I always love primos and never have a problem, but today I ordered a roast beef diablo sandwich primo size. When picking it up I noticed on the screen it said pork diablo. I triple checked and asked why it said pork and was told it was the same thing and she just rung it up that way. I even asked again before leaving that it was roast beef because I do not eat pork. When I got home to eat it I had to throw it away because it was a pork diablo. If someone does not know the difference between the meats they should not be working there. read more

I want to start off by saying how very much I do love Primo Hoagies and how I have never been disappointed no matter the location until today. Today I was in the store in Sicklerville and I was appalled at what I saw. I am not a picky person by any means or a complainer, however, when I'm paying $10 for a hoagie I expect not just good service, but all around satisfaction, including not being grossed out (for lack of a better term) when going to pick up my sandwiches I crave. Today, for the first time ever, I go to grab my all time favorite mozzarella balls (which they were out of) and I see dead bugs in the refrigerator where they are kept. I immediately was turned off, but still paid for and left with my sandwiches that I did not eat due to lack of appetite. I do love my primos but I must say I was completely disappointed in this experience. read more

PrimoHoagies - Sandwiches Near Me - Sicklerville, New Jersey

See all

First Primo hoagies used to be the absolute best hoagie around. Not anymore. They are way over priced 9.49 for a small hoagie and the roll is just falling apart. I asked for pickles and peppers and didnt get any! There are way to many places around that have better quality for me to go back. read more

Visited the Sicklerville Primos location! As always, had a great experience! Sandwich was delicious and the staff was engaging and friendly! Store looked great! Keep up the Awesome Work Sicklerville Team! Look forward to coming back soon. read more

They expanded and now have comfy seating. Staff that was there before like Bridget are awesome. They have improved on the prep time for sandwiches which is nice. Good place to stop by and hang while getting awesome sandwiches. Over all an improvement from before. 5 stars now. read more

They need to pay attention to those that special order. My boyfriend is a picky eater and wanted a chicken parm hoagie dry with sauce on the side. The hoagie was drenched in sauce and the cup they gave on the side literally had a splash of sauce in it. The girl that took the order even read it back to me and they still got it wrong. I ordered a knuckle sandwich and there were hardly any roasted red peppers on my hoagie. read more

My husband and I really like this location, the staff is really friendly, the restaurant is super clean and the hoagies are always fresh and delicious. We got a surprise on our last visit, we were told that we won phillies tickets and they were for that night. They were 9th row and it included free parking! I'm assuming it was one of the mangers that gave it to us, he said that they were going to be giving eagles tickets away too! Anyplace that has awesome food and gives away tickets to our favorite teams is top notch in my book. read more

Hoagies are very good but expensive and it would be nice if they wiped down the tables from time to time..most of the tables have lots of crumbs...they recently extended their operating hours..big screen tv showing sports is nice read more

I decide to try this place today near my house in Woolwich Township New Jersey. I knew I made a mistake when they got my order wrong, Tuna don't sound like turkey). When they finally prepared my Tuna Sub I was happy until I took a bite. it's was dry, and just plain nasty . It tasted horrible. I will never ever step foot in one of their stores again. The tuna smell was just to strong. Hum, no zero star? read more

First time at the new location and Hoagies came out quick! Staff is very friendly and polite! Hoagies are delicious and it's very nice to be able to sit down and relax and eat! read more

Ordered hot sandwiches for lunch at 12:30. When I places order, it stated that the food would arrive between 1:20-1:30. Called Primos at about 1:55 to see where my food was at. Food showed up at 2:10 & cold. Super disappointed. read more

Just got a cheesesteak, came home opened it up didn't expect to eat more than half but the whole damn thing is gone. It was absolutely delicious. Probably one of the best cheesesteaks I've ever had the meat was tender no drizzle fried onions were cooked nice cheese and with an excellent roll. read more

There's no point in putting a pick up time if you still have to wait over 30 mins more on top of your 'pick up' time. Horrible service. Called curbside pick up and employee said they're working on it. Called 30 mins after sitting in the car waiting and employee said they're still 'working on it.' read more

Yes I agree the prices are tooooo high The subs are very good but not really worth the price At least their not like jersey mikes no meat and total rip off prices read more

Love the new location, a few doors down from their old spot. Much bigger unit with a very nicely done decor. This place has a much larger dining area. Upon arrival, all I could notice out front was a parking lot littered with cigarette butts and Primo order receipts. As I peer over to the gym next door, their lot is clean and free of such debris. The main register area looks very nice and the girl behind the cob tee was very polite. I ordered, paid and took a seat In the dining area. About 10 min later a young gentleman brings out my order. Very polite. As I'm eating, I begin to look around. 6 employees behind the counter just carrying on with conversation, one answering orders and one making them. The other 4 seem to be more interested in talking about their events from the prior evening. Not a huge deal, except, the floors in and around the tables in the dining area look as if the Cookie Monster went on a serious binge, all the tables were in desperate need of a wipe down, Napkin holders covered in dust as well as the window sills and trash receptacles. For such a nice and newly done location, this place is pretty dirty. Not really sure what the food pre area looks like but I'd hope they are paying a little more attention to that area since they seem to habitate there. The sandwich was made nicely but the roll was much more crusty than usual. One side was just a touch softer than a bagel chip. This leads me to believe they're not rotating their bread out of the brown paper they come in, after the rolls crust up a little. Or, they've over ordered and are freezing their rolls. Nice place but it appears they need may have a management issue. I recommend the Primo size Pork Diablo, fully loaded. Delicious. read more

Only complaint, why have staff wear masks if they are not going to wear them properly while making my order?

Ordered 2 Italian hoagies online. Our orders were made quick and correct. The bread was so fresh and delicious and I could tell that the meats were high quality. This is definitely our go-to hoagie place. read more

Done ordering from this location. Three sandwich's ordered today and the roll on two of them were so stale that they crumbled when you tried to bite into them. Ordered extra onions on one and hardly found any on it. Last time we ordered got home and found only meat and cheese on the sandwich. I did not know you had to specify to add onion lettuce and tomatoes when you order a hoagie. They my have gone into a larger location but not improved the service. read more

I love this location. The staff doesn't make mistakes on the sandwiches like other locations. The hours are also great and convenient.

I work at the Turnersville Auto mall and my department just had our $150+ Saturday lunch delivered. The food came on time, but they forgot the oil & mayo. My supervisor called to let them know what was missing and to have it delivered and the woman who she got on the phone was very nasty. She kept cutting my supervisor off, said they had call outs so "what do you want me to do about it...." My supervisor asked for a manager and the woman, who said her name was Bridget, claimed she was the manager. I dont understand how anyone so rude, with such poor customer service skills could be a manager. Even if she isn't the manager, she clearly doesn't need to be answering phones and dealing with the public. All we wanted was mayo and oil (which was ore ordered the day before) for a sandwich order. I dont think its asking too much to have condiments for a $150± order. With this place being so close to our job, a lot of us stop here on lunch or after work. Never again. read more

I ordered an Italian hoagie on Mother's Day for Mother's Day lunch for my mother in law who never had primos. After driving a half hour to pick it up, got home and realized the hoagie was not an Italian at all. It was a veggie hoagie?!? My mother in law is highly allergic to eggplant, so I called to ask if I could be refunded, being though it was almost time for our dinner plans. The lady that answered the phone ( maybe lacy, the phone had terrible reception) was so rude. She stated she could not help in refunding without the manger approval. And that my husband would have to drive another 1/2 hour to pick up a soggy Italian hoagie that was sitting there from over an hour ago. Needless to say I will never order from here AGAIN, the chicken cutlet hoagie that we did order was soggy and we had this hoagie before from another primos, it never looked or tasted like this one today- we know how this should taste/look. So disappointed!!! Overall I will never order from this Primo location ever again!! Save yourself the 25.00 per sandwich and go to verrichios deli Same size, better taste, excellent customer service for a fraction of the cost. read more

Ive Been going to Sicklerville Primos for a few years now. Love the new store and the bigger seating area. Any time I visit the store, it is neat & clean! The staff is always friendly and the Food is always Top Notch! My favorite in the Bada Boom! I highly recommend this Primos location! Go Check It Out! read more

The first time I went there was 7/12/18. We ordered a cheese steak, turkey sub and a tuna sub. The cheese steak was good. The turkey sub was okay and the tuna sub was not good. The tuna came out of the can and was place on the roll with lettuce,tomatoes and onions. We were given a mayonnaise packet to put on the sandwich. On a scale from 1 the lowest to 10 the highest score. The steak was a 8, the turkey sub was a 5 and the tuna was a 0 score. read more

I wanted to take the time to commend the manager, Al, and staff at our local Primos in Sicklerville, NJ. We ordered 2 finger sandwich trays from Shoprite for a birthday party. When my husband arrived for pick up, they did not have the order. Being frequent customers, he ran across the street to Primos to see if they could put together some hoagies for us for the party. The manager began cutting rolls before my husband even finished talking! They even offered to deliver them so my husband could come help at the party and not have to come back. They had 10 DELICIOUS sandwiches delivered to us within 20 minutes, just in time to be put out for our guests. I can not commend the manager and staff enough for their professionalism, understanding and urgency. THEY SAVED THE DAY! We obviously realize our mistake, and will be using Primos for future catering needs! I can not thank Sicklerville Primos enough. Thank you! read more

In the times of the COVID 19 outbreak, we thought it would be a good idea to order out tonight and support our local businesses who might be hurting. So, we called ahead, was told it would be 20 minutes, and I arrived 25 minutes after placing my order. I was disappointed to hear we could not give payment over the phone, so we could just run in and out. I would have ordered online, but we had a coupon. So, even though I did not want to have to spend any extra time inside, keeping social distancing in mind, I went in to pay and pick up my food. I was surprise to find a busy lobby and continued to try and keep socially distant to others, taking about 10 minutes to pay. And then to my surprise, another 15 minutes waiting for my order. So, from my phone call, it took 50 minutes. I should have left and sat in my car, and informed them to call me when the order was ready, but I truly kept thinking, I must be getting my order any minute. No information relayed as to what the hold up was or even that there would be a longer wait. 4 people making the hoagies. I have no idea what the problem was. While the food here is great, I think the restaurant needs to have an accurate pick up time, and if for some reason this delays, communicate with your customer and give them the option of sitting in their car. You can call their cell when ready. I wanted to support my local business, but I was very upset with the situation. PAY ATTENTION PRIMO...... and change your practices!!!! read more

The customer service here is awful. I have let it go since the food is so good. There's been many times I have waited and waited and have been ignored. Meanwhile others walk in behind me and are greeted so kindly and helped quickly. Yesterday was the last straw. It was my birthday so I had received a coupon for buy a primo size sandwich and get one free. My husband tried to use the coupon and was treated as if he was trying to get over on the owner since their computer screen showed a different birthday date. He also was ignored when he walked in as others behind him were treated as a customer should be. Instead my husband had to be questioned over a coupon and made to feel as if he was some kind of coupon criminal. The owner tried telling my husband my birthday was June 29th my husband said no it's today but the coupon does say it's only good for 7 days could that have something to do with it? The owner would not let it go and said he had to make sure it was corrected so that I didn't receive another coupon. My husband said he wasn't worried about the coupon he just wanted to get out of there. The owner would not let it go and kept trying to figure out the "problem" instead of just letting my husband place his order and be on his way. His whole demeanor was nasty. Talk about terrible customer service. We won't be back. read more

Terrible service! Messed up our order and when contacted told us to come back up to replace the sandwich, but did not offer any compensation. Even argued with us about it. Do not go here! Go to the Hammonton location! read more