The pizza is good My husband swears by the eggplant parm hero. I've never tried it, but I believe him. The place is always empty tho so idk how they stay open. read more

I'm sorry but if you hang up on me I can't deal with you. I called them, the guy said something and put me on hold. Then he came back said something that wasn't English and hung up. What kind of service is that? BAD SERVICE!!! read more

One of the most underrated pizzerias around. Not cheap on the sauce or the Mozzerella and cook the pies well done, As it should be done. We got a brick oven pie which was light and had a great crispy undercarriage. The Sicilian was also cooked perfectly. This place does it right read more

Visit Date: April 17, 2020 My son had to poop and because of Covid-19 I'm finding I'm using local businesses to either use the bathroom myself or let my son go if he has to. This turns into an $11 to $30 trip to the bathroom though. Anyway I came in here to have my 3 year old poop and I decided to order a gluten free pizza, garlic knots for my son, a soda for my son and 2 slices of pizza for my family since my social distancing is in between two houses (where I live and where my dad lives). They had my order done in the standard amount of time and didn't give me an issue about waiting inside the pizzeria for my order. When I got to my dad's I stress ate the whole gluten free pizza (this social distancing has done terrible things for people's weight and I'm actually not as bad as other people). It was really delicious though, worth the stress eat. My family liked the regular slices and my son seemed to be happy with the garlic knots. I'd come back again I noticed they had family meals so I might opt to get a family meal for my family. read more

Really good local pizza joint. It's a little hidden in what seems like the middle of a residential neighborhood. Nice variety of pizza and heros to satisfy everyone in the family. Staff if friendly and prices are par for the course. I'll be sure to return. read more

Rosario out did himself once more!! If you on a diet or just cutting down your calories intake , must try cauliflower pizza!! Soo chewy , crispy and fresh . 4/2020 - they deliver pizza and leave it by your door steps during this quarantine time . What a service !!! read more

See all

While I was battling some dairy issues from a previous meal from another restaurant, I wasn't partaking of the pizza or chicken parm subs that were being offered for dinner from Rosario's. I wanted to because everyone was RAVING about how good everything tasted, but I wanted to be safe than sorry, so I instead ordered a beautiful Greek salad with chicken. I hated to disrupt the beautifully prepared salad. I thought I took a picture of all the food that my son-in-law brought home, but it turns out, I didn't. Disappointed I didn't do that. Anyway, the salad was amazing, and the Caesar dressing I got (yeah, on my Greek salad) was delicious. They gave me one whole chicken breast, and with as much lettuce and other veggies as there were, there was so much chicken that the chicken to veggie ratio was amazingly high. I truly enjoyed this salad. I just wish I could've tried the pizza and/or chicken parm subs. Great food even if it was take-out only !! Too bad we live 3,000 miles away and were just visiting the area. Rosario's is close to my daughter's house, so I'm sure we will get another chance to eat this food again on a future visit ! read more

I'm giving this place one star to be kind. The sauce on the pizza was a little too sweet and listen I'm a BIG candy lover , but the sauce on this pie was a little too much for my liking. The garlic knots needed garlic and they gave me penne aka vodka sauce as the dipping sauce. I could've saved some cash by buying 2 tombstone pizzas at shop rite for 5 dollars which has a lot more cheese on it. Also, the next day I didn't even want any leftovers nor did my mother. The dough was sitting in my belly. I still had the remainder of that taste. Normally we eat 2 slices , but we could only eat 1 that night. The photos were nothing like what we got. I wanted to try a new place, but now I think I'm going to head back to my original pizzeria. read more

I've had pizza from every spot here in the Seaford area and no one makes a better pie. It's a thin crust with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. Hands down they make the best pies in town. read more

The pizza here is very good, I am a fan. Pizza is one of my favorite foods and I'll most likely be stopping here a lot more often. Clean, modern atmosphere. So far only have had a plain and cecilian slice, both delicious. Very convienent location on Jackson avenue in Seaford. I love that I can walk here in a few minutes! read more

Rosario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

The new Pizza parlor in Seaford, The Pizza is Delicious Went there for dinner tonight I had Rigatoni alla Vodka with Grilled chicken,My Wife Diane had a chicken roll it was all Delicious. I guess we found a new watering hole Thank You Bart read more

Rosario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

Rosario's has never disappointed! Ordered Meat Lasagna, Chicken Parm Hero with A La Vodka sauce and upside down cheese Pizza and Garlic Knots! Picked up and it was Hot and Tasty! Support Local businesses! #rosarospizzeria #seaford #owneroperated #localbusiness #morethanpizza #karencassrealtor read more

Ordered a pie half sausage and meatball tonight. Very pleased. Sauce was flavorful, right amount of cheese and the meats were on point. Cooked to perfection with a nice crisp to it. Staff and owner (?) were pleasing. read more

Rosario's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seaford, New York

Food was amazing. I had a Buffalo slice and it was so yummy and very filling. Will be going back.

I dedicate my life to avoiding gluten and dairy, but, Rosario's requires having that occasional cheat day. They make one awesome thin crust pizza with detailed attention to all three layers of a pizza. No, it's not about their crust. It's not about their sauce. It's not about their cheese. It's about their pizza as a whole. It's so good. I crave it so often that sometimes I just gotta cave in and get some. read more

Small and perfect! Food is flavorful and great portions for the money. The pizza is bigger then the box and that's the way a large round pie should be.Keep up the Great work. read more

FOOD IS SOOOOO GOOODDDD. I work 5 mins away and my My coworkers always order the cauliflower crust margerhita pizza . I tried it and loveeeddddd itttt.NOW I AM A FAN!!! The pepperoni pizza is amazing. And the penne a la vodka is to die for !!!!!!! read more

My wife and I came to an agreement that this place has the best cheese slice we've ever had. Nothing like a hot crisp & crunchy slice to satisfy your hunger. We will return to explore the menu. Happy Thanksgiving to you all. read more

Stopped in and ordered a combination pie, broccoli/chicken and veggie. Done in 20 minutes, looked like a picture from a magazine and tasted great. Best pizza in the area, service very friendly! Well done my friends. Love the Grandma and Sicilian pies! read more

First visit to this Seaford newcomer. Put simply - Not bad, but a few gripes. Ordered a round pie with some toppings (Sausage, Peppers, Mushrooms). Very good sauce. High quality cheese and fresh green peppers. Sausage & mushrooms not so much. Especially the mushrooms which looked and tasted liked they were straight out of a can. Why use fresh green peppers but canned mushrooms is a mystery. Dough was chewy even on my very well done pie. Also the pie was a bit thicker then I like my Neapolitan style. Would return occasionally. Place looks real nice on the inside. read more

Best Pizza around. Especially their Sicilian pie. I used to go to invert is in the ivarone parking lot, lunacy. This pizza is better and there's plenty of parking. read more

I wish I couldn't even leave a one star rating. This food was disgusting at best. Meatballs were mush, we paid $3 extra for cheese and there was no cheese on the horrible meatballs . Then when we contacted the owner and advised him there was no cheese on it he basically called us liers. I have pictures to prove it had no cheese. We are new to the area and we like to support local businesses, but I can not and will not ever use them again or even recommend them to anyone. The sauce was sour tasting on top of it all. Sometimes businesses owners should listen to the customers that would support them. In this case the owner failed terribly at this and would never ever give him a second chance. Carmellas is 1000 times better for anyone looking for a good pizza or Italian food. Please trust me, there is a reason there are no reviews. Its because of constant bad reviews and they are trying to hide from it. read more

I just tried the pizza here today and its great The dough is crunchy and taste good and the pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese are impressive. They also do a good ratio of pizza sauce to mozzarella cheese. read more

Great people. Great food. Big thanks to Rosario for always coming through with big orders and never making a mistake even once. What a gentleman. Cauliflower pizza here is also phenomenal! read more

I have been loving his pizza since the day he opened. I won't name names but everyone around this areas slices of pizza have shrunk over the years Not here. The biggest slice of pizza I have enjoyed since 1975. Lol. A real piece of pizza. Deliciously made. My favs are the inside out Scicilian and his grandmas. Everything is fresh and outstanding. And he's a nice guy. Rob Nappy read more

I highly recommend Rosario's. Super friendly, great service and very flavorful sauce. Which I think is what makes a pizza great. We order pizza from them all the time. Great local spot! read more

Best pizza on Long Island by far!!!! Just wish they had baked clams though!!! But great service great food 10/10 would recommend!

Very very good old school Brooklyn type of pizza. Lots of cheese and no overload on the sauce . Delicious

I'm such an Italian food snob I lived in Italy for a while and ate like a pig the whole time. There are so many pizza and Italian places in seaford but this place is so tasty. The sauce is on point the crust. Don't just explore the pizza (ravioli vodka sauce pizza um yes please) but also get into the entrees and pastas. I go when I'm not feeling like cooking myself and always leave pleased. read more

Found a fingernail clipping in my grandma slice...... I ate around it and it still wasn't good. I also saw someone's skin flake into calzone. I'm scared the clipping is lodged in my throat omw to the ER.. will update read more

I'm gonna beg to differ with the consensus thus far. Had regular and margherita slices and I thought they were both pretty bad. Dough was ok, sauce was really bad. SWEET as hell. Crust was cooked generally ok but it was too thick. I'd love to like this place since most of the pizza in the neighborhood is pretty lame but we've tried them 3 times and I think they are dead to us. read more

Great Neighborhood Pizza place. Food was delicious and reasonable. Will keep coming back

Great service and amazing food. If you like a good slice or some expertly cooked Italian food you have to come here.

True neighborhood pizza place. Very friendly and food cooked to order and fantastic. We found our new pizza place. Great addition to the neighborhood. We need more businesses like this here in Seaford. read more

Awesome food. Great pizza. Happy to have you in the neighborhood.

First time eating here and the food was absolutely delicious. My husband and I shared the lentil soup and rigatoni bolognese and were beyond satisfied with our choices. Will definitely be visiting again. read more

I just tried their delicious pizza and wings Sunday night! The pizza is excellent! I would like to bathe in their sauce. The wings were huge and tasty. I will definitely be coming back! read more

New pizza place in Seaford. Pizza is excellent and the hero's are great. Very good bread.

Just had Rosario's for the first time. So nice to have a delicious pizzeria right down the block! Ordered an 18" round pie, a chicken roll, and a spinach roll and was not disappointed in the least! Rosario's dough is delicious! Although we ordered out, we walked in for pickup. The atmosphere is very inviting, clean and modern-villa looking. Staff and service is friendly and respectful. Can't wait to try different items next time! read more

For a fledgling pizza place in a location with no parking where every other business has gone quickly out of business they ought not to be ruling $10 and up for debit card purchases. I feel they should be happy to get a $5 sale and let the customer ring up on debit/credit card. The use fee for the credit card machine is so small it doesn't warrant the $10 min, it's a joke, I was completely taken aback. Probably will be out of business within a year or two. Sits right next to the local methadone clinic as well so you get all the flavor of the neighborhood. read more