Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pretty Sweet Bakery

    4.0 (1 review)
    Closed 10:00 am - 1:00 pm

    Pretty Sweet Bakery Photos

    Business Info

    Recommended Reviews - Pretty Sweet Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    5 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 3
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 119 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cone Zone - Grasshopper Pie with Chocolate Dip

    Cone Zone

    2.6(5 reviews)
    0.7 mi

    Yummy place, just take out, cash only unfortunately. Great flavors and really good serviceread more

    There are businesses that make you think, "I'd come back here just to support these people." Not…read morethis one. As for the ice cream itself, it's Perry's. Same as most everywhere else you'd stop in WNY. Nothing about it was memorable, special, or remotely good enough for me to understand why I'd pay ice-cream-shop prices for something I could pick up on a Tops run. Since many of these ice cream shops are alike, I want them to do something extra to stand out a little. Otherwise, I'd just go to Dairy Queen. Don't get me wrong -- I love supporting locally owned businesses. In fact, I'm usually willing to spend a little more locally when I feel good about where my money is going. I don't feel that way here. The service was sub-par. The ice cream was meh. The sundaes are basically ice cream with a cheap toupee. A very ill-fitting, cheap toupee. Nothing about the product or my overall impression of this business gives me a reason to choose it over the many other locally owned places where I'm genuinely happy to spend my money. So if you're looking for extraordinary ice cream, I can't recommend it. If you're simply looking for adequate ice cream with apathetic, crappy service, you can certainly find it here (and be prepared to bring cash). Personally, I'd save the money and buy a pint at the grocery store. Or if you're looking for a date night where you can really enjoy yourself, I'd do Tinsel, or as another reviewer suggested, The Hojack Ice Cream Shack in Lyndonville.

    Photos
    Cone Zone - Father's Day ice cream for the hubbs. Peanut Butter Reese Pieces Sundae.

    Father's Day ice cream for the hubbs. Peanut Butter Reese Pieces Sundae.

    Cone Zone - Cyclone

    Cyclone

    Cone Zone - Father's Day ice cream for the hubbs. Banana Split.

    See all

    Father's Day ice cream for the hubbs. Banana Split.

    Double Dips - Large Cyclone - Vanilla Custard w/Butterfinger & Cheesecake Pieces: I would've liked a little more vanilla custard

    Double Dips

    3.4(10 reviews)
    10.1 mi
    $

    In little, old Medina, NY, Double Dips is the spot to grab a scoop of Perry's ice cream, custard,…read moreCyclones (think DQ Blizzards!), and other ice cream novelties. The stand is surrounded by several parking spots, which will fill up on a warm evening. The staff working are young and courteous. Double Dips accepts cash and credit cards. I don't make it over to Double Dips often as I live in Buffalo, but when I do, I get a large Cyclone made with vanilla custard, Butterfinger (or Oreo), and cheesecake pieces. The cup is large but the last few times I've ordered this, I've noticed they don't fill the cup all the way, which is a bit of a bummer. Plus, the distribution of mix-ins isn't the most even - Last time all the cheesecake pieces were at the top while all the Butterfinger was at the bottom. Prices are a little higher but in 2026, everything is priced higher and they are THE ice cream spot in Medina. Double Dips posts frequently on Facebook about their weekly special custard and non-dairy custard flavors as well as other ice cream novelty specials. All-in-all, Double Dips remains a solid ice cream stand in small town Medina.

    We were in the area, walking along the Erie Canal and on our way home stumbled across this ice…read morecream shop and had to stop and give it a try. We were glad we did, and I bet you will be too, so top on over! The place is small, visitors wait in line outside, only the workers are inside making the goodness happen. They have a wide variety of options including quite a few Perry's hard ice cream flavors, soft ice cream, sundaes, floats, and blizzards. I chose the Bart Simpson sundae. Soft ice cream, peanut butter sauce, and butterfingers. Yum! I opted for no cool whip, peanuts, or cherry, I'm weird I know, but that's why you don't notice any of those in the pictures. My husband got the key lime custard and was very satisfied. Great place to stop if you're hankering for some ice cream. Stop by and try one of their many treats!

    Photos
    Double Dips - Large Cyclone - Vanilla Custard w/Butterfinger & Cheesecake Pieces: Cheesecake pieces all at the top

    Large Cyclone - Vanilla Custard w/Butterfinger & Cheesecake Pieces: Cheesecake pieces all at the top

    Double Dips - Large Cyclone - Vanilla Custard w/Butterfinger & Cheesecake Pieces: All the Butterfinger was at the bottom

    Large Cyclone - Vanilla Custard w/Butterfinger & Cheesecake Pieces: All the Butterfinger was at the bottom

    Double Dips

    See all

    Oliver's Candies - Oliver's Candies

    Oliver's Candies

    4.5(114 reviews)
    17.1 mi
    $$

    After living in Batavia for a few years, it is always nice to go back and visit some of my favorite…read morespots. Oliver's is at the top of that list. Do you like candy? Do you like ice cream? This is the spot to go. We came in for a quick stop to grab some ice cream on the way home. We also had to pick up some candy too because I mean, we were here, might as well! This place always feels like walking into Wonka's factory. There are so many different kinds of chocolate and candy that there is something for everyone on that front. Then the ice cream parlor is pure nostalgia and there are so many flavors offered. I got a milkshake and it was made perfectly, topped with whipped cream and a chocolate wafer. The staff here is always friendly and helpful. The vibes are so happy in here. I suggest this spot to everyone looking for some sweets.

    I went to Oliver's for some ice cream and had a delicious cup of dairy free ice cream! They had a…read morebunch of flavors to pick from for standard ice cream as well as two dairy free options and the price to serving ratio was incredibly reasonable. The girl working was very sweet and helpful to make sure the ice cream was also gluten free for me. They had a few picnic tables outside to sit at and enjoy. There was a cooler with tons of treats available to purchase and there is also a gift shop located in the lower part of the store. It was a great stop and I'll be back soon!

    Photos
    Oliver's Candies - Oliver's Candies

    Oliver's Candies

    Oliver's Candies
    Oliver's Candies

    See all

    Pretty Sweet Bakery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...