Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Faye's Pizza

    4.0 (86 reviews)
    ModeratePizza, Italian
    Closed 3:00 pm - 9:00 PM
    Updated 2 weeks ago

    Faye's Pizza Photos

    Business Info

    FAYE'S PIZZA ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Moderate noise
    Good for kids
    Good for groups

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Faye's Pizza

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    a drawing of a man and a woman

    Out of towners, just passing through... we stopped here and we're so happy we did! Delicious pizza, awesome potato sausage soup (a homemade recipe I was told) and great service. Cody was authentically kind to each customer in the place, and very warm and welcoming to us. Highly recommend; love the family atmosphere. If we're ever back this way, we wouldn't hesitate to go back again and again. Yay for local family owned businesses!!

    Deluxe pizza minus mushrooms, plus jalapeños & garlic.
    Kimberly H.

    Everything was great from the service to the food and pricing was low. On a drive home to De Pere from Milwaukee on a Friday night we were craving classic family style pizza and this hit the spot. We enjoyed a deluxe pizza and I had an amazing sausage & potato soup. Our kids loved the cheesy garlic bread (it was as an 80s baby would want it to be from their childhood) and cheese pizza because they're toddlers. Service was prompt and fast.

    Pepperoni and green olive
    Jill O.

    If you think of delivery pizza in your head, whatever you conjured up is probably a lot like Faye's. The food came to us hot, correct, and pretty quickly, which ultimately is what I'm aiming for when I'm ordering something for delivery. The pizza itself was alright. It has a good crust. I appreciate that they have green olives as a topping since in my neck of the woods, black olives seem to reign supreme. The pizza sauce and cheese were kind of bland though. It tasted fine. I wouldn't write home about it, but I'm not mad that I ordered it. There's other places in town that I like better, but this is a perfectly acceptable "we need pizza and we need it now" type of place.

    Poorly made pizza

    See all

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 months ago

    Very warm and casual atmosphere. Cracker thin pizza which was excellent. 13" enough for a couple.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    It's the best pizza in Sheboygan! Our go to for ordering in, it always arrives hot and on time.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sam B.
    0
    37
    3

    1 year ago

    Great pizza! Our favorite was the BLT! Gets busy after 5 PM. Only ask is please add French fries to the menu for the kiddos.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Rich M.
    29
    18
    0

    1 year ago

    Great pizza, and the sausage potato soup is fantastic.........plus the take and bake is excellent. ...........................

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    Pizza quality has gone down over the past decade or so. Won't order from them anymore.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Delivery driver trying to charge for a pizza that has already been paid for . Pretty shady practice

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jill O.
    106
    593
    4940

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Delivered to blue Harbor resort. Delivery person was very friendly. Food was fantastic. Would definitely recommend this place.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of W B.
    250
    162
    4

    3 years ago

    Ordered cheese / mushroom and was excellent. Recommend if you are looking for simple yet delicious meal!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    The best thin crust pizza around! Fresh, quality ingredients along with a friendly staff makes Faye's a longtime Sheboygan landmark!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Best pizza in Sheboygan! Nothing better for fresh baked thin crust. Always hit the spot.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of L B.
    1
    46
    2

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    My favorite pizza in Sheboygan. Never have a bad experience. Great service. I love the BLT and the House deluxe.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of F S.
    0
    12
    1

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 1 of 3

    Ask the Community - Faye's Pizza

    You might also consider

    Uptown Slice - Pizza available by the slice in house

    Uptown Slice

    4.7(32 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    I've had occasion to try Uptown Slice about five times now. Initially I wasn't so sure as I've…read morenever been a "New York slice" type of guy. However, the fact they do full pies and have stellar reviews meant I had to try them. I wasn't so sure after my first experience as again it's not necessarily the style of pizza I default too. That said it was good enough and very fresh and well prepared. So I gave it a few other tries and I'm now a big fan. For context, I only do cheese or cheese and sausage and will sometimes do extra cheese. Their cheese pie is excellent. I don't think extra cheese is necessary, but I've done it and it's also excellent. The sausage isn't the style that I normally prefer, the sliced sausage, but it too is very good. I tend to go cheese though because even when I ordered "light" sausage it had way too much on the pizza. That seems to be the norm these days though, but for me it overwhelms the rest of the ingredients. I'd rotate between the two, but not sure if I'll get light sausage when I order. Anyway, the pizza is fantastic. Sauce for me is what it makes it, but crest and cheese are spot on as well. I do love garlic bread, specifically cheese garlic bread, and have had both. This has seemingly changed recently, but anytime I've had it it's been good as well. Currently it's more of a traditional garlic bread delivery which is slightly better. They do have two locations which is nice. One is dine-in, but they do accommodate orders if to go if needed. The other is the Uptown Sline Depot which is a to-go location. Both are great and they deliver the same result. The dine-in was packed on a recent Saturday visit and the concept with some craft beers, etc is good. Two things if the owner is listening. Go lighter on the toppings if asked. Second though and more important please expand outside of Sheboygan. You'd kill it in West Bend with little competition which you'd easily best.

    This place is friendly, welcoming and affordable. We grabbed a slice of sausage and a grape soda…read more Tastes like delicious nostalgia.

    Photos
    Uptown Slice - Pizza case

    Pizza case

    Uptown Slice - Gabagool

    Gabagool

    Uptown Slice - Uptown Margherita

    See all

    Uptown Margherita

    Sheboygan Pasty Co. - Sheboygan Pasty - really good and super-filled (bratwurst, potatoes, cheese, onion).

    Sheboygan Pasty Co.

    4.9(8 reviews)
    1.6 mi

    At the Wisconsin State Fair, I got a massive Sheboygan Pasty from their table and it was love at…read morefirst flaky buttery bite! Inside was bratwurst, potato, onion, and cheese with zero empty space. Even after a whole day of fair food, I still made room for it and I'd do the same on my deathbed! NOTES/TIPS: **Super friendly staff **In the Expo Center at the fair

    Pasties in Sheboygan. Awesome! Usually have to drive a few hours north to the Upper Peninsula to…read moreget this Cornish Delicacy. Place is not easy to find. It's actually located in the back of a bar called Four of a Kind. I ordered the Traditional UP Pasty. It was pretty darn good. Crust was light and flakey while the middle was dense and tasty. Just the way I like them. Gravy is an extra buck, but well worth it. I ordered my pasty in the back of the restaurant (behind the pool tables!) through a little window into the kitchen. This area has limited choices for beverages so I went to the bar to order something else separately. Wasn't too impressed with the staff. Kind of felt like I was a stranger coming into a someone's local hangout (which I actually was!!). I just thought I'd get a "thanks" or at least a "have a nice day" as I walked past the employees as I left. Nice thing is that if you are with someone who might not want a pasty, the bar has a pretty nice bar food menu including soups. Pasty was very good, will give them another try and maybe I'll get my "have a nice day" then!

    Photos
    Sheboygan Pasty Co. - Enterance

    Enterance

    Sheboygan Pasty Co. - Traditional UP Pasty w/Gravy

    Traditional UP Pasty w/Gravy

    Sheboygan Pasty Co. - Menu

    See all

    Menu

    Geno Nottolini's Pizza

    Geno Nottolini's Pizza

    1.9(22 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $

    Food was bad, and their delivery guy was racist, when i called and complained they stopped taking…read moreour orders & hung up on our call. 0/10 don't recommend.

    Wanted some New York style pizza and Faye's was closed so we found this place and ordered. We got a…read moreNew York style "basic cheese" pizza, 16", and mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were okay. Kind of oddly sized; one was an inch and another was 3-4 inches. But tasted okay. The marinara sauce was pretty good. The pizza... *sigh* ... someone please get these guys a ticket to NYC to taste the real thing because it seems like they got a description from Google and just made it without a recipe. Hell, just go to Faye's; they have the closest I've seen in Sheboygan. As a New Yorker, it's outrageous. A real New York style pizza is juicy, with very flavorful sauce and lots of it, and gooey, oily cheese all over. It fills your mouth with euthoria and slides down your throat effortlessly. This, on the other hand, was the driest pizza I have ever encountered. I didn't even know it was possible to make pizza dry, but these guys did it! Congratulations! I had to have a cup of olive oil on the side to chase this pizza down just so it wouldn't activate my gag reflex. It was mostly dough, and dry dough at that; very little flavorless sauce, and an adequate amount of cheese. The cheese was not oily, as if it was a store-bought Tombstone pizza or something. OH! But wait! They sprinkled some italian herb seasoning on top! That's gonna make everything better, right? Both the guy on the phone and the delivery driver were nice and courteous. So they've got that going for them, I guess.

    Photos
    Geno Nottolini's Pizza
    Geno Nottolini's Pizza
    Geno Nottolini's Pizza

    See all

    Faye's Pizza - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...