Always a good meal here. First visited in 2022 or 2023 and was so impressed by the cheese board. It was amazing! On a return trip this year (2026), ordered it and was very disappointed. It was downsized to a plate with much less on it and the items included were not at all impressive. We won't be ordering it again. Otherwise, the food & service are good. read more

We had dinner here on a wintry Tuesday night and fell in love with the place. It had a great speakeasy vibe with fun music playing. We sat at the bar and enjoyed socializing with some of the regulars as well as the bartender. For drinks we had an old fashioned and a lemon-tini made with their homemade limoncello which were both very good. We then shared a broke which was a light dough with a dipping sauce of tomatoes, cheese and veggies. Very unique. We also shared the beef Marsala pizza. The beef was very vendor and the crust was light and yummy. During our dinner the owner came by and introduced himself. We had a very fun evening and look forward to joining them at one of their wine dinners. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Beef Marsala pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Nice indoor patio with great view of the lake. The ambiance is on point with the prohibition era theme. Service was prompt and attentive. However, the wood fired pizza left a lot to be desired. The peso and bread were delicious. But the pizza crust was very soggy. The Marsala beef pizza was a bit bland despite the sauce and mushrooms. Same with the margarita pizza, soggy crust. The only pizza that's decent was the lemon one with arugula topping. Likely because there's no tomato sauce. I've been to Italy and had authentic Napoleon style pizza. This didn't measure to it. Maybe the pasta and calzones are better but the pizzas are not the best. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Lemon pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

This was a home run 5/5 for everything. Sat in the sunroom patio for a little evening sunlight. Temp was still warm even though it was cold out. Our waitress provided more than quick friendly service, she had her own personality and engaged in conversations with us. The food was AMAZING. Love the wood fired bread/pizza crust. The sauce for the mussels had a delicious garlic lemony butter that I soaked up with the bread. Everything had so much flavor and I cannot wait to return! read more

See all

Outstanding pizza! Authentic Naples style with a great tasting crust. Excellent assortment of spirits, wine and beers. Pleasant ambiance along the river. Friendly and attentive staff. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Decor - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

A real high point on my trip. Respectable crowd considering it's pre-season. Fully intended to go for a salad type meal, but when the bartender (apologies for forgetting his name, he was very good) described the pizza special I chose that. Pro: Best pizza I've had, and I'm 70 years old! Con: Being a special, you'll never know when they'll have it again. Hint...custom sausage, made for them and a leek sauce they make up just for this pie. However, since the crust was also one of the best, I imagine any pizza would be great. Super location, great friendly service, reasonable prices. A real win. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Pier side view of the Bistro. - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Atmosphere was nice and the food was brought out pretty quickly. Will be back to try the pizza next time! read more

Prohibition Bistro - Bistro bolognese - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

See all

Favorite spot for dinner in Sheboygan! As casual or as nice as you want your night to be. Food is always stellar and the staff is so kind. 100% a must go and come back! read more

See all

A great spot! Pros: -Strong pour -Yummy wood fired pizza -Cute ambiance -Went here for our anniversary and got limoncello shots in celebration -Mezza luna pizza is a fun 4 part plate for 1 price. You get a sorta mini calzone in 1/4 of the pizza since it's folded over. In the space where folded over section was you get a mini arugula and greens salad with a vinaigrette dressing. The last two slices are a classic margarita pizza! -Tiramisu is super sweet creme that halves the bitterness of the coffee creating a delicious dessert -Service was fast and we were promptly seated Cons: -The prosciutto pizza crust was slightly fired too long and all the bubbles were burnt. Ordered: -Pomegranatini -Rootbeer (bottled real sugar stuff) -Mezza luna pizza -Prosciutto pizza -Tiramisu read more

Nice place along the water. Decent food. Mediocre service and not kid friendly. We asked about options for kids and they said they don't have a kids menu but could make them buttered noodles. I didn't think I'd have to ask how much but when the check came they charged us $21 per dish... for noodles and butter. Wow. Also our server was great until she abandoned us for the last 20 minutes of the meal and then never apologized. Not a great experience. read more

We were here a few months ago and the food was excellent. This time it was extremely disappointing. Everything was way too salty and the pizza was so badly burned we couldn't eat it. Unfortunately, we will not be back. read more

Went out for a family dinner and had their margarita pizza, which was delicious. Service was great and the staff were very attentive to our table. The venue was well decorated and prohibition era themed. Will definitely be going back! read more

Prohibition Bistro - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

We stopped in Sheboygan for a few hours and had dinner here! It was so relaxing to sit outside and enjoy the weather and view, but the inside of the restaurant looked really nice and fun too! Our food was very good...we ordered the Focaccia Fritta to start and then the Spicy Chipotle pasta and the Spicy Beef Sausage pizza. The service was a little slow though and it seemed like we had a lot of different servers come up to us and ask the same questions. Overall, it was a great experience! read more

See all

I have been here about 20 times. My favorite thing are the patio, mussels in the white wine sauce, and that they have a good wine menu. The rest of the food menu is salads (served on pizza crust), pizza, or pastas. I wish they had more entries like a salmon dish, for example, or more innovative salads. I love the balsamic pasta but it's very rich. I like coming in the winter but in the summer time the food is quite heavy. Many portions are large enough to share! The patio on the river is really nice and has great views. Everyone has always been friendly. If there is a long wait for tables you can usually find a spot at the bar. My only other negative is that the interior near the front (near the bar) is cluttered with boxes of wine and other supplies. I will continue to be a loyal customer but perhaps mix in some seasonal menu options!! read more

The food was delicious. We had great service. It was our anniversary. They gave us a free glass of wine and a free dessert. We sat in the heated four season room and it was very comfortable. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

Great place to wind down after a long day. The staff are great, food is great! If you are in the area, you should stop in for some great pizza!! read more

Enjoyed the pesto bread appetizer, Chicken Gnocchi and Creamy Pesto. The appetizer was delicious, freshly baked bread with tasty pesto dip that my wife and I shared. Main courses were excellent. The creamy pesto was full of flavor, yummy creamy pesto covered noodles with plenty of tangy sun dried tomatoes. The chicken Gnocchi was even better. Grilled chicken and prosciutto with asparagus, sun dried tomatoes and Gnocchi in a creamy sauce. Service was excellent the hostess and the wait staff were friendly and very attentive. Lovely dining room and bar located river side. read more

When to Prohibition again this week. Some of the things I like were off the menu, but I have to say they were replaced by even better dinners. I understand they may change some appetizers and I now think that's great. You may miss some oldest but you are definitely going to find some new goodies. They have their own drink menu1 of the drinks is Gin and Cherry compote. This drink is very good and refreshing. They are mainly an Italian Restaurant and wine bar but they sell beer and cocktails also. I think this is an Italian restaurant that everyone should try it if your from Milwaukee or Chicago. I'm telling you, you won't be disappointed. The owner is young and has a great palate. read more

Best place that I went to on my visit to Sheboygan. Pizza was great and the area is beautiful.

Welp! I wish I was writing a review under better circumstances, my family and I decided to come here as they are from out of town and we wanted to treat them for dinner. Our overall wait time was exactly 1 hours 15m since our group was larger they had to wait for a table that could accommodate us which they ended up putting us on the patio in a pretty uncomfortable corner with 5 different round tables set close to eachother( not the most ideal situation for wanting to talk) our service was slow, food was practically cold by the time it got to our table and an entire order was missed. Very dissatisfied read more

This place has a great atmosphere and really good food. Definitely going back there again. read more

I traveled across the US to Wisconsin and was looking forward to eating here. I'm a combat veteran who has a service dog for PTSD and the owner would not allow me to bring him on the OUTSIDE patio area. This was on the 4th of July no less. The owner was very rude (short man complex) and condescending. There will be a ADA lawsuit forth coming. read more

The food here is excellent, wood fired pizza is so good with all kinds of options! Building is a cool location along the river.

Great food, drinks and atmosphere. We had their salads and veggie pizza and it was awesome. Would definitely recommend to others. Great waiting staff that check with you frequently. read more

Delicious pizza, kind workers, fast service! Still thinking about this pizza 2 days later! read more

Prohibition Bistro - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Nice food options and atmosphere. I liked that they had both a covered and uncovered outdoor dining options. We opted for indoors because it was rainy and everything was great. The waitress was especially friendly and attentive to us. We dined with 3 small kids and they were very accommodating. They didn't have an official kids menu, but it seems like they are ready for kids with different simple food options (plain pizza, spaghetti, etc) so it didn't feel like we had to ask them to do something special for us. We got one of their pizza specials and it was great. Had prosciutto and arugula and just a really fantastic crispy, puffy crust. I would absolutely eat here again if I were in the area. There are also some nice spaces to walk along their pier and a beach on the other side like 10 min walk away. There is a nice ice cream parlor nearby as well so you can make a full night of it. read more

My girlfriend and I didn't even know this place existed until we walked past it on our way to South Pier Parlor. We decided to come back and give it a go, and we're definitely glad we did. The interior is really cute and is, as expected, prohibition themed. The waitstaff are in hats and suspenders, the lights are dimmed. It's a cool looking place. We opted to sit outside, so that we had a view of the river. Our waiter was really nice and made sure we knew all the specials, and checked on us often. The owner, Harry I presume, also came around and talked to all the tables, which I thought was a pretty cool touch. He's a nice guy and seemed to really care that our food was good and that we were comfortable. He ended up lowering our shade for us because we looked too much in the sun, which made us laugh a bit. We started off with two Stella Cidres ($4.50) and the Pomodoro appetizer, which appears to no longer be on their menu but was I believe about $8. It was bread, mozzarella, tomatoes, and oil and balsamic, and it was delicious. It was also a bigger portion than we had anticipated. Then came our entrees. I ordered a lemon pizza ($11) which comes with smoked mozzarella cheese, lemon, arugula, parmesan cheese and fresh basil. My girlfriend ordered the Chicken and Gnocchi ($18) which is (according to the menu) grilled chicken and potato gnocchi, onion and garlic sautéed in white wine reduction and fresh cream with sun-dried tomato butter topped with prosciutto crisp. My pizza was pretty good. The crust was thin but still soft, which I appreciated. The flavor was nice. The smokey cheese went well with the bitter lemon. My one issue is that I thought the arugula would be on the pizza like a normal topping. Instead it came in a weird, salad-like pile on top. I ended up just moving the pile off to the side to get my pizza. It was good, but I'd order a different pizza next time. My girlfriend's chicken and gnocchi however was fantastic. The chicken was well-cooked and juicy. The gnocchi were cooked perfectly. The sauce it was in was absolutely delicious, creamy but not to heavy and full of flavor. Admittedly, I kept shoving my pizza crusts in her bowl to dip them in the sauce, it was that good. I'd order that again and again. For dessert, we decided to split one so we didn't feel guilty about going to South Pier later. We opted for the vanilla Panna Cotta ($4) French style, that is, with the burnt sugar layer on top like you'd find on a creme brulee. It was really good. It was the right consistency and texture, it had a nice creamy flavor, and I mean, who doesn't love that moment when you get to tap your spoon against the sugar? We're sad we waited so long to come here, but we'll definitely be back. There's a great, relaxed atmosphere, friendly workers, and good food, all with a view of the river. read more

See all

We had a wonderful dinner tonight at Harry's Prohibition Bistro! Great pizza, a calzone and two wonderful salads, and a double expresso. Our waitress was very kind and gave us great food advice, we will be back! read more

The best darn wood-fired pizza around! The service was cordial, attentive, and fast.

We enjoyed a fabulous dinner here this evening! The atmosphere, the food and service is always great! Tonight I enjoyed the mussels & shrimp linguine! Delish!!! I'll definitely be ordering this entree again. We also enjoyed the Prohibition Salad! It was also spectacular! read more

Prohibition Bistro - Love their pizza salad! - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Great atmosphere, apps, salads, pizzas, and drinks. Manages to be both date and kid friendly without an odd atmosphere. Notable whisky and wine list. Everyone loved their food. We had a boardwalk salad with chicken, truffle pizza, mesa Luna, and a four cheese. All were excellent. The lemon cello is the best I've had in Wisconsin. read more

Prohibition Bistro - Truffle pizza and a moon man - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

If you do not visit the Prohibition Bistro when you are in the Sheboygan area you have missed one of the best restaurants EVAH!!!! The food was superb! My friend ordered the Chipotle Pasta with shrimp and I ordered the shrimp linguine. So yummy!!! I have dined in wonderful restaurants all over the world. This matches any of them. The service was superior, the view was wonderful and the food, well, so good! Treat yourself! Visit the Prohibition Bistro! read more

Prohibition Bistro - a group of people sitting at outdoor tables - Pizza Near Me - Sheboygan, Wisconsin

Love this place we go here every time we're in Sheboygan. The outdoor seating is awesome, but the pizza is even better! And the wine list is top notch. Can't wait to be in area again to go back. One of my all time favorite places in Wisconsin read more

Awesome menu! Get the cast iron mussels, so delicious! We eat here often and always enjoy whatever we order

Been here a few times and every time food was delicious and plentiful. Definitely recommend their mussels in their white wine garlic broth. So delicious. Love the ambiance and servers were great. Every now and then, the owner will stop by and chat with his customers. Very friendly place. Love the location as well. Highly recommend and will definitely come back. read more

See all

Excellent lemon pizza. Burrata is ok. Bread is very good. I will definitely be back.

Visited for the first time last week on a Monday night. I noticed that the signs on the door about not being a family friendly restaurant for families of 6 or more have been taken down. I was surprised by what a big deal people made of this. I think I understand why the signs were there, since I've dined out a few times and was annoyed by screaming or crying children or those just misbehaving or playing at the dinner table. They're kids. They can be kids at a kid-friendly restaurant. Now I just won't go to those restaurants anymore. If I wanted that distraction during dinner, I would go to Chuck E Cheese's. Not all kids behave in public. Not all parents can control their kids. The business owner has to think of his/her larger customer base and the type of experience he/she wants the guests to have. Not all restaurants have to be kid-friendly. Get over it. Go back to the nicer restaurant when you have a sitter. (End of soap box) Anyway, I was seated on the patio, which is heated and next to the river. My server, KJ, arrived soon after and provided excellent service. Harry, the owner, came out and checked on me and we chatted for a bit. I felt very welcome. I ordered a Hot Sopressata pizza with sausage added, and it was amazing! The sopressata was actually spicy, as I hoped it would be, and the flavors were perfect, but the crust is what I was most impressed by. It was slightly crisp, yet perfectly soft where it needed to be. I get why this is one of only 4 certified Neapolitan pizzerias in Wisconsin. The Nutella pizza topped with roasted marshmallows was also amazing. I ended up taking most of that home, since I was satisfied from my entrée pizza. I wish I lived closer because I want to go back again very son and explore more of the menu. Il Ritrovo is the better known certified Neapolitan pizzeria, but I definitely recommend you dine at Harry's, as well. If you have kids, make sure they behave or those signs might go back up. read more

See all

The food is solid but two major complaints, especially as it relates to families eating here: 1. Two kids meal options; noodles and marinara and pizza. 2. The above are $14 each for KIDS! The complaint isn't the limited kids meal options, but 1) the noodles are about 4oz or less. So little that the server asked if we would like some more. We said "yes thanks that would be nice. We appreciate it." The bill comes and we were charged for 2 orders = $28 for less than an adult size pasta dish (which range from $20-$23). After bringing up that the offer for a little more pasta was appreciated but that we weren't expecting to pay another $14, they ONLY charged us $10 more. The crazy thing though is $14 for a kids meal in general. We're from Chicago and I don't know one place in Chicago that charged this much for a kids dish. Usually kids meals are $6-8 at most and include a milk or soda and sometimes fruit or a side. Good option for couples/adults. Terrible option in terms of value for a family with kids under 10. read more

We came in on a whim on a busy Friday night. As we were waiting for a table the owner stopped by and shared with us how he was making black walnut infused vodka. He gave us a sample of some that he did with English Walnuts- it was sooo good. Very welcoming and kind. We got seated right away. The pizza was amazing. We ordered spaghetti for this kids / that was some of the best sauce I've ever had. Great service and awesome food. read more

We agree with the other reviews about GREAT food, ambiance!! We also agree with those who are dismayed about the anti-mask environment. This is Not Acceptable! Until this changes, we will not be dining here. So Sad. Really thought the owner(s) were more Responsible. read more