I thought the pizza was very good. I also had a cheesesteak with extra meat and extra cheese. It was huge, the size of 2 sandwiches and tasted as good as it looked. The staff was friendly, overall a good experience. I would go back again. read more

This is our go-to spot for wings. I love the customer service, and the garlic Parmesan wings are amazing. Ask for them extra crispy--they'll happily oblige! read more

I was told that the food was exceptional. I wound up ordering from there and when I walked in I noticed that people were not using gloves and they were touching people's food. I ordered a calzone from them it had so much ricotta in it that it was mushy. When I called in to let him know about my order a female put me on hold and never picked back up. I was on the phone for almost 10 minutes before I hung up. I would never order there again especially not knowing your people are watching their hands properly and handling food product. read more

Best buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had! Been here a few times but the first time I went with my son and one employee gave him a lollipop. Another time they thanked me for the support. Seemingly there are humble people working here who make some killer Pizza. You have a fan for life! read more

Great service. Great pizza. Friendly people. This is our go-to for Cheesesteak pizza and we're very willing to drive 20 minutes for it. read more

Pine Hill Pizza And Grill - Cheesesteak Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine Hill, New Jersey

See all

I stopped in one day to meet a friend and had 2 slices of great pizza. That weekend I ordered a large pie that I picked up. It was almost black on the bottom and inedible and wound up in the trash. I stopped in a few days later and ordered a slice and explain to the owner of my bad experience having to throw a pizza away because it was over cooked. He explained that sometimes the oven gets too hot and the pizza gets too dark on the bottom. He didn't offer to comp me the slice I ordered or replace the pie or even apologize for my bad experience. I will never go back there again! I can't afford to throw a $16 pizza in the trash! read more

Finally talked my wife into getting a pizza from here and as I told her. It's so damn good. Perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and plenty of pepperoni. They don't scrimp. read more

Best Italian hoagie I've had in years of living in New Jersey. Hot peppers are excellent read more

Pine Hill Pizza And Grill - Italian hoagie with hot peppers. Best Italian hoagie I have had in years Best in New Jersey for me. Yeah, I said it. - Pizza Near Me - Pine Hill, New Jersey

We don't get panzarotti in Florida and have been crazing them for months. We were back in NJ for a family funeral and ordered takeout while we worked on a few things. All four of us ordered panzarotti ($4.99) and I was bad and got two. It seemed like minutes when they arrived​, piping hot, crispy not greasy and gooey delicious on the inside. You can't beat an Original Tarantini! Pine Hill Pizza is absolutely our go-to when we are back visiting! read more

Best ceasars steak sandwich on the planet!!!!! Rhe mushrooms are tasty but you have to get the meat lovers pizza!!!!!

I have gone here several times but never thought to submit a review before. I have to say Pine Hil Pizza and Grill is one of the best in South Jersey in my opinion. The salads are plentiful, love the pizza, the cheesesteaks are very good, the fried mushrooms are perfect, and the absolute best french fries. Better than McDonalds in my opinion. The staff is friendly, and the hours are perfect - check them out you won't be disappointed. read more

Just moved back to the area after being away for 20+ years. I used to order when they were in another location. I was craving a cheese steak and I was not let down. Love this place. Staff was friendly and when I arrived my food was hot and ready to go. read more

Was across the street from a dance competition being held at the high school across the street. Food was good, standard pizzeria fare. We ordered a cheeseburger, cheese fries, and chicken tenders with fries. Staff was friendly and helpful. Drunk fellow came in with his lady and child. It was awkward, but they got him served and on his way. Definitely a good local business to support. read more

The pizza is addicting! It is SO good! The garlic knots are a little to oily unfortunately so a little stomach ache after eating those, but the pizza is EPIC! I'll never be able to do a complete diet with them right around the corner from me lol it's always so good so tasty so delicious and so fresh! I wish the garlic knots were made the same!! read more

Food is rather greasy all around but the pizza is a main offender. Wings are never consistent and are either drenched in their mediocre sauce or so dry you have to use your own. Also, I once got to listen to someone in the back rip out a delivery driver for forgetting to take something to a customer's house and he was pissed that "your mistake cost me money"... I understand reprimanding and training but this went on for minutes and was embarrassing to everyone who had to hear it. Super unprofessional and awkward to have to hear some hot-head like that screaming inside a restaurant when he isn't Gordon Ramsay or a 5 year old. Parking is atrocious, always, and despite numerous mentions the owners have done little to zero maintenance on the lot itself. I had to park in front of the store next-door since their delivery driver takes as many spots as he wants and even if he didn't often speeds into the parking lot making me fear for the safety of myself and my child. Speaking of cars they seem to have enough cars along the side of their business for 7 employees despite having a total space that could fit 13 people... tops. I remember going to the pizza place across the street from my high school when I attended there because it was close in proximity. I bet that is why this place is still around at all. If you don't attend any of the schools in Pine Hill you're better off ordering from a better place. They're convenient in a pinch I guess, but I won't be returning as there are just too many places without any of these issues close by. read more

Now this is a hoagie! Filled to the max and delivered in 15 minutes. These guys are the real deal for sandwiches... I'm interested to know if they do a hoagie tray because I will be ordering for Super Bowl! read more

Pine Hill Pizza And Grill - Pizza Near Me - Pine Hill, New Jersey

Great place. Pizza, cheesesteak, half lb burger, garlic knots and hot wings were all awesome. We'll be back on Sunday.

Love this great little pizza shop. I've never had a bad meal. And they have great unique sandwiches. Salads are amazing with everything cut to bit size!!!! Close to home and they are always quick with deliveries!!! read more

Pine Hill Pizza And Grill - Pizza Near Me - Pine Hill, New Jersey

The owner of this establishment has decided to alienate 9.3% of the population by telling them they cannot check their blood glucose levels. This is very insensitive to people living with a chronic illness that they must monitor and control 24 hours a day/ 7 days a week. I wish the owner of this establishment would educate themselves about things before banning them. I will not be visiting here again. I would suggests the same for you until this policy is changed. Thank you. Gary- a type 1 diabetic. read more

The food is great but sometimes the woman taking phone orders is a little slow on the uptake. We recently returned from a tiring road trip and decided to order hoagies. I wanted what they called the "Pine Hill Chicken Steak" which is a chicken cheesesteak with mushrooms added. Although prominently featured on their menu she argued with my wife about its existence. When the order was delivered guess what? I got a regular beef cheese steak. Too tired and hungry to call and complain I ate it. It was excellent. My wife had a tuna hoagie she enjoyed but she thought it had a bit too much mayo. We have ordered pizza in the past and it is very good. read more

I live locally and tried this pizza a few times. In my opinion, it's a glorified Dominoes. White pizza was bland. Sausage was like breakfast sausage. Crust was too chewy. Very disappointing. read more

One of the top 5 pizza's I've ever had! Very nice staff and fair prices! Wish I could take the place and it's people back to Chicago with me. read more

A neighbor suggested we try this place and so glad I did. The cheesesteaks are amazing. Bread is always fresh and it is never soggy when it comes. This is now the only place I'll order take out from. read more

Pizza was great but sad to say I had to spit out the nastiest chicken wings I've ever had but I think it was just a bad night. Great service

Had to try this place after they bought Maria's. Appetizers were iffy, pizza steak was edible and pizza was forgettable.

Great place. Killer food. Fast delivery. Never got a bad meal. They will even customize the menu choices for you. I get a different stromboli every time I go. read more

Great to have a place that's local and taste good. I love supporting my local small businesses. The delivery is always fast even when I have strange requests. Example: I walk in, I order, I pay & then I ask can you guys deliver that. I always get a very pleasant, not a problem. They're great! read more

We've ordered from this pizzeria more times than I could possibly count. It's always our go to pizza place. I've never been disappointed with any of the varieties of food that we have ordered on nights where we just feel like sitting back and relaxing! The location is very convenient as well! read more

I'll keep it simple, if you're looking for delicious finger foods (pizza, burgers, wings, sandwiches) this is the place to order from! The owner is extremely humble and what you want to expect from a local business. Delivery is fast and a reasonable fee of 1$. Looking forward to ordering more :) Thank you Angelo ! -Toy world read more

Wonderful owners and staff! Food is always great, service is excellent. Best cheesesteaks and pizza in Pine Hill!!

I tried this pizza place first time last week! I can't believe I've never been here and I live in the same town. I got a cheese steak hoagie,and I must say it was really good. The French fries are the best I've had around,they're extra crispy,i ate the whole portion and i don't usually do that! I recommend this place. I will be going back to try the wings,I've heard they're good also! read more