Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Post Road Pub

    4.0 (1 review)

    Post Road Pub Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Post Road Pub

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    13 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Hilltop Pub and Grill

    Hilltop Pub and Grill

    3.8
    (215 reviews)
    3.1 mi
    $$

    food is amazing service is extremely fast…read morethe venue is awesome 5 starts is not even enough. hats of to Hailey for an amazing service to my family.

    We were in town and someone suggested going here, so we headed over for Saturday dinner…read more Unfortunately, if I'm being completely honest, it was just not great. When you consider the food prices, the credit card fee, and the taste of the food itself, it's hard to even give this place 3 out of 5 stars and call it "average." I hate giving lower reviews, especially to smaller businesses, but this place needs some work. I'm going to write the kind of honest review I wish I would have seen before going here. To start, the prices are quite high. For what they're charging, I expected much better food. On top of that, they also charge a credit card fee, which means they are passing that cost onto the customer in addition to the high menu prices. That alone is an immediate negative for me. The ambience of the place itself isn't bad. It's a larger restaurant, and the curved door and circular shape are actually kind of cool. It's also cool having TVs all around. We were there on a Saturday night, and it was pretty slow. That said, if the locals have been here before, I can understand why it was slow, given the food quality and prices. I got the 1/2 Tequila BBQ Burger, and it was pretty boring. I can make much better burgers at home. It needed better seasoning, or really just any seasoning at all. The tequila bbq sauce was fine, but it mostly tasted like very sweet barbecue sauce. I got waffle fries with my order, and they were also just fine. Someone else at our table got the beer-battered fries, and those were much better. I do want to give them credit there. The beer-battered fries were actually quite good. I asked my wife and sister what they thought of their meals, and both of them were incredibly disappointed. My wife got a salad with chicken, and it was very boring. Again, it was something we could make better at home for cheaper. My sister got the salmon, and she was not impressed at all. I read through some of the other reviews, and I think a lot of them may be from locals, whereas I was just visiting town. But I agree with many of the negative points people have made, and I've already said it here: the food just isn't good, especially considering the prices they're charging. I'd recommend looking for a different restaurant in the area. If management happens to read this review, I think they could improve things by reviewing the quality of the food they're serving and working to improve the overall taste. Otherwise, they should consider lowering prices to better match the quality of the food. The portion sizes were good, and that is another thing I do want to give them credit for. At the end of the day, maybe we just didn't order the right things, but no one at our table enjoyed their meal enough to want to go back. This place needs a lot of work, and I hope they have better success in the future. Next time we are in town, though, we will be going somewhere else.

    Photos
    Hilltop Pub and Grill
    Chicken sandwich w/fries and bbq sauce
    Chicken sandwich w/fries and bbq sauce
    Hilltop Pub and Grill

    See all

    Final Score

    Final Score

    4.0
    (18 reviews)
    4.2 mi
    $

    Great place to watch a game and eat good food. They have great appetizers like the pucks and bee…read morehives. The service was good even with things being super busy during game time.

    Final Score, more like final hell. We'll go with the four innings…read more.. Establishment is adequate. Chairs & tables are decent, though some tables needed to be balanced. Atmosphere is younger crowd, waitstaff are definitely college girls with some old man that I can assume was the owner would pop back behind the bar often. Plenty of tv's for sports games also have a pool table and darts. I'd say it's your "Average Wisconsin bar". We ordered a Bloody Mary with Tito's & Virgin Mary. However, we were informed that they pre-make their mix with rail vodka. I asked if there was a possibility to make one separately and again was told they premade the mix. I asked if it was possible to get a Virgin Mary, she said yes. They were the BLANDEST lackluster tomato juice drinks I've ever had. They both were garnished with a damn near frozen beef stick, sad spear of pickle, soggy mushroom, Peperoncino and olive. The actual Bloody Mary had very little (if ant) vodka but did come with have a chaser. We ordered a 14" pepperoni pizza and a chicken club. I was informed that I couldn't substitute or change my fries to cheese curds (even though there are other items listed for up charge sides on the menu) so I went with fries. It was a subpar frozen pizza, the chicken is a frozen bought flattened piece of meat on some limp lettuce & the driest bacon I've ever had (McDonald's bacon is better). The fries were not seasoned and had to ask twice for ketchup. We also ordered another Bloody Mary but asked if it could be made separately with Tito's or Grey Goose (both of which they have on hand). Same response as previously "it's premade mix with rail vodka" so we asked for an additional shot. The 20somethjng chic brought us the drink, abruptly put it on the table and walked away. No interaction, no garnish & no chaser! We weren't asked how everything was, had to flag down the staff for the check. We stated that she can take the second Bloody Mary off as it wasn't good. She immediately popped off with "I can't do that, you special ordered it". I asked her if the bartender was incompetent of making a Bloody Mary & that's why they did premade drinks she said it wasn't me that made it. Now she was visibly defensive, had a horrible disposition. I pointed out we didn't want to pay for the drink as it wasn't the same as the first. No garnishes & no chaser, why would we pay MORE for it when we got less. She stated she didn't understand where we were coming from. Left and returned with a cup of garnishes & a chaser and said "there! Now you have everything." This is NOT customer service, this is NOT rectifying a situation. I would NEVER step foot back in this establishment.

    PJ's - SentryWorld

    PJ's - SentryWorld

    3.6
    (157 reviews)
    4.6 mi
    $$

    Service- great Food -delicious…read more Ambiance and restaurant- woodsy and chill My friend told me all the food at PJ's is great, so I gave it a try! We ordered: Cheese curds Truffle tots Pjs burger w/ sweet potato fries Pjs burger w/ wood oven veggies Ny strip, w/ oven veggies Brussels sprouts Lemon blueberry salad Wood oven crisp Clafoutis She was right, all the food was really good! My favorite were the cheese curds because coating was crispy and well seasoned, and the Brussels sprouts because they were well seasoned and crunchy. I would definitely recommend PJ's and order from here again.

    This is one beautiful restaurant and grounds. The bartenders are friendly and make great drinks…read more Sitting at the bar before dinner was enjoyable. Unfortunately our dinner experience was not good. We spent almost three hours at dinner waiting for missed drinks and missed food! Management please work with your servers. Educate them on the meals that are offered. Not knowing what is in a dish is ridiculous. Not telling us about the Friday fish fry (we found out after dinner). When a burger got missed on our order because of the server, have the kitchen rush on a burger instead of one person in our party of eight waiting 45 minutes for their burger while we all ate. Such a shame because our food was good. We just did not plan on sitting there for almost three hours! We wanted to have an after drink outside but it was too late. I worry for this place.

    Photos
    PJ's - SentryWorld
    PJ's - SentryWorld
    PJ's - SentryWorld

    See all

    Post Road Pub - sportsbars - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...