Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Melfi & Santangelo

    4.4 (5 reviews)
    Closed 2:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Melfi & Santangelo Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Melfi & Santangelo

    Recommended Reviews - Melfi & Santangelo

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kelly H.
    109
    16
    2

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Melfi & Santangelo

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 2,835 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Salvatore's Italian Grill - Maximo, subbed out the chicken for salmom

    Salvatore's Italian Grill

    3.7(104 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$

    What a find! Went with my good friends and their 4‑month‑old and had a fantastic meal…read more The complimentary pizza bread and warm bread were divine--the pizza crust was perfectly crispy outside, chewy inside--with a clearly homemade sauce that had the perfect spice balance. Entrees come with a choice of soup or salad; one friend had the wedding soup, while the other two of us upgraded to the Caesar for $2--well worth it. Generous portion, fresh crunchy lettuce, and both shaved and grated Parmesan.The dressing came on the side. Service was impeccable: water glasses never ran dry and empty plates/bread baskets were cleared before we noticed. The restaurant was busy, so food wasn't instant, but everything arrived hot and delicious with no complaints. The staff definitely deserve a shout out for anticipating our needs and taking such good care of us. The menu looks extensive (we didn't order drinks), and there's a separate seasonal drinks list with cocktails and mocktails. Seating includes a large dining room and booths that easily fit big family groups; the vibe was lively and welcoming. Portions are generous--many people including all three of us left with takeout boxes with leftovers. A couple of tips: make a reservation if you can--we arrived at 5:00 and luckily were seated right away, but there was a wait by the time we left 90 minutes later. Also, the place is very family‑friendly: they offered us a car‑seat carrier for the baby, which made the visit stress‑free. Highly recommend for great Italian food, solid portions, and warm service in Cortland.

    Tried this months ago with take out and enjoyed it. Since then I've been recommending it to friends…read moreand family. We decided to dine in and I took a good size party with my family. Right away the server had a strange attitude. She kept asking if we're ordering an appetizer. My family member asked for soup please. She ignored him. She asked again if were doing appetizers and we mainly said no thanks but my family member asked again if he could please get soup. The server said, "I'm doing appetizers right now". She said it with a very abrupt and rude tone that shut my family member down. Later she came to ask us if we wanted dessert, and I tried to order my dessert but she was distracted and said she'll take my order right now but left and never took my order. After the meal we noticed our bill had a 20% forced gratuity on the bill. I've been a server for over 6 years and 18% on a psrtybofn6 or kore is common but ALWAYS stated on the menu and/or up front at the host stand. There was no such thing here, not a single sign telling us gratuity would be forced on our bill for 6 or more parties. And nowhere did it say they'd increase gratuity with an added 2% We asked the server about the 20% gratuity and she said, "that's automatically on there, i don't have time to do anything about that." There was a small pause as we took in her comments then she said, "I'll be back." And as she left some family members heard her clearly say as she walked away, "I don't have time for this". We know Ohio law says that something like that must be posted to inform people ahead of time. Especially at 20%, that not gratuity anymore, that's a service charge, I mean thats 1/5 of our entire bill. We went to the front to ask about it and the host said it was posted on the menu guy we asked where and no one could find it. Manager came, she said they did not have to tell anyone about the 20% added tip but she'll remove the 20% and we choose decide what we want to tip. Thr server came out and said was everything ok. We made a clear point that the gratuity wasn't as big of issue but it was the servers bad attitude and they way to spoke to us that was not professional or appropriate. The server said she was sat too many tables and didn't have time to deal with things. We said we understand she's busy and working hard but her attitude and rude comments are very unprofessional. The server left the area. I'm so sad that I really liked this place at first and kept recommending it to my visiting family and we all ended up with a terrible experience. I'm embarrassed by Salvatore's tonight. I've literally done this done for 6 years at a very similar restaurant with heavy traffic and posh clients so I know the stress of serving especially when servers are sat too many tables at once, but still, I NEVER gave my customers a bad attitude or said any rude comments. If you can't handle the job maybe try something else as a job. Don't be in the hospitality and serving industry. Maybe one day we'll give them another chance, but that's a big maybe. Until then, we're looking for another Italian restaurant to make our go to restaurant. 1/5

    Photos
    Salvatore's Italian Grill - Starter Bread

    Starter Bread

    Salvatore's Italian Grill - Afternoon delight!!

    Afternoon delight!!

    Salvatore's Italian Grill - Grilled octopus

    See all

    Grilled octopus

    Salvatore's Italian Grille

    Salvatore's Italian Grille

    4.0(227 reviews)
    4.8 mi
    $$

    We were recommended by locals that this was the best Italian restaurant in the area--and we're so…read moreglad we listened! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted with a cozy, welcoming ambiance that set the tone for a great evening. The service was top notch--our server Jessica was incredibly friendly, attentive, and made us feel right at home. She knows the menu very well. What impressed us was the fact that She anticipated our needs as if she was a mind reader. Without even asking, she brought out leftover boxes for our meal. The food did not disappoint. We started off wedding soup---which was so rich in flavor and amazing. Followed by the bacon wrapped shrimp and scallops and had the Linguini Fra Diavolo and the Veal Florentine. Everything was perfectly cooked with just the right amount of spice and flavor. To top off our meal, we had to have a takeout of the desserts. the tiramisu and the lemon mascarpone cake (recommended by Jessica as the two top desserts) ---both were the perfect sweet ending to a delicious dinner. Highly recommend this spot if you're in the area and craving authentic Italian with warm hospitality!

    Great dining experience. Our friends treated my husband and I to Salvatore's, it's one of their…read morefavorite places for Italian. We found the food to be very good so we can see why they decided to bring us there. We decided on an appetizer and we ordered the bruschetta, it's served on warm focaccia bread, highly recommend it. For the dinner I chose the fettuccine with olive oil and garlic sauce, excellent choice. My husband had the baked gnocchi and it was delicious!! Service was excellent... Highly recommend this place!!

    Photos
    Salvatore's Italian Grille - Inside

    Inside

    Salvatore's Italian Grille - Cheese Pizza Old World Briar Hill Pizza

    Cheese Pizza Old World Briar Hill Pizza

    Salvatore's Italian Grille - Outside view

    See all

    Outside view

    Red Plum Pizza And Pasta

    Red Plum Pizza And Pasta

    4.3(70 reviews)
    5.6 mi

    Yes yes YES! This is…read morequite literally the best pizza I have had in my entire life. Who knew it would take this long to finally find that. So cool that they are opening up TWO new locations in Boardman & Kinsman to spread the pizza goodness!! The Detroit Hot Honey Roni is my favorite. This was my first time having Detroit style pizza and it makes me feel like I don't have to travel to truly experience it. The baked cheesy goodness of a crust is phenomenal. Flavors? Out of this world. Cupping pepperoni is simply the best, their sauce doesn't give me heartburn and considering I try to stay away from red sauce that says a lot! OHHHH but their basil is always so fresh and flavorful. I think I could eat a bowl of it! The Detroit Chicken Bacon Ranch is also delicious. Best CBR pizza and I've had a lot of em. No words! The Detroit 8 Mile, same thing. Raving about it! I was thoroughly pleased that you literally get slices of garlic clove on top. The hot peppers ain't too hot & it's just GOOD! Period. Penna Alla Vodka with a fresh baked roll... my Lord! This was on a separate visit, but figured I would include it in this review. (I have been there 3 times within a month, oops) Pasta came out piping hot, flavors were immaculate; sausage, sauce, cheese, basil, OH MY! Just try it. I cannot wait to continually support this business and try new things with each visit!

    I saw we are getting a Red Plum in Boardman , curiosity got the better of Me. I decided to go to…read morethe Warren location rather then wait til our location opens Nov 1st. Restaurant is Beautiful, staff very friendly and tons of parking. One of my dearest friends went with me. They have a great stocked bar and nice outdoor seating for those that prefer that. We started with the Oven Baked Meatballs, plentiful with a nice amount of fresh ricotta, it also came with a huge roll with fresh garlic and spices on it. The Meatballs were delicious. We tried the Plum Salad...the flavors were amazing the Feta was soft and creamy and the dressing was unlike any I have ever had. Best Salad. Small size enough to share. We tried a few Pizzas...took 90% home. First up New York White ...I added Ricotta to it. It was cooked to perfection and full of flavor. Second up was Detroit style The Butcher...My friend said it was really yummy, with a great amount of Sausage Meatballs and Bacon. This is the Ultimate choice when those ingredients are your Joy. We got smaller size with 4 huge square pieces. The under carriage of this pizza was pure perfection. Third up was New York Style Pesto, Vodka Sauce and Red Sauce with the perfect blend of Mozzarella, We chose to have them not add the pepperoni. This pizza delivers every flavor imaginable. I'm going to ask them if they can recreate on Detroit crust which is my new favorite. This pizza was tied for my favorite.... Fourth and final the tie for first place pizza.. Detroit Style Greektown ... Between the fresh spinach and the creamy Feta add olives hot peppers and light Mozzarella this pizza was Epic. The under carriage was perfect. The pizza delivered crunch after crunch bite after bite. It doesn't really get better than this. Our waitress was wonderful. We had her bring each pizza out in its box as we really only shared one square of each pizza. I am New York Born and live in Ohio. Truly here There are very few pizza establishments that truly bring it. Red Plum 100% delivers. Quality, Taste and price. Excited they will be in My neighborhood when the new location opens. This is a truly hidden gem. I plan on going back very soon. Hands Down Best of the Best!!!!!

    Photos
    Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - PENNE ALLA VODKA

    PENNE ALLA VODKA

    Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Garlic Butter Parmesan wings.

    Garlic Butter Parmesan wings.

    Red Plum Pizza And Pasta - Original BBQ Wings

    See all

    Original BBQ Wings

    Melfi & Santangelo - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...