really, the vast majority of these restaurants are making pizza in the same mediocre manner. With a heavy, thick & doughy crust, that is really not cooked very well, and packed with excessive cheese. For goodness sake, it almost seems like, these pizza makers were all trained by the same incompetent chef! ROB CERVONI TO THE RESCUE Rob, owner of Taglio's, began working at a pizzeria restaurant at the young age of 14, and it was here he realized that he wanted - one day - to be the proprietor of a pizza restaurant. Many years later, after visiting Italy and sampling Roman style pizza, Rob decided that his restaurant should be different from the Long Island norm, and thus would instead focus on Roman style pan baked pizza. To enable this venture, he trained under Master Pizzaiolo Massimiliano Saviea, one of the foremost experts on Roman style pizza in the US. And once Rob felt he fully understood the process, he opened Taglio's Pizza in Mineola. Fast forward some years, and after receiving countless accolades for the Mineola location, the second Taglio's in Massapequa is now perhaps surpassing the phenomenal success of the first. PIZZA CHEF EXTRAORDINAIRE Taglio's is not mass producing pies, and pilling ingredients on top - in an attempt to make things interesting - as so many others do. Rob is a master craftsman chef, creating unique and bold pizza experiences. Here, the Roman style pizza starts with a light, airy and wonderfully crispy crust, which is then used to create multiple unique artisan slices. For example, the Diavola slice is made with mozzerella, hot sopressata, cherry peppers, tomato sauce, and then dressed with olive oil, oregano, and Pecarino Ramano. Another, is the Sausage & Broccoli Rabe slice, which also includes mozzarella, cherry peppers, olive oil, oregano and Pecorino Romano. Then there's the Vodka Roni slice with mozzerella, vodka sauce and pepperoni. And there's even a slice named after Hall of Fame UFC fighter Matt Serra, with mozzarella, tomato, vodka, and pesto sauces. But it's not just Rob's creativity making each slice extraordinary, as he only uses the highest quality ingredients, with many being specially imported from Italy. So even the standard Classica Roman slice with just tomato sauce, mozzarella, oregano, olive oil, Pecorino Romano, and basil creates an unexpected explosion of flavor and texture in your mouth. And it's not just Roman style pizza here, wowing customers, as the classic NY style pizza at Taglo's, with the thin crispy crust and fresh ingredients is probably as delicious. But here's a few words of advice - for the best possible experience, try to eat your pizza fresh out of the oven in the store, as it looses a good bit of its magic on the trip home. NOT JUST PIZZA Taglio's could have focused exclusively on artisan pizza, and still been a resounding success. But chef Cervoni chose to use his culinary skills to delight his customers in other ways also. An example of this being the fantastic heros served here. And as a matter of fact, the Prosciutto Hero, with Prosciutto Di Parma, arugula, roasted red peppers, burrata, olive oil, and balsamic glaze on a Semolina bread, is undoubtedly one of the best heros I've ever tasted. But you'll find that any of the ten different hero choices here are absolutely delicious. Growing up in a mostly Italian family can sometimes, over time, cause you to become bored with certain foods. And to be honest, after all these years, the last thing I want to look at when visiting a restaurant, is lasagna or chicken cutlet parmigiana. Oy Vey! But surprisingly, the outstanding Parm Plates at Taglo's have caused me to rethink things. Because the MVP Parmigiana Plate, made with fried chicken cutlets, topped with fresh mozzarella and then striped with a trio of tomato, pesto, and vodka sauces is admittedly better than any parmigiana I've eaten at any Italian restaurant. Even though it's served in a plastic takeout container! A TOTALLY DIFFERENT EXPERIENCE Unfortunately, some individuals have been eating crappy Long Island pizza for so long, they actually prefer it. And because of this, it can be somewhat of a shock when they walk into Taglio's, with the busy & exciting music-pumping-neon-menu-vibe, in addition to the large number of different pizza and hero choices. And yes, five or six dollars for a slice of pizza is somewhat expensive. So these confused customers, wanting a cheap plain greasy slice may unffortunately not feel comfortable here. And so to this, l can only say - I feel sorry for them! As Taglio's is undoubtedly one of my all-time favorite pizza restaurants. read more

See all

Hard to choose from so many great options of Roman style pizza. Service was great and the pizza was amazing. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pesto Pepperoni was great. - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

Probably the best damn regular slice I ever had. Everything was perfect about this pizza. Sauce, cheese, flavor and most importantly the crispy crust. Pair it with a Peroni at the bar, amazing! read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Very excited to see Taglio open a second location! This placed is mobbed for good reason, the roman pizza is insane! There's a ton of parking here which makes it easy to get there. I love the new ordering system for full pies - just find the screen under the carousel screen menu (which we used) it was super efficient! The design in here so dope! i love the visual of the roman gods on the wall. The crust alone deserves a trophy we got the roman half queen and half hot honey pepperoni sausage and it was out of this world. The sauce is so unique and delicious! I'll be coming back to try the potato slice and eggplant. read more

See all

10-2-25. My first time visiting this location. I've been to the Mineola location quite a few times and thought it was better. But I've always gone during peak lunchtime or dinner hours. Tonight, I came to the Massapequa location at a little after 8 p.m. Ordered a white ricotta slice, regular slice, hot honey pepperoni slice and a mortadella slice. They were all pretty good but they didn't taste as fabulous as they did during the peak hours. I'll have to give them another try a little earlier next time. They have a few booths and about 6 tables to sit and dine at if you do choose. Staff is friendly. Prices are a little expensive but they do offer a selection that is more unique than the average Long Island pizza joint. Music was a bit too loud in my opinion. It felt like I was in a nightclub until one of the workers put the Yankees vs. Red Sox playoff game on. Anyway ..... 3.5 stars for tonight's visit. I'll be returning to hopefully give them a higher rating. read more

Taglio Pizza - 10-2-25. Hot honey pepperoni burrata slice and a regular slice. - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

i went to try out this location for the first time as i have also been to the mineola location and the food there is pretty good. I went in on a saturday night and the place was really packed with no place to sit. I ordered a few pizza slices and paid as the line moved further towards the register. At first i thought that this place is alot more expensive then mineola location but after looking at the pricing on their board i realized she definity over charged me, possibily for someone elses order. It was over 20$ and i didnt get a receipt so i was pretty upset.. Maybe an error due to busy time and not enough staff? read more

It's definitely hustling and bustling in Taglio Massapequa Park. They're getting a lot of recognition and hype rn and well deserved. I don't know if it's because it's being pumped out so fast I felt like when I had tried their pizza at the mineola location when it first opened to me it tasted better but I still loved everything I tried. Rob has created an awesome environment here at this new location and with addition of Dario I can't wait to see what they'll do. I feel like maybe I want to go back during a weekday lunch to see if when it's not as crowded maybe I'll have a better experience. Regardless it was nice to see both owners chatting with customers and being present in their store and not feeling that gross feeling when we finished thanks to Rob's bromate free dough . I will go back to try all the other varieties; Especially the serra slice because today, sadly they were out. read more

Taglio Pizza - Bianco Buffalo Chicken BBQ Chicken Mortadella Pistacio Eggplant Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Great new pizza place in Massapequa park. I've never had pizza from their other location, but the pizza I'd say is worth the hype. Came here for their opening night, and even though the place was packed and had about a 30 min wait, the food and service was still very good. We split the classic, buffalo, san gennaro, hot honey, and pepperoni. We also got a frozen sangria and pina colada. The pizza was great and you can taste the quality of the dough, was nice airy, and fresh. Honestly the classic might have been my favorite. The frozen sangria and pina colada were sweet but flavorful and blended perfectly. The inside is a classic pizza place vibe and they have a walk up window, which I'm imagining will be used during the summer. Overall I'd highly recommend for a different pizza experience with great quality. read more

See all

Hate to do this cause I did love the one in Mineola, recently went to the one in Massapequa Park and did not find one positive thing about it. Order a pizza came out burnt also ordered a white slice which they forgot to put in the oven had to go back and literally beg for it. Music in the place was way inappropriate and too loud if I wanna listen to EDM I'd go to a club had to leave because it was so annoying. I will not be back read more

Coming into Taglio, one can expect good quality ingredients that you can taste and see. If you're into Roman style pizza, they have a pretty good one, but I was more impressed with the Neapolitan Margherita slice. Not only was the first few bites nice and crispy, but the crust was pillowy, and the sesame seeds on the crust added a nice nuttiness as you worked through the last few bites. Their sauce is on the tangier side if that's your thing, but the dough itself was really tender and perfectly crispy. Although I got a good slice, I did notice that some of their Neapolitan pies were a bit charred so I imagine that wouldn't be as tasty reheated before service. The Roman slices are nice and the toppings are always on abundance. With the Roman style slices, one can look forward to a crispy bottom with a tender center. The sides though can get a bit chewy, which I don't mind; I'm just not a huge Roman style or Sicilian fan. Price wise, the pizza is on the pricier side which makes it hard for me to want to return, especially when there are other pizzerias around whom are just as good (if not better) an slightly less expensive. I also wasn't wowed by the service and have definitely had friendly and warmer service at other places. If I'm in the neighborhood though, I would definitely stop by. read more

Pizza is excellent. I love the mushroom truffle pie. Ive been to the pizzeria 3 time and ordered for delivery 2 times but i live In Bethpage and it's kind of expensive to have it delivered. That being said, it's worth the 15 minute drive to go there. I Definitely recommend Taglio Pizza. read more

I finally found a pizza place that is comparable to Taglio's Mineola! As I've said previously, having never had a "go-to" pizza place (I know, it's rare for a lifelong New Yorker), but Taglio has changed that. The Roman-style slices are downright decadent and indulgent. You cannot indulge in them too often. But when you're ready, get the heck over here. The selections are all good; it's like a parent choosing among their children, which to spend time with. But there are two that are the best to me: barbecue chicken and the burrata with fresh basil and ham. Admittedly, the sauce they bathe this chicken in is so sweet; it might even hurt your teeth. But goodness gracious that flavor is a jolt of dynamite to your mouth. The burrata? It's like nothing you have ever tasted. The dough/crust is airy and cratered, like the best fresh Italian bread. They layer on that salty, sweet ham, basil, both leaves and a puree and globs of soft, creamy fresh mozzarella. And if the guys don't drizzle some of that flavorful oil on top, then you go back and insist that they do. What a taste experience. Believe me, when you're done, I know you will have eaten a lot, and a lot of calories. But trust in that you won't care to eat again for a long while, because nothing will match these cravables. Bravo! Mangia Bella!!! read more

Taglio Pizza - They're all special, like one's children; but these two are the best. - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

I don't understand the hype they're good but not great the prices are insane not worth it

I've been to the Mineola location before but favor this location since it is is easier to park here since there is a large municipal lot in the back and a back entrance to the store. Taglio specializes in Roman style pizza where the crust unique. It is rectangular in shape and is heartier, lighter and crispier than a Neapolitan crust. My favorites are the Buratta and Mortadella Pistachio. The Buratta pie is creamy and topped with a Balsamic drizzle which adds a nice sweetness to balance the salt. Mortadella on top of pizza is quite uncommon but works especially with the nutty pistachio. They also offer their combinations on Neapolitan style crust and in sandwich form. They were just added to the Foodie Card program which will definitely come in handy for many future visits to come. read more

Taglio Pizza - Inside - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

See all

Absolutely love this place, The pizza is crispy and always delicious, I haven't tried them all yet but so far spot on. A definite must try.

Stopped to give them a try and I must say I have had much better tasting pizza in the local area. Service was very fast to warm up the pizza and the young man was very nice. I set outside because it was a great day so I really didn't notice the inside. My understanding is they're taking over the store next to them for more room. The owner puts a great show on, but the pizza is just ok. read more

First time trying. Had a regular slice (Triangle) and a Roman Broccoli Rabe, Sausage, Cherry Pepper. The regular was good the B Rabe slice was ok - honestly I think the crust did not compliment the toppings on this slice. I'll have to try something more traditional with red sauce. The slices are Expensive at $6.25 a slice for a much smaller than average slice. If you are going to charge that much then don't serve small slices. Will try again but was underwhelmed. Daughter liked the Spinach & Artichoke. read more

Taglio Pizza - Pesto Triangle Mushroom Truffle Broccoli Rabe, Sausage, Cherry Pepper Spinach & Artichoke - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

We came here on a cold and inclement night. My boyfriend and I were driving through the area, and we decided to stop in to the nearest pizza place for a quick bite. James at the counter was an incredible help, seeing as my boyfriend couldn't decide on which slice to get. He was helpful and incredibly friendly. The pizza was heated perfectly, wonderful flavor and really hit the spot with the horrible weather. Growing up Italian, I'm extraordinarily picky with my pizza/pasta, and this was one of the best slices of pizza I ever had. Shoutout to James and crew for the amazing experience! read more

We tried this place opening weekend and when we got there they were sold out. Not a slice in the house. So we had to go back to see what all the hype is about. The place was packed but they move the line pretty quickly. There is a large variety of specialty style pies to choose from. The crust is very light, airy and crusty, unlike the traditional Sicilian style that Long Island Pizzerias are known for. The Bianca was loaded with cheese and bursting flavor. The Vodka slice was also a good choice as was the Classica and Broccoli Rabe slice. This Roman style pizza gets high marks. Unfortunately there is not much room for dining in with only two booths and a few small tables, I would recommend you take yours to go, the music was a bit loud and there was a lot of people standing around waiting to pick up food. Definitely a must try looking forward to going back. read more

Taglio Pizza - Bianca, Vodka and Broccoli Rabe - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

If you love pizza, slushies, and house music this place is for you! I was so excited to try this spot because I heard the pizza was crazy good and I was not disappointed. I went in on a Wednesday around 2pm and was able to snag one of their few tables. I had a vodka slice and it was so delicious! I also ordered the watermelon slushie which was also so good. I was so happy to dance to some epic dance music while I happily ate my delicious slice. I can't wait to go back and try more! read more

Taglio Pizza - Virgin Lemonade and Watermelon Slushies - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Absolutely incredible Roman-style pizza! The crust was perfectly crispy on the outside, light and airy inside, and packed with flavor. Fresh ingredients, generous toppings, and every bite was better than the last. If you love authentic Roman pizza, this spot hits just right. Can't wait to come back! One of the best slices, on Long Island for sure. read more

See all

New location just opened. Stoped in today. Got a few different slices. Plane, pepperoni & burrata. All were very good. Place was a madhouse inside. They had 3 different lines, one for slices one for a pie where u had to order from a computer and one to pay. IMO they should make it a little simpler. You order, u pay the person u ordered from when your food is ready they give it to you. What do i know, I was only in the business for 20 years. But the review isn't based on that it's based on the food, which was very good ! We were 100% be back! read more

Taglio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Massapequa Park, New York

Stoped in quick for a few slices and was not disappointed. The Roman style pepperoni pizza was crunchy and airy. They had a nice selection of choices and everything looked delicious. The vibe is funky inside with nostalgic KTU music bumping and a graffiti mural of Julia Cesar with face tats. Overall a solid pizza place read more