The indoor eating area was closed so that upset us as a bad first impression, however we were there…read moreto order and pickup to go. You're probably wondering why the 5 stars however. The quality of the pizzas are amazing, and it's worth the added price for the quality you're getting. We had a rather large order and it took about 50 minutes to make from scratch to box. We ordered the following pizzas: Spinach Ricotta Calzone style - 5/5 Veggies & Ranch Chicago style - 5/5 BBQ chicken with onions - 5/5 Ham, Pineapple, & roasted peppers NY style - 5/5 Sausage and pepperoni - 4/5 Compare the quality to Scotto's or Giovanni's. I would say the pizza is less greasy than Giovanni's but there are slightly less toppings and the flavor is the same as their two competitors. The slight price increase appears due to be due to the quality and care that the pizzas are put together.

Really great meatballs and chicken parmesan! Leftovers are amazing and I look forward to the next…read morefamily event to order.

This place takes me back to the old Shenango Valley Mall days when I worked at the record store…read more next to Scotto's. The pizza is still very: very good. We go with choose or with the veggie pizza with Italian sausage. No matter what you will get authentic and delicious pizza. FYI this pizza is every bit as good reheated as it is the first day. That rare but it just might be the crust ;)

Food is great. Even though it is a pizza place, the Strombolis, subs, pasta, and much more are very…read moregood choices. The services is very good, better communication, for a restaurant with limited seating. I would give this four stars because I prefer to sit in a restaurant but Scotto's seems to be the type of restaurant that prefers carry out.

Cash only, if it's cash only just know the Italian food is going to be great!! One of the best…read morepizza places in the area, lived up to the hype for me.

The best pizza in the world, hands down. Only open for a few hours a day after 4, so be ready!read more

Great pizza and fast delivery! It's a staple here in the valley. This joint has been in the area…read morefor a while.

Good pizza, fast delivery, and affordable prices . This is a consistently good, fresh pizza we…read moreenjoy getting for delivery .

Pizza was excellent. I ordered the lunch special pepparoni slices and will definitely be trying…read moremore of their menu.i definitely recommend if you haven't tried them you should.

Not just very good Pizza, but the staff there is exceptional!…read moreI have been a regular there for many years even before they moved to their new current home. PS you've got to try the nut roll that's not always available but for sure over the Christmas holidays!

I just discovered this place last month. Great pizza. Friendly staff. I highly recommend.read more

This is a MUST stop for us whenever in town! The Buffalo chicken wing Pizza (extra saucey!) that's…read moreour order and it never disappoints! Whenever we introduce people to it they are hooked too!

Let's start with the food. The Hilltop, also known and searchable as Basilone's, is the best value…read morein the area from New Castle to Youngstown to Sharon. Hilltop has Margie Dogs, unique to the area (although some say "uhh, Stanley Dogs?") and a short menu of local traditional favorites. Today it's about the first Friday of Lent, 2026, and the fish dinners associated with Lent in this area. That plate of deep fried haddock, with mac and cheese, and cole slaw, and the bread and butter was $9.00! Nine freaking bucks! And it came out blistering hot and delicious. I also got a couple Margie Dogs. You can't have Margie Dogs, because you think chili dogs are the best. You have to CRAVE a Margie Dog. And anyone who has ever HAD a Margie Dog, CRAVES Margie Dogs. So suffer. Margie Dogs are so much better than chili dogs, so you don't deserve them. (Hilltop does have kraut and chili dogs as well. And there's catsup on the table for your chili dog...) Anyways, the wife and I got two fish dinners, two Margie dogs, the sides and bread. Oh, and two Black and Tan pints. For $25.00. And I tipped a fin cause, man! Take care of your wait staff mang! I would bring my Mom here, lots of stuff to look at, pictures all over the walls, and a quiet and safe bunch of customers. In a quiet and safe part of Farrell, Pa. If you haven't been here, even in a couple of years, come back. Farrell is up and running great!

The food is unbelievably good and thoughtfully made- especially for how low the prices are! The…read moreservice and environment are perfect. Welcoming, unpretentious, and authentic. I moved to Philly a few years ago and this is the first place I stop when I come home to visit. No place compares.