The pizza is good but a little pricy. A personal pizza runs $10+. Pretty good atmosphere but what gives it two stars is the owner/head-chef. Simply put the guy is a jerk. The ice-machine was not working. When my wife and I made him aware he looked at us like we had two heads and mumbled. Then he mopes around the place like it has a stench. Look, I am sure that the owner thinks he is hot stuff because maybe he went to the Cordon Blue institute and was a head-chef in Minneapolis but these are not reasons to be a jerk. And it is a pizza place. We will not be going back because of his attitude. And if you think I am being unfair, look at my other reviews. Never have I given a bad review because of jerk staff. read more

Probably the worst woodfire pizza in Twin Cities. 1. 90 seconds to cook pizza.... 10 mn you wait and watch them make it. 2. No ambiance. No music. Nothing. 3. Overcooked pizza. To the point of nasty. Pizza tasted aweful. Not burned... but way overcooked. First time I did not take home or eat our food. 4. Rude workers who care more about themselves then customers. 5. Mixing Buffalo Mozz with cheap shred.... WTF 6. Operational management needs to be checked here. A lot of wait... unnecessary wait. 7. Was blamed that I asked for the special yesterday that was posted on the sign. My fault they did not change the sign.... whatever. 8. Lots of touching of ingredients with bare hands and handling of food when unnecessary. This must be a healthcode violation. Management: goto punch line service pizza and see how they do it.... cause your no punch. Comparing this pizza to: Pizza Nea, Element, Punch, Lola, Brick. read more

If, like me, you prefer your pizza NOT overloaded with goopy toppings, Quickfire's offerings are a welcome change from most of the other pizzas available in Stillwater. The line-up-and-order routine at Quickfire would be fine if it wasn't crowded, but I went in to buy five pizzas to carry out, and I would have hated to be in line behind me (and the party behind me that ordered four.) It's nice that they have the wood-fired oven. Actual cooking time was pretty quick. A good woodfire pizza should have a bit of charring on the edges, but my pizzas were all on the burned side. Quickfire's pizzas are not on par with real Neapolitan pizzas like those at Brick's, Pizza Nea, or Punch. I wouldn't make a special trip to Quickfire, but if I am in the mood for pizza in Stillwater I will go again. read more

Glad we gave this place another shot, the experience and food was 100% better then our last visit a few years ago.

Great concept, I love pizza and when it's cooked in a wood fire oven it's usually hard to beat. I ordered the goat cheese, arugula and prosciutto pizza (how good does that sound!) and was really excited to try it. Visually the pizza was awesome, and the fact that they shaved the prosciutto fresh for each pizza was a nice tough. However the pizza was really bland, which is shocking with those ingredients. The arugula was put on the pizza before it was cooked, which made it a little soggy and sapped the flavor from it, the sauce was bland and the crust was a bit tough and under seasoned, a little salt would go a long way. One person in our group had the buffalo chicken pizza and loved it, so my advice would be to order a more traditional pizza and it might be pretty solid, however the sauce and crust being bland is tough to compensate for. read more

Great pizza! Fresh ingredients, served hot! My only wish is that the people prepping the pizza would use gloves while handling the food. Other than that, 4 stars! read more

Stopped here last Saturday. Line was short, pizzas were made and cooked fast. Tried the Mac & Cheese pizza with smoked bacon and a create you own sausage and cheese. Was not sure on the Mac & Cheese the kids wanted until I tried it. It was excellent, the sausage and cheese was good too. Both pizzas perfectly cooked. I really liked this place, only wish they had a larger option than just the 10" pizzas, otherwise great place. read more

I got a pizza to go. It was a take on the margherita, with basil and feta. The sauce is strange. Too sweet? The basil came out looking charred because they cooked it with the entire pizza. The crust was good.... the middle was soggy. I'll stick with Punch whose pizzas are also larger. Pretty disappointing. read more

Don't assume the food will be quick because the name is Quickfire Pizza. We waited over 45 minutes for 3 pizzas. When they finally arrived, the crust was bland, soggy and there was almost no cheese. The one good thing we got out of the experience is an ongoing joke - we always laugh about how ironic it was. We will never be going back. There are plenty of better, cheaper and faster pizza places around. I highly recommend Punch over Quickfire. read more

Excellent Pizza & Service! We visited this place for the first time late on a Monday night when they were just about to close. They treated us amazing and did not rush us out of there or anything, which we really appreciated. I had the cuban pizza and it was AMAZING. My husband had the ordinary average guy pizza which was very good as well. Can't wait to go back and try the Cajun although it will be hard not to order the cuban again, as it was delicious. Would definitely recommend this place for a unique pizza experience. read more

Our first try of Quickfire Pizza last night when the young grandkids stopped in and picked Quickfire for takeout. The 4 and 5 year olds lobbied hard for "Mac and Cheese" pizza. I made he call and the pies were ready as promised. I found out later that Quickfire only needs a few minutes to have a pizza ready, they live up to their name. Hot and tasty, sadly no left overs for today. We will be back. A welcome addition to historic Stillwater. read more

The place is amazing! The most difficult decision is picking just one pizza!! Great service. Good price... I usually get one pizza for there and then get another one to go... I have zero shame. The place is great!!! read more

This was our first visit to the QuickFire Pizza. We were a little apprehensive as the place was empty when we stopped. My wife and the boys (11 yoa) tried the Mediterranean pizza and a build your own combination with Pineapple, Canadian Bacon and a few other toppings. We also tried the Antipasto... What was left over, the boys finished off the next day, Service was excellent. Menu has something for everyone if you like pizza. We like to experiment! Excellent value, great food! We will definitely go back! read more

We love the pizza here! We used to live in Stillwater but now drive from White Bear to get their Pizza. I love the OAG. Amazing!

The pizza looked good and they had gluten free options but they service was so slow to even get acknowledged that we left. Understaffed.

Food and menu are really good. The pizzas are smaller than most other wood fires restaurant pizzas so we under ordered for our group a bit. The flavors and options were good though. They could use a bit more sauce so if you like sauce I would recommend asking for extra when you order. read more

Best Pizza! I love swinging into QuickFire Pizza when I'm working in town. Pizza is ready to go in minutes and still hot when I get back down to the marina to eat it. Hawaiian is my jam! -Marine Clean read more

My wife, newborn and I ate at QuickFire on the second weekend they were open. Usually this is when businesses are still finding their flavor. This was NOT the case at all. We wanted something quick, and the restaurant looked very appealing from outside. Very clean and moderm design, and the logo and specials caught our eyes. Watching them cook in the huge quickfire oven was pretty fascinating (kids would love it). We walked in and even with 3 people in line before us, were helped really fast. I ordered their gourmet Macaroni and Cheese, and my wife ordered the Hawaiian Pig Roast. Baby ate formula :) We didn't know what to get, but the staff let us sample different toppings and made suggestions to us. They took their time figuring out what we would enjoy. Anyways, got our pizzas in minutes and they were cooked to perfection. We both REALLY enjoyed our food and think this is both our new "pizza place" and our go-to whenever we are in Stillwater. As for the 1 star review I read, I had a completely different experience...both the first time we visited and the last two times we were there. Maybe you need to revisit...our food was great, and we had nothing but smiles and great customer service from the staff. However, I will agree with you on the ambiance...could definitely use some music in the background :) read more

We love this place. They have great pizzas and are pretty good about substitutions since I mostly don't eat meat. My only negative is the name is a giant misnomer. You will never get your pizza quick here. They cook quick but everything else is slow. If you are looking to have a great slow night out eating this is perfect. read more

I was looking for a pizza place in Stillwater downtown area and I found this pizza place with my girlfriend, worst service, they made us wait for 40 minutes and they are really disorganized about orders. Don't recommend this place at all. read more

I've been here a few times over lunch with my work mates and we all love the food here. Customer service is ok, pizza and apps are excellent! Great topping choices and pizza comes out quick. Restaurant is spacious and clean. Great place to meet up with friends for a quick meal. read more

The only Restaurant I know that bakes your pizza in front of you in a large pizza oven. The pizzas were really good. But I would definitely pick this place for a date or family coming into town to visit. read more

Had the Margherita and my son had the build your own Hawaiian. Both excellent! Courteous service.

We were here on a random Friday and it was pretty quiet! You go up and order at the counter and they make individual pizzas to order. I enjoyed my pizza but would say it was not as good or close to as quick as Punch Pizza or other places with similar concept in the Twin Cities. The toppings were pretty good and the crust was good but in the center of the pizza, the crust was so thin that it was difficult to pick up the slice and it couldn't support the toppings at all, making it a little difficult to eat! Might have ranked it one star higher but the service was very weird while we were there - one of the staff who took our orders was difficult to communicate with and didn't look anyone in the eye and was just strange and gave it a weird vibe. One of our group's pizzas also tore in the middle and therefore had to be remade, meaning she was waiting to eat for quite awhile after we were all served. They do have an okay gluten free option that is cooked in a silver tray so no contamination, which is good! read more

Where do I start, I ate here for lunch one day in february with a few associates from work, It was literally in the upper 50's temperature wise in the dining area, all of the diners were wearing winter jackets while eating. My overpriced pizza was greasy and worse then pizza i make at home. The restrooms were nasty and even colder then the dining area. I will not return. read more

We visited without knowing what to expect and were VERY happy. This is an incredibly positive and helpful atmosphere, where we feel welcome. Not to mention - food and drinks are incredible and a great deal! Live music, dog friendly, and a great atmosphere. Thanks Tap Society for a great night out! D was very helpful! read more

This place is awesome! I went here as one of my stops on the "foodies on foot" tour in Stillwater. The owners came out and talked to us about the story of how they created the restaurant. Their craft beers were good and service was fast. I had the macaroni and cheese pizza and it was fantastic! I like how we were able to pick out our own ingredients and watch they make it right in front of it. They have ingredients being imported from Italy every week. It's impressive. I'd definitely recommend this place. read more

Excellent, tasteful, and unique pizza. Sort of a Subway type deal; pick out toppings for pizza, then moved through a chain to a wood-fire oven. Would recommend for a 20-40 minute meal. Definitely would go back. read more

My family and I came across this little pizza joint in the heart of downtown Stillwater and were quite pleased! The service was phenomenal! With their personal attention to creating each pizza pie, customers truly feel welcomed and their food treated like an individual piece of art. An excellent late night bite! Personal pizzas starting at $7 with .50c add on ingredients or any pre-customized pizza from 10-14 dollars all baked in a wood burning pizza kiln and ready in about six minutes. Although they were busy, workers made sure to keep tables cleared and clean with smiles and thanks as we exited the door. read more

I was so disappointed. I went there at 6 pm today and stood in line for 15 minutes. When I got there to order the employee told me that they were out or sale and pizza dough. I asked why when she saw us standing there she didn't tell and she said well I didn't know how many people wanted. The people ahead of us got last dough and she knew this and let us stand there anyway. We never got a apology, read more

Excellent service. I ordered the mac& cheese pizza with green olives. It was delicious. I am definitely coming back. First great experience

Paul made our pizzas and was very aware of everyone at the place. He was friendly as was the rest of the staff. I've had brick oven arugala and prosciutto before, but the peppers and goat cheese make this a stand out. Get the peppadew poppers to start off with. We stop ever time we are in Stillwater. read more

The pizza was exemplary and the workers were very friendly, definitely coming back! I suggest this restaurant to anyone looking for a good pizza place in downtown Stillwater, MN read more

I went in with my kids when we were craving a pizza. My kids got the mac n cheese pizza, it was a little on the spicy side. The Margherita was pretty good. Staff was very helpful, I love that you can pick your own toppings, the pizzas were really quick. I would love a little more atmosphere in the restaurant for those wanting to dine in though. Nice change for Stillwater, I hope they do well read more

Fantastic Neapolitan spin off. We originally came here with a groupon and were back within a week for more. While I wouldn't go as far as saying it tastes as authentic as punch. It's very good and the pizzas are slightly more substantial. I like that it's more unique and a trip to Stillwater is always worth it for their Main Street. We've also had their s'more and Nutella desserts. Skip the Nutella one. It tastes like a Burger King cinna mini. The s'more treat is delicious though. Worth getting two if you have a sweet tooth. read more

Staff somewhat friendly, pizzas are good due to quality ingredients. Forgot my andouille sausage on my pizza, and when I told the older gent (assuming manager or owner) I received a grumbled "sorry". Then he walked off. Good food, poor service, high price. read more

This is now my favorite pizza in the the twin cities! It is a simple place. You tell them what to make, and pay, then they deliver the personal-sized pizza to you in just a few minutes. It's fast and delicious! As others have mentioned, you don't go here for the ambiance. But it is not a cheap plastic fast food restaurant either. There are a couple nice window tables that allow you to watch the downtown Stillwater traffic. I go with the cajun sauce, which is a mixture of their regular red sauce plus a spicey nice buffalo sauce. It's an awesome combination! I also like pepperoni, kalamata olives and prosciutto, which they slice up fresh, but there are lots of other ingredients from which to choose. The crust is just-barely-done, just the way I like it. They have a small but nice selection of beers on tap too. I was there on a Sunday afternoon and 16oz beers were $2. read more

I love this place, great pizza, had great flavor and you can make your own!!!! It is only 10" pizza but price and flavor, you can't beat it

We tried the Thai Chicken and Ordinary Guy pizzas. The crust is crispy outside and chewy inside. They are so flavorful and have fresh ingredients. We would come back again! read more

Very good personal pizza. Pizza is made fresh with fresh ingredients in front of you; like a Subway sandwich. They use woodfired oven adding nice flavor. Modern atmosphere inside. Very clean. Flatscreen monitors used for the menu options. It's not a gourmet place. However it's nice place to go for a light lunch or dinner. Also note that the dough is very fresh and hand tossed. The crust is not baked in a shroud of fat like Pizza Hut. I wish we had quick fire in our town. read more