Potpie's owned a spot on my list for date nights for years. My wife and I have celebrated special occasions there many times. We went to celebrate for our anniversary this week. This was the first time going as a party of three as we brought our toddler. The food was as good as ever. It's so hard to choose an entree other than the potpie, but I always want to because the entrees other than the potpie sound and look so delicious. We ordered good appetizers: a white bean hummus and salmon cakes. I'd recommend both of those if you have those options on the rotating menu. While they have high chairs and the staff was so patient with our toddler who was mostly well behaved but got a little restless, my wife and I struggled to keep him entertained in the quaint and cozy space. I think next time we're going to look at the takeaway, cook at home potpie dinner option. I didn't know they offered that until this visit. read more

Did you ever read a great book and rediscover it 20 years later, delighted to have the same unparalleled experience? That's how Potpie was for me recently when I came across their to-go menu and gave it a try. Back in the early 2000s, I went to Potpie regularly with work colleagues. Times changed, friends moved ... long story short I hadn't been to the restaurant since '05! I'd described their pot pies to a chef friend as the best ever, so when I was in Westport recently, I stopped in to place a carry-out order. The goat cheese salad (worth the up-charge), two pies, and bread pudding were out of this world. Chef had never been to the restaurant; he was blown away. Dinner was every bit as good as I remembered, and the espresso martini I enjoyed while I waited for my order made me wish I'd made a rez so I could order a second drink. Pure craftsmanship, pride in their offerings, and a delicious food experience: all the things that originally drew me to Potpie are still being served. If you've forgotten this favorite, do yourself a favor and stop back in. read more

I ordered takeout for 1 beef and mushroom pot pie, 1chicken pot pie. The crust and flavor was good. The problem I have was the size and price. The pot pies size was about 5 by 6 inches at $22.00 a piece. Way to expensive for the portion size. Kentucky fried chicken pot pie about $5.00 dollars, a large pot pie at Costco $15. This will be my one and only time purchasing pot pies from this place. read more

If you are ever down in the KC Westport area there is a little spot called Potpie at 904 Westport Rd. It is American comfort food that is delightful. The popular dish is the potpie but they have other things on the menu. I tried the roasted chicken with mashed potatoes and green beans. The waitress was pleasant, knowledgeable and attentive. The crispness of the skin was top notch and the chicken very moist. The place could be a great date night or even a family night. This is a great spot for comfort! If you are ever down in the KC Westport area there is a little spot called Potpie at 904 Westport Rd. It is American comfort food that is delightful. The popular dish is the potpie but they have other things on the menu. I tried the roasted chicken with mashed potatoes and green beans. The waitress was pleasant, knowledgeable and attentive. The crispness of the skin was top notch and the chicken very moist. The place could be a great date night or even a family night. This is a great spot for comfort! read more

See all

Oh. My. Goodness! I had some work friends wanting to go here so the first chilly day we had here we came for lunch. I had never really been a pot pie lover. Thinking of those awful Marie calendar meals. But this is on another level. I did t realize their menu was French inspired or what exactly they offered besides pot pie. I got the chicken and veggie lunch pot pie and it was absolutely perfect. The amazing crust on top was warm and flakey. The chicken inside was perfectly tender and the sauce was seasoned just right. I also got a side of pomme de fin which the waitress described as a fancy tater tot but they were SO much better! The inside of the restaurant is reminiscent of little French cafes with a dark interior and a small bar. The people who worked there were real and pleasant. I will 100% be back for another pot pie would also love to try dinner there. read more

Potpie - Chicken Pot Pie, pomme de fin, tomato sauce - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Okay id like to start by saying the service was excellent. The place is small so id suggest making a reservation. Parking is also very limited so be wary of that. Personally for the price i would not go back. The portion size and the quality just wasn't all the way there. It didn't have enough flavor. The puff pastry was also misleading when you dig in there's not much underneath. read more

See all

One million stars! So amazing... my mom got us reservations for 4 of us last night, They were very accommodating to my young daughter. The Brussels sprouts were to die for... we all got something different so we could try a little bit of everything. Obviously the pot pie is a need. Perfect for a date night. The bench In the front window was so cute. read more

Little to none filling inside the pie, over priced, chicken was overcooked. I could have made a better pot pie. Also the service was terrible, super hot inside even though it was 30 degrees outside. Made reservations but still waited 30 minutes took the server 40 minutes to come see the table. read more

Potpie - Chicken Pot Pie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

I like the pot pie that I ordered it was really good and tasty , we got some appetizers that were really good also. The waitress was very pleasant and friendly. Will I go back ? Probably not, but only because we are 35-40 minutes away. If we were closer than definitely. read more

The food was amazing as always. Ambiance was incredible with the dim lighting and good music. The drinks were so yummy. The wait staff was super attentive and friendly. We ordered the red snapper and matzo ball soup. My mom would make me matzo ball soup when I was growing up. The soup at pot pie did lack the usual other ingredients (chicken, actual chunks of celery and carrot) even though there was very tiny tiny tiny cut up veggies part of the fun is getting to eat them. But I will say it had flavor.. my mom's does not. So that's a win! The only thing was my partner got really sick when we got home.. he threw up and I'm not sure if it was related or not but we'll still be back read more

Potpie - Red snapper, couscous, broccoli, mushrooms - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

The food was very good, the ambience was great, service was good! Go in expecting to pay for the quality of the food and experience, not a big meal you won't finish. I left happy and full with a clean plate. I would definitely visit again! It's a very cute and cozy little place. read more

See all

Open for lunch, had my favorite must have goat cheese salad with beet dressing. Always perfect. Had the steak frites, delicious. My favorite restaurant in KC for more than a decade! read more

Potpie - Mussels in magic butter - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Our recent dining experience at Potpie was truly exceptional, I felt I had to leave them a glowing review. We had dinner with another couple last weekend and they suggested we all go here, I'm certainly glad they recommended it. When you walk in the restaurant is on the smaller side, but not too small, with a small bar on the right and a mixture of different sized tables. The menu is written up on a large chalkboard at the back of the room. It was very buzzy, and intimate, I really liked it. The staff was second to none, everyone from the bartender to the owner were wonderful. The food was excellent, you can tell most everything was made from scratch, if you go I highly recommend you order one of their namesake potpies. I had a chicken and vegetable version while my wife had a beef and mushroom pie. The crust was perfectly tender and flaky at the same time, and the filling was seasoned and cooked to perfection. The drinks were also great, they offer signature cocktails or they have a full bar. I can't wait to return. read more

I have been coming here for years and I still enjoy their pot pie to this very day. I think it's nice that they have been consistent while keeping it versatile with different menus based on seasons. In my opinion, I think it's a KC staple and everything just taste wholesome with fresh ingredients in every bite. I enjoy other parts of their menu as well but my heart belongs to a really well made pie. I like the ambiance as well. It's quaint and cozy without overdoing it like mass produced restaurant groups out there. read more

Such a cool little hole in the wall in Midtown. With nice seating options and a bay window spot, so many options. I got the chicken pot pie with the pammes das? Reminded me of home style cooking and a big warm hug. I couldn't get enough of it. Sooo good. I recommend coming here for a little lunch stop or nice dinner for a night out! I will so be coming back here. On their menu it says "Good food NOT Fast food" and yes, the food didn't come out immediately, but it took a short amount of time to make the perfect meal! So yummy, definitely stop by! read more

Potpie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Excellent service and food, combined with a cozy atmosphere. What else can I say? Go eat there.

An hour after arriving and after tables that arrived after us had dined and left, we were served our food. The pot pie was OK. The crust was a frozen puff pastry that was slightly burnt around the edges. Nothing that I couldn't make at home. Everything on the menu was a la carte. The atmosphere felt crowded even though the restaurant was half empty. Probably won't go again. read more

Potpie has a warm and cozy vibe in a historic building in Westport. You can dress up or down here without feeling out of place. It's a small building and gets a little bit loud but that kind of gives it a local pub feel. They have free bread service, with butter and a crusty French baguette they slice in-house. They definitely didn't skimp which we loved! We ordered two pot pies - the vegetable root and chicken and vegetable. The crust was flaky and nicely salted on both. The chicken and vegetable pot pie had a rich chicken flavor and a good amount of chicken inside. We felt that a more substantial vegetable would have been nice but overall enjoyed the dish. The vegan pot pie had a hearty feel with tender brussel sprouts and carrots, but a bit lighter in flavor than the chicken pot pie. Their cocktails were good as well - the overwhelming crowd favorite was the Tulip which was refreshing and not too citrusy. We were a table of 9 on a Friday night, so the service was a bit slow but did not effect our experience. Our waitress was friendly and our water was always full. I think this is a nice restaurant to eat at and then walk over to Westport main for a couple of drinks. read more

Potpie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

Cozy casual spot with friendly service and delicious food. We had the fried shrimp tempura for an appetizer, scallops (spicy!) and pan roasted chicken for dinner, and chocolate chip bread pudding for dessert (worth the price of admission alone!). Everything was delicious. Reservations are pretty much a must - a very small place - one of our favorites! read more

First experience here. I have to say it won't be my last. The chicken pot pie was to die for! Best I've ever eaten. Flaky crust and savory gravy with perfect seasoning. My husband had the short ribs. He said they were good but not the best he's ever had. Tables are very close together or very cosy if you want to take the positive side. Limited menu and beer options but if you like cosy and love pot pie, this is your place! read more

So excited to walk up and they had a table for 2 available! Bread to start, the menu is updated on the board, a selection of drinks and the smells are heavenly. The pot pies come out fresh and so hot! The soup was very flavorful and pot pies are very large - huge portions. Cute setting & atmosphere! Parking is on street. read more

See all

Lovely small restaurant surprisingly intimate great date night spot. Love the mussels!

The cutest Kansas City find. We wanted to try a new spot for Valentine's Day and got lucky enough to find a reservation last minute. The service was quick and friendly. You walk in to see a dimly lit room. While it maybe small, it is designed well to feel spacious. Finally, the food! Most notably known for the potpie, of course. Trust me, it's worth it. We both tried the chicken pot pie and love the idea of grabbing one to bake at home for our next gloomy sick day. We had the roasted Brussels sprouts for an appetizer. We left full and happy with our dinner selection. read more

Potpie - Chicken Pot Pie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

I had my 70th birthday luncheon at Pot Pie. Victor and his team went above and beyond to make it a very special day. The food, the service and especially the drink demonstration was excellent. Victor was so helpful with planning my private celebration with me. We will be back!! read more

It's been some time since I've stopped in to this KC staple and I'm so happy to report a wonderful experience!! Literally, they remembered me from visits yrs ago! Talk about phenomenal service. These folks care about thier patrons, and it shows. On to "the tea". The specialty drink menu has several offerings and if my selection was typical, then they are all great (ordered a Megillah) the cream of spinach soup is tasty, goat cheese salad was great and a lil different. Perfectly dressed greens, with 3 generous goat cheese topped crostini served from the oven. Yum! The roasted chicken, mash and green beans did not disappoint! I was so full I didn't order dessert but will be back! I'm so happy to have rediscovered this city gem! Thank you, Pot Pie!! read more

One of the best restaurants in KC for both quality of food, service, ambiance and more. The inside is cozy and smaller than many restaurants but it matches the menu! The vegan pot pie and the mussels are both consistently delicious. My server recommended the short rib this time around since it was a seasonal item and I ate every bite - delicious!! It was so tender and the sauce and polenta base perfected it. read more

Delicious food. The steak & mushroom pot pie was so flavorful and the crust was flaky perfection.

Great food, service and conversation. Found this gem on a a work trip and plan to return and try other entrees. Went with the namesake with beef and mushroom and it was everything I hoped it would be. Looking forward to trying the scallops and risotto next time! read more

Happening spot. We were staying nearby and just walked by. I had the tulip cocktail which was lovely and balanced. The server answered my many questions with patience. We split a garden salad that had thinly sliced marinated cucumbers hidden underneath the greens. The small tomatoes were varied colors and delicious (I don't even like tomatoes). Salad was served with bread and butter. We both got the pot pies. Husband got the chicken one and I got the spring veggie special. I couldn't pass up the spring veggies, but I actually liked the chicken one better. Super filling. I could only eat about a third of mine. We walked in just before 6 and were seated, but by 7 the place was full. I would recommend reservations on a weekend. Tables are pretty close together, but the mood is lively and welcoming. read more

Everything. Every time. It's always perfect and delicious. This is one of my go go's here in KC. I always also recommend it to out of towners. Their menu is delicious, their space is so cozy and welcoming. I'll always go back! They also are very good at working with me and my dietary restrictions. The owners, managers, servers, bartenders and kitchen staff are always welcoming and accommodating. One of my absolute favorite restaurants. Food recs- Chicjen pot pie, THE pan roasted chicken and the bread pudding. They also have a great wine list and their whiskey cocktails are on point. read more

This place is so good! Truly a hole in a wall vibe but amazing food every single time

I love everything about this restaurant. It's a small restaurant in Westport and the food is amazing! We have been here multiple times and will continue to go back. If you are looking for a delicious home cooked comfort foods, this is the place. Today, I had the braised short rib and I loved everything about it. It is very well seasoned and tasted like a nice comforting beef stew. The short rib is perfectly cooked and just melts in your mouth. My husband had the pan roasted chicken and that too was very delicious. The chicken was moist and well seasoned. We typically get the bread pudding for dessert but did not have room for that today. For appetizers, I recommend the steamed mussels if you like seafood. It is very garlicky and buttery. The complimentary bread dipped in the steamed mussel sauce is a must! read more

Potpie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

This place is just Great! Too bad I live in Texas, but luckily my son is there! Being welcomed at the bar was the best first impression. Very friendly outgoing guy! We were sat less than 10 minutes from our reservation time which was pretty good considering it's a pretty small place at 8:30 on a Friday night and it was Good Friday. Started with mussels. They were great! The broth delicious! We had a hard time choosing our dinners. Everything sounded so good and from what we could see coming from the kitchen it All looked soooo good!! Finally decided on the pan roasted chicken and chicken pot pie. It wasn't just my hunger talking, it was literally the best chicken ever. Both dishes. The crispy skin on the roasted chicken!! I could eat a plate full of it. From the skin to the last spoonful of gravy (gravy I could have finished by licking the plate!) it was just DELICIOUS. Pot pie. What can I say?? WOW! The crust is this flaky, buttery, perfectly salted goodness. Then the filling. Best homemade pot pie filling. Overall. Amazing! Just go! You have to eat for yourself. But do get a reservation! It's small and gets busy. read more

See all

I loved Potpie! This is one of the most darling restaurants I've seen in KC. The wait staff was incredibly friendly and helpful. I had two drinks off their cocktail menu and they were very tasty. I also had a goat cheese salad which was fresh and coated in a beautifully pink beet-dressing. My only complaint about Potpie is that my chicken and vegetable potpie wasn't anything special. There weren't enough veggies and the chicken wasn't particularly tasty. I plan on going back to try something else because I had a completely charming experience. read more

See all

When the temperature hits a certain point, we all crave comfort food and what better way to satisfy that then having a nice warm hearty pot pie from none other than PotPie. It's awesome this restaurant has been around in Westport since 2003. It's small and cozy which totally adds to the appeal. They have a selection of three pies to choose from: chicken & vegetable, beef & mushroom, and vegan root vegetables plus a whole menu full of other delicious-sounded options like pan-roasted chicken, short ribs, and even scallops. I ended up getting the classic chicken potpie because I HAD TO. It had a piping hot filling with carrots, onions, and shredded pieces of chicken and then crust which is almost in-between a bread with the chew but a flaky pie dough. The beef & mushroom was also delicious and that one definitely had some dark ale in it haha. The service was friendly and we ended up having some fun banter with the owners too over my ring light. There was even an accordion player playing some tunes over dinner which was quite nice. Overall, definitely a great spot for a nice comforting dinner. Happy eating and remember: Don't deny, satisfy! read more

Great food great staff this Borderlands on casual but it is a premium restaurant great for All Occasions. I give it six stars but they only let me go up to five read more

This was my favorite restaurant when I lived here in 2005/2006, and was thrilled to see it is still open and serving nearly the same (limited) menu! Hubby loved the chicken and veg potpie (big enough for two to share but a grown adult man finished it all). I wanted to try the root vegetable vegetarian potpie but ultimately went with the mussels since I loved them so much all those years ago. The restaurant is tiny, busy and loud so make a reservation AND request a table along the wall. Some nice folks at the table next to us were raving about the desserts but we were too full. Next time we'll share an entree so to save room for something sweet. We were not impressed with the spinach blueberry vinaigrette salad and would skip it next time. read more

Potpie - Pino noir and mussels. Not shown: sliced baguette to soak up all the sauce. - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

I'm trying to support local where we can during Covid-19, so why not hit play on the 'Greatest Hits' in KC? Potpie has always been a clutch date night spot for my wife and I, and while we missed the cozy interior, the curbside takeout option worked surprisingly well. This is a down home spot with some rib-sticking dinner options; hearty pot pies, crispy chicken over a massive bed of mashed potatoes, warm, chocolate chip bread pudding.. All as good as they sound. While the menu might feel a bit limited, they nail each and every item on it. I have a hard time straying from the crispy chicken; it's so juicy, the skin is in fact crispy, and I don't know what magic goes into the mashed potatoes but they're some of the best I've ever had. Be warned, you will be beyond full if you finish this which of course I did. The warm bread pudding is also insane. It comes with a Creme Anglaise to drench it in, and it's like five pastries crammed into one dessert. Very rich, very delicious. If you get it curbside like we did, it makes for a round 2 of dessert at another time. As of writing this, they do Friday and Saturday curbside orders, 3-7 p.m. You order and pay over the phone, set a pick up time and roll up curbside. They'll come check in with you and have your food out in short order. For takeout, we know things like Chinese, Thai, Indian, etc. tend to travel well, and I was a tad skeptical on this, but it did indeed travel. It was as delicious as the past times in the restaurant. Highly recommend for a great, classic meal in KC. read more

See all

We had a great time here at PotPie. Started off with steamed mussels and the goat cheese salad which were both 10/10. Probably could have stopped there, both these items with some bread were delicious. Since we were here for the first t we both got a pot pie. They were both good but the filling lacked substance. Not a lot of meat or mushroom in mine. The chicken was better and a bit more hardy. Luckily by this point we were both completely stuffed and didn't save room for the bread pudding. Would try the pan seared chicken next time and skip the beef pot pie. read more

Potpie - New American Near Me - Kansas City, Missouri

See all

My brother and sister in law took me to pot pie for dessert of bread pudding and espresso martinis. I left euphoric. Little did I realize until the first bite that the bread pudding overlaid a super rich, heavenly chocolate sauce. And the martini was a perfect complement. Ryan at the bar is a classic mixologist and gift of gab storyteller. read more