Lots of weird things about this guy:
Takes forever for them to answer their phone. The lady asked for the last four digits of my _father's_ social security number (assuming I'm a college freshman still on my parents' insurance.) When I came to the office, the receptionist would ask me a question, then start talking to the delivery guy instead waiting for my answer, as if I wasn't even there. It was odd.
Dr. Pugh sure takes his time---as if he has nothing else to do all day but ask you about your medical history and reminisce about 1970-something. Maybe some people like that style, but it wasn't for me.
He asked if I take any vitamin supplements. When I told him that I don't, he wrote "NEEDS MORE INFO" on his form and said that I would want to start taking them once I know what he knows. Maybe that line works on the freshmen, but I know enough to know that anyone who says you have to buy vitamin supplements in order to have healthy eyes is probably selling you something.
The doctor seemed overly convinced that diet and nutrition are the cause of various eye problems, rather than genetics. I'm sure this can be true, but something about his emphasis on nutrition made me feel weird.
He wanted me to watch basically an infomercial about the eye scanner he uses. That combined with other things felt sort of patronizing, like I was just some kid who needed educating. Maybe I'm just prideful, but something seemed condescending about his attitude.
It was in the middle of the video that I decided I had so little confidence in the doctor's judgement that I did not want to waste my once-a-year vision insurance benefit on his services. So I stood up, said I was leaving because the visit wasn't what I was looking for, had them cancel the insurance authorization, and left.
The worst part of the whole thing: as I left, I saw that he had a display with a bunch of vitamin supplements. I can only guess that he would have been happy to sell me some!
When I told people about my experience, it seemed everybody but me had heard that Dr. Pugh is like this. They suggested he might be part of a multilevel marketing scheme, hawking those vitamins at people. I don't think Dr. Pugh is a horrible guy, he may have done just a fine job with the actual eye exam if I had stayed (one friend of mine said she was happy with him). But there are definitely better.
My appointment the next day at a place recommended to me by my coworkers (Timpanogos Vision Center) was WAY better. We got down to business and figured out what was up with my eyes, instead of trying to sell me a bunch of vitamins. read more