The best pizza in the world, hands down. Only open for a few hours a day after 4, so be ready!

Cash only, if it's cash only just know the Italian food is going to be great!! One of the best pizza places in the area, lived up to the hype for me. read more

See all

Cash only. Amazing pizza. Been coming for 30 years. Best pizza in Mercer County. Takeout only.

I had my birthday dinner at Chez Panisse Cafe last night. We ordered one of their pizzas which was amazing. We had half at dinner and took home the rest; it was still amazing the next day. Why does this matter and why post this under some place on the other side of the country? Luigi's pizza is better than Alice Walters. She is going to win hands down on the rest of the meal, but you crushed her pizza. Can I spend a day with you in December or around Labor Day to learn how you do it? read more

So I unfortunately don't live in Hermitage anymore, but I come back quite often. And to be honest I always forget about Luigi's pizza. But let me tell you what I still love it. I was just home over Christmas break and we ordered it, and it was awesome!! We got 3 of their pies one plain one with pepperoni and then a pepperoni and sausage. The dough is perfect airy and crunchy at the same time the sauce is sweet kind of how I like it. I have had a lot of pizza and this is always a good point, the sausage was perfect! Not spicy or hot just like breakfast sausage. That's the only and best way I can describe it. I did ask for no peppers in the sauce as they will add fresh peppers to the sauce automatically if you don't request this. The peppers add another level of taste to it, sometimes I don't like them and unfortunately I just wanted their pizza. As far as service and cost, service is still the same. The make pizzas and sling them out all one size 6 cut round. They are friendly and will let you know what is what. There is no place to eat in the store as they sell them but I have seen in the summer tables and chairs outside of the shop. They are open for a limited time, and sell out pretty fast so best option is to order quickly because when they are out of dough they are out for the night. I don't have pictures of the pizzas but I did snap a shot of the menu to share this is as of 12/27/2023, and prices do change. read more

Luigi's Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Hermitage, Pennsylvania

Best white pizza I have ever had. They only sell Pizza and it's cash only if you plan to order.

We love this pizza! Ordering is easy. Taste is amazing! That 1st bite has you hooked! So yummy...never disappointed. The staff is always courteous. Keep up the good work. read more

Luigi's hasn't changed their recipe for great pizza since they opened many years ago! Cash only, and one size pizza are their staples. Having a slice from here always brings back childhood memories and I continue to come here when family is in town! Great pizza, and a wonderful family owned business! read more

10/10 for flavor, crust, sauce & ingredients. The sausage is 11/10. xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Love the pizza here--just a plain 12" with that peppery sauce. Cash only, worth every penny.

Outstanding pizza!! One of the best in the area. You can't go wrong at this place and very simple.

This is a Hermitage classic. I moved away 5 years ago and this is the only restaurant in the area that I feel like I MUST eat at when I visit. There's just nothing like it. They are cash-only, and I think it just adds to their charm. They're a small business with a strong and loyal customer base who knows that they've got a great pizza worth a trip to the ATM for. read more

Been ordering pizzas for many years from Luigi's. I remember going to their little corner shop in the Hermitage plaza before it was rebuilt. Still one of the best tasting pizzas in the area. read more

Some of the absolute best pizza I have ever had with very friendly service. I can understand why this place is so famous around here. I'm however forced to dock a star because no one inside was wearing a mask. read more

Fantastic pizza!!! Tastes exactly like childhood. We try to pick up a few whenever we are in the area. My son says it's his favorite...he is right!!!! read more

Not sure how this place is still open. The pizza is average at best. Additionally, it is served with a side of 'we don't care if you come here or not' attitude. Especially when they remind you 'they only take cash'. It is at that point that you get the privilege of taking home average overpriced pizza. Marchelonis, plaza pizza, and Aldo's are SIGNIFICANTLY better - and much more friendly as well. read more

The BEST pizza around! I grew up eating their pizza back when they were located on Idaho St in Farrell and continue to eat it today.

Love this pizza -- the green peppers in the sauce are fantastic. I like it plain or with toppings -- sausage is always great. I live about 45 minutes away and have eaten it out of the box on the way home. Yum. read more

Fantastic Pizza!..always in our top 3 places we rotate through for pizza in town. I have never had a bad pizza from here. I've been eating it for 25+ years.. I only wish they delivered ;-) read more

Luigi's makes some of the best pizza I've ever had, the sauce is tangy, they use lots of good quality cheese and they manage to make the crust both chewy and crispy. I won't go anywhere else for pizza. read more

I originally had this at 2 stars, but I gave it another go and if you ask for extra cheese you get some extra time in the oven getting much more crunch. If you get the regular I've noticed some inconsistency of doneness which on two separate occasions I had a doughy underdone pie. The cash only still is an inconvenience and the lack of choices in sizes is disappointing. However if done right this can be one of the best pies around Mercer county. read more

The best pie in town,great service and friendly. I been eating there pizza since the Farrell day's.

By far one of my favorite pizza pie spots around!! My favorite pie is the pepperoni and sausage!!!!! Three drawbacks are no credit cards, only one size pie, and they are aren't open during the day. AMAZING pies though!!!!! read more

Best darn pizza for over 60 years that I can remember! Have their own unique taste and no one beats the sausage!

Legendary pizza. I've had pizza in every major city in the states, and Luigis is the absolute best. Family owned and operated for probably over 60 years, originally in Farrell. Lots of great locally owned family run pizza places around the valley, so no need to ever get one from some crappy commercial chain pizza place. Luigis is the best of the best. Just one size. Great prices. Only open from 4-9, cash only. read more

Well we stopped in at 8:15 to order a few pizzas to go. They close at 9:00. The response by the 4 people standing around who work there? Sorry we are all sold out of pizza!!!! I would think if the owner knew that they would be very upset!! read more

Some of the best pizza in town 5 star but they close early so don't wait to late. This pizza has been one of my favorites for 30 yrs

This is the best pizza in the area! I have been eating it for over 30 years (except for the few years it closed). The daughter of the original owner has been running for the last 15 years and it is still the same consistent pizza every time. I recommend the sausage it is very good. read more

Luigi's is the best pizza I've ever had hands down. I have eaten a lot of pizza over the years from NY to Chicago to LA. I've had all of the famous ones and nothing quite compares. Actually I haven't seen anything that comes close. It's truly one of a kind. read more

Best Pizza in all of Western Pa. Yeah you have to go pick it up and you can only pay cash....But ordering is convenient ....one size for all and price is reasonable. Pizza is always hot and the homemade chunks of Italian Sausage are so yummmy!!!!! We loved this pizza so much we ordered one and ate it and then called in and went and got another in the same day. Can't wait to bite into the goodness again. Please go to Luigis's Pizza!!!! read more

My absolute favorite pizza in town!! From the crust, to the sauce, to the toppings...it's the absolute best! I have relatives from out of town that can't wait to visit and order this pizza. Some of the closer ones even order and take a pizza home with them. I just wish they would take debit cards and be open for lunch. read more

the best pizza in the shenango valley. aldos is aclose second but more expensive.