Local bakery! Our first order! At Red Rose Bakery Chocolate birthday cake for my future son in law! The cake was decadent chocolate! Cake, icing and filling! We loved it!! read more

See all

Have not had a bad piece of bakery goods in this place. From Cinnamon Twist to apple turnovers.

Found this nice little place while parked on Hooper Avenue so I decided to grab a few little cookies very big fan of rainbow cookies so I wanted to try theirs. While they're good and have a nice amount of jelly, they're a little thick not a lot of chocolate, but they have a great taste . The other cookies were good just as expected, but the rainbow cookies is what I really look for overall 3.9 out of 5 read more

Red Rose Bakery - Variety of cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

I had some last minute company drop by last week, so I used UberEats to get some cookies and a layer cake from Red Rose. I was a little disappointed. The cake I ordered was "vanilla fudge", and was described as vanilla cake with fudge frosting and fudge filling. What I got was a cake that was chocolate, with a very odd, almost watery, chocolate filling, and one thin (1/2") vanilla layer running through the middle, covered in chocolate ganache. It was OK. It wasn't what I was expecting, and it was a little dry. We ended up tossing maybe 2/3 of it after it sat in my refrigerator for four days. The cookies were described as "butter cookies". I was anticipating the usual bakery, butter cookies, with sprinkles, maybe dipped in chocolate on one end. What I received was a very odd assortment. There were cookies that were like soft snickerdoodles, there were other cookies that seem to be lthe same dough, but with pistachio flavoring added. There was a cookie that was two small, soft chocolate wafers with marshmallow cream in the middle, dipped in chocolate with chocolate chips all over them. They had two of the Italian rainbow cookies, those were very good. They were very welcome after the disappointment of the other cookies. And the last thing was a free item that I got because my purchase went over a certain amount, and that was a cannoli. It was made in a cannoli shell that was so heavily dipped in dark chocolate that the shell was soggy, and I could not tell what the filling tasted like. All in all, very disappointing. read more

A very quaint delicious bakery, they fulfilled my order n exceeded my expectations. The cake was a picture I saw in Pinterest n it was perfectly executed. The cookies were perfect in size, flavor n decor. read more

Red Rose Bakery - Cream cheese cookie w a red velvet crumble - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

First visit--disappointing. We got a vanilla cake with chocolate frosting. There was very little cake. The cake was basically all frosting, and the frosting was not very good. The inside layer cake was thin, and it didn't seem fresh. For $27, I would expect a better quality cake. I don't think that we will be returning to that bakery. read more

Walked in at 12:15pm. Everything looked beautiful! I was really hungry, and the crumb squares looked fantastic. I bought the blueberry cheese crumb and the plain crumb. Took them home (I live only 2 miles away) and could not wait to devour them! One bite of each... I could not even swallow them. SOOO STALE! Such a disappointment. Threw them both in the garbage. So sad.... read more

Cannoli cake / beautiful and yummy. Customer service was great on the phone and in the bakery. read more

Red Rose Bakery - Cannoli cake - beautiful and yummy !! - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

If I could give 10 stars, I would. The red velvet cake we ordered for my daughters baptism came out AMAZING. Everyone was raving about how delicious it was, and it was. Definitely the best red velvet I've ever had. Plus the design on the cake was just so beautiful. Thank you again!! read more

Red Rose Bakery - Red velvet cake with cream cheese frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Was looking for fresh pastries to take to my cousin's house for dinner and was very happy to find this one. They just finished filling their cannolis and cream puffs as I walked in the door. The lady behind the counter was extremely helpful, friendly, informative and had great customer service. Felt welcomed here, and I will be back!! Fair prices, too. Very fresh. read more

I am giving 2 stars because they really are a great bakery with quality goods. Today however I went in to place a simple custom cake order (vanilla with raspberry filling) and was told rudely that they were not taking orders for this week, and that I needed to give them at least a week notice. Must I add that I have been going here for years and I have never given a weeks notice, I usually pop in 4 days before an event and have no trouble. The young women who was helping me was extremely rude and told me "I can come and pick from the case of what is left from the week if I need cake on friday." Needless to say, unhappy with the customer service not with the goods. read more

I placed a custom order here and the woman on the phone was very helpful and understanding of what I wanted. When I went to pick up my order the two girls behind the counter were so friendly! Highly recommend this place for their customer service, and the cake was delicious too! read more

Red Rose Bakery - a chocolate birthday cake with blue frosting - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Love this bakery! Cookies are delicious and the prices are great. This is our go to place for cookies and small desserts. read more

THE BEST BAKERY!!!! I go to this bakery like all the time. I found this hidden gem going to another spot and because I have a sweet tooth I stopped. The best visit ever. #1 the customer service is always the best. Friendly, fast, and genuinely nice people #2 the selections are supper fresh. I always get cookies or their cupcakes!!!! Omg sensational. Always moist and not overly sweet. #3 reasonable prices #4 they just opened up their 2nd location in Asbury!!!! Congrats. Well deserved for top notch service and always fresh products. I could keep going on and on but I will leave it for you to decide. Please support this local bakery. I would choose this place over and over again. In fact, they are my #1 spot for all of my cakes. read more

See all

Ordered a 10 inch cake for bday. It was decorated beautifully, they did exactly what we asked for. The inside was dry and nothing exciting to the palette unfortunately. I was sad. I was looking forward to eating the cake after reading the great reviews on here. When we came in person to put our cake order in, we decided to buy a variety of pastries from their display case. They were also beautiful looking but to no surprise they were dry inside too. I was hoping maybe they just left old ones in the display case, but i was wrong. The girls working in the front are nice but don't seem like they know what they're doing. read more

Well I drove 45 minutes to get to this bakery and boy was it worth the ride - there cannoli's are one of the best ever - and I've tried many including Carlos bakery In Hoboken and Brooklyn shops too- the Italian cookie selection is on point and I loved them all- also had the cherry cheesecake and it was fabulous- also the service was friendly and very helpful- can't wait till my next trip- they are right up there with the best- read more

I don't even know where to start! We are staying down here for my friend birthday and I really wanted to surprise her with a delicious cake! After hours of research I found this amazing bakery and even though it was 30 min from our AirBnB I decided to give it a try. All I can say is WOW! The cake is amazing! We even bought some cookies and other treats when we picked up the cake and everything was amazing! Thank you so much for this amazing experience, for following my instructions to a T and for making my friend so happy! I highly recommend this bakery! read more

Red Rose Bakery - a chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and strawberries - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

See all

They have fresh bread and pastries. The cakes are delicious. Always have a great selection of cookies too. They are across the street from work & I stop in too frequently. Love having a good bakery close. read more

Awesome cake and service!!! I showed a pic of a dolphin cake that I was buying for my sisters 50th Birthday and they made it spot on!! Thank you for making Mary's 50th the best ever! Cake top tier was tiramisu (didn't really taste same) however bottom tier was cannoli and it was spot on! Extremely satisfied. Party was @beacon70 in Brick and almost EVERYONE asked where the cake came from and LOVED it!! Thank you for participating in the most memorable birthday for my sister read more

See all

3 tier cake customized for my dads 50th birthday! So happy how this cake turned out!! It was cheap! The other bakery asked me for a 1000 dollars to have this cake customized like this! I'm extremely happy, thank you!!! He is going to love it! Definitely will be going back :) read more

Red Rose Bakery - 3 tier cake - Bakeries Near Me - Toms River, New Jersey

Great bakery items, cakes, cookies, bread etc. Lots of Italian goodies but also typical American . Prices seem a little lower than other bakeries in the area read more

The woman in the Toms River store was very short and unwelcoming. I came in with intentions to order a dozen or more cupcakes and a cake. I asked for a menu of flavors "we don't have that" okay well that makes my decision hard... no response. No paper menus of flavors? No pricing? Unwelcome attitude and no customer service? Yea i'll take my money elsewhere They also shame bad reviews read more

Went there on a whim back when they first opened for a Christmas cookie order, as our previous baker was a bit "meh". We haven't gone to another bakery since. We have tried their crumb cakes, cookies, cupcakes, cakes, tarts (crumbles), pies... I guess the whole nine yards. We have yet to find anything that we do not like. It also helps that their customer service is top notch (they now label all their goodies - but back when they didn't do that, the cashiers were always very helpful in explaining what all the different cookies were!). Keep up the good work and good luck on your expansion! read more

I called a few weeks ago asking for help with a small breakfast pastry service after my mother's memorial service. All I got was what they don't do: they don't deliver, they don't cater, they don't have time. I was told the message would be passed to their event manager who would contact me, but never did. So I don't recommend. read more

We had a " unicorn"layered birthday cake from Red Rose Bakery on Sunday. Chocolate layered with chocolate mousse. O.M.G. is all I can say!! I, who never eat birthday or wedding cakes because they usually are not good-ate two and a half pieces. Cake was fresh and moist, mousse was perfection-frosting was wonderful!.. Decorated so beautifully we didn't want to cut it! read more

If you're looking for a great bakery look no more. Red Rose is by far the best Ocean County has to offer. Just had my husband's 70th birthday cake made there and it was fabulous. It looked beautiful and the taste was out of this world. From there everyday goodies to there specialty cakes, we are never disappointed with Red Rose. Thanks for making our day extra special. read more

Ordered online for moms 90th .Wow what a cake everyone enjoyed it ,fresh tasty nicely decorated .We will recommend to Friends and family

Having been born and raised in Brooklyn, NY I think I'm a pretty good judge of Italian pastry and cookies. My husband and I moved to central New Jersey 30 years ago and have not found one good Italian pastry shop where we live. Going on 3 years ago we bought a summer home in the Toms River area, and I've been trying different pastry shops . Some were good others were a definite no no. This week it was Red Rose Bakers turn for me to try. We bought a few Italian pastry, I have to say it was delicious! The closest thing to my favorite pastry shop in Brooklyn. I also bought one cupcake to try because usually cupcakes that are store bought are overly sweet, and not so moist. Let me tell you next time I go back I'll be trying a lot more of their selection. They were moist, not overly sweet, and very fresh! We will definitely be repeat customers! read more

This bakery did an excellent job on cake for my retirement. I bought the decorations, but they did the beach theme exactly how I requested!! Everyone commented on how great the cake looked and how wonderful it tasted!! Great job! read more

I'm not reviewing the quality of their products. I have tried a few pastries and everything was fine and tasted fresh. So, I decided to try their custom cake for my parent's 50th wedding anniversary and support a local business. Online ordering was simple and convenient. It said you can order up to 2 days in advance. I ordered 3 days in advance. It was only a small round cake, nothing grand or outrageous. I got an automatic confirmation email and it said someone would contact me asap to go over details. The next day I figured someone would call but by the late afternoon still no call. I called them as I wanted to make sure they got my order and if they had any questions or needed a deposit. No one answered so I left a message. About 15 minutes later I received a call and the girl told me that unfortunately they were unable to fulfill my order because they cut off orders early. I asked her why she hadn't called me first thing in the morning so that I could make other arrangements and she told me that this was the first time she saw my order! Well, she only saw my order because I left a message and then she looked it up. Otherwise, was no one going to call me until the last minute? Then it would have been too late to order a cake from anyone. I was so upset and fortunately I was able to call Wegmans who was able to fulfill my cake order and save the day. I will never order anything from this bakery again. I was so disappointed in their customer service and lack of courtesy. read more

After reading reviews I had to try it out since I was looking for a good bakery in the area. The girls behind the counter were friendly. I brought home a few things for my family to try. I did not bother with the donuts since they get them from another bakery and I know what they taste like. They even advertise they are from the donut shop. There hard rolls were good. Cupcakes were tasty and moist, although the frosting was just so so. Their black and white cookies were fresh and the cake part was good. The white frosting tasted great, but the chocolate was horrible, it was hard and you could tell it was made with cheap ingredients. Too bad they do not make a cookie just with the whit frosting. I tried some of their smaller fudge cookies and threw them out after just eating half of one, the cookie tasted stale and the chocolate tasted like the same stuff as the black and white cookie. I did not try any of their fancy brownies, but the normal one was good. I will go back to try some of their pastries and cakes and maybe try a cupcake with different frosting. read more