Roberto's is one of my favorite places! I am obsessed with their Korean bbq wings. I love the thin sliced cucumbers that come on the side along with their homemade blue cheese dressing. They also have delicious pizza! They have made a few pizzas for milestones in my life and I'm never disappointed. It's always busy when I go and the staff is always working hard. There is a variety of drinks offered along with dessert. There is outdoor and indoor seating available. During the warm months there is also lots of seating out back. Inside is a little crowded with limited seating. The owner is so nice and very dedicated to his work. It's a must stop if you are in the area!! (There is also the pub next door!! Same owner, same menu, but it has a bar and a totally different vibe.) read more

See all

I love Roberto's! It's an hour drive but worth it. The meatballs are the best, and this time, we had the fries with lemon and truffle, and this was addictive! We also had the Roberto's pizza; this was good too, add some red pepper flakes for an extra kick. We sat at the bar, and the service was friendly, and the restaurant is clean. read more

See all

Excellent food and service, will definitely be back. Great pizza in a small community

*Updated 6/23/2024* Over the last year 50% of the time there's been something wrong with the order. The pizza is still the best in the area. But what seemed like missteps in my first review now seem more like habits. It's not worth the hour drive anymore. read more

Roberto's Pizza - Vini Vidi Vici is not a Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

Pizza is easily the best in the Berkshires and could hold it's own in the pizza capitals of New Haven, NYC, Chicago, and SF!

We love Roberto's best pizza ever! We have been driving down to New Haven for our pizza fix, no more! You want good pizza that rivals New Haven look no further! read more

Great place!!! We ate in the PUB great service, bartender was great. Korean Wings were bangin...Meatballs on point and the pie was amazing, highly recommend! read more

Brick oven goodness with original combos and delish toppings? Best "Hey, let's get pizza moment" EVER! One small pizza yields four large slices that served two people well. Delicious sauce and perfectly cooked. Perfectly cooked means none of that burnt crust that frequently happens to the brick oven pizza that I truly dislike. everyone in our group of 6 tried a different combo and everyone was impressed. The hours are only 4-8 pm, so plan accordingly! Beverages are canned sodas or beer, but large bottles of chilled water are provided for the table. Remember to order at the counter before you sit, and check out the ice cream menu for dessert. read more

Roberto's Pizza - Small pizza with mini portabella and olives (photo taken by mistake by friend, haha!) - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

Someone gooned on my pizza and it lowkey tasted better. It had very good flavor and I liked the texture. read more

Roberto's Pizza - Someone gooned on my pizza and it lowkey tasted better - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

Love Roberto's Pizza! The owner, Robbie, is so welcoming, staff is great and you don't feel like you're sitting in a pizza place. Each table has a candle, making it feel cozy. Definitely recommend. read more

The only real New York (City) pizza in the area. If you want real pizza, you found your spot. The menu is simple but inspired. For example, the yummy garlic knots come with vodka sauce instead of marinara. Delightful. If only they would deliver! read more

I have been coming to Roberto's for about eight months. The pizza is wonderful, the place is cozy and there's a great outdoor space too! You can bring a date or your whole family. Highly recommended! read more

Roberto's has great atmosphere, excellent pizza, superior service with friendly staff and good beer. read more

Roberto's Pizza - Veni Vidi Vici pizza. Yum. - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

10 * stars ! Simply delicious. Please don't compare Roberto's to your local town pizza parlor, this is a collection of artisanal creations in a country setting. Great outdoor space out back, very picturesque setting. Great crust, thin and chewy... A must if you are in the area..Hannah Bella is amazing. read more

See all

The food here is delicious. It is the best place for pizza in our area, and there are a couple of good ones around. The Hippy Dippy is their vegan pie and the flavors are wonderful. Our family also likes the Veni, Vidi, Vici as well as the bacon buffalo chicken. They recently expanded into the adjoining space and added a bar, so more room for eat in and parties. read more

2 small pizzas 4 beers and 1 espresso martini. 85$. The pizza was a total flop with the cheese not even fully melted in the middle.

Robbie has THE BEST Caesar salad !!! The pizza is amazing. The Pub is quaint and cozy. If you're near Sheffield, even if you're not, you should make the trip. read more

I wanted to be grumpy and upset about the wait. Waited 45 minutes past our requested pick up time for pizza. Once we dove in, could no longer complain. It was worth every second! read more

So much fun to have my birthday party at Roberto's. Pizza was fabulous. Everyone raved. They also loved the wine and beer selection. Service was great. Appropriate for all ages. I even got to hire a musician of my choice to play. And had a local baker deliver my birthday cake. Robbie could not have been more professional or more accommodating! read more

See all

Owner is SOOOO nice! Hand delivered the food to me, in my car cause I had my baby with me, I was so grateful for that small act of kindness, because no matter how small it was it showed what type of person he is, and what type of business he is running. Since then I've watched Roberto's business grow and him continue to make THEE BEST PIZZA IN THE COUNTY! One Sunday night we had Roberto's pizza then our son wanted pizza again Monday but Roberto's is closed on Mondays so we had to get pizza elsewhere and none of us could eat it, we were all saying going from Roberto's pizza to any other pizza is just inedible!! We kept saying we wished Roberto's was open! (ALSO BEST GARLIC KNOTS EVER & SAUCE!) Also the amount of free drinks / desserts we have received from being weekly customers shows how genuinely nice Roberto is. He's not giving us free stuff to make up for bad meals or us complaining! He's giving us free stuff out of the kindness of his heart, i'm assuming because we eat there, at the very least once a week ever since the place opened, and he has also brought out the food so many more times since that first time I went there!! Also beautiful inside u love the way they designed the inside ambiance is very cool and relaxing! read more

Being from Brooklyn I've had a very hard time living all over the state of MA. Was so happy to find Roberto's Pizza. We eat here once a week and always look forward to it. Roberto's sauce is the boss! I love getting their specials whenever they have them and love the New England clam chowder as well. Great staff too. Always friendly and helpful even when they are swamped. read more

Roberto's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

you're going to have sell stock to buy the caesar salad... would start off by saying the pizza is great and fairly priced. this review is in regard to the price of the one item that doesn't make any sense in its portion or pricing. in what world is a salad, of any kind, $28.00..... $7.00 more than a large, 16" pizza with three ingredients? and that they call it a "family size". my only thought is roberto must be a family of one. look at the pictures and ask yourself what you think a bin of romaine lettuce and croutons with, admittedly great dressing, should cost. read more

See all

Great artisan style pizza. Fresh interesting salads and desserts as well as local products. Next door to a great little bakery.

Outstanding pies! So pleased to have this amazing pizza in the Berkshires. The crust is delectable. You can't go wrong with Roberto's!

Ran a 128 Massachusetts Pizza Shop tournament, and Roberto's is currently in the final 4- so we made the trip from Boston to try it out. The pizza absolutely lives up to expectations. QUALITY ingredients, light/airy crust. It's not a true Neapolitan pizza by design - but its very close. The Korean BBQ wings were excellent - tender, crispy. Outdoor seating in the back, BYOB. A must stop if you're in the Berkshires. Should be on any top 10 Massachusetts pizza list. read more

See all

Running from Family Fun Weekend to The Work Week, We hit Gold at this Sexy Hot Tasty Resturant in Sheffield. The Owner treated me as his Guest in his Home. Two Meatball Apps and Mind Blown Shrimp DJ ceviche!!!! The Perfect End to A Great Family and Friends Weekend. read more

See all

We feel so fortunate that Robbie, who is such a solid dude, opened up a pizza place in downtown Sheffield. It's obvious that he REALLY cares about making his customers happy and he has a proven track record after spending so many years at the Marketplace paying his dues. The pizza is so solid. They are inventive too. Recently they created this new pie with Burrata, Vodka sauce and peas of all things. Its amazing. The cauliflower wings are solid along with the accompanying sauces. The layout in the restaurant itself is spacious and clean as well but because of the pandemic we haven't had the opportunity to eat inside yet and have just done takeout. read more

The place is not air conditioned. I t was 88 degrees out and not much better inside. We order two small two topping pizzas, A house salad, and two glasses of wine. With the tip it was $64 dollars. The flavor of the pizza was good but the amount of topping on the pizzas was ridiculous. There were about 12 pieces of each topping on the whole pizza. The onions and peppers were cut so small the pizza looked more like a cheese pizza. Just not worth the money especially with no AC. read more

Fabulous thin crust pizza, cheerfully served and deliciously cooked. Fresh ingredients and moderate pricing make Roberto's our go-to favorite! read more

We ate at Robertos the evening and we were pleased. Greeted by the owner and he explained how to order your food.we had a salad that we shared and it was okay for the two of us. Then the piece de resistance arrived. Thin crust pizza, sauce was delicious sprinkled with basil and mushrooms. Simply delicious. Best in the Berkshires read more

What a gem. Went for the first time this past weekend and ordered the large Roberto pizza. It is now our favorite pizza and reminds me of some really great thin crust NY style pizzas I've had. Will definitely be stopping by again. read more

This place is the real deal. The aesthetic is super sleek. But most importantly the pizza is delicious. The crust is perfectly crispy/chewy. We got the Hannah Bella and it's the best pizza I've tasted since moving to the Berkshires. Will have to come back with a larger group and enjoy the fire-pit and historic Sheffield backdrop. 10/10 read more

Roberto's Pizza - Buffalo Cauliflower - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

See all

Roberto's is an excellent restaurant. The pizza is as good as it gets. This place can hold its own with any New York heavy hitter--and the prices are a lot better (so you probably won't spend more than Dominoes but you'll eat better than Grimaldi's). The owner is always there and puts everything into his restaurant, which is another reason to root for it. Plus the music they play normally pretty good. read more

My husband and I were in the area and needed dinner. We were pleasantly surprised at the gem we found in Roberto's! The staff was very helpful, kind, and cheerful. The garlic knots were amazing and the pizza was some of the best of my life. The overall experience was terrific and I highly recommend! read more

Fantastic restaurant. Robbie the owner and his staff are great. We stumbled onto this place and went in for a quick slice. We were greeted so warmly and friendly that we decided to stay, sit in and eat. They made one of the best pizzas I've ever tasted. We had The Gulotta (meat lovers). If you are in the area, this is a must stop. read more

Most people enjoy a good pizza but there are a few spots in Connecticut that i would put up there as the best! Robertos has been added onto the list! All the ingredients are fresh and the crust is the icing on the cake! Garlic knots were also amazing ! We had the good fellow margherita and the roberto both were amazing! Cannot wait to go again!! read more

Roberto's Pizza - The Roberto - Pizza Near Me - Sheffield, Massachusetts

Amazing food! Great service! Amazing restaurant! Cool decor! Would totally recommend.

Stopped by a few nights ago and ordered takeout. Ordered the Margherita and the Gulotta, as well as the wings (ordered half Garlic Parmesan and half plain - they ended up giving us the sauce on the side as it was easier. The pizzas were fantastic! Flavorful, great bread. I liked the wings too - they are on the drier side FYI. Would totally visit again. read more

Fantastic service from the moment we walked in the door. Burrata salad, wine and pizza were all really great and just like the wood fired pizza of Rome. We tried the cauliflower buffalo wings and they were super flavorful and piping hot. We even spoke to Roberto for a little as we checked out and he was truly interested in our opinions. Can't say enough about this awesome eatery in the Berkshires. Were headed back with family this week. read more

One scoop ice cream I mean one scoop was very small was $5.00 .2 scoops was 11 with tax. Bring your wallet if you're going to go there you're going to pay. read more