I really like this restaurant. I've never had their pizza, but dinners are always great.

Stopped by yesterday to have lunch with my son and enjoyed everything we got! I bought a Clipp deal a few weeks ago. I paid less than $9 for $25 worth of food. So we walked in and there were a few other patrons in the place and the counter was full of options! So my son picked a chicken marsala slice and a drunken grandma slice. I picked a rice ball with a side of vodka sauce. We also got a regular sicilian slice, a piece of fried capellini, and a coke zero which used up the entire deal. They quickly heated our food and put everything on a tray. Each worker offered to help me carry it to a table but I handled it myself to not take away from the other customers waiting. We sat down at a booth, I grabbed some napkins and forks, and we started chowing down. My son really loved his giant slice of pizza but kept asking for "more mushroom" so next time I order it I'll ask them for extra. The rice ball was also very good. My daughter loved the sicilian slice I brought home for her. My husband also loved his fried capellini. Every worker was so nice and helpful and also very welcoming. I look forward to our next stop in! read more

DON'T order the sausage, onion and pepper hero. The sausage was barely cooked ( I thougt it would be grilled - not a chance) and there was virtually no peppers or onions. The white sauce consisted of cut garlic slices and something wet. Not sure what it was. Poor. read more

What has happened to Crostini's pizza? I've been eating here and or ordering in from here for the past 9 years. After ordering from here this past week I don't think I'll be back. The food has been hit or miss for months now but the pizza has been terrible. The sauce has a sweetness to it that doesn't go with pizza. The Focaccia pizza which was one of my all favorites was covered in a sweet balsamic vinegar which it doesn't need and it never had before. The upside down Sicilian had the same sweet sauce as the regular pizza so I don't recommend it. Whatever changes you've made recently -- I highly recommend going back to your old sauce. The new sauce is terrible. They've always had nice delivery drivers so no complaints there. I don't know if she's still working there but the young woman who answered the phone on the Sunday evening when I called to mention that they forgot part of my order answered the phone 15 minutes before closing and announced "we're closed and hung up." Nice touch. read more

Crostini is amazing, Ive had them a couple of times recently and its been nothing but the best. I've had the regular slice, the artichoke slice (amazing! Actually it's the slice of the week this week. And today I Had the phenomenal mac n cheese slice and WOW! Instant favorite! They also have specials during the week nights for dine in customers, Tuesday night is pasta night and Wednesday Seafood! The Owner Joe is very nice and very hospitable!! One of a kind. Great food great service , Will definitely be back. read more

I called to order Crostini for delivery. They took my order and were courteous over the phone. I was pleasantly surprised when our order arrived maybe within half an hour or so if ordering. I wasn't expecting it to be ready so quickly. Our Pizzas were made exactly as ordered and the sauce on the pizzas was extremely flavorful. I would definitely order from here again. read more

See all

great pizza and delicious garlic knots. Great service too. This is our go to pizza place!! read more

We have been going here for a few years but now that there is a new owner (Millie) portions are LESS, Nor does she give discounts for paying with CASH but the food is just not as good. We even got charged more on special chicken night. Looks like Millie just lost customers. Today we placed an order in store and waited over 1hour for takeout order. What a shame. There are very few Italian restuarant workers, cooks.. we need them back bye bye Crostini's read more

genuinely the best pizza place in the whole world not one pizza place is better this place is my second home if I were to die on one place in the world, it would be in the store with pizza on my body. I love this store so much. I would do anything for the store. I will sell my organs for the store. There's not one thing that I don't like about crostinis . read more

Food was delicious and the portions were generous. We had the Crostini salad, pasta pomodoro and pasta with broccoli and sausage. The service was great, we especially enjoyed chatting with Alex. read more

The worst ever since change of ownership, on top of that I don't think they participated in the annual Italian feast on Broadway. Will never eat here again read more

Picked up an uber eats order, there seemed to be miscommunication so I had to wait. No big deal it happens. I waited about 20 minutes bc it was a large order, and they gave me a slice of pizza for waiting. Super kind workers. The pizza was delicious. read more

I placed an order with them online and it said it went through. The food took a while so checked back and it turns out they canceled it without even calling me to let me know. I wasted 40 minutes of my time when I could've been getting it from someplace else had they just had the courtesy to call me. read more

We had a small family party and had it catered by Crostini Pizza in North Massapequa. They delivered everything on time and the food was fantastic as always. I highly recommend them read more

The food is absolutely delicious. Everyone that I have referred or invited to dine, has enjoyed every bite. I even held my a mini Highschool Reunion, in the dining area, and there were no complaints. I will be sure to be back and I am sure my classmates will have become new customers. Great addition to my restaurants that I will be sure to return to. Thanks for a great experience. read more

Good pizza, friendly service. Sidewalk tables. A neighborhood favorite. read more

Let me start by saying, I love this pizzeria and order from them on a regular basis. Being gluten free and having Celiac disease, they're one of the few places near me that have an extensive and delicious gluten free menu. However, lately they have been so hit or miss. Last night my husband and I ordered from this location and even paid the excessive $9 delivery charge to avoid having to pick up after a long day. I was so disappointed in how I received my order. My receipt was placed on top of my husbands pizza pie, like stuck to the cheese and all. The gluten free mozzarella sticks were a mozzarella blob with breading. This isn't the first time I've received an order in such a mess like this and it makes me question whether they're actually being careful when handling my food (due to my allergy) and just the overall standards of their business. I stuck with them before and during Covid, but they've just been disappointing lately. read more

Crostini - Gluten Free Mozzarella Sticks - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

Great Pizza! You say crispy they make it crispy! Clean / Clean Clean! Everything looks fresh, not like its from the day before, The owner wants EVERYONE happy! Just a great place for dinner or a slice!Enjoy say Rebecca the Realtor sent you. read more

Crostini - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

Hubby and I stopped in for a quick slice- as I had dinner already made but we were out running errands and got hungry. We walked in an no one was in the dining room. We ordered at the pizza counter and they guys had it ready in a few minutes. We sat in the dining room so that was nice. I really enjoyed the upside down slice-1st time ever having one, soooo good! Hubby had a regular slice which was piping hot. We normally don't eat cheese (familial cholesterol issues) but this was worth it - we'll just offset it with some red rice yeast tonight! The restaurant side is clean but the decor is nondescript. I like the big windows so you can see what's going on outside. I understand as these places are mostly neighborhood take-out orders. If it keeps the price down, keep place status quo! read more

Crostini's pizza is the best place ever!!! Best avocado salad ever and best pizza in the area!!! My go to!!! Everyone should try this place if they have the chance! read more

They were doing a lot of takeout the day that I came to visit this restaurant which means more attention for me lol,, but seriously this is a wonderful pizzeria restaurant, Dylan was very good, the soft drink glasses are large, your standard pizzeria restaurant but they have more choices with the type of sauces and pastas you might want with your meals , Love the bite-size fried raviolis, pasta fagioli, Chicken rollatini was outstanding read more

See all

Crostinis is absolutely amazing I used to go there every-time because I was next door from Them. It's a very good place. Me and my friends got a pie, salads, eggplant parm, chicken parm. It was very good a lot of people need to try this pizzeria because they make amazing food and the staff and the owner are cool/ amazing people. Please go and try Crostinis NOW!! read more

My family and I have been going here for years and no exaggeration, I am here on a weekly basis getting their mango salad! It is hands down one of the best salads I've ever had. If I want to splurge on calories I'll get a slice of pizza - which is also delicious. Staff is always extremely welcoming and friendly. Highly recommend this place! read more

Crostini - Mango salad: grilled chicken, roasted peppers, Carrots, noodles, cashews - amazing! - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

See all

Food here is great. They also went above and beyond delivering my order in a rain storm. 10/10

I was visiting a friend in Massapequa, so I decided to order delivery while there. We ordered a pizza, garlic knots, pepperoni bites, and spinach bites. When it came, there were no garlic knots and all the cheese on the pizza was stuck to the top of the pizza box. I called them, and they were soooo great about it. They sent another pizza and the garlic knots. read more

Great comfortable and delicious food. Crostini is our place to go for delicious fresh food and generous portions. My children and grands love to go there with us. The desert is my grands favorite the cannoli is made fresh . read more

My favorite salad EVER!! I crave the mango salad and get it about once a week for takeout. Last week they forgot the cashews in it, but mistakes happen. Counter guys are always very nice and the order is ready on time. I like this crostinis better than the other one mainly because their presentation is nicer and the balsamic dressing is better at this location. Closed on mondays ( which is when I always want it haha ) but their salads are a must try!! read more

had a grandma pizza with sausage it was horrible sausage was a disappearing act. never again. rating this pizza, i wouldnt give it to a dog

A treasure trove for Celiacs. My non-Celiac partner and I went to Crostini's for dinner Friday night and had a wonderful time. I hadn't visited in a while but the food was just as excellent as I had remembered. Our server Joanna was a gem and took excellent care of us. She was courteous, thoughtful and very funny! Not only will we be coming back for the food but with employees like Joanna, the dinner was all the better for care and attention. Give that girl a raise! read more

Crostini - Gluten free Chicken Scarpariello with GF penne and vodka sauce and GF Chicken Verde with GF penne and pesto. everything was delicious! - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

See all

So many pizza places to choose from in this area. Crostini easily blows them all away. Great food , specials and always friendly employees. Which is not always the case at other places near by. Love their Sicilian slice, one of the best I've ever had. Really like the grandpa slice as well. Caramelized onions and toasted bread crumbs. Slammin! read more

FOOD SAFETY ISSUE**** AND MEAN. I ordered two heros from crostini to be delivered on uber eats and I was concerned the bag was not sealed which is strange (usually uber eats food deliveries seal the bag with tape or staples) the food was spilled all over the inside of the bag and the driver had full access to my food so I called the resturant nicely to speak to the manager. I asked if the food was sealed prior to delivery and when he said no I said i needed to report it on uber as a food safery concern so they refund me but just wanted to let them know to prevent it from happening again in the future. i stayed nice and calm the entire time for a total of a 5 minute phone conversation but he immediately became defense and argumentative raising his voice yelling at me with such an attitude for ordering via uber and that he will "never seal his food" bashing uber that has nothing to do with me. he would NOT let me speak he continued to scream and cut me off anytime i tried to speak to the point where i had to tell him hes being incredibly disrespectful i wasnt calling to bash them i was calling to let them know of my concern if they want to prevent it in the future to staple the bag. Ive never experienced in my life a grown man yell at me like that and especially not over something so simple like this by a business owner. I am sad this is how he reacted it completely ruined their reputation for me. read more

Crostini - a close up of a sandwich - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

Restaurant has gone down, not as good as it use to be. Ordered lasagna to take out about 2 weeks ago. Could not believe how small the portion was as have been ordering it for years. Ordered it again today. Very small portion and very dry, will consider going back read more

We went here on a recommendation of two People. There was 3 of us. The avocado salad was vert good & the chicken salad. My other friend ordered a panini. The two salads came out to the table the waiter walked away and never said anything about the panini. We finally asked after 15 min where's the panini he said they are making it fresh. All meals should come out to the table together. It is very awkward for people to eat when someone doesn't have their food. He never came back to see if we needed anything also. The service was not up to par but the food was good. Interior needs to be cleaned up too. read more

Came here on a tuesday with my parents because they are always raving about how great pasta night is! It really was great! So much food for only $10.95 a person They start you off with bread with sauce and garlic bread basket. soup or salad. I choose soup. So good. Large bowl of egg drop soup. It was very tasty There are about 20 different pastas to choose from. I chose rigatoni fiorentina. So did everyone else at the table. We absolutely loved it! The portion was huge! I had a lot left over for dinner the next day! Dessert is coffee or tea with either connoli or rice pudding. We all got rice pudding. It was delicious. The service was running around like crazy. They were very busy but very attentive and friendly I will definitely be coming back for pasta Night! read more

Crostini - Rigatoni Fiorantina. Large portions - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

Crostini is somewhat popular for locals. Friendly and food is fresh. Very friendly staff. Fast, efficient. .. busy place. Hero's were hot big so don't think share, Sicilian pizza is good,, sauce has good flavor. read more

First time sitting down for dinner dinner service. And it was less then average. Pizza was ordered as well as entrees. The server brought out the pizza 10 minutes before the entrees came out. The salads came out with the entrees. The glasses where always empty. I asked for water, and never got it. I had to ask for napkins, even though mine was clearly in need of replacement. The food was awesome. As always read more

What's better than getting great pizza for the end of your shift at work is getting a free piece of pizza from the owner always great food and always great specialty slices A+! read more

Crostini - Great specialty slices! - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York

We were in the area and wanted an early dinner in a sit-down restaurant. Glad we took a chance here. Read the reviews and saw the popular salad is the mango so I ordered it. Perfect! Crispy chicken, mangos that were peak freshness, not soggy. Yummy balsamic dressing. The hub ordered chicken parmigiana and said it was very good, and that the chicken had a nice crisp texture. The restaurant was clean, the food came fast and everybody was friendly. I'd go again if I had business nearby. read more

Ordered a tray of Calamari Fritti and was totally disappointed. It smelt very fishy and was not fresh. I am a frequent customer of their pizza and other dishes which I always liked. But I will not order any seafood going forward. Seafood needs to be fresh and this was not. read more

No NY flop. Little bit oily, paid $10 for the pie. The crust is nice it's crispy with non of that flour on the bottom that dries out your tongue. Cheese is very tasteful. Sauce is subtle but perfect about . Over all this is a solid slice above average for the neighborhood it's in. I give this a 7.9 out of 10. read more

Crostini - Pizza Near Me - North Massapequa, New York