My absolute favorite pizza place!!! I'm not in this area too much anymore and I miss it! Chewy crust, plenty of cheese and toppings! Served up in an amazingly friendly kitchen by a local Italian family. Truly the best pizza shop in the Valley! read more

This is an old school pizza shop. The owners are very friendly and the pizza is top notch. My favorite is their New York Style Pizza. In my opinion, it's the best in the Mahoning Valley. read more

I can't believe I never wrote a review for this place. We don't go here nearly as often as we should but it's definitely some of the best pizza around. The ingredients are fresh, the sauce is delicious and the crust.....oh mamma the hand tossed dough that makes the crust is phenomenal. It's also a plus that the owner usually greets you at the counter to take your order of whom has an obvious Italian/broken English accent. We've had the three styles they offer of New York, Sicilian and Chicago over the last few visits and all are great. I find myself partial to the New York style but all are equally as delicious. They offer salads, subs, wings, pepperoni rolls, Stromboli and other dinner options (i.e. Cannelloni, Manicotti, etc.). While I've only had the pizzas they offer, I am looking forward to trying some of the other options they have. You will not be disappointed in the pizza, that's for sure. read more

See all

Love the family orientation, good food they pay attention to detail very laid-back and honest family business and I love supporting places like that good Italian food read more

New location...same great NY style pizza. Here is my review from their previous location... If you've been looking for a local place with some decent NY style pizza. I've finally found it! Tried Renato's for the first a couple of weeks ago. At the time, I had not heard anything about the place other than seeing the sign when driving by. I'm glad I decided to give it a go, because they've got some really good pizza. I ordered the 16" NY style pie, 1/2 with just extra cheese, the other 1/2 with sausage, pepperoni, and mushrooms. The extra cheese side was nice and chewy (in a good way) and the cheese was sooo buttery. The other half was very flavorful with a little spice on the sausage. If you want some delicious big, floppy, foldy, NY style pizza...this is your place! They also have Brier Hill style, white pizza, Chicago stuffed pizza, Sicilian style, and specialty pizzas. Check out the pics of the menu I uploaded for more info. I'll be back here....lots! read more

See all

Oh Lawdy! Lawdy! I think we just found the best pizza ever! Bravo Renato's Pizza! Found this gem while browsing yelp and took a chance... so glad we did. Awesome sauce, thin crust, lots of great sausage & pepperoni, plenty of cheese layered into it all! P.S..... I hardly ever take time to write reviews read more

Renato's Pizza - Sausage & pepperoni (after being reheated and attacked) - Pizza Near Me - Niles, Ohio

Amazing...! This place never disappoints.... Great business in our community and love to support them. read more

Renato's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niles, Ohio

Never disappointed in anything we have ordered. Deluxe Stromboli is hubby's fav and mine is calzone. Got a brier hill, mushroom and sausage and so delicious! read more

This place can't be beat when it comes to Stromboli or New York style pizza. The prices are very moderate read more

Renato's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Niles, Ohio

See all

Very good pizza. A little thicker than I normally like, but still really good. Outside crust is nice and crunchy. It's too thick for the bottom crust to be crunchy, but no worries. Also the Philly Steak and Cheese sub was also very good. read more

Renato's Pizza - This is their NY style thin crust with pepperoni and banana peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Niles, Ohio

Great little place in Niles Ohio. I have been here quite a few times and every time we are satisfied. Stromboli is big enough for 3 people because it is filled so full that everything spills out on the first cut. The salad is delicious and for the 9.00 dollars you get your money's worth. Grilled chicken salad comes with pepper rings,onions, olives,tomatoes and a nice portion of cheesy goodness and the chicken is delicious. Tonight we ordered the Italian Stromboli and it was full of ricotta, mozarella, pepperoni,peppers,sausage and sauce. Can't go wrong with the Stromboli.. read more

See all

One of the best places around to get real Italian food for carry out. Very friendly Ma & Pa type of place. As a vegetarian, I recommend the veggie roll. My friends like the pepperoni roll. Good size for the price. read more

We have never had a bad meal from this place. The owners remember all their customers names and treat everyone great. They truly appreciate your business and it shows. read more

Fantastic authentic pizza...highly recommend stopping here! Great prices as well. Large pie $12.00 best I've had in a long time! read more

Amazing. Great food, great service. Highly recommended. Great value for high quality ingredients.

Wonderful young Italian family serving up authentic fare. We adore their stromboli ..they are generous with the cheese. The owners..Mario and Laura are humble. In Niles. ..a town of Italians...they lead the pack in delicious hand made pizzas and stromboli. Their basil garlic knots are to die for. I have heard good things about their wings also. They are closed on Sunday to spend time with their son Renato and I find that endearing. If you are in Niles this is THE best place for pizza or Stromboli. read more

No other pizza in the tri state area can hold a candle to this place. Salads are huge . Pasta fabulous. Stuffed shells oh so good. Give it a try read more

Delicious pizza and pepperoni calzone!! Very reasonable prices. Highly recommend!!

I was passing through Niles on a job, Yelped a good pizza place and stopped in at Renato's expecting an amazing pie. While the toppings were abundant...lots of cheese and quite a bit of sausage, the crust was way too chewy for me. I spent more time chewing through it than enjoying the good stuff on top. Maybe I was expecting a nice crispy thin crust, but this was not a very good pie. read more

Everything is wonderful! Haven't had a bad meal here ever! Great value for the money! Makes the greatest spinach roll ! Great pizza! I'm so happy we found this place, worth the trip from kinsman! read more