On Tuesday, I ordered a pizza for pickup on Wednesday. Arrived at the specified time. Door was locked. Called 20 minutes later, no answer, left a message. They called back and said they had my pizza. I called back a little later to verify that they had my pizza ready. They said they did. I went and pizza wasn't ready, It was still in the oven & I had to wait for it. No discount offered, no apology, nothing. Last pizza from Boardman Cornersburg. From now on, I will go to Cornersburg location only. read more

this place is constantly locked-up, even when there is a guy working inside. I talked to someone that knows the situation. She said they have trouble finding counter help and they have trouble buying food stock items!!!??? They close and turn out the lights on their whim. WEIRDO-RAMA situation. This place used to be the best. read more

We have been getting pizza here for 40+ years. Sunday we got the worst pizza . The crust was thin, it had way to much sauce on it and it was soggy and undercooked. We will try it again to see if the bad pizza was just a bad day. If we get one like it again, we will have to look for another favorite pizza shop. Very sad. I will update my review up or down after our next try! read more

I don't want to give my opinion on this place, but I feel Cornered because Yelp keeps asking me to. So OK I will. It's been a year or so since I had their pizza, which Matt ordered in because he loved it. Based on that experience, I might have given them 4 or 5. I couldn't decide which, so I stopped by one lunch time to finally figure out how much I like their pizza when it's hot and fresh out of the oven. Only guess what. I didn't get to try it. Because they don't serve slices! You need to start serving slices. You'd have a 4 or 5 rating if you did. Even if they've been sitting out all day, idc. Throw one in the oven for me, take 2 dollars from me and get a nice rating on Yelp. Oh well. No slices in North Eastern Ohio. Well, lots of people beg to differ but a lot of the better places (cough Angelo's) don't serve slices. BTW if you want the best pizza in the region, get the Loaded Baked Potato pizza at Angelo's in CLE. Deep dish. read more

See all

I really like this pizza. Just order it crispy especially if you get the 14" size. Sausage and mushrooms, and get the peppers in the sauce. Seriously. The sausage is the best, not those large chunks you get at most places. Ground up crumbly not greasy sausage. Extra cheese is good too. read more

Updated review! I'm beside myself with the new ownership/management. Pizza is garbage, and a shame to Cornersburg alone. They were famous for their sausage pizza. See my pictures and what's become of the legend. They said ownership/management has changed! We took back the pizzas for a refund. This is so sad.... read more

Cornersburg Pizza Boardman - Pizza Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

I think it's good pizza, but It's location sucks. Trying to make a left is like getting the pizza, takes a long time. No Pepsi and they run out of stuff I swear every time I go to order. read more

Although small in stature, they are mighty in pizza. Highly recommend the delicious pies made by friendly folks.

This has become my favorite pizza ! The toppings are generous, and the pizza has such a delicious crust. Love this place and the staff !!! I crave their pizza so often it's ridiculous ! Going to order one for dinner today. read more

Great tasting pizza...one of my favorites in the area. Crust, sauce and cheese are all very good. I like the way that they put green peppers on the pizza for free...that's the way it comes...no extra charge. Very tasty without having to order toppings. read more

These guys truly kill the pizza game. Who else grates their own cheese, takes half a day making sauce or sausage, makes their dough daily etc... and doesn't advertise it like you should kiss their asses because of it?! -- That's because this is how it SHOULD be, (at least anywhere you're expecting wholesome / handmade food.) Fair prices with generous toppings and fully customizable. Christ, these guys will make 1/16 of the pizza a certain way if need be! Another valley staple, approaching 50 years (for good reason), you'll never regret getting yourself a pie from here... Recommended: 1/2 Mrs. Lou (Brier Hill + onions + sausage) & 1/2 white pizza with hot peppers. Staff and Owner are genuine down-to-earth people. Come in and BS while you wait for the best pizza you've ever tasted. read more

Just met the new owners. Great people, great pizza. This pizza was just like it used to be. Outstanding. Best of luck will be back

Pros: 1. Best-tasting pizza in Youngstown (subjective, I know!) 2. High-quality ingredients 3. Consistency (always made fresh, hot, and always tastes the same -- great!) 4. Staff rarely gets order wrong 5. Cheese is amazing 6. Sauce is amazing 7. Crust is amazing 8. Variety of toppings 9. Store is cleaner now that it's under new management 10. Coca-Cola products (if you like Coke better than Pepsi, you're in luck) 11. Takes cash, debit, and credit Cons: 1. Don't deliver 2. No sides FYI: 1. Portion of food is ample but not huge 2. Prices are average (a little over $10 for a large pie) 3. Pizza style is a cross between NY and Chicago 4. Red pizza cheese is a blend of mozzarella and romano 5. They'll make it extra crispy if you ask them to 6. WHEN I GO: I always get my favorite pie! Large, red sauce, extra crispy, with pepperoni, and after it comes out of the oven, I ask them to oil the crust and sprinkle romano cheese on the crust. (It's like free crazy bread!) read more

The business is under new ownership and they are using the original recipe that I grew up on. The pizza is delicious, and the sauce and cheese are on point. I drive out of my way to go to this location, and I'm happy to once again have Cornersburg pizza. read more

This pizza is the best pizza I've ever eaten.... I grew up in Ohio and this was a awesome treat while visiting the armpit of America

The best pizza in town. The place has got a new owner and takes debit and credit. It is the same great recipe! The crew is super nice. Try it You'll love it! read more

Always great never disappointed with there pizza. Best around just the right amount of sause. Plenty of ground sausage. Great taste. Always friendly and courteous employees read more

The crust is tender with a light crispness on the bottom. A nice flavor balance of the sauce and cheese!

Very Good pizza, would give 5 stars, but they offer no wings, no drinks... just wonderful delicious pizza. Peppers and Cheese is the best!

Let me start with this: I have been a customer for 45 years. For so many years, I always counted on a pizza that I loved. That was always the case, and when I went to Cornersburg Pizza Boardman I knew that EVERY time I went I could count on got the same great experience. Over the years, I tried the other branches in this local chain in the area - Poland, Cornersburg, etc. - but they were NEVER up to the standards of Boardman Cornersburg. Not EVER. Not ONCE. I think Mrs. Matula and her son simply provided the absolute BEST Cornersburg pizza there is. Last week, I was shocked to experience a pizza without pepperoni - although I ordered it with several toppings. Mrs. Matula would NEVER have given me a pizza without the toppings ordered, nor would Larry. Under new ownership, this location cannot hope to be what it was: The best pizza anywhere around - and JUST the pizza. CARING. Think for a minute about this. No matter who takes it over, Cornersburg Boardman is a crazy SPECIAL place - not because of the name, the location, the owner(s), but just because of THAT PIZZA OU CAN COUNT ON. Unfortunately, since they can't get a topping right for a 45-year veteran in this now situation, the thrill is gone. Sorry, CPB, but you don't have the magic of the original. read more

This business lacks class and cares little for the needs of its customers. Their complete lack of integrity makes it difficult to even talk about their pizza. Don't go there if you want either speedy or good service. You find neither. Not only don't they deliver, but they are also disorganized and unfriendly. You can get better pizza and service down the road or even at the original Cornersburg Pizza on Meridian Rd. read more