Ordered takeout, so service wise they were quick and delivered no problem! (As in 20 minutes or less!) Food was good. Had the gyro with lamb meat, fries were perfect and still piping hot! Never been to the brick and mortar but I'm sure it's fine ambience wise. If you're looking for a quick meal for 1 look no further! read more

Fabios Pizza - Gyros - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

My sister came in and she got the chicken Italiano on focaccia bread. She said you have to try it so I went in and got one and Oh my God and I tried it. It is absolutely fantastic. My husband loves it. My son loves it. My daughter-in-law loved it. It was absolutely fantastic. The best sandwich I've ever had in my life THE BEST EVER!!!! if I could rate this, it would be 1000 stars YUMMMMM O read more

I only ordered from Fabios because my normal place is closed Mondays. Last time i ordered here the food arrived cold. I live 4 blocks away. Gave them another chance tonight and the food arrived cold again. I'm done. I will eat dog crap before i order from these clowns again. And yes I've called. Their response - o sorry. Have a good night. read more

We ordered cheese sticks from FABIOS PIZZA in Atco, NJ. You can see by the photo they gave us cheese sticks with no cheese. I could forgive it if they had just given a new order without charging us again BUT they didn't - they have only 10% off and charged us for a new order. Poor poor customer service at Fabios in Atco, NJ. *** BUYER BEWARE AT FABIOS PIZZA IN ATCO,NJ *** read more

Fabios Pizza - Fabios gives cheese sticks with no friggin cheese in them! - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

The. Willy. Pizza. Best pizza I've had in my life. Whoever is making this pizza... you are an artist. The medium is well large enough to feed at least 3 adults. Ive got delivery twice from here now and both times the delivery worker was friendly and delivered the pie in great condition. Words seriously can not do this pizza justice. I have been showing all my friends and family this pizza and everyone is blown away. Vodka sauce, crispy chicken, ham, fresh mozzarella and basil. Just a 10/10 read more

Fabios Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

Been in the area a few years now. Genuinely enjoy Fabios. Give their quesadillas a try. Counter people are always nice and everything's always on point. read more

I order a lot at fabios great place and good food and the delivery is fast also great place I give it

Stopped in for a quick lunch while working in the area. I ordered the lunch special, 2 plain slices and a fountain soda for $5. No brainer, right? Solid slice of pie. Hot, fresh and tasty. I would definitely stop again. read more

2nd time in a row that we ordered cheese fries that were put under the broiler and burnt such a dark brown that the cheese was impossible to get out of the pan that it was adhered to. Delivery was supposed to be 35-45 minutes when ordered at 4:05 pm, but wasn't delivered until 5pm. Guess that's why, despite the bottom being too dark, the cheese was cold and congealed on the pizza. Burnt cheese fries and cold chicken parm pizza cost over $30. So disappointed. Will never be back. read more

Was visiting family in Jersey today and after hearing about this spot decided to give it a try. Ordered a Sicilian pizza and a buffalo chicken cheesesteak, both were hot and ready when I arrived. The buffalo was very good, but honesty the pizza was just average and lacked any real taste. The people working were super friendly both on the phone and in person. Overall good spot, just wish there was a little more taste in the pizza, maybe some spices in the sauce or something. Would definitely go back again for cheesesteaks. read more

Fabios Pizza - Sicilian pie with half pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

Very disappointed lately. We thought we found our go to pizza place. But another disappointment. Another night pizza was not cooked all the way. In addition to Pizza we ordered cheese fries but when getting them out of the bag the lid was not on properly and they fell to the floor so I called and was told I would have to pay for another. I couldn't believe what I was being told. THEY DID NOT SECURE THE LID AND AM AT FAULT! NEVER AGAIN.. We where good customers ordering frequently and would not complain even when the rolls where not fresh, pizza burnt, or when the order was not correct. Good loyal customers are hard to find. Well Fabio you just lost us and all over a few fries. And if you are reading this skip Fabio's and continue looking. read more

This had been my favorite spot for take out close to 2 years now. But well into the pandemic workers wear masks as chin straps, delivery drivers park out front blocking you in. And if it gets busy chaos and panic take over, the checkout girls stop and do other things while customers are there for pickup . The delivery drivers all sit with masks off and talk. I'm done! read more

My family frequently gets delivery and takeout from here and the food is decent however the customer service is not! I picked up a pizza turnover from here tonight and it was so greasy it leaked all through the box all down my jacket. When I called them the girl wasn't sympathetic at all and said she didn't know what I wanted from them-pepperoni is greasy. I pointed out that it shouldn't be leaking out the box and all over customers just from picking it up and they should have put it in a bag or extra box or something. They basically said they didn't know how to solve my issue as they weren't paying for my clothes or dry cleaning nor did they refund my meal. I wasn't expecting them to replace my $100 jacket but a little sympathy and an apology and a refund or attempt to make amends would have been nice. Especially considering how often we order from them. There are plenty of other decent pizza shops in the area with better service! I'll be giving them my business instead! read more

See all

You ARE NOT going to find better, cheaper, faster food! The girls who work here actually care about the food but often times the customers ordering think they are the only one placing an order. A lot of the bad reviews are people who are mad about one instance of a mistake made by THEM. The woman who tilted her box and got grease on her jacket??? Come on now ... If there is ever a mistake with you order, CALMLY call back and they will fix it right away or give you credit for next time. No one is perfect and mistakes do happen, don't let it be the end of your world. This is a quality pizza place! read more

The amount of cheese they put on there was lovely. Buffalo sauce wasn't too spicy with some good ranch on the side!

Best place ever good food and they put up with me and my friends I give them props with that bc we are loud. Super friendly staff

This is our go to spot Mondays for five dollar cheesesteaks pepperoni pizza delivery burgers are great price is always right delivery is lightning fast .. We have many pizza places to choose from around us that deliver and we always go back to Fabios! Excellentt read more

The web site says 40 min delivery, it took over an hour and a halve and the food is not hot! Nothing like cold cheese and meatballs!!!

This was my go to place for years! Fabio doesn't own anymore, unfortunately. The food is bow hit or miss, mostly miss and even absolutely disgusting. read more

While at my boyfriend's this weekend, we ordered some takeout from here. My bf and his dad were all about getting Buffalo chicken pizza, his mom wanted a white pizza and I wanted a grilled chicken salad. When we picked up the food, the cashier let us use some of the discounts that they offer on their menu ( a $1.00 off a salad, free topping on a pizza, etc) Verdict - My bf and his dad liked their pizza more then gallery's but not as much as Lil' Dom's on Atco Ave( which I'm"m not even sure is open any more ) His mom thought her white pizza was so-so. ( I must mention that we ordered her a personal pizza, and it was gigantic, only a little smaller then their specialty pizza size, easily feeds 2 people. ) My salad was huge. And had everything on it including a chopped up bread stick. My favorite part was the chunks of fresh motzella which was a pleasant surprise. I got the raspberry vinaigrette which was tasty too and automatically comes on the side. Yay. read more

My favorite Italian spot to order from. Pizza is amazing and so are the wings. They also have "mac and cheese bites" which are VERY delicious. I've had multiple of their Italian entrees, all of which were very good. The salads are also very good! Antipasta is especially good here! Occasionally they will send something free if you order a lot. They will take orders and deliver them 10 minutes before closing if you call with zero complaints. Fabio works there everyday and is phenomenal. Always goes out of his way for his customers! I have not had a negative experience with Fabio's yet and my family and I have been ordering from there for over 6 years. read more

This place recently gave us stale rolls for our hoagies. Even if they weren't stale, the roll isn't tasty at all. Unfortunately, this place is going downhill in terms of food quality. They just don't seem to care about delivering good food. Thank you! read more

Best pizza in town! Sandwiches are big and filling. Prices a little high, but food is worth it. I had them cater a Deaf event for me a few months ago, everyone Loved the food!! read more

If you live in south jersey, you know there's a pizza parlor practically on every corner. However, Fabio's stands above the rest! I've never been a Sicilian pizza guy, but the Sicilian pizza at Fabio's is phenomenal! If you are not a Sicilian pizza eater, you will be after you stop by Fabio's. That being said, Fabio's also chefs up a mean regular slice of pie if that's your preference. You can't go wrong with any slice you get here! I also need to applaud their hoagies. Fabio's is also the best hoagie I've eaten recently. The meat they put on their hoagies along with the rolls themselves are fantastic! Stop it with the fake Wawa hoagies and come to Fabio's for a real hoagie with real meat and bread! In addition, the service at Fabio's is fast and friendly. Fabio is a very friendly business owner who cares about the satisfaction of his customers and he is accompanied by an equally friendly staff. Do yourself a favor and get on down to Fabio's for some good service and some good eats! read more

A hole-in-the wall average pizza parlor, Fabios Pizza offers everything you want in place like this pretty well. My friends and I were at next door Atco Breweing Company, which allows outside food, and being able to walk next door, order from here, go back and drink for twenty minutes, then come back to pick-up is the main selling point here. The food is nothing revolutionary but it hits the spot and is relatively inexpensive. Stick to the basics - pizza, wings, hoagies, etc. and you'll walk out of Fabios Pizza very satisfied. read more

Lifeless salad? Not at this place. They're pizza is delicious and I highly recommend the chicken caesar salad or grilled shrimp salad, it also comes with bread. Great service, friendly, and fast. read more

Love their food is amazing and their service has always been fantastic. Love their pizza, is easily my favorite in the area, and their burgers hit the spot perfectly. read more

This place is the best! The girls answering the phone are so sweet ! The food is really good ! I placed an order of wings last week the blue cheese dressing was missing ! I called and they brought it right away! Can't say enough good things about them read more

I love Fabio's Pizza, I think they have the best pizza in the area. Great ingredients, cooked right, and not too greasy. Their strombolis are amazing as well. read more

Went there during 90 degree summer weather. They didn't have the air conditioning on. The waitress said the owners refuse to put it on. Also there were more than 15 (I stopped counting at 15) dead flies on the window sill of just 1 of the windows. We told the waitress, as we were sitting close to the window, and she said she's been trying to get them cleaned up for months but no one will do it. Hmm makes me wonder how clean the kitchen is! This was our 1st and last visit to Fabios Pizza! read more

Fabios Pizza - These are the dead flies on just 1 of the window sills at Fabios Pizza!! The waitress said they have been there for months - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

I order from this place quite a bit and have for many years now. The food is good, the service is friendly and they always get my food to me hot and in less time than they promised. Love the pizza. Good cheese steaks and I'm a big fan of the wings. read more

Everything I have had there is amazing, from the pizza and dinners, to the cannoli and awesome salads. I have tried it all and have found nothing to complain about. read more

Fabios Pizza - a variety of pizzas in a display case - Pizza Near Me - Atco, New Jersey

See all

Let me start by stating I rarely write reviews...nothing ever tips the scale enough for me to put in the effort, until now. To be clear, my review comprises ordering pizza for delivery. From top to bottom, I was extremely satisfied with my experience starting off with the all-business answering of the phone, to prompt, faster than expected delivery, to the quality and taste of pizza. I can honestly say this was one of the best pizzas I've had to date. The next time you want pizza, please close your browser to stop another crappy online pizza delivery that you'll be ok with. Do yourself a favor, call Fabio's and realize there is still a company that cares about its customers and provides quality, delicious food produced by someone who actually gives a crap. Seriously, stop reading this review and order a pizza if you'd like to support a business that actually deserves it. Highly recommend! read more

I am extremely disappointed with this establishment. I ordered delivery and provided my credit card. The card number and expiration was read back to me. Upon delivery they asked for payment at which time we advised we paid by credit card. Fabio advised the driver they did not have a card number, nor did he check to see if a charge was listed for the amt of my order. He basically advised we were not truthful. This was an insult. Payment was expected and luckily I had enough cash on hand. After payment was made we returned to our order and found a portion of the order was inaccurate. I ordered the Chicken Italiano dinner and received the sandwich why by the way was overcooked and not tasty. I contacted Fabio to discuss the issue. He advised me he is training the person who answered and took our order so he would know if we provided a credit card for payment. He did advise if the card was charged he would refund it to me but may no effort to take any further action. He said they put the card # into their system immediately so I asked him to check the details. Interestingly in 30 seconds he was able to advise me that there were no charges for a specific amt although the amt quoted was incorrect. In another 10 seconds he was able to advise there were no charges for my amt. Having a retail background I know it takes longer to print the report than that amt of time and I did not hear it print but could hear everything else happening. Never before have I encountered an owner who made no effort to resolve an issue, apologize for the inconvenience and make every effort to resolve the issue together! Even when I spoke with him there was nothing but excuses. I will be the first to understand honest mistakes and errors but this is over the top. It is clear there is no value in the customer relationship with this owner. I am frustrated to think I have been supporting them for quite some time. I will take all of my business down the street to Gallery. When they made an error they rectified it immediately, apologized and made sure I knew they wanted my business. read more

The worst! They say home of the famous Boardwalk pizza and I say the home of the worst pizza ever. The good reviews have to be written by employees. The sauce on the boardwalk pizza was so acidic it gave us canker sores and the tomato pie tasted like it came from a bowling alley. Given the choice between Fabios or Ellios the choice would be simple. This was probably the worst pizza We've ever had. read more

It's just he best! This is MUST every time I come home to visit South Jersey. read more

I am only 10 yrs old but I have been going to Fabio,s Pizza ever since I was 2 and it was Pizza Town! Pizza is great in fact I just ordered one. I already know it will be great! My whole family loves it! I used to live in a neighborhood that was right next to (when it was called)Pizza Town and I went there everyday until I moved 2 years ago. To this day I still miss it! Fabio's has always been and always will be my Favorite Pizza Place!!! read more

Monday $5.00 cheese steak and soda special. In little writing says take out only!!!! Really I can see why place not busy. I made the mistake of eating in, WOW no AC ceiling fans only. Checked out temp with temp app. 91 degrees read more

Me and my girlfriend eat here often. We come here a couple times a week for lunch. Fabio is always nice and not only to me but every one I see step foot into his establishment. No matter what we oder the food is always tasty and hot. If your last visit was with the old owner when it was pizza town, do yourself a favor and try it now. Much improved! read more

When we moved to Atco we tried all the pizza places in the area. This place is the BEST. The pizza is fantastic, but the pasta dishes are AWESOME. I also had an Italian hoagie. A+ on the hoagie, my hands were not dripping from oil and vinegar. The staff is super nice and after the first call they have all of your info right there when you call back, including delivery notes. read more