This was our last stop on our self-made tour of six wineries in North East. The service was good, but it is probably the least picturesque place that we visited. They did mention an outdoor space where they have concerts and events at night, and it sounded really pretty. They said they have lights hanging and they build a fire. If we were staying for a couple more days, we would have probably gone the next night to listen to some live music. You choose your own flight here and they have buy 5 get the 6th one free. They serve the flights on a light blue plastic plate, which a wooden paddle like the other wineries would give it a more special touch. I also don't believe they serve food here, just saltine crackers. One of the employees suggested a place we go for dinner which was right down the road, Skunk & Goat Tavern, so I was glad for that. read more

See all

Ordered over $700 worth of supplies in Jan. 2025 and have not received anything. They said they would refund the money but that has not happened. Have sent several emails, made phone calls and they don't call back. Am now pursuing possibility of small claims court. read more

Came here in the ol RV and reserved my spot with harvest host, got a premium spot right next to the band. We got a bottle of the Freeport red and the BLUSÉ, the Freeport red took the cake no doubt. Everyone was very welcoming and we got to walk around the creek and enjoy the fire pits. read more

Cute winery. We came within an hour of close so we only had one flight but overall a good experience. The staff were very nice. I bought two bottles of wine and enjoyed. Overall a nice wine spot. read more

Presque Isle Wine Cellars - Wine flight - Wine Tasting Room Near Me - North East, Pennsylvania

DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE! I am currently out almost $600 from an order back in AUGUST that I cancelled immediately after placing. I have been in contact with their general manager multiple times. I talked to her the other week on the phone, and she never got back to me, and I still haven't been reimbursed. I have literally been stolen from by them. read more

Don't order from this place!!! I have been holding off on a review for almost a year now. That's how long I have been waiting for a $200 refund on a product I paid for and they never provided. To this date I am still waiting. No one returns calls, no one knows how to issue a refund, no one is taking responsibility for stealing my money. Bad business! Bad customer service! I will post this everywhere. read more

Cozy, charming atmosphere and friendly, helpful employees. You can sample 6 wines for $5 When you check in on Yelp they offer free samples to your entire party. They are currently offering your 6th bottle of wine free when you purchase 5 read more

See all

Award winning wines with plenty of options. Newly renovated tasting room. Great service. 2 locations on property. Supply room down at creek. This us a unique winery and a must stop. Cheers! read more

See all

We make the trip here for two purposes -- 1) to get wine supplies for my husband's wine-making hobby and 2) to enjoy wine tasting, of course. Today he purchased juice for making Concord and Reisling. Staff was very helpful and cordial. Then we enjoyed some wine tasting (note that Yelp check-in provided us with one free tasting). Wine tasting is $2 a person for 6 tastings. I prefer tasting the whites; my husband the reds. We did purchase a couple bottles and, all in all, were satisfied enough with our tastings. read more

See all

Great spot we camped at through Harvest Hosts. Nice brook next to the winery. Will probably stay again.

We sampled the wine then enjoyed a glass by the creek and waterfalls. Beautiful view worth the trip! Wine bottles were very reasonably priced read more

Presque Isle Wine Cellars - Waterfalls - Wine Tasting Room Near Me - North East, Pennsylvania

See all

This review is for my experience purchasing winemaking supplies from their online store. I purchased an S02 apparatus which they shipped to me incomplete. They did not warn me ahead of time that multiple items were on backorder. They then avoided returning my phone calls and emails. After two months the situation is still unresolved. They said they would refund those items, but the refund was not at the price as agreed. Absolutely terrible customer service - worst I've encountered. read more

We have done almost every winery on the wine trail and this has got to be our favorite! Rose was so knowledgeable and personable. We really appreciate the amazing service even on a busy Saturday. We ended up purchasing the buy 5, get one free deal which was a plus. They offer wine slushees, chocolate pairings, and great employees! read more

Friendly staff and great wine! Went with my husband and when we first arrived they were extremely busy (to be expected on a Sunday afternoon) but as the crowd thinned a little we were able to talk more to the woman doing the tastings and she was very friendly and easy to talk to. My husband is new to wine but likes dry red and he enjoyed all of his samples, especially the Syrah. He even bought a bottle of the Hot Kisses! It is a Thai pepper ice wine that you just have to try, I've never had anything like it!! I drink sweet wines and my favorites were the Creekside Blush & Concord and a new one called BluSecco which was an amazing blueberry sparkling wine. Definitely a must stop while checking out Erie wineries! They have something for everyone! read more

Tiny tasting room. Like the size of your bedroom. Tasting counter space for 6 people. We visited on Columbus Day weekend. And it was a beautiful weekend. The kind that gets people out and exploring. There were only 2 people working. That's for the tasting room, the front register, and the cafe! And I think the woman waiting tables was also the cook. It's a holiday fall weekend - you really need to plan staffing better. We didn't eat here nor look at the menu but I did over hear the tasting hostess say the menu was very limited because it was just the 2 of them. Wines were good. $2 for 6 tastes and there's a Yelp check in for a free tasting. Again tiny tasting area and by the time we left people were 2 deep. read more

We purchased Presque Isle wines at the store at The Colony during our last trip to Erie... it was good wine! So, this time we decided to go to the winery for some wine tasting. 6 samples for $5 and it was great. The staff was fun and gave us a lot of information about types of wine and offered great suggestions. And, I can't say enough about the Blue Moon slushies that we enjoyed sitting in the breeze, under the trees outside! We'll go back! read more

We stopped here on our way home to Ohio from a fishing trip in New York. While in New York we went on wine tastings to several wineries along the Niagara Trail. Although the New York wines were good, Presque Isle's wines were phenomonal! We are partial to dry red wines and there was a whole list to choose from! Each wine on the list was better than the next. We loved that they had some interesting red wines made from grapes we'd never heard of too (the Marquette is amazing!) The old house that houses the wine tasting room and gift shop is quaint and comfortable. A quiet walk by the waterfall rounded out a romantic Friday afternoon. We didn't sample the food but we intend to return when we have more time. We took home 2 bottles and lots of fun gifts! read more

Presque Isle Wine Cellars - The beautiful waterfalls at Presque Isle Wine Cellars add to the ambience of the vineyards. - Wine Tasting Room Near Me - North East, Pennsylvania

The best wines on our mini-tour of Lake Erie wineries this location is well worth the stop. Our server had the broadest knowledge of wines and wine making of the wineries that we sampled. The tasting room is a bit small but the converted home was old world wood quaint. One tip: the entrance is a bit small and hidden. If you have a GPS use Catholic cemetery rd as a cross street to help you find your turn. read more

This winery has really delicious and unique wines. Love your new blueberries line of wine selection. If your into wine making they have all the supplies and knowledge to help you thru it. Thanks to Doug Moorhead and crew for your wine seminar this past weekend. read more

Really nice business. They have a tasting room and cafe in a cute old house, as well as beer and wine making supplies in another area. The wines were good and were the best tasting deal of the wineries we went to; 6 for $1! The woman who did our tasting was extremely friendly and gave us info on their wines as well as wine-making in Pennsylvania. read more

Most awesome place .. They have their own vineyard and a full line of wines to try ...the owner Doug is one of the nicest people I've ever met ..if you're in the area this place is a MUST... read more

It was winter so we didn't get to see the waterfall but would of been nice. Wine was good attended was very nice and super knowledgable about the wines. We did not try any food but it looked good, there was some samplers of dips that where very taste and I bought one. We bought two bottles on sweet for me and one for my husband. read more

* $1 to taste whatever you want. * great flavors *good service *nice place to stop and also have some of their pizza...very good, and seems just right in between wine tasting! read more

We did a tasting for $2. You get to try 6 wines. Every one we tried was delicious ! We ended up purchasing 3 bottles for $40 . We brought a chilled bottle down by the waterfall and enjoyed a glass on a beautiful fall day. The staff was ok..could have been friendlier and more informative. But all in all I had a great time. read more

My go to store for wine making advice & supplies. Very reasonable pricing & well informed employees. The juice selections are always good. And the wines! read more

Wine Bingo was a hoot! Cannot wait to do it again. Would love to see more events at Presque Isle Winery.

Pink Catawba was good - everything else largely mediocre. 6 tastings for $1 is more than most wineries around the area give you for a buck. We are a young couple and one of two couples there - we were mostly ignored by the girl pouring samples and she acted annoyed when we would ask for a new sample. Sorry for annoying you with my business. We were going to have a small meal here, but chose to leave, as we couldn't stand being ignored any longer. The girl pouring our samples also tried to shoo us out at 4pm when the tasting room didn't close until 5. Not sure what that was about. We wouldn't go back solely based on how we were treated here. We went to Courtyard afterwards and were treated like royalty. read more

The woman helping with the wine tasting was surly and seemed annoyed that she had to explain each wine selection. This was a disappointing experience. Also, they no longer serve food, but have not updated their website accordingly. The wine was average-nothing exceptional. The wine tasting room was tiny and lacking any atmosphere. read more

Spent $70 on tastings and wine and a gift.. The cashier girl would not let us out with a wine glass to sit in their patio outside. They advertise a waterfall that is nowhere near the wine tasting area to enjoy your glass of wine by the waterfall. read more

Decent wine, friendly staff until they found out my girlfriend was from Cleveland and then we got treated like crap.