Have eaten Avalon Gardens pizza back in the 70/80's. Ordered a Old style pizza and a regular pizza with mozzarella cheese and pepperoni. The pizzas were good, dough and cheese was good. The sauce is off. Something in the sauce isn't good. You don't need to listen to me but I have been around and owned a pizza shop years ago. Just my opinion that would make your pizza better. read more

I recently went to the restaurant across the street that was a wine bar, I ordered a margarita pizza and I was highly disappointed. On the way home I questioned whether or not I should stop here, but I did. I am very happy that I did. It was a true Margarita Pizza. Full of tast, cheese, tomato, and sauce that complemented one another amazingly. read more

Brier Hill Pizza is apparently Youngstown's claim to fame, and now that I've had it, I totally get it. The pizza here is fantastic, and I would definitely try the brier hill if I were you, but the buffalo chicken and taste of Italy were also delicious! With its proximity to the Covelli center, it's a great option for before or after a show too! Will be back. read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Brier Hill Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

The restaurant is tucked into a very old/historic building. It gives a lot of character. The service was spot on and had very good prices on beer, wine and food. We had to try pizza which was good. I guess we weren't expecting it to be so thick but it tasted good. The meatball sub had nice sized meatballs that were juicy. Prob my favorite thing we ordered. We also had the calamari. Nothing special, just good ole' fried squid. Glad we stopped in. read more

See all

Have heard great things about the pizza here so thought we would stop in. The service was quick and friendly. Table says order by phone but bar tender came by and offered to take our order. The pizza was very good and will get again. Meatball bowl with Cavatelli left something to be desired. The sauce was sweet and watery. Pasta was cooked well. Didn't care for the meatballs. The fish sandwich was nothing special. $5 for a side of fries is steep especially when it's just bagged, thin cut fries. The cannoli was very good. Kind of small but very tasty. read more

See all

The crust is good Not enough sauce No answer on the phone yo complain Will not return read more

The food was excellent. The service is excellent. The place looks very aesthetic fits Youngstown perfectly. I especially have to give a shout out to the my cashier, Epernay W for being very nice and welcoming will be coming back and bringing my family 5 stars read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Photo of wall - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

See all

Pizza was good. Sweet sauce and thick Pizza . Seemed like a popular place to be at for families and more. Service was friendly and atmosphere was festive . read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Top 3 pizza in Youngstown. Argue with a wall. Parking sucks, though, I wish they would leave downtown. Pizza is very very good read more

This is the worst pizza in youngstown. I won't say this is the worst i've ever had, but i can't say i remember a slice worst than this. The dough is way too chewy. The sauce tastes like it's from the can. For the price point i'd hope you'd make your own sauce, and if you are making your own it sucks. Do better. The cheese is the wrong type of cheese for pizza. The crust was alright. Crust was 6.5/10. Finally pizza should be dough, sauce, cheese, and then toppings. Not dough, sauce, toppings, then cheese. My god this dough was thicker than a brick. Not trying to become obese with one slice. The thickness does not add to the experience. In fact it detracts from it. I rate it 3/10. Would rather chew glass than eat this again. read more

Went for lunch, got there about 1:45 pm, 3 guests. Waitress was friendly, we ordered 2 wedding soup served hot and delicious. Other courses where cavatelli. cheese ravioli, fish sandwich with onion rings. All ofvthis food was cold, wondered if the waitress was too interested in talking to bartender and left food sit. She never checked on us until where ready to leave. Told her the food was cold and she could have cared less. And what's with plastic ware?. Probably won't go back. read more

We went to our granddaughter's dance competition in April 2024 at the DeYor Performing Arts Center and had dinner at Avalon afterward. There was a line out the door to be seated on a Saturday night, but the customers waiting in line were friendly and assured us that the line moves fast - this restaurant obviously has a regular following. We sat at the bar and again sat among regulars. I had a Cabernet, and Ray had a beer. Heaven! I can't believe the menu here!!! It reminded me of my ex's Italian family recipes. I had the fried smelts and Brier Hill Pizza (just like my ex-grandmother in-law's homemade)! My husband had wedding soup - with homemade soup breads - another Youngstown staple! I make soup breads at home, but I have never had them at a restaurant. Impressive and delicious! My husband had a meat pizza and loved it. We ordered a potato pizza and cannoli to go. I didn't realize a restaurant still existed that served authentic Italian food. By the end of the evening, my cheeks were sore from smiling! What an experience! read more

See all

It was festive but not spectacular. We were seeking spectacular. The food was good but we were starving and wanted the appetizer first. Everything was served at the same time. The server was good but not super attentive. Prices are fair. Chairs are uncomfortable. I paid 7.00 to park but that may have been my fault. I've heard amazing reviews about The Avalon so we might try it again. I think pizza is their specialty. read more

See all

Good service. Antipasto was excellent. Really different and tasty crust. Place was old school cool and laid back. I would give it a 4.5 if I could. Will definitely return. read more

Love there food. Amazing The best food i ever tasted. If anyone ask me what is the best place to eat. This is it Thank you!!!!

Haven't ordered from there in a long time but have been patronizing downtown restaurants. Gave them a try. Very disappointing! We ordered pizza and wings. They charged $18 for 12 tiny frozen wings (yes I called and asked if they were the frozen battered kind- like Banquet brand) Pizza was okay. read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

The pizza was fantastic. The sauce is one if the best I have tasted and the crust was good as well. I would recommend it.

The antipasti platter...killer. Taste of Italy pizza was fantastic too. Never disappoints.

The pizza is delicious and the service was fantastic. We found this place traveling home from New York to St Louis. If we were local to the area, we would be eating here all of the time. read more

We drove an hour to eat an early dinner here and attend an event nearby. paid for parking and went inside where a sign said please seat yourself. We found an open table, among a few others, and began to browse the menu from the QR code offered at the table. It was about 15 minutes before a waitress offered to get us menus, So we closed the online order. It was another 5 minutes when she returned to our table and said it was reserved for another party and we needed to leave. It was going to be 45 minutes until she could get us a table and by that time we would have been late for our event. I have eaten here once before and the food was great so I've wanted to take my husband. Sadly because of poor service we will not be back. we wasted 5 dollars on parking for nothing, ended up grabbing a bite at a fast food nearby. And had there not been a sign saying please seat yourself maybe this wouldn't be such a big deal but it was a humiliating experience. I wonder if we would have went through with online ordering at the table what would have happened? So unprofessional! Do not ask your customers to seat themselves than ask them to leave after 20 minutes because you are too busy! read more

They cavatelli and meatball is amazing. I am always going to get it every time now. I never had any thing better like that. 5 stars

I love grabbing a pizza here from time to time because they are one of the rare establishments that offer VEGAN CHEESE!! Oh how I wish more pizza places had it, but Avalon does! Their crust is amazing and the pizza itself never disappoints. The folks that work there are always nice, too. It's a bit loud honestly if you dine in, but that's to be expected with a pizza place and it was never so bad that it bothered me. Will definitely be back again and again! read more

This place is located in downtown Youngstown and we've been coming here off and on over the past few years and it never disappoints. On this particular visit, we were here for my son's 21st birthday celebration. From my wife's first phone call to them a few weeks in advance to paying our bill on the night of, the experience was fantastic. They allowed us to make a reservation for fifty people at 6PM on a Saturday. This is even considering that Youngstown State University football had a home game and this establishment is a favorite for many to visit after the game. No charge or anything like renting a hall, just allowed us to make a reservation. On the Monday before our reservation, my wife called our order in of 7-pizzas and several sides/appetizers. We arrive at approx. 5:30 on the evening of and we immediately notice that several tables have reserved signs attached with our name on them. We are greeted by two young men who took care of us the entire evening. One's name was Vince (my son knew him) and the other was I believe KaShawn or something close to that. I should have written his name down for this review. These two young men took care of us from start to finish. The food was brought out hot and on time. As soon as my glass was empty, a new beer was poured and brought to me. They checked on us regularly and were more than accommodating. Kudos to such great service and they did it with a smile. Now to the food. The pizzas we chose were the Traditional (Tomato sauce & blended Mozzarella & Provolone), Traditional with pepperoni, Brier Hill (Tomato sauce, sweet peppers, imported Romano ), Taste of Italy (Tomato sauce, capicola, Genoa salami, Margherita pepperoni, blended Mozzarella & Provolone), Mad Greek (Sautéed spinach, fresh garlic, Kalamata olives & Feta), White (Oil, sea salt, black pepper, parsley, imported Romano, blended Mozzarella & Provolone ) and the Buffalo Chicken (Baked chicken breast, buffalo sauce, blended Mozzarella & Provolone). The sides/apps consisted of their homemade peppers in oil, butterflied smelts and Italian fries ( Fried Avalon dough topped with marinara sauce and imported Romano). Everything as fantastic. I must mention that they have a tad bit sweeter sauce then I prefer but the crust and toppings make up for my pickiness. The Italian fries and the peppers in oil were equally delicious but the smelts were just OK. Too much breading to where you couldn't really taste that delectable little Smelt. Fantastic place and highly recommend. read more

See all

service was great. pizza was good. we ordered french fries $5 ok but then they charged us 75 cents for Ketchup !!! that's ridiculous and $1 for extra ranch dsg was a large salad with just 1 am container of dsg. prices are not low no reason to add these charges !!!!! read more

Let me start with. Not a fan of deep dish type pizza. Found this place while in town for work. Walking distance from the double tree so big win there. First night I went I ordered the 8" pizza. Pizza good but not my thing. It's a deep dish style I think. Lots of crust but not bad flavor. Sat at bar. Staff seems to know everyone but it is a small town so not surprised. Got the meatballs to go for a snack in the room. That's what kept it a 5. Meatballs awesome. Second time I went got the pasta with meatballs. The fact that it comes out in a plastic dish that looks like it came from a prepackaged meal was a tad disappointing but again...'meatballs for the win. Pasta was ok. I don't think sauce is house made. Not much flavor. Overall decent food but great atmosphere. Staff super friendly and everyone is helping everyone. Will stop by again when/if in town. read more

My husband and I celebrated our 50th wedding anniversary last week! We spoke to the owner about having a party there to celebrate and she went above and beyond to make it a very special night for us! The pizza was excellent and we had ordered chicken fingers for the kids and the adults loved it so much we had to keep ordering more! The bar service was outstanding as well! Not only did we have over 30 people show up for our party the restaurant was packed because the YSU game had just ended! We are regulars but this was just the most amazing service and food! can't thank everyone there enough! read more

AMAZING PIZZA! Called for reservations before the PBR event at the Covelli Center this past weekend and was greeted promptly and taken right to our table. I wish I would have gotten our servers name, she was tremendous! Very attentive and getting our refills quickly! The Moscow mules-DELICIOUS! read more

I loved the environment of this Youngstown staple; however, the experience was dampened by the fact that all the food was served on paper plates and takeout containers..and the silverware was plastic wrapped in plastic. Normally I would say that is not a big deal, but when you are charging an average $12-15 per plate, that price is not valid for the dining experience. The service was good. The food was subpar. Also, Avalon should consider adding French fries to their menu. Dining isn't what it used to be post-COVID but dining here felt like takeout was their priority and they were just trying to accommodate dining-in customers. read more

I ordered half pepperoni half cheese pizza for me and my son. After an hour wait they bring me a full pepperoni pizza. I went to the car and gave my son a slice and noticed. I brought it back in and Katrina at the counter basically told me I was lying because her boss made it and it's not full of pepperonis. I literally had to pick the pepperoni off each slice in front of her for her to take the pizza back . Then she tried to tell me since my son bit a slice it's nothing they can do. Very rude. No empathy. They acted like I was trynna steal a pizza I paid for!!!! I just wanted what I paid for read more

Food: lousy. Frozen meatballs, frozen French fries. My friend couldn't eat her salad it was so bad. Service: Paper plates and plastic cutlery. Servers all look like they want to quit & run. FROZEN PIZZA!!! HOW DOES THIS PLACE STAY OPEN??? I wish I could say the ambiance even existed!!! Uncomfortable metal chairs. No small tables except in the back by the bar. Everything is 6 ppl. NEVER AGAIN!!!! read more

One of the best pizzerias in the Mahoning Valley. I highly recommend! You won't be disappointed.

Excellent, excellent pizza. The Buffalo chicken pizza has a lot of chicken no with great flavor. The Italian pizza had great sauce, flavor and cheese. Really great crust too! read more

See all

Had the peppers and meatballs and they were delicious. One of the best pizza's I've ever had. Great service and very clean bathrooms. read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Taste of Italy Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

First time going here you seat yourself and get fast service from the waiter I went here to go on a date with my girlfriend and we had a good time we had ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and man that pizza was good and spicy after we munched up the pizza we wanted desert and ordered a cannoli after we got done with all that we got the check the check was a decent price I would go back here read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Best Briarhill pizza in Youngstown. We ordered for lunch at work the other day. We got the briar Hill which hot peppers a couple of cheese pizzas and a meat lovers pizza. The crust was thick and fluffy the pizza was cooked properly was delivered hot. We also got an order of the fried though which was deliciousHad just enough sugar to make it sweet but not overpowering. We also ordered the peppers and oil which were one of the best peppers and oil I've had in a long time so if you want a good Briarhill pizza this is your place read more

We got three 8" pizzas. That is probably not their specialty. The flavor was fine but overall the pizza just was not great. We will give it another try and get larger pizzas and see if that is better. read more

The food is amazing. Hands down the best pizza in the area. When my friends come in from out of town who's to live here they always request us to have Avalon. The service and staff are always nice and quick. This is a true Youngstown staple as well as an Italian staple. read more

This is the worst pizza I've ever eaten. I'm in Youngstown area visiting family and this place was chosen for takeout pizza. I'd describe the pizza as "stale toasted bread with some pizza sauce lazily spread across it." This isn't pizza. I'd vote it a 1.3 on a scale of 1-10 read more

Avalon Downtown Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, Ohio

Love this place, their briar hill pizza is the best and the wedding soup out of this world, really homemade and reasonably priced.

Six of us craved pizza after a game at the Covelli Centre and we found Avalon on Yelp so we walked the .4 mile. The restaurant is two store fronts. It's huge. One room has a few tables with the carry out counter. The other room has lots of tables and a long fully stocked bar with some imported and craft beers. Unique to the restaurant was the big mural and historic signs on the walls. It had a very nice feeling. We learned that the pizzas were thick crusts and came in three sizes. The signature pizza was Brier Hill which had a sweet tomato sauce, sweet peppers and Romano cheese. So we ordered it. Half of us really liked it. The others said it was too sweet. We also tried the spinach pizza. I told the owner that our group thought it was dry due to too much spinach or the spinach needed sauté more, and a drizzle of balsamic vinegar or olive oil would be a nice on top with a little sauce. She appreciated the comment and would talk to the chef. We also had fried dill pickles, fried mushrooms and fried cheese. They were all lightly breaded with a yummy crunch. We agreed that the wedding soup was delicious and filling. Three different salads on sandwich-sized plates were very good. The place was hopping on a Saturday after the 1 p.m. game. The nice bathrooms were in the rear. Parking is on the street. The rooms are wheelchair accessible. Check it out. read more

See all