Visiting in the area for a short couples trip. Stopped at a local liquor store and got a big suggestion to get pizza from this place. The guy was passionate about this pizza and he sucked me in to give it a try. Called in an order for a large pepperoni pizza. 20 minutes until pickup. Stopped in to pickup and the first thing I see is a note that says "I am having a miserable day / life. But I appreciate your business. lol! . I am like, WTF?! Dude comes out with my pizza and rings me up. Had to be the guy who wrote the note. Totally miserable SOB and unfriendly. Just had to laugh because he reminded me of the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld. Looks just like him and equally friendly. Took the pizza back to our house. Pizza is fantastic. Exactly what the dude at the liquor store said. Highly recommend the pizza but probably would not eat in as it is very depressing and unfriendly. NO PIZZA FOR YOU! read more

We ordered a small deluxe pizza along with a regular slice, mushroom slice, and jalapeño poppers for lunch. While not amazing, the pizza was decent for the area, much better than the great barrington pizza fiasco. The pizza had a good crisp and plenty of toppings. Skip the jalapeño poppers as they had no flavor or spice. read more

As far as pizza in the Berkshires id say they are the best. I especially recommend the Salad Pizza (I have cucumbers added and sometimes bacon) Its delicious So good I had to have a slice before snapping a pic read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Great Barrington, Massachusetts

Ordered take out... it took about 25 minutes and the man working was really nice. Had the New York style pizza with sausage, mushrooms and onions.. it wasn't as thin crust as I expected. The sauce was okay, a little bland for me, toppings were good and generous and it was loaded with mozzarella cheese which surprisingly I enjoyed. Not a bad choice this side of Massachusetts, considering we have the best New Haven style pizza in Connecticut. read more

This review is at the request of my 7 year old kiddo. He says: I would give it ten stars. I loved the chicken fingers with fries. And I really liked the server's voice. It's a great idea to come and eat here. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Great Barrington, Massachusetts

See all

First, the pizza here is great. True NY style. However, their waitress is terrible. She's a bitch. We go there all the time, so I hope she sees this. She has an attitude while serving. She admonished me to "let him [my husband] choose what he wants." My husband and I had been having some playful banter, and we did order different things. Next visit, my husband politely asked for two to-go boxes. She brought us the check instead. My husband politely reminded her, and she snapped "I'm getting them!!!!" We asked her if she would prefer if we pay up front or at the table. She very rudely said she didn't care. Then, we wanted to box our own pizza, but she wouldn't let us and whisked it away. Pretty sure it had spit in it. I promise we're not rude people. We go out of our way to not bother servers. read more

This is the first time I have tried pizza since moving out East from the West Coast. The ease of ordering online was great! They offered made to order pizza by the slice - which was pretty amazing! And the price was super affordable for a huge slice (one filled me up). The flavors were great and the crust was perfect and New-York-style. The restaurant was clean with plenty of seating. I will definitely go back again! read more

The only reason I gave this restaurant even two stars was because the pizza was actually good otherwise it would have gotten one star. Manhattan Pizza has a reasonably sized dining area and absolutely no waitresses. One guy (assuming the manager) behind the counter taking to-go orders and answering the phone was also trying to wait tables. His personality was shit, I won't beat around the bush. They charged me $12 for a Caesar salad that had absolutely no dressing on it. Essentially I paid for chopped romaine. Overpriced and absurd service. Sadly won't be going back. read more

We stopped in late for a dinner and it was absolutely wonderful. I had a wild mushroom raviolis and the sauce was terrific. My husband had a sandwich and my daughter and son-in-law had a large fantastic pizza. Our drinks were great service was wonderful it was a great night love this place read more

Great pizza, excellent service, highly recommended. Have a nice seating area behind the pick up booth. Service was amazing.

We ordered pick-up of a pepperoni pizza at 8:30 on a Sunday night in late September 2023. It was ready in 15 minutes. Service was quick and polite. The pizza was OK. We were happy to find a decent place open, and it served our needs. read more

At the height of coronavirus self isolation our family has had it with a month of eating in. The idea of Manhattan Pizza has us salivating and a quick phone call tells us we can pick up TWO lovely greasy pies in 25 minutes. Luckily a mask and gloves enables curbside pickup. We appreciate you, pizza makers! Your Deluxe Pizza made our life threatening foray into Gt Barrington worthwhile! read more

It was an OK pizza place, we got a couple varieties to-go and while they were OK, they didn't stand out and seemed a bit plain. Maybe it was because we waited a while to eat them, not sure. Other people like them so I might give them another try and have it in-house read more

Best pizza in the GB area - super quick and easy! Sometimes hard to reach on the phone on a Friday night but you just call back (:

Good pizza! They serve it by the slice as well. No gluten-free. Haven't tried the other food yet but would like to. Daily specials on the board inside the door. Haven't eaten in yet. read more

See all

I was vacationing in Great Barrington for a few days, and I'm from New Jersey, and this pizza was EASILY A 9.1/10 I loved it. The owner was so nice and told me I wouldn't find any better in the area and he was not wrong ! read more

We just needed a quick bite and this was great! Small little town and the price was great! $7.99 for two giant slices and a fountain drink. read more

See all

So... pizza in the Berkshires. What can I say... There is not a lot of good New York style pizza, or pizza by the slice in the Berkshires. I have now tried Manhattan Pizza twice and it will be my go to place for pizza by the slice. It's a nothing fancy kind of place located on Rt 7 at the intersection of Rt 23, just south of the center of Great Barrington. The order counter is tiny and looks like it could use a good re-organization. There is a seating area and they will bring your slices and drinks to you with table service. The same person working the counter brought out my order and check. So it's kind of a mash up of a pizza by the slice counter and a sit down pizza restaurant. I've tried their regular slice and their Sicilian pizza too. Both were very good. A nice, light and airy, crispy crust. It's two for two in my book so if you're looking for regular hand held pizza (not truffle, artichoke, etc... artisanal pizza which I love too), try Manhattan Pizza. read more

We had the BBQ chicken pizza. It was good but not great, fairly light on the toppings, especially the chicken, and the sauce. It was average pizza, however, the price was well above average which left me disappointed overall. read more

The pizza was great and ready on time. We got three large pizzas and everyone was happy. Very friendly and helpful staff.

Not my favorite at ALL! Maybe I hit a bad day but the sauce was bitter and the dough tasted "blown "

Manhattan Pizza is not only the best in the Berkshires, it's the best pizza period! I highly recommend Manhattan Pizza for those looking for that NYC style. read more

Yesterday, while it was pouring rain and I had three sleeping kids in the van, the gentleman working here offered to bring it out for me. The pizza is delicious but service like that, where someone goes above and beyond the call of duty, makes supporting a local business like this an easy choice on a regular basis. Thank you! read more

Basic pizza bordering on not good. Sign says "pizza by the slice,' I order 2 slices to go. Owner comes to ring me up and i notice the sign on the register 'credit cards 10 dollar min.' I apologetically say that I only have credit, does he want to do a smaller transaction (5.89) or not? He grumpily says "no mater how big you make the sign they never read it!' after taking my card. If he had said it before i would have walked out. Thats something you say to your coworker, in private, maybe; not something you say to the customer. Gave him a few extra bucks tip on the card to cover the processing charge, and I will never, ever, go back in there. read more

I dont usually write bad reviews but...today was the 2nd time ive ordered from here. The first time, about 2 weeks ago, i ordered a pizza sub, with pepperoni, green peppers and onion. What was delivered was cold, with banana peppers and onions, no pepperoni. Literally was not edible....today, against my better judgement, decided to order again with my wife and daughter. We ordered in store. I ordered a chix bac ranch sub with lettuce tomato onion and ranch. It was fine. My wife ordered a italian with everything on it. She got a italian sub with lettuce and mayo. Nothing else....wont waste my money again.....ciao read more

Manhattan for the most part doesnt have a lot of good food. Two things I like about them, they are one of the few places in Great Barrington that will deliver and secondly, I do LOVE their pizza. Love a pepperoni pizza or a onion and garlic. A perfect foldable slice. read more

A mistake was accidentally made in our bill due to a new server. When I went back the next day to have it corrected, not only did the owner refund the overdue amount, he also gave me a gift certificate for the future. That's awesome customer service. The pizza is great too! read more

Tonight was one of the coldest nights of the year thus far- 6 degrees to be exact, and we wanted a nice hot pizza to warm us up. We only just moved to GB in July and rarely eat out, but the last time we ordered a pizza we were not thrilled so we thought we would try Manhattan Pizza Co tonight. We ordered a medium pizza with spinach, broccoli, mushroom and red onion. They told us it would be ready in 15-20 mins for pickup, and we arrived 20 mins later. The pizza was ready and the total was $19.75 (not cheap, but could be worth it for good pizza). We were so excited travelling home with that warm nice smelling pizza in my lap, eagerly imagining a piping hot pizza overfowing with veggies. Unfortunately when we opened it up upon our arrival home, we were dismayed to find a tepid pizza with a sparse smattering of overly done to a hardened crisp veggies. I don't think it's due to the cold weather that the pizza was not hot either- when I arrived they had it sitting out in the box on the counter, not in a warmer or anything. We are only 5 minutes drive away and the car was warm, so I wouldn't have expected that to be an issue. I will say on the positive side, the crust was thin and crispy and the sauce was flavorful. Also, the restuarant itself is very warm and pleasant inside, so maybe we will give it a second shot at some point in the future and eat there rather than do take out. read more

Had the Pollo something or other pizza here last week and it wasn't bad. I would say that the pizza here is comparable to NJ/NY pizza. The BF and I came here on the suggestion of his cousin who raved about the pizza here. The owner was actually from NY which would explain the name of the pizzaria. The Pizza I ordered had onions, fried chicken pieces, spinich and ricotta. The pizza came out hot and the cheese stringy, which I liked. The service was impeccable (which i guess it should have been since we were the only people in the dining room) lol. All in all, I'd come back ! read more

Haven't been here in years. Cane tonight because the Chinese restaurant was closed. Was not impressed. Pizza was very bland and the wings weren't very good. It wasn't expensive thought. Large cheese, wings, and mozzarella sticks only came to $35. read more

Two stars for the delivery guy who was very sweet and prompt, now for the bad.... First off, my partner is not fussy when it comes to pizza, truthfully neither am I. The crust was the only edible part of the pizza, there was no sauce, the cheese was tough and greasy and it was so salty I had to chug a glass of water after a bite. The wings were ordered mild but had no sauce, just a dusting of salt and pepper. Thanks for having delivery, but I'll drive somewhere better next time. read more

Great pizza. Crispy chewy crust and well done toppings. We also like Roma's across the border in CT. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Deluxe pizza w/o anchovies - Pizza Near Me - Great Barrington, Massachusetts

See all

Tonight was one of those really cold ones when comfort food was in order, so I ordered dinner from Manhattan. I had a small pizza with a mushroom topping, and it came to a little more than $12 including taxes. The crust was thin and chewy, and the portion of mushrooms wasn't skimpy. There was a good balance of cheese and sauce, although the pizza did seem to be on the salty side. Even though the pizza was a "small," it was actually pretty big. I didn't bust out a ruler and measure it, but the diameter appeared to be more than 12". It was cut into six large slices. I've ordered from Manhattan a few times, and the staff is always friendly. Whenever I've called in a take-out order, the food is ready exactly when they say it will be - no unexpected waiting. The location of Manhattan is a bonus. The parking situation in downtown GB, where a lot of the restaurants are located, is atrocious. Manhattan is a little under a mile from the "hub" of downtown, and it has a private lot that it shares with Trotta's, a liquor store (another bonus - you can pick up your beer and your pizza in one stop!). It's not a hassle to get there like it is for some of the other places in GB. Thumbs up for Manhattan! read more

My girlfriend and I ordered a large buffalo chicken pizza for dinner one weekend while staying at the Fairfield Inn Great Barrington over the summer. We had it delivered and when the pizza arrived the guy opened it up in front of us to show the order was correct. I noted that it was loaded with chicken, red sauce, and buffalo sauce and voiced this to the driver. He responded with, "Yeah, I make a mean buffalo chicken pizza." We chowed down shortly after and he wasn't lying - Awesome NY style pizza. read more

Asked for a turkey sub with bacon, lettuce tomato and yellow mustard. Was told "no yellow mustard but it will be close". Whatever that means. Got... turkey, no bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayonnaise. I knew he was going to screw it up because he was barely paying attention as some bratty little girl was trying to talk to him while he was dealing with customers. Subway would have been better. read more

Very nice place!! Ironically enough, we were visiting from NY. This place beats some pizzerias in NY..(never thought I would say that). The garlic bread to start was delicious, the baked ziti was to die for, and the pizza was great. Can't wait to visit and eat here again! read more

He delivery driver Complains when I gave him a two dollar tip I thought that was fair for $14 order I only ordered six chicken tenders and a tiny soda and I came to $15 technically 1448 but it won't let me see the receipt so and this guy look very very sketchy look like he was on something read more

The signs in the window say Pizza by the Slice and Help Wanted- waitress. Only one is true. We sat in the restaurant for over 45 minutes after ordering 2 slices. This was at noon on a weekday. Our order never came out nor did the woman who gave us menus and took our order. When questioned about our order after 30 minutes the so called waitress said they were very busy (!) and it would be another 10 minutes. We explained we had a doctor appt. and couldn't wait much longer but all we got were two glasses of water. There were only three tables with customers in the dining room and they had food when we arrived. Lots of laughing and chatter at the front counter. After 50 minutes we walked out and nobody said a word to us, read more

Silician pizza was subpar, cheese was not well distributed :/

Great pizza. This is the best "regular" pizza place in town. Delivery is prompt, prices are great and if you happen to eat inside the staff is friendly and it's spacious. This is the place to go in GB if you're looking to grab a couple slices and a beer with a friend. read more