Random Lake Pizzeria

Delivers to saukville for a very reasonable fee. The 16 in pizza is far bigger than I thought,…read moredefinitely left overs. We ordered 2, one with vegan cheese and it was so creamy and rich, think i like it better than cheese cheese. Delivered faster than expected, and streaming hot. Will be ordering again.

We've really enjoyed their pizzas, and once I figured out to order them "crisp," they've been…read moreconsistently great. (We also order double toppings now) We've only been disappointed a couple of times. One Sunday night, I called for delivery, but the driver had already left for the day. The manager/owner answered, asked where we lived, and since it was on his way home, he made our pizza and personally dropped it off. That kind of service sticks with you. We truly appreciate having Bada Bing deliver all the way out to Little Kohler.

See all

DeO's Pizzeria & Pub

4.1(102 reviews)

13.5 mi

If I could give this restaurant ZERO stars, I absolutely would. My husband and I brought our…read moregranddaughters here yesterday, and the entire experience was a complete shit show. The hostess seated us, and we sat there for 45 minutes without a single person coming over--not even to take a drink order or acknowledge us. We then watched the same hostess approach a couple she had seated about 20 minutes AFTER us and apologize because she "forgot to tell the server they were there." I called out to get her attention, but she blatantly ignored me and kept walking. My husband finally had to flag down another waitress. Only then did the hostess come back and say, "Oh my God, I'm so sorry--I forgot to tell a server I sat you." By that point, we had been sitting there for nearly an HOUR. The restaurant wasn't even busy! We finally got up and walked out--completely disappointed and disgusted by the lack of service. The atmosphere was also dated, dingy, and uninviting. I will never return, and I would never recommend this place to anyone. Absolutely horrible experience from beginning to end.

Beware of price gouging! If you order a split pizza, you…read morewill pay double for toppings. A $15.99 large pizza quickly becomes $25.59 if you add two toppings. The menu says $2.40 per topping, but if you split the pizza it's $4.80 per topping. The menu and the waitress will not tell you this until you are presented with the bill. If you ask to have it fixed, they say you must talk to the manager who is not there. It's sad that they need to nickel, dime, and dollar their customers like this.

Storefront - pretty

Spicy green beans

See all

Bar seat view, Knob Creek & Coke, Spotted Cow

Harry's Pizza E Vino

5.0(24 reviews)

19.7 mi

We love this spot. The pizzas are delicious and there is a good variety. We like the lemon,…read moreprosciutto or Marsala beef. There is a simple menu overall, mostly pizzas, salads and a couple apps. But everything is delicious. They also do takeout which is handy. It's a must-try in the area!

All we can say is "WOW". This is hands down some of the best pizza my family and I have ever had…read more The appetizer with pesto was amazing as well. The pizza dough comes out so crispy, but yet very light. The pizza holds up and doesn't get soggy AT ALL! It didn't leave you feeling full or stuffed after either. Love it! I'd come back to this wonderful town just for the pizza alone! Thank you to Harry's for a truly wonderful meal!

Campfire Pizza

See all

Inside. Very comfortable

The Random Cup

4.0(4 reviews)

0.1 mi

Great food and atmosphere! Enjoyed the quiet space for coffee and a great bagel sandwich!read more

Great new coffee spot in random lake! I ordered an iced chai with cinnamon sugar syrup and the…read moreavocado toast. The toast was some of the best breakfast I've had in a while. They were all decorated for christmas and staff was super friendly. I would totally come here again!

The Random Cup

White Chocolate Raspberry Frappe

See all

Caramel Mocha

Bada Bing Pizza

3.9(24 reviews)

7.2 mi

Good food for Wisconsin Needs help w delivery and service…read moretho but we're all short staffed RN so I feel that

This little spot in Cedar Grove may not look like much on the outside, but it has some of the best…read morepizza, sandwiches and garlic bread I have ever had (and trust me, I've had my fill)! Everything here is fresh and made to order, so service can be a little slow on a super busy night, but it's worth it! The Italian Beef Grinder is my go-to, and is made even better after adding Giardiniara Peppers! Don't let the distance off the freeway or the unassuming front fool you. This place is an absolute must!

See all

Riverview Inn-the Next Generation

4.2(40 reviews)

11.1 mi

Literally some of the best pizza in the country. 16" thin crust for the win. Add sausage and…read moreonions. I don't know what magic they put in this thing, but it's even better the next day or as a midnight snack if it makes it that long lol

Excellent service and delicious food. Hidden local gem! I'm so glad we found this great diner.read more

Bar

16" thin with sausage pepperoni and onions

See all

Pizza of the Month, French Onion, so GOOD!

Maricio's in Barton

4.4(74 reviews)

13.4 mi

Maricio's must be doing something right as we drove past several other closer pizza places to pick…read moreup pizza from here during my recent visit to the area. When we decided that pizza was what we wanted, my friends immediately said Maricio's and I now know why. We ordered several pizzas for take out, everything from gluten free crust to fully loaded and each of them were piping hot and delicious! The staff is friendly, and I love small towns where people know each other by name. For this South Florida gal who misses the thin crust pizza that Maricio's makes, it was one of the best dinners I had during my visit!

Excellent food! We enjoy Maricio's pizza!! My kiddos love their the thin cheese homemade pizzas! So…read moreflavorful and delicious. I can't believe I didn't know about Maricio's before. Will definitely be back.

Inside

See all

Supreme thin crust and deep dish white sauce with chicken.

Dino's Pizza & Subs

4.8(18 reviews)

13.5 mi

Pizza the way it is supposed to be. The subs are great (club…read morewith extra sauce). The place had been remodeled beautifully. A lot more seating.

Best sub sandwich I've ever had! The ham is my favorite, but they're all delicious!! And the pizzas…read moreare incredible! Dino's secret sauce is the best and all the toppings are fresh. My favorite place to eat in Plymouth!

Classic Ham sub & Pepperoni pizza

See all

Il Ritrovo

4.3(402 reviews)

18.5 mi

Had a delicious lunch at Il Ritrovo today. We opted to sit outside and enjoy the beautiful weather,…read moreand were able to be seated immediately. Our server Dylan was excellent, and the rest of the staff kept our waters filled and dishes cleared. We tried the Vegetariano panini (fantastic) and the Lombardia pizza Bianca (also fantastic). Everything is clearly prepared with intention - the greens on top of the salad were perfectly dressed, and the veggies on the panini were chopped into small, uniform pieces so every bite was perfect. It was hard to decide what to order, so we will be back to work our way through the menu!

Cute place but SUPER TINY. the place was super busy and cramp. I think if you get a booth you're…read moreokay, but because it was just us 2, we got seated right by the door, in the middle aisle. It was IMPOSSIBLE to talk to each other. It was so loud, we were basically yelling at each other, the waiter too. Our table was so tiny, it barely had room for our food. What if we had ordered more? Our waiter was super nice and very knowledgeable. However, when he was telling us about the pasta special, we both heard him talking about adding berries to it. But when it came it, we were confused what he was even talking about. The pizza was great BUT only when you eat it fresh. After it got to room temp/cold, all you could taste was the burnt crust. Unfortunately, now that it's off my list of place to try, I probably would not go back. Also, we had to wait 30mins which was fine but a party of 2 who came AFTER us, got seated before us.

Dining room

See all

Interior decor

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Nicole S.

0

1

0

15 years ago

This is truly the best pizza I have ever had! The crust is simply amazing and the flavors and freshness of the pizzas are awesome! The menu features such a variety of different pizzas from a gyro pizza to your classic topping pizzas. The ingredients are natural which makes it even better. The owners are husband and wife and you can tell that they are truly passionate about their business. The restaurant is so warm and inviting and it is a great place for families, date night or hanging out with friends. They have a wide vareity of beverages and even have homemade custard. Save room for dessert! They have some great specialty sundaes. Believe me, you will want to save pizza for later! This is worth the drive to Random Lake. I said it once and I will say it again, this is the best pizza place. read more

Karen T.

15

1

0

7 years ago

This is my favorite pizza place. The atmosphere is great, always welcoming you in. The food is amazing. They do not only have pizza they have amazing sandwiches also and some great appetizers. Great place to meet up with friends for drinks and food and a great time. read more

Tami G.

0

8

1

11 months ago

Great pizza atmosphere and delicious home made ice cream! We will definitely be back!

Anthony R.

0

5

0

8 years ago

This might be the best pizza I've ever had. It's unsuspecting and amazing.

Mitchell W.

0

1

0

11 years ago

Excellent Pizza! We go there several times. Best pizza ever.

Random Lake Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Desserts near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Restaurants near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Coffee near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Things to Do near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Shopping near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Dinner near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Burgers near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Breakfast near Random Lake Pizzeria

BEST of Random Lake, Wisconsin Thrift Stores near Random Lake Pizzeria

Best of Random Lake

Things to do in Random Lake

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Random Lake Pizzeria also viewed

Maricio's in Barton

4.4

(74 reviews)

Maricio's must be doing something right as we drove past several other closer pizza places to pick…read moreup pizza from here during my recent visit to the area. When we decided that pizza was what we wanted, my friends immediately said Maricio's and I now know why. We ordered several pizzas for take out, everything from gluten free crust to fully loaded and each of them were piping hot and delicious! The staff is friendly, and I love small towns where people know each other by name. For this South Florida gal who misses the thin crust pizza that Maricio's makes, it was one of the best dinners I had during my visit!

Excellent food! We enjoy Maricio's pizza!! My kiddos love their the thin cheese homemade pizzas! So…read moreflavorful and delicious. I can't believe I didn't know about Maricio's before. Will definitely be back.

Tomaso's Cedarburg

3.7

(151 reviews)

Tomaso's is a great casual pizza place right downtown Cedarburg! We walked in not really knowing…read morewhat to expect, but we were pleasantly surprised. You order at the bar, and the employees were super friendly. We all really liked the sauce - note, the cheese is UNDERNEATH! A little different, but we had a good time.

Worst crust like cardboard. Spaghetti tastes like tin and veggies cold. Owners not good people.read more

Falls Firehouse Pizza

4.1

(40 reviews)

This is the best place to get pizza or whatever you crave. The prices are very reasonableread more

Pizza was unremarkable. I ordered a cobb salad, was given the wrong salad and had to go to the…read morefront desk for eating utensils. Definitely a do not return experience.

Michaleno's Pizzeria

4.1

(14 reviews)

This was our first visit. They only have carryout at this location. The staff and owner were…read morevery friendly. The food was ready on time. When we arrived at home we dug right in and the food was fantastic. The pizza was cooked perfectly, as was the canzone! The Italian sub sandwich was very good, but I would have liked a little more red sauce. That's just me and I will order it next time. We will be ordering again. If you are looking for quality Italian food at a very affordable price, order from Michaleno's!

Very average. Not the best pizza around but not bad in a pinch. Delivery and carry out only. Fish…read morewas ok. Calzone was very thick with pizza dough, very little filling.

Bada Bing Pizza

3.6

(25 reviews)

Delivers to saukville for a very reasonable fee. The 16 in pizza is far bigger than I thought,…read moredefinitely left overs. We ordered 2, one with vegan cheese and it was so creamy and rich, think i like it better than cheese cheese. Delivered faster than expected, and streaming hot. Will be ordering again.

We've really enjoyed their pizzas, and once I figured out to order them "crisp," they've been…read moreconsistently great. (We also order double toppings now) We've only been disappointed a couple of times. One Sunday night, I called for delivery, but the driver had already left for the day. The manager/owner answered, asked where we lived, and since it was on his way home, he made our pizza and personally dropped it off. That kind of service sticks with you. We truly appreciate having Bada Bing deliver all the way out to Little Kohler.

Even Odds Pizza

4.4

(88 reviews)

Very god pizza. My construction crew had worked a very long week, so as a thank you, I ordered 12…read morepizzas from even odds. I ordered them for pick up at 1115. Mind you, they open around 1030-11. When I arrived, there was no wait..I got my pizzas and took them back to the site. The guys loved the pizza and asked me where I got them from. Long story short, my men loved the pizzas and not a single slice was left.

We've been ordering from Even Odds Pizza for some years. Always great pizza and the absolute best…read moresauce!

Bada Bing Pizza

3.9

(24 reviews)

Good food for Wisconsin Needs help w delivery and service…read moretho but we're all short staffed RN so I feel that

This little spot in Cedar Grove may not look like much on the outside, but it has some of the best…read morepizza, sandwiches and garlic bread I have ever had (and trust me, I've had my fill)! Everything here is fresh and made to order, so service can be a little slow on a super busy night, but it's worth it! The Italian Beef Grinder is my go-to, and is made even better after adding Giardiniara Peppers! Don't let the distance off the freeway or the unassuming front fool you. This place is an absolute must!

Theo's Pizza

4.4

(18 reviews)

Awesome pizza! I've tried several kinds and they are all delicious. If they delivered it would be…read moreperfect.

This is some darn good pizza! Ordered via Eat Street. Very reasonably priced. Will order again!read more

Uptown Slice

4.7

(35 reviews)

Really great pizza. I'm from the east coast and this is as close as I could get to the real deal!…read moreYummy

My family and I have been to Uptown Slice a handful of time when we come back to Sheboygan. Great…read moreslices, great craft beer selection, and great bartenders. Uptown Slice always feels like home!

Faye's Pizza

3.9

(89 reviews)