So far I've had my inspection done here, an oil change and just had my brake pads and rotors replaced. They have always done honest, good work and at super competitive prices. I might add they are all really friendly and always smiling which goes a long way. Very happy to have moved to West Orange and found Derrick and his crew. read more

My hubs swears by Prospect Exxon for his every car needs. The professional maintenance service is so unassuming at this small gas station but they're legit. Tip: Ask for Derrick, the owner, he'll evaluate your vehicle, explain the situation, and repair the problem at cheaper than dealer rates. Honest repair shops are hard to come by, so based on my husband and all of his friends coming here, I'd say it's a safe bet. read more

These guys are the best, hands down. Took my car here to get my brakes checked, they gave me an estimate quickly (after testing them and a visual exam) and from my understanding was very fair & honest. Derrick was very kind to explain why I needed to replace certain parts, and actually took the time to show me how the parts in question work. Interacted with both Derrick and Dave. Both are seriously knowledgeable, honest, great guys! I've only been there on a Saturday/end of the day. I'd suggest dropping off your car if it needs to be worked on, as they do seem to very busy. read more

This is the best garage I have ever been too. I brought my Porsche here for 2nd opinion after another shop told me I had to buy a new catalytic converter for $3,100. Derrick found the problem was actually caused when my battery died and caused the sensors to act up. He also worked on my Indian motorcycle and found a small wiring problem that caused my battery to keep dying. I will be bringing all my vehicles here for service. read more

Prospect Auto - Auto Repair Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

George (who we had gone to for almost 20 years) sold Exxon, and the new staff is great. In the 2.5 minutes it took to meet the new owner Derrick, they fixed my front right-turn signal and brake light for $20. read more

Moved to the area and was worried about finding a reputable and trust worthy mechanic since my old one is over 30 minutes away. The sign of a good shop is when they honestly tell you what you NEED and what you might consider. I brought the truck in for rotors and the guy called with an estimate and explained that front rotors in addition to the back ones were warped. He said as long as i didn't mind the sound, it wasn't necessary to change yet since the brakes still had some meat. I know other shops that would have pushed for the extra work. I don't know a damn thing about cars so a honest mechanic is a gem to find. The prices were also very reasonable compared to other shops i have used. read more

Just got back from Prospect Exxon and had a very positive experience. Clean shop, very polite and responsive staff. I came in thinking I needed to replace my front brake pads, since I had the old ones for 30k miles. They got my car up within minutes, checked out the front brakes, and said that I still have 60-70% left in them, so no need to change them. Then they checked the rear brakes, took calipers off, made sure everything is fine. They did a thorough inspection of the car to make sure there are no other issues. Throughout this time, the mechanic was walking me through everything he was doing and explaining how things worked. Awesome guy! He spent easily 30-45min on the car and charged me for maybe 30 min of labor. More than fair. Will definitely come back! read more

Thanks to all your Yelp reviews and recommendations from a local group on Facebook, I went here for an oil change and to replace a headlight and brake light months ago to judge the shop for myself. Quick, considerate and honest about my inquiries for other services I was told I needed by my dealer. Just from simple dialogue and an observation of the men working the shop, I knew I had finally found a reliable place to take my car! I don't know anything about cars apart from what my dad still advises... but I'm married now and stay home with 2 babies. I need quick, affordable and reliable, for sure. Having lived in NJ for 7 years now, this is the first time I've found these qualities in an auto shop. I just got another oil change today and had to bring my 5 month old with me. Though I was worried about possible fumes, I walked-in first thing in the morning and asked if they could accommodate me. I was out in 30 minutes. Thank you. Thank you. THANK YOU. Quick and reliable! Such a relief. I look forward to bringing my car again for future services... hopefully, at the oil change level and nothing more serious! read more

Great shop with genuine mechanics. They fixed up my 4 runner and got me ready for my long road trip to Colorado. Thank you Guys! It's still doing great. Definitely a trust worthy honest mechanic shop. Five stars!! I would go back to them every time I have a problem. Even if it's out of my way. read more

I challenge you to find a more honest and skilled mechanic then Derek and his guys! They are super friendly, the job is always done right and so is the price. The first time I came to Exxon on prospect was many years ago. I was pricing out a timing belt on my Toyota Highlander (which is a difficult timing belt to change). The first place wanted $1200. The second $800. Prospect Exxon did it for $600. Always a pleasant experience. Comfortable waiting room. Wonderful staff. It's hard to find a good mechanic. If you go to Prospect Exxon, you'll find one. Not only good,... the BEST! read more

Derrick and his team are freaking awesome! Brought my car here for a Hail Mary second opinion after another shop told me that the knock I was hearing was internal, and that I would need a rebuild, or new engine. They said the car wasn't worth the cost of fixing, and that I should simply sell it for whatever I could get at that point. This first garage I took it to was not trying to rip me off, they simply mis-diagnosed in a very big way. Took it to Derrick and literally, within the first minute, or two, after looking under the hood, pointed into the engine compartment and told me the noise I was hearing was coming from the pulley wheel, NOT the motor! I was so thrilled, and relieved to hear the engine wasn't the problem that I gave the guy a hug! Told him, "That's it, you're my mechanic!". I couldn't be happier, and so glad I took the chance. Thanks Derrick! : ) read more

I took my truck here for brake fluid leak. Derek gave the car a very through inspection and worked with me to fix what was most important while respecting my desire to not sink a lot of money into a very old car. They were very through and I felt what I was charged was very reasonable. They don't have the lowest prices but they are fair. This is the best mechanic I've found in the area. read more

I found a referral to Prospect Exxon on West Orange 411. I will definitely be back. I had an oil change and they saw s problem with my tire. I will definitely go back because they are trustworthy and didn't try to push any additional services on me. read more

incredible service! im so grateful to the mechanics here. I was on vacation and my car was parked in long term parking and wouldnt start when I got back. Derrick was able to diagnose the problem over the phone and had my car up and running in a few days read more

Would absolutely recommend this place. Derrick and his crew have expert knowledge and are very professional. I would recommend calling ahead to make an appointment as this shop is extremely busy (very popular!). This place is more a great all-around mechanic shop that happens to sell Exxon gas vs the other way around. read more

The best shop around by far! Very honest and they do great work. Had my brakes done and Derrick & team couldn't have done a better job.

I went for a second time to get brakes on GMC and the gentleman was super super nice. I got the car a couple hours later Although the service part was closed but I was able to pay and retrieve the car. The price was right and I will be back for different issues that I want to get done in my car. read more

Derek is the best! Took a pre-purchase inspection at the last minute, and did an amazing job walking me through the car and possible pitfalls. 100% honest mechanic who I highly recommend!! Great all around guy who - thanks for showing me that great chassis you had in the shop! read more

Derrick is genuinely the best mechanic probably on the east coast. He's knowledgeable and has experience with all types of vehicles and motorcycles. If he doesn't know something, he we research and find out. He's honest and operates his business with integrity. Vehicle problems are stressful enough, but rest assured Derrick and his team makes it painless and will find the source of the problem. I've recommended all my personal friends and coworkers to him without hesitation. read more

Prospect Exxon fixed the bearing and was very honest about the other issues! Excellent job!

I shopped out my repairs to a few shops in town but Derrick was the most responsive of everyone. He asked me questions up front and asked me to bring my car in for a look. I have a 2012 Honda Civic which needed a new drive belt tensioner and shocks and struts. One of his mechanics took the car for a drive and Derrick himself took a look. He had me in the shop to show me exactly what he was seeing and gave me a quote that was super reasonable and affordable. I made an appointment on the sport and brought the car in a few days later. I dropped it off overnight and came back after they closed to pick it up. It was super convenient since I do work far away and couldn't make it during their working hours. My car drives like new and it didn't hurt the bank. I will definitely be bringing my car to Derrick and his team for all my car needs! read more

Saved me around 700 bucks vs if I had listened to my local Pep Boys about my oil pan. Pep Boys recommended I replace my whole oil pan and estimated price to be over 700 dollars for parts and labor. Had Derrick check it out, and he fixed my oil plug for less than a tenth of cost of what Pep Boys quoted. I am going here for all my oil changes and car needs despite the extra drive. A trustworthy and professional mechanic is hard to come by and Derrick and his crew are as good as it gets read more

I will never get my oil changes at another spot. These guys are fantastic, fast, personable, and know how to treat my car.

Great professional service. Derrick really knows what he's doing and will definitely get your car fixed for you quickly.

I called this shop based soley on Yelp reviews. My 2005 Chrysler 300C's check engine lite was on and giving off (P3400) engine codes. I was told by AutoZone that code indicated either a bad PCM ($300-$450 in parts) or $45 VVT Valve. I then did reasearch on the subject and was hit with figures from $200-$1k :-( (https://www.yourmechanic.com/article/p3400-obd-ii-trouble-code-cylinder-deactivation-system-bank-1-by-jamahl-walker). I spoke with Derrick and he said I should bring it in and he would look it over for FREE so long as he did not have to spend more than 15 mins to identify the problem. This place is the REAL DEAL! There were customers there from Staten Island that were repeat customers! I had VERY low oil pressure, which I had checked just days prior and it seemed fine. Net Net: I needed an oil change with the "PROPER" OIL viscosity as specified by the manufacturer. $40 later, engine lite was off and I was back on the road!!!! This shop could have easily parted me from my wallet and told me anything! I immediately left and returned the same day with a 2nd car that I use as a back up to get around town. I was given estimates as low as $1.8k-$2.5k at a previous shop to repair my 23yr old Camry that keeps shutiing off even while hwy driving. These guys called me back the same day and said a sensor costing $35 was bad! That part plus labor was $120. I told them to keep going thu it and call me once the invoice hit $500. I'm back on the road after changing temp sensor, new battery and battery cable, all for $300!!!!! read more

It's very hard to find an HONEST mechanic.....i first went here after being impressed with the reviews online, and I have to say they were 100% CORRECT. These guys are true mechanics, which unfortunately many shops don't have these days. They were able to diagnose a problem that TWO different shops were unable to figure out, and they speak to you in a way that you can understand what's wrong with your car. I've been here several times since the first and have been very happy every time ! I wish I knew about this place years ago, I would have saved myself a lot of headaches from going to crappy shops !! read more

Wasn't the biggest fan of this place in years past, but since the new owner Derrick took it over it's really gone uphill. The service is always quick and at a great price. Derrick's great - really keeps you in the loop with the status of your car/what he's doing/etc. HIGHLY recommended read more

Hands down one of the best auto service shops I've been to. Being that I'm REALLY picky on who works on my G8, I come all the way from Queens to get my car serviced here. Derrick and his team really know how to precisely diagnose, troubleshoot, and service your automobile. His attitude and his patience in explaining what is wrong and what needs to be done is quite reassuring in this age when customer service seems to be lacking in most consumer establishment these days. Another plus, he is definitely going to be cheaper than going to the dealership!! read more

Prospect Auto - Auto Repair Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I've had some not-so-great experiences with mechanics in the past, so I'm always a bit nervous taking my car in. I needed to get a problem with my car checked out and after a recommendation from a friend and reading the reviews on Yelp, I decided to take it to Prospect Exxon. Derrick gave me a detailed estimate with all of my options (my car is almost a decade old, so I wasn't eager to spend an exorbitant amount of money) and even made sure to include how much extra it would cost if they had to add freon, as well. The cost was definitely more affordable than I expected and now my car is working as it should be. This is the first experience I've had where I feel like I can really trust a mechanic! I will definitely come back here if I ever need work done on my car and I highly recommend them! read more

Go here for all car related issues and they are always resolved! Great staff and great service.

Derrick is exceptional - not only at actually working on cars, but at relating to his customers and explaining the work that needs to be done. He is quick, efficient, thorough, reasonable, and kind. Derrick is a fantastic mechanic, a very fair business owner and an absolute pleasure to deal with. I will never take my car anywhere else ever again! read more

Reached out to Derrick about a broken mirror the night it occurred, he responded immediately, told me to bring the car in the next morning, and ordered the part right then and there. It came in later on the same day and my mirror was replaced less than 24 hours after it came off! Great service, will definitely come back for any future car troubles and highly recommend to others seeking service. read more

Derrick and his team are awesome, i found my new place to get my car fixed. They were honest, and felt like I wasn't being had. Great overall experience and I thought the pricing was fair and best of all my car is running very well. A no brainer here, I will return, especially for oil changes!! read more

Truly the most honest and trustworthy mechanics I have encountered to date. Very considerate and thorough, they took time past their closing hours to examine the cause of a broken headlight. Once problem was diagnosed, work was scheduled and completed promptly and at a reasonable price. Very glad I found these guys. read more

We were pleasantly surprised when Prospect Exxon helped us under difficult circumstances last week. Our rental vehicle got a flat tire and we were on a tight schedule. They ordered the tire and mounted it the next day, and the price was surprisingly reasonable. There's a reason they have great ratings on Yelp et al. read more

I had busted my Rim on a pot hole. Derrick took care of me with out any prior notice. He did so very quickly and professionally. The very next day, as I was returning to pick up my tire. (i left ot there so i didnt have to wait) I busted my Rim on the donut spare. I got towed to his shop and I did not give any prior notice to Derrick (which I should have). He again took care of me on which seemed like a very busy day. Derrick and his team are caring professionals who are very efficient. I would recommend him and his team to anybody who is looking for great and honest service. I will be returning for all my mechanical needs read more

HONEST. It's extremely difficult to find an honest mechanic. I moved a few years ago and I've been looking hard for an honest local mechanic. I've tried a lot of different places and I've literally (I mean literally) caught each one of them cutting corners. The problem is it's too hard for normal people to verify the work has to be done or even done. I mean have you ever checked to see if your brakes really needed to be replaced? I've even gotten my car back with the same dirty oil! Recently, I found Prospect Exxon and these guys are the real deal. GREAT PRICES. I compared their prices by going through my old invoices. Prospect's prices seem pretty good. (Actually, I think they should raise their prices a little bit. I know this comment might hurt me but I like to tell it like it is.) One thing that they might change is perhaps their oil change prices. I only checked for synthetic but Prospect had one of the higher oil change prices, even more than some dealers. They use Mobil1 which is much more expensive but I think it makes them appear expensive when they really aren't. QUALITY. They really seem to care about their work. They will go out of the way to do really make sure you're happy. I was really surprised by some things that they did like drive my car around to check up for some noises that I said there were. One small thing impressed me. Prospect saw that my tire valve caps were missing and put on new green ones without asking. These guys appear to be nice and honest people. (I hope I'm never proven wrong...) read more

Great service and more than fair prices. I definitely recommend the Prospect Exxon crew!

New favorite mechanic! So glad I found Derrick and his staff. Derrick (owner) is very honest and fairly priced. Nowadays it is very hard to find an honest mechanic that won't try to rip you off. His staff is also great. Will definitely you be coming back! Wonderful find! read more

I have never written a Yelp review before, but based on the outstanding experience with Derrick and the team at Prospect Exxon, I feel compelled to do so. I had a major problem with mice infestation in our car. I took it to our local dealership no less than 3 times -- in the span of 1 week. Each time they claimed it was repaired and charged me. Each time I picked it up, the same problem occurred. The first visit cost me about $350. By the third time, they were quoting me $2800. Not having any faith in them (and after meeting the very young "technician"), I told them not to touch my car and I decided to bring it to Derrick -- based largely on the reviews here. What a great experience! Within a few days, the team worked out all the issues at a cost of about $450 (mind you, the dealership was $2800). The car performed perfectly. In addition, when picking up the car, we had to park another car there temporarily. We returned after the garage had closed (which we were aware about) to pick up our car. To our very unexpected and pleasant surprise, there was a note on the dashboard saying "we noticed the air in your left front tire was low so we fixed it". No charge. I can't recall when we received such service. We will be going back to Derrick for all our automobile needs in the future! Thanks Prospect Exxon!! read more