This place is so under rated because I don't hear enough people talking about them and more people…read morereally need to try them out. I'm constantly raving about their food so I hope they stay in business for forever. We ordered the Arrabbiata pie for the first time tonight and it was a 10/10, so I had to come back to leave a new review. This is me and my husband's new favorite pie! You can taste how fresh all the ingredients are, and you don't get that stream of grease down my hand, so you know the ingredients are good. The crust is thin and crispy without being too well done, the chunks of garlic are mouth watering and cooked to perfection, and it's got just the right amount of spice.

Just moved from Lido to Wantagh driving around looking for my new pizza joint. Stella's didn't cut…read moreit, nor did Wantagh pizza. Glad I found Pizza Italia. Apparently it's the home of the round grandma pie. Place is airy and clean and the owner was friendly. Got a couple slices that were way above average here on Long Island. Will be a regular.

Of course we are back! We brought my son's friend who just moved here and had to introduce him to…read moresome awesome coal fired pizza. As usual, it was perfectly thin crust. We ordered a new to us pizza: Speck and it was delicious. It was our guest's favorite! This time we also tried the Depequa pie which my daughter because it was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Patio seating is now open since it is summer but we chose to sit inside where it was less noisy. Service was efficient and attentive. Highly recommend!

Desperate for neapolitan pizza and not willing to sit through traffic so we landed here again. The…read moredough isn't exactly what I was craving for which is thin, chewy. We ordered: Broccoli Rabe sausage Fig arugula Speck with truffle oil Meatball ricotta

Under new ownership the last few months. But nothing else…read morehas changed. Still have the most delicious soups in town. And still excellent pizza. And all the other same delicious choices. Friendly service. Convenient location near the train station.

This whole public transportation venture is terribly inconvenient and annoying me, it really is…read more So I got on the Long Island Railroad at Jamaica station to meet a friend. I see my friends mostly at wakes now and my ride fell down on me, so here in Jamaica i stand. For all who've not been, it is about the dirtiest, most germy place per square foot in NYCs transportation world. Its the kind of place I hope you'll never ever see in your life. Everybody's bumping into you and yelling about track changes, looking like a bunch of morons who think they're going somewhere important. ​Anyway, I ended up getting off at Massepequa and going to Leonardo's Pizza hoping they had a beer but they didn't, figures. ​First, I had the Italian Wedding Soup. It arrived looking like a drowned swamp with all those stringy, pale noodles swirling around in the broth like a bunch of white wigglers, similarto what i had for first lunchies. They were just sitting there next to these limp green leaves and the carrots were just floating in it. It's like the soup is trying to convince you it's healthy, but the whole thing just looks depressing. You take a bite, and it tastes, well, it tastes rather good, but the name is what really gets me. "Italian Wedding Soup." That's a odd name if I ever heard one. What does soup have to do with getting married? It just makes you think of a bunch of grandmothers crying and guys in rented tuxedos talking about their golf handicaps and portfolios. Plus I'm never getting married again, never ever - i learned my lesson. ​Then came the Detroit Slice. It sat there on a paper plate next to my copy of The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, which was the only thing in my whole damn life that's keeping me company. Look at the edge of that crust--it's burnt to a crisp. Black as night, dark as spadesbut maybetgats how they do it on Long Island. The sauce is piled right down the middle like a thick red streak, covered in all these little dried oregano herbs I applied. I sat there eating this cheesy crusted square, staring at Mark Twain on the cover, and I swear it made me feel sad. Not because the book is terrible, it reminded me of my childhood, another complete disaster. The pizza actually had that crispy, cheesy edge going for it, I'll give them that, but because it felt lonely eating alone in public,vi never do that. Me, Samuel Clements and a thick slice of pizza on a cheap paper plate. Next time I'll be sure to eat out with someone fun.

My go to pizzeria for my neighborhood. Good selection of sliced pizza. Also willing to make what…read moreyou want. Parking is a little tight though

I had takeout from Gino's for the first time. Chicken Francese with a side salad. It was excellent…read more People there were very nice. Will be back for dinner.

The pizza at Brooklyn Square is superb. My husband Michael and I are very hard to please when it…read morecomes to pizza, so when I evaluated Brooklyn Square pizza if I could have given it 10 stars, I would have. And their Shrimp Parmesan is one of my favorites. I highly recommend Brooklyn Pizza. Believe me, you will not be disappointed.

Love this place! Every slice is great!…read more My favorite is their square slice maybe they call it upside down slice. It is almost the same as L&B and I don't have to drive all the way to Brooklyn! The chicken and broccoli slice and salad slice were great too and they have sesame seed crusts which I love. Will be ordering again from them!

The pizza is crisp on the bottom so it stands up to the toppings but has a softer more bread like…read moretop that's airy and light. It's a nice neighborhood pizza spot with great pizza.

Had a Rosario's $100 gift card from a friend , used it several times as it's only two of us, owner…read morecomplained that Ibe been coming in for 6 months which wasn't the case as I only got the card in April and that I shoulda used it all at once. He was so rude and obnoxious and told me not to come back

Great mom and pop pizza spot that consistently has good quality food…read more To start their house salad is just so good, it sounds basic, but their dressing is awesome and we love to add shredded mozz. They have some quality pies, heros, and dishes. We have catered from here numerous times and the food is always delicious. The meatballs, chicken franchise, and eggplant are all very good. They constantly have specials and discounts in the papers. Owner is a super nice and helpful guy. Staff is friendly. The place is on the smaller side, but they have a few tables and chairs. Definitely recommend.

Very tasty pizza and delicious Italian food also!! Owner and…read moreworkers very friendly! Very accommodating in placing delivery orders for a small or large crowd! Prices reasonable for what you get. Usually nice pizza and very delicious. Another good Italian restaurant where your money is well spent. Give them a try you won't be disappointed. And eat in also nice clean restaurant! 5 s

Carmela's, a neighborhood staple for decades. The best slice of pizza around! Mouth watering…read moreItalian food & efficiently run by an incredible team of people. Hot, yummy takeout or to dine in for a superb meal & dreamy atmosphere ... you can't go wrong with this local landmark.

Best pizza around it was amazing. You must try it very good tasting pizza. You won't regret it…read more The balsamic salad slice was the best !!!!!