My birthday was recently and my family got some slices of carrot cake to celebrate. I love when you can buy cake by the slice. Carrot cake is one of my favorites and this was pretty good. I felt like the icing was too strong. Solid cake though read more

Prantl's Bakery - Carrot cake - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I am a sucker for Prantl's Almond Torte. I was extra excited to be able to order the smaller version through DoorDash and have it delivered just in time for my birthday! Yum. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Almond torte - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Came here on a cold Saturday morning because several have recommended this bakery on Walnut Street. Since it's just a small walk-in, we purchased a few goodies and took them to a cafe to enjoy them with some coffee. They have two cases of their delicious looking pastries, one table of discounted items, and a case serving hot items. Open that case and serve yourself the hot mini quiches and empanadas. Started with a mini quiche and a beef empanada. Hubby liked his quiche. I'm not a fan of olives and they were all over my beef empanada. Will not be getting that one again. The kind young lady behind the case helped us order our very first Burnt Almond Torte. It comes in different sizes and we chose the bar as it easily serves two. She even gave us sporks to eat it with. We really loved the Burnt Almond Torte. The inside has a soft, moist vanilla cake layered with a thin layer of icing and enrobed with more icing and topped with the buttery, crunchy almonds. We will be back for more. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Boxed goodies - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

Dirty depressing store. Rude employees. Unpleasant experience. They've also been cited by the health inspectors.

I stopped into Prantl's on a Saturday afternoon for sweets and savories, and I was not disappointed! I ordered a three-cheese quiche, and it was delightful. The crust was buttery and fluffy, and the eggs were perfectly cooked. I also took home a few cookies, and they didn't even last 24 hours. They remind me of the sugar cookies a relative only makes for the holidays, so now I'll be able to get my cookie fix year-round! I was also in and out of Prantl's within minutes, but be prepared to wait if arriving when they first open! But, overall, you will love what Prantl's has to offer. read more

See all

We, recently, moved to the area and decided to try Prantl's today. We ended up with the Burnt Almond Torte Bar, a quiche, and an Empanada. I started with the quiche and enjoyed it; the crust was just average but the egg filing was very good. My wife was not a fan of the empanada so we will not get that again. It was around 10 hours before we tried our Burnt Almond Torte...wow! That dessert is something that I will eat again, and again. The toasted almonds were soooo good! They were crunchy, crispy, and perfect. The Bar Cake had a white cake inside and icing on the outside; it was heavily coated in those almonds. The person who assisted was knowledgeable about the items to a point; she did not eat anything in the bakery so it was by observation. Don't care, that Burnt Almond Torte is the real deal! read more

I came here after hearing about their burnt almond torte and had to try it! I think it was my first time trying this and I really enjoyed the cake! I really liked how the almonds and the custard filling came together. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Finally got around to trying this very famous cake that some call the best in the USA. The burnt almond torte. Tried for a special occasion, the torte and the carrot cake pastry. The burnt almond torte was very good. The best I've ever had? Maybe, but not for sure. The cream is so tasty, the cake itself is soft and surprisingly flavorful with some vanilla, and the almonds are just so so good. So crunchy and sugary. It is really good and well worth the price. I love that they have smaller bars now, which are actually still quite large. However, can't say the same about the carrot cake. It was so tiny and not that flavorful at all. I am surprised they came from the same bakery. read more

See all

I came to this location after finding out the Forbes Ave location is closed permanently. I was warmly greeted and then overwhelmed by all of the selections of pastries. The staff patiently waited for me to peruse all of the cases. I ended up getting about 8 items and only paid about $23! The Jr Pecan rolls were a perfect bite. The almond croissant was delicious as well. I was hoping for some almond paste in the middle but it was still pretty delicious. I will definitely be back next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

I really wanted to like this local bakery.....but everything we tried was just okay. The pastries we tried were a little crumbly and tough and not very buttery (which made me think they are probably not made with real butter and instead a substitute). I'd go here on a pinch if I was craving something sweet but overall I've definitely had better pastries/sweets. read more

We recently celebrated our parents' 50th anniversary and wanted to recreate their original wedding cake. After reaching out to several bakeries, only Prantl's was able to bring this vision to life--and they did an absolutely incredible job. We worked with Shanon, who was wonderful from start to finish. We sent her a 50-year-old photo of the cake, and she and the team perfectly captured every detail. The result was stunning and tasted just as amazing. The delivery was right on time, and the delivery person went above and beyond--carefully arranging the cake and even bringing along an extra to-go box for leftovers. Thank you, Shanon and Prantl's, for helping make this milestone celebration so memorable for our mom and dad. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I was reading that the toasted almost torte is an absolute must when visiting Pittsburgh. Yea. Skip the sandwich with French fries on it. Just get this. Get ten of these Jrs. Stop reading this. Book a flight. Rent a car. Get down here. Do it now. It's that good. That's all I'm going to say about it. #eatpittsburgh #almondtorte read more

See all

I love Prantl's. Everything -- *everything* -- is delicious. The cookies, the cupcakes, the bread, the pepperoni rolls. They'll even heat them up for you if you stop in on your lunch break! But the star of the show is, of course, the iconic Burnt Almond Torte. Luckily, you don't have to shell out $30 and feed 20 people to get a taste of their most loved flavor. It's also available in little bites, cake bars, and cakes -- all of which are smaller and less expensive, perfect for when you're craving a sweet treat. read more

Ordered a 1/4 sheet of the original almond Torte. It was phenomenal! All 16 guests raved about it! I/We highly recommend this almond Torte. It is worth every cent! read more

Absolutely disgusting. I used to like their burnt almond torte, but I can no longer trust them to not have rat droppings in their baked goods. From the Allegheny County Health Department (5/14/2026): Droppings observed in the following areas in the facility: - Next to the dish machine - To the left of the rear exterior door - In the box of rags on the wire shelf near the rear exterior door - On the shelf above the icing station - Under the 3-compartment sink - On the tabletop next to the mixer to the right of the grease trap - Behind the prep tables near the kitchen entrance - Under the rows of coolers - On the trays and on top of the boxes of sprinkles - Behind the rear counter in the customer area to the right of the kitchen entrance - In the wall cubby to the right of the upright cooler in the customer area - Under the small stand across from the upright cooler in the customer area - Around the upright cooler in the customer area - On the shelves behind the display cooler where pastry boxes are being stored - On the pastry boxes in the customer area - Under the bread slicer - In the crumb tray of the bread slicer - Under the register counter - On the paper to-go bags stored under the register counter - To the right of the front door when entering the facility - Behind the hot case counter and the pastry display counter along the right wall - In the employee restroom around the toilet - In the storage area under the stairs off the employee restroom - In the side closet where miscellaneous items are stored in the customer area - On the basement stairs - On the floor at the bottom of the basement stairs REPEAT VIOLATIONS Rub marks observed in the rear corners of the bottom shelves where the pastry boxes are being stored in the customer area. *LOW RISK* One very decomposed rat observed in the basement by the furnace. https://www.alleghenycounty.us/files/assets/county/v/1/government/health/documents/food-safety/food-inspection-reports/2026/prantls-bakery_foodsafety_inspection_report_20260514.pdf read more

When visiting Pittsburgh I always say there are the 3 P's of food destinations and Prantl's in Shadyside is one of them. (Right next door is Pamela's). When visiting my alma mater (Carnegie Mellon) recently, I had to go to Shadyside, site of my old haunting grounds, for breakfast. Much had changed over the years but Prantl's is still a fixture. I was going to a friend's home for dinner and wanted to make sure I brought some of their Famous Burnt Almond Torte. It was a small affair so I bought one piece of the Pastry, one of the raspberry and one of the Custard. Pittsburghers are always happy when someone brings Prantl's over. By the way, I picked up some cookies as well that I flew back with me to California and ate 3 days later and they were amazing. You can order the tortes two days in advance to make sure they don't run out but the lady assured me over the phone that they wouldn't. We had a 40 minute wait for breakfast next door and I made my order in advance and they told me they could hold it for pickup later in the day as it was 80 degrees and humid out. We came back 3 hours later and took the cakes back to our hotel room and into the fridge. Everyone was so friendly, helpful, and accommodating. My host was so excited to get the Burnt Almond Torte for dessert. It was the perfect way to end the evening. read more

Prantl's Bakery - World famous Prantl's - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

I grew up only eating Prantls and if it didn't come from Prantls it was not as good. Thats not my thoughts anymore. I recently drove the 45min to Shadyside for a cake and my family and I were disappointed. I will say it was fresh but the batter amd icing did not have flavor. It was not good amd it was nothing like we all use to love. I also was sticker shocked at a $47 price tag on a round cake for 8-10. I will be moving on next time to another bakery closer to Cranberry. I hear the up and coming Wegmans is a great bakery. read more

We used Prantl's for our wedding cake because the burnt almond torte is my favorite thing on the planet. They worked closely with me on exactly how I wanted it to look and the size, and the details of getting my decorations to them ahead of time. They delivered it to my venue about 40 minutes away and everything went flawlessly. They even advised us that it was a better decision to not get the extra layer to freeze for our anniversary because it doesn't freeze well, and to save the money and get a fresh little cake when the time comes (which is this weekend!) read more

Prantl's Bakery - Our custom 2 layer burnt almond torte wedding cake, delivered and set up by Prantl's at our venue - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Prantl's bakery was just okay. I feel like this bakery gets a lot of hype, so I was excited to try it. I got a broccoli and cheese quiche, which tasted like it had been thawed from the freezer (I swear I bit into a piece of ice). The apricot hamantaschen was lovely though; I had never tried it before but the cookie was perfectly soft and I liked the apricot jam filling. There isn't seating inside and the service was fine. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

My son-in-law's birthday was approaching during our visit in Pittsburgh recently and I wanted to find him a special birthday cake. Not being a native to the area I started my search on Yelp and was determined to seek out a promising bakery in the area.  I eventually settled on Prantl's Bakery, located at 5525 Walnut St, in Pittsburgh's Shadyside area, that's a renowned bakery that's been serving the community since 1970. With a rich history and an inviting atmosphere, that offers a wide range of baked goods, from cakes and pastries to cookies and bread. When I read that the bakery's founder, Henry Prantl, developed their famous Burnt Almond Torte, which has been praised as the "Best Cake in America" from several sources, I knew I had to check it out. This renowned dessert, along with other popular items such as the Chocolate Chip Cookie, Almond Cookies, Raspberry Thumbprints, Apple Strudel, Cinnamon Rolls, Elephant Ears, Peanut Butter Pie, Cheese Danish, Apricot Kolache, and much more, hooked me!  In addition to its sweet treats, they also offer  custom cakes, catering services, and a cafe where you can enjoy a cup of coffee and a pastry. The bakery has a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff that make it the perfect place to relax and indulge, and I did. First, let me say emphatically that their Burnt Almond Torte is indeed one of the best sweet treats I've ever had so the reviews nailed it!!!  So, I ordered the birthday cake at 9am on Saturday and picked it up at noon, easy peasey. While there I loaded up on assortment of sweet treats to share and of course the almond promise :-) The cake was their half and half which was a half white cream and chocolate cake that was gorgeous. Even better the cake was a BIG hit with everyone and I was very pleased with the not-too-sweet delight. Every one of the cookies, tarts, pies, and patties were delightful and all the locals were very impressed.  Bottom line: There's actually parking nearby, which is a big deal around the Burgh, and this beloved Pittsburgh institution with their variety of delicious baked goods and a warm, welcoming atmosphere is sure to satisfy your cravings. Highly recommend!!!!! Hours from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM Their website, https://www.prantlsbakery.com/, provides more information about their menu, online ordering, and catering services. Customers can also follow them on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/PrantlsBakery/ for updates and promotions. read more

See all

I'd only heard about Prantl's from a handful of friends but had never tried them myself. We ordered a red velvet cake online for my wife's birthday. Ordering was simple and efficient, and the day I went to pick it up it was ready at the time I'd chosen. The cake was amazing. Everything inside their store looked and smelled amazing, looking forward to trying more of their baked goods in the near future. read more

Went in asking for a ham and cheese croissant warmed up, and the person at the register said "I guess we could do that" like warming up a croissant is an unusual thing to ask for. Got my warmed-up croissant and started eating it, realized there was one half-slice of ham folded up and what I believe to be no cheese. I am sad to say that this place had poor service and even poorer food. (should've just gone to Starbucks down the street) as someone that loves supporting small businesses!! I also encourage the small businesses to have better customer training and food than the chains. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Ham and cheese croissant - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Stopped after lunch because I wanted a sweet treat. Figured pals is one of the best shots to go to right? I thought so. Though I do have to rave about the chocolate buttercream icing on the thumbprint was fantastic! But the Beetlejuice cupcakes decoration, cute, and festive for the time of year. And the movie as well. But, the cupcake was dense not a problem. But it was bone dry extremely disappointed when you're paying $3.50 a cupcake. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Over priced dry or possibly stale cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

"A picture is worth a thousand words".....soft, pillowy cinnamon buns topped with a sticky, crunchy, caramelized pecan topping. They're simply divine. I seek out good sticky buns, and I guarantee you won't find better ones than those baked at Prantl's. They're wonderfully delicious! read more

Prantl's Bakery - Pecan rolls - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

What a great, old school bakery with a huge variety of baked goods! This bakery is super cute and small, but has tons of products! I wanted to try a homemade sweet treat, and I had a hard time picking what to get! I ended up going with the red velvet whoopie pie and a box of heart sugar cookies for my family. The workers were friendly and helpful! I tried the red velvet whoopie pie and it was super delicious! Love the flavor of the cake and the buttercream icing. However, the top side of the whoopie pie was dry. I did get it in the afternoon, and it felt like it had been sitting out for a bit. Maybe wrapping it in plastic wrap would help keep it more moist! Other than that, I really enjoyed it! If you need cakes, cupcakes, or anything in-between, this is a great bakery to check out! read more

Prantl's Bakery - Red Velvet Whoopie Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

See all

I always love they're Burnt almond torte! Staff is helpful/ friendly! Also have good cupcakes & cookies

August 19th 20251 I ordered a birthday cake for my granddaughter and Summer took my order. I called the bakery on August 27 and was told by Shannon the cake is in the system to be picked up today August 28. My son went to pick my cake up and was told there was no cake on order. Needless to say I was not happy. My son ended up buying a cake from inside the counter. Prantls cannot be trusted to buy anything from and therefore I will never buy from there again. Very poor establishment. Patricia D. read more

well regarded as one of the "best cakes," i was curious to try the burnt almond torte from prantl's bakery. this slice of cake comes at a price - $7.99 for one. but i decided to try due to the raving reviews. maybe too good to be true? the cake slice is a decent size and they gave it to me in a box with plastic utensils. the outside is crispy burnt almonds that are lightly salted with a very sweet cream or icing. the inside is a very light angel food cake. i think there is supposed to be some cream/custard filling in between the two layers but my slice was very scarce. overall, i did like the toasted almond taste. however, the outside layer was far too sweet and then the inside was very simple and dry. it was too sweet so i finished it later that day and the cake part became hard. ultimately i'm glad i tried it but i'd pass on it next time. read more

See all

I got my husband a birthday cake it was delicious and beautiful. Andrea was so kind and helpful beautiful job well done!!!

Someone has commented to the effect that different branches have different recipes (I'm paraphrasing)...unfortunately that's true. Much as I want the (new) Bellevue branch to succeed, after trying them a few times I still think they're skimping somehow. The huge cookie I had last time, with a couple tablespoons on chocolate lard on top was tasteless and the hamantaschen that's so good at the other stores was definitely inferior, as was the lemon loaf. Unfortunately Squirrel Hill doesn't seem to be able to keep staff and they've closed, but the North Side and Shadyside still offer the best pastries...c'mon Bellevue--straighten up ! read more

Horrible almond torte. Used to love these but the last two I purchased were horrible and the almonds tasted so bitter. I think we are done with Prantls just no longer worth the drive or the cost of a horrible cake. Also purchased a scone that was awful. read more

Christmas pastries were put into a too small box so the overpriced goodies were crushed. Besides the prices too high, a handling fee is surreptitiously added to the total and then they also expect a tip!!! What???? read more

I'm not sure why they would close their other locations closer to downtown. This location is a little out of the way but it was a much worth the drive. I bought their burnt almond torte. I wasn't sure on what to expect honestly, but damn. I all I need was our quick bite and I was instantly sold. Its creamy, crispy; and a perfect amount of sweetness all on the outside. I would order this again and again. I don't have any plans on returning to Pittsburgh so I would have to see if they ship these bad boys to Chicago. I'd you're in the area, this is a must. If you're in the downtown area, then the drive here is a must. read more

See all

I originally wrote a review for the Prantl's Bakery in Bellview -- the one that used to be Lincoln Bakery. But, it was originally posted to the Shadyside location. Nonetheless, I'll include it below, since it is the same organization. I still hope that Prantl's can do the right thing by the former customers of Lincoln Bakery. We visited Prantls' (in Bellview - the former Lincoln Bakery) on October 29, after not being there for a while, and were so disappointed. We'd been Lincoln Bakery customers for years and were hopeful when it seemed that Prandtl's wanted to keep the spirit of Lincoln alive. The first thing one noticed - there were none of the signature Lincoln Halloween cakes in the windows that seemed to mark the season in such a warm way. Okay, we still wanted the place to be good. But, once inside, it just felt so different. The place seemed empty with people behind the counter overly eager to please the few customers. We purchased quite a few items - the almond torte, thumbprint cookies, cannoli, doughnuts and a cake. The usual Lincoln items were not there - iced pound cake and Ho-Ho cake. But, again, we wanted to have an open mind. The person who helped us told us that the shelf from which we purchased the cake was a "Lincoln shelf." So, we happily purchased the cake and could not wait to consume that wonderful, Lincoln icing. Instead, what we received was an overly layered cake with the kind of sickly-sweet icing that one might find at Giant Eagle. We were further mislead when it came to two almond doughnuts we purchased - which we were told were croissants. They were ordinary - and not very good doughnuts. Yes, the almond tortes are good. But the thumbprint cookies are stacked with that overly sweet icing. They have this odd station where they fill cannoli on demand, so we tried the "traditional" and "buttercream" filling. These were also disappointing - once again, overly sweet and the shell is not an improvement over Lincoln's. Is it worth going there just for the almond torte? Unfortunately, no. I wish the owners would do better and bring back what was special about Lincoln Bakery - especially the icing - but some of the more popular items as well. The crowd they seem to be targeting can go to Prantl's original location (or Giant Eagle) if they like that sort of thing. read more

I had gone to one of Prantl's other locations and was very disappointed both in service and pastries. I was in the mood for some pastry and decided to give Prantl's another chance by going to another location. I walked in and was greeted immediately and the staff where very friendly and very helpful. The selection was good and everything looked great as well. I ordered 2 almond chocolate croissants. I have to say I was again disappointed in the amount of chocolate actually in the chocolate croissants. I have to say the pastry was fresh and tasted great. My only complaint is that there was virtually no chocolate in the chocolate croissant. I give them 5 stars for service and overall taste of product very fresh. But as with other location no chocolate int he chocolate croissant so i give them 3 stars overall. I would go back to this location and try some other items. I do recommend this location for your bakery needs. read more

See all

Very nice people. Very average baked goods. Skip it and go to Enrico Biscotti on the Strip!

Not my cup of tea. Was looking forward to trying the famous burnt almond cake but it was good in theory, lousy in execution. Too much lard-y tasting frosting. We tried two donuts, as well, but they were nothing special and tasted a little stale. Service was friendly. read more

Everything looked pretty good and I know people that say it's their favorite but the have such steep competition nearby with Gaby et Jules. Their pastries could have been just as good and they were absolutely friendly and gave free samples. I just wish they had more coffee options and the bakery itself didn't feel like an experience. read more

This review only involves bear claws. Nothing else. Not commenting about any other desserts. But boy... talk about wetting the bed. These were by far some of the driest, most unflavored, inferior pastries ever tried. I bought them in the hopes to impress... nope. Failed. Epic failure. These things would have been better as a paper weight. No filling inside. Crumbled up tasteless icing on top. Zero cinnamon accents...Just bad. At least today I grabbed Bartram House for their bear claws and had some tremendous redemption. So disappointed... especially from an institution that has multiple locations now and is expected to be the best! Ughhhh. read more

Ordered a birthday cake for our daughter. $40 which I was ok with. Icing was really good. Cake was stale. My daughter's comment was, that's garbage. What a disappointment. read more

Prantl's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania