You know what I love about this potbelly's? The people here are happy. The food is consistent. And it's fast. Cathy was super nice. Her smile was contagious and made my day. Thank you Potbelly's! read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

VERY DISSAPOINTING EXPERIENCE! I ordered online for a company group lunch. I put in the order 2 days in advance for pick up at the Willowbrook location. Unfortunately, we experienced several problems with the order. Out of 14 lunches ordered, 8 had an issue. - The 4 powerhouse salads were missing the grilled chicken, and 2 were missing the extra avocado which were all paid for. - 1 of the salad was missing the feta cheese that has been requested and paid for. - 1 order has the wrong sandwich in the bag. - 2 lunches were initially missing from the pick-up package, requiring us to go back to the restaurant and tell the staff about it. Given this was an almost $200 order and half of the individual lunches had an issue, the number of errors was disappointing and disrupted our office lunch. This issue was sent to the customer service on the same day of the incident, but I did not receive any feedback. I hope the management will do something about this. Please reach out to me. The Order Number: 46077524485767181 picked up on August 26, 2026 at 11:15 AM. read more

I visited this location just for a cookie and shake for my man...the man that helped me was named Gil and his associate was also very kind. It was by far the best strawberry shake I've ever had and the cookies were so fresh!! I'll be back anytime I hear! Pls check them out! read more

Potbelly - Strawberry shake and cookie - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

Potbelly, you need Guard rails or bollards to protect your customers, a vehicle can easily crash through and injure customers. This just happened at Portillo's and killed a child. You have great sammys, now protect your customers. Thanks read more

Potbelly - Need guard rails to protect customers - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

See all

Good tasty sandwiches made quickly. Staff is always friendly and the place is clean. Ready to go when there's a deal/craving. read more

Potbelly - Great location - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

See all

Food was disgusting . A lady did don't have her hair tied up all the way and I had 2 strands of hair in my salad ew. I ordered a veggies melt and the mushrooms were old and mushy. Not even speaking about the brown old avocado on my sandwich. Horrible food and the customer service was worse . Nobody cares about their customers read more

I had a difficult order and they handled it with ease & the utmost professionalism Mikayla was my host today read more

Honestly it's been a while since we had Potbelly for lunch. I was really happy with the online ordering for pickup, BUT be sure to check the customize button. My Italian was great, exactly what I expected. Our other sandwich the BLTA was on the dry side as we didn't check out how you could customize it. We popped for the meal deal, chips and a drink to share. If you are a salt and vinegar person, these are great chips. The large diet coke bottle was perfect for sharing. Probably what most impressed me was that it was ready as promised and it was noontime-lunchtime rush. I was greeted as I walked in and directed to the pickup area. In and out in less than a minute. Next time we order we'll be sure to check the customize for all of our order. Keep up the great customer service. We'll be back. read more

See all

#31/2022 First things are back to full hours again contrary to what Yelp says they do not close at 5:00 p.m. they are now open Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Saturday and Sunday 10:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. I hadn't been to this one for a while thought about getting a wreck like I usually do; but I must say what a pleasant surprise to walk in and see that big billboard saying get the Cubano for a limited time! I said oh hell yes I will. And I did It was great. They should bring it back as a regular sandwich all the time many people agree it was one of their best you got the pulled pork the ham the thin sliced pickles the melted cheese with the Dijon mustard and I added a little bit of seasoning to it toasted perfectly it was fantastic. I went with the chips and the drink and I did the regular size 8 in and I walked out very pleased the iced tea unsweetened was brewed perfect and fresh a fantastic experience so I'm up in this one for today's visit to the full five bar Stars keep up the great work at this one. The employees were very cordial and friendly any questions asked they were quite prompt and courteous definitely coming back around again hopefully it stays that way I know they had some trouble here with employees for a while but it looks like they're back on the up and up. read more

Potbelly - Current specials July 2022 the Gyro is here - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

The staff here is super nice. The quality of the chicken salad (one mixed in mayo) in the chicken salad sandwich has gone down tremendously. I recently got a sandwich that was so darn disgusting I had to throw it away. There was a big piece of cartilage in my chicken salad and it ruined the rest of the sandwich for me. Upon further inspection, there's a lot of fat, skin, tendons in the chicken salad. read more

I vow to never visit this Potbelly ever, again. I am almost tempted never to visit any other Potbelly either, due to their horrible customer service and sandwiches. However, this location is the absolute worst. I ordered at the actual ordering section and went with a Biggie Veggie and a Biggie Tuna. In addition, I splurged and ordered an Oreo milkshake. Upon entering the payment section I hear the woman in front of me also order an Oreo milkshake and immediately receives mine. Which had been waiting for me, because I ACTUALLY ORDERED IT IN THE AREA I WAS SUPPOSED TO ORDER IT. The worst part was I heard her announce that she thought it was someone else's, but she had the audacity to readily take it anyways. Rather than start a scene with her, I kindly informed the employee that was actually my milkshake he had given away. He apologized and said they would quickly make me another. Hence, my milkshake was runny and tasted like milk only. Strike One. I went home and greedily opened my sandwich in anticipation. I got to the second half and noticed something about it tasted off. I attributed it to the bread being slightly burnt and took another bite. Nope, this sandwich was definitely off, because there was MEAT(tuna) ON A VEGETARIAN SANDWICH. Yes, a vegetarian of over 20 years had just consumed tuna. I felt ill for three hours after. Strike Two. Once I started to feel better I contacted Potbelly and was able to speak with the store "manager" Ryan briefly until he asked to place me on hold. I was on hold for ten minutes. I then called back and he informed me that staff had called in and they were extremely short so "could you please email exactly what happened and I will respond immediately?". I therefore wasted my time and energy writing an email and attaching a picture. I waited a day, then two, and then a week. No response. I contacted Corporate, no response. I even called back this location again and was assured by the assistant manager Ryan would call me back. No response. Strike Three. Potbelly is overpriced and sub-par as it is, but to have incompetent and rude "manager's" such as Ryan takes the cake. Add in a disgusting and inadequate response from Corporate? I am done with Potbelly and I advise others to do the same. read more

Potbelly - Tuna, spread out on my VEGETARIAN sandwich in all it's glory. - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

The bread was the best thing. Had the meatball sandwich and it was bland. The place was very clean. They have a big selection of drinks. Was going to get a chocolate shake but they were out of chocolate syrup. read more

Potbelly - Haven't been here in forever. - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

I've eaten at other Potbelly's. I knew what to expect, so it wasn't like I went in expecting something that just doesn't exist. My mother and I went in to pick up some lunch. There was a lot of staff there, but most were stocking shelves and doing other things. We ordered a couple of sandwiches and chili bowls to take home. Service was slow given how outnumbered we were in the staff to client ratio, but when you want something good, you know you should be patient. When we got home, my dad opened the chili and said it was bland and he wasn't a big fan of it (he usually is). The next day, he tried the other chili and said it was much better. Not sure if it was because we received the end of one pot and then the new one or not, but he was still disappointed. Neither my mother's nor my sandwiches were correct in the order. Not what we ordered, nor what we asked to go on it. Really bizarre stop, but enough to make me not want to go back any time soon. Bummer. read more

Been going here since i was a kid, solid joint. That being said that was an UNHOLY amount of jalepenos. I like spicy but that was extra without the prompt. Tip: order light? read more

Awsome staff, good food, good vibes, clean. Honestly a good experience. Can't ask for anything better from Potbelly.

Extremely rude staff. Walked out without even ordering. It's not hard to be nice. While everyone is busy and short staffed this type of attitude loses your company money in sales and doesn't help anyone. read more

Rude customer service, not at all helpful when I was given the wrong order and took over an hour to get anyone to give me any assistance to get my correct order. Would never return to this location due to how rude the workers were read more

I've been to a few Potbelly locations now and this one probably ranks about the same as the rest. They seem to find the perfect spot because they're always packed every time I come in, no matter which store it is. I guess it's good for them, but bad for me 'cause I don't like lines. I put my order in early to try and beat the mad rush at lunch. I scheduled it for 11:15 AM pickup and made it there by 11:25. At 11:45, I was still waiting. Meh. This bothers me because I went through the trouble to put it in online to still have to wait. Might as well saved the trouble of ordering online and just waited. They were really busy when I got in, so this is obviously why my order was pushed to the back and made once I arrived. Food wise -- it's a great lil sandwich shop. Today I had the skinny tuna, which has less meat and cheese than the regular subs but only cost $4.00. I'd never had their tuna before (my usual is the wreck or roast beef) but I thought it was good. Less mayo than Subway, but packed with flavor. One thing I love about Potbelly is that the ingredients always seem really fresh and I love that you can add fresh mushrooms to any sandwich for $0.50. Mushrooms ARE the best vegetable out there. Their shakes and oatmeal cookies are also so dang delightful, that I don't allow myself to order them or even glance at them. If I do, I'll want to order them every day for the next few weeks. Overall, I'd give this location 3 stars due to the slow service today. I'll still be back because the food is good, but I hope next time they don't let me down again. (Oh and I second the person that said parking sucks here. There is a Qdoba, Smashburger and Potbelly here. It's near impossible to find a spot during lunchtime.) read more

See all

This is my favorite sandwich place of all time. I have been eating Potbelly's since I was very small and there was just the original shop near Children's Hospital in Chicago (my mom would bring it home to me occasionally). And now, whenever I am near a Potbelly's, I MUST HAVE IT. As a vegetarian, I order the veggie sandwich/mushroom melt with everything on it -- especially a healthy dose of giardiniera. It's perfection. I get a pickle on the side to complement everything. Their cookies and shakes are also quite good -- I split those with my husband. All in all, super YUM!!! read more

Great food! I just visited this location for the first time two weeks ago. My usual turkey sandwich was great! I ordered online and quickly picked it up within the take-out kiosk in the restaurant! read more

The quest was on for a dinner that would fill, but not stuff. Restaurant after restaurant went by, until we stopped at Potbelly's. Stopped is a relative term for this one - you have to do jumping jacks to get to it on Rt 83 in Willowbrook. It's worth the effort. The staff was friendly, the interior was nice and antique-y, and the food was just plain good. My wife and I both went for the same thing, along with a bag of their salt and vinegar chips, both of which were good. The service was fairly fast. Overall, not a lot to complain about. It was a good meal that didn't over-stuff us. read more

I just love Potbelly's.! They have one of the best warm turkey sandwiches and THICK shakes. YUM! Great cookies and now salads. I am not sure if the ones in the burbs have it but the city ones serve breakfast and omg that is just as good. Who does not like a good egg breakfast sandwich that is def better than fast food. I like that this one was an old gas station. I like that they kept the original garage doors for the windows. I think all of the locations have a cool set up inside as far as decor and loft like atmosphere. I never had a bad experience at this one or others. They are pretty good at moving the line but this location could maybe use a little more seating. The only bad thing to say is getting in there can be a challenge if you are coming from the other direction but I manage. :) Overall, love it. read more

Potbelly - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

See all

This is the WORST Potbelly I have ever visited. I've never had a bad experience in years of Potbelly until I visited this location for the first time today. We had issues with the horrible service and the quality of the food. We went to Potbelly solely because we saw an ad on their Facebook page that said it was free shake day. They did not want to honor the promotion. Told my husband it was only if you paid with the app. So he downloaded the app. It was raining and I waited in the car with the kids and they said all customers had to be present to get their free shake. We came in the store and then they said they needed to see a copy of the promotion so we showed them the ad from their own Facebook page. Then they said we could only have one. The ad said free shake with entree purchase. It did not say limit of one per family. My husband said we would just ring up our 4 entrees separately and they said they couldn't do it. Said all four of us have to have the app, sure like my children have smart phones. They kept delaying making our shakes and finally my husband just asked to be refunded for our food since they were not making shakes for us. They had moved on to making the orders for people behind us. The manager had the audacity to tell my husband that we were holding everyone in line up, when this whole situation was due to them not honoring their own Promo. They ended up ringing up our 4 meals separately and giving us the shakes but not after making a huge production and making us feel extremely unwelcome. Not sure if this was also a fail on Potbelly Corporate's marketing dept because there was certainly no rules on the ad and it felt like the store kept making them up on the fly. Took over 30 mins before we had the transaction resolved. My TKY was incredibly sparse, the meatball sub was dry with barely any sauce, and the baked potato soup was inedible, clumpy and the color and texture was off. I'll never go back to this Potbelly!! read more

See all

I have been to this Potbelly a lot of times. They are the best sandwiches. The place is clean and neat. The people are friendly. And best of all, the food is very good. You can eat inside or outside or take it on the go... read more

Ordered lunch for 12:30. Had kids in car waiting while I went in. Lunch was not ready until after 12:45. Staff just disregarding order confirmation or details. read more

This is how "everything on it (except hot peppers on the side please" looks like on a Sunday night. Disappointment. Was craving this sandwich for a while and whoever works the evening shift on a Sunday night makes these awesome sandwiches taste nothing like they should... read more

Potbelly - This is what "everything on it" looks like - Sandwiches Near Me - Willowbrook, Illinois

Pointless to do online orders. Ive ordered 30mins 45mins and over an hour before I get to the store and they never have it made. Every time i get there thats when they start making it. Ridiculous read more

My husband and I had our second date at the original Potbelly's in Chicago--way back when. Fast forward 24 years and find Potbelly's everywhere. They're even in St Louis now! That says a lot. Often, when local joints expand, quality suffers. Not the case for Potbelly's. The menu selections are varied and the service has been great in every location, this one included. The ingredients are fresh and the sandwiches are well put together in terms of ingredients and assembly. I love the way this Potbelly is a repurposed gas station that was vacant for years. I used to work in the area----wish this option had been there then. read more

Okay, so I hate chains. I also hate fast food. But lunch options are limited near my place of employment. And, since moving to Chicago, everyone keeps telling me I have to eat at Potbelly's and Portillo's. So, okay, whatever. I love spicy food, I mean love it. I want my mouth to be on fire, I want my food to be uncomfortable to eat. I had never had giardinara peppers before and after my first bite of a Potbelly's sandwich covered with this goodness I could see what all the fuss was about. Spicy=Love. read more

Not a fan of the location here... if you're coming from South RTE 83, you must make a tricky U-turn at 75th to enter... be careful the red light camera at that intersection is brutal! You cannot enter from 75th street heading west... unless you make a U-Turn about 2 blocks further up. The parking lot here is also insane. Could use some new lines painted and maybe police to enforce the folks who block the RTE 83 entrance with their cars. The employees here are always friendly and prompt. No complaints about the quality. Cafe is usually pretty clean. read more

This is a Potbelly's in a pretty busy area. It was a busy area when the Potbelly's went in a few years ago, yet the parking is inadequate for the restaurant. My advice to you is to go early or late, because during the peak lunch rush, you will likely be parked in an area that's not an actual spot. They are also ill-equipped to deal with many lunch groups larger than four. They have one table that will work for that kind of party. And it's frequently staked out by one guy and his laptop [note: this last part is not Potbelly's fault, but is my own pet peeve about diners]. In the warmer months, there is a patio out back that's generally pretty great to sit at. The food's fine, and I tend to not have any problems with it; however, I have failed to go here without at least one member of my group having their order wrong. They are quick to fix things, and always apologetic. read more

Just picked up a catering order. The staff was super helpful and so nice. Thanks!! We ordered a variety of 36 sandwiches, assorted chips, and cookies. It's too bad they don't have gallons of tea or lemonade. But they provided us with cups. Highly recommend them for catering with large groups. read more

I'd choose Potbelly's over Quiznos (GROSS) or Subway any day. They have a quaint atmosphere, friendly staff and good sammies. Turkey on wheat for me! This parking lot is pretty crazy busy though. I had their breakfast once and wasn't huge on their bacon, but to be fair it was a different location in an airport... read more

I used to work at this Potbelly location so I have a soft spot for this place. Even knowing the ins and outs of the place, I find it only to be an average sandwich shop. Potbelly sandwiches are unnecessarily messy! Even with the double wax wrapping paper, the liquid somehow messily dribbles out of the bottom of the sandwich onto my clean pants every time. Another thing that gets me every time is how the toppings station is set up. Unlike other sandwich joints where you can scrutinize every topping addition the sandwicher slaps onto your sandwich, you have no idea what is going on behind that counter! My sandwich was just messed up. I DID NOT ask for tomatoes and ordered a BIG sandwich. Since I did not see my sandwich until I opened it at home, my messed up sandwich is irreversible. There are the great parts of Potbelly. It's a quick place for a good priced tasty, baked, and warm sandwich. The meat is always a pre-weighed amount but the topping station is always under the discretion of the guy asking what you want for your toppings.Make sure you make clear what you want! read more

My favorite sandwich place. Good bread, love their chicken salad, they have giardinera. They took classic sandwiches, and did them right. MMMMM!!! You can get your sandwich skinny with some of the bread scooped out, or you can live dangerously and get a Wreck. Much better than any standard sandwich shop. I bought 2 jars of giardinera to take home with me last time I was in town. read more

This potbelly is actually a joke!!! Avoid this one at all cost. They got my order wrong multiple time's, made me wait a ridiculous amount of time, and were super rude about it. DO NOT GO!!!! read more

Potbelly's does not have a particularly large menu, but it has all the basic sandwich options: turkey, ham, roast beef, Italian, etc. They also have various drinks, chips, soups, cookies, and milkshakes. I think the sandwiches are pretty good. They're generous with the meat, the bread is hearty and toasted, and the veggies are fresh. The soups are hit or miss, never had the cookies, and the milkshakes are really good!! All in all, a great sandwich joint (much better than Subway or Quizno's and on par with Jimmy John's). read more

I got a sandwich from here and it was amazing. The worker Adam handled me very professionally and is a very sincere worker.

This review is only about the physical location itself. The sandwiches are good as usual, and I love Potbelly's pizza sandwiches. But today was first day I came here. And I came here because I was starving, had no lunch prior to 4pm, and it was in the way back to the city. The place looks cool. It was converted from a gas station and Potbelly really did a good job inside. BUT the place was insanely cold. Granted, outside, temperature today dropped negative and 15 minutes outside exposing bare skin would give you frostbite, but there wasn't an excuse that I couldn't escape inside and warm up a little. Was that expecting too much? I ate my sandwich cold and wishing just to leave as fast as possible. Anyways, don't think you can be warm here during winter. :/ read more

Went today at peak lunch time: 12:15 p.m. They had quick and friendly service. Sandwich was wonderful as always. The store seems a little smaller than most out there since it appears they remodeled the gas station it took over, but we didn't eat in. May have to try that next time. Overall, great experience. read more