Great burgers and good custard, what more could you ask for?! Oh, they have popcorn and friendly staff too!

Was visiting friends and decided to stop into Pop's. It was a nice burger and custard place! Not really busy, but busy enough! They have a lot of sundae options and plenty of food options. Pretty comparable to Culver's or Kopp's. There were huge cookie chunks in the cookies n cream custard, which is available daily! My burger was pretty good and the service was friendly and prompt. There's a pretty big parking lot. Some of the plastic chairs outside will buckle, so just be careful sitting down. A friend of mine almost fell! Yikes. read more

See all

Today me and my dad went to pops and I it took us 15 minutes to get our food but on the bright side that we have went to Pops for 9 years and my dad ordered a burger with no cheese and once we got home there was cheese on it! But sadly they close at the end so of August read more

We ordered the garden salad and the fish sandwich and they were good. I was impressed with the size of the salad! The three pieces of breaded cod in a bun made a good fish sandwich. For dessert, custard! This is a great place to find it. The service is good and the ambiance casual and relaxed. A hot spot for families with kids and dogs. Their outdoor area is pretty good. read more

Pop's Frozen Custard - S'mores custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

We've been coming here for years, but the last three times I've been disappointed in the counter service. They are very young and seem disorganized. My recent visit, I called in my order and was told to come in 15 minutes, so I did. I still had to wait 40 minutes for my order. Only to find out it was sitting the entire time bagged up on the counter. I had them make my, now soupy, shake over. The food is still decent and we love the ice cream but they have to do something about the service. Maybe more training, an easier system, or maybe have more than one person over the age of 18. Idk. We will try again but if this would have been my first visit we never would come back. read more

Excellent staff, very clean facilities, and the many flavors of custard are amazing. I wish they had one closer to my house.

This longtime diner in the Menomonee Falls neighborhood is definitely worth a visit! It has the oldschool interior design, and the food here is just what you would expect it is - cheesy greasy tasty and satisfying. We had the grilled cheese, hot chili dog and loaded potato fries, sooo good! They also have frozen custard freshly available each day, super delicious! read more

See all

I've stopped at Pop's a handful of times over the years. Pop's is an original fast food/custard drive in that's been in existence for 30+ years. In all the time that's passed I think the majority of Pop's original nature still remains today. A sheer fluke I'm sure, but today I felt I took a step through time. There were 5 individual customers spread around the cozy (small) inside dining area and 4 employees. I'm in my 40's and I would guess I was the youngest person there by about 20-25 years. Kind of made me chuckle and think of Happy Days. The old gang reuniting at Al's Diner 50 years later. I'm not from Menomonee Falls, but I imagine the locals are quite nostalgic of their little place called Pop's. Pretty standard fast food faire with prices you'd expect. Many probably return to reminisce of visits from their youth. I think most of us probably have that home town "go to" drive in location somewhere. read more

Pop's Frozen Custard - Classic drive in - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

My family and I have been going to Pops for many years. Sadly, after today's visit, that won't be happening again. When we got home, we noticed that our chicken tenders were not cooked throughly. So, my husband took them back. The chicken tenders had white stuff coming out of them. When my husband got there, he asked if they can be remade. He was told that he would still have to pay for a new order. My husband stated that didn't make sense as he was asking for them to be remade because they didn't looked cooked. He the. Asked to speak to a manager. The manager stated that they cook the tenders in a new lawd, so that is why they look like that, but he would still need to pay for a new order. So basically, they were not willing to remake the food and trying to force my family to eat chicken that looks uncooked. My husband stated that we have spent so much of our money here, and we have never seen the chicken look like this. So, he walked away without a new order! Needless, to say we threw it in the garbage and wasted our money. Our kids were going to take that for their lunch the very next day. I am so disappointed in Pops, but won't be returning ever again!! read more

The burgers are delicious, can't wait to try other things on their nice menu. Oh, and the ice cream as well

Very good ice cream and food however if you sit inside its freezing. I understand air conditioning in the warmer months but it's uncomfortably cold for dining. read more

Good food good fast service Great custard Their Oreo custard is the best Staff is very friendly and courteous read more

Burgers are good ... custard is usually good but I had the pecan crunch today and it was flavorless

Great frozen custard with changing flavors every day. Also great burgers. Huge portions. I've always gotten my food to go so I don't even know about the ambiance or seating options. Service is always great for carry out. read more

First time visit since moving to the area, brought the whole family and dined in and was a great time. Burger was excellent, 5-stars, double jumbo butter burger with ketchup mustard and fried onions, so good. Kids loved the grilled cheese, chicken tenders also and my wife loved regular cheeseburger. Fries, cheese curds and onion rings were also sampled and cheese curds and onion rings (both battered not breaded) were three stars, fries four stars. Unfortunately we were full and didn't get custard but will next time for sure, maybe that will move this rating to five stars once we try it :) read more

Great place to have a burger and custard! Stopped in there on a whim and was impressed by the homely feel of the place and the good food. Definitely will be back. read more

I finally made over to Pops while shopping in the area, hell its lunch time and a burger sounded good. The place is in a strip mall and doesn't look like much until you walk in and it's like country charm on the inside. The place is small and cozy, I can see this place being standing room only during peek summer times. The menu has everything from butter burgers to fish and shrimp but I was there for a burger. The burgers are ala carte which means I ordered the jumbo burger for $3.99 and they ask what you want on it and I got bacon, cheese, lettuce, tomato, raw onion, mayo and ketchup $$$$. Toppings are all extra which I'm fine with so my jumbo burger ended up at $6.50 The jumbo butter burger must be a sarcastic name because there was nothing jumbo about it at all, smaller than a whopper. The beef patty was very thin and slightly thicker than the super thin tomato slices while the raw onion was so thin that I could barely even see it. The lettuce was the thickest topping and the nice leafy kind, thank you. The bun was a nice soft/light style which complemented the bacon cheeseburger well. Overall it was an ok burger with the patty being moist and you could actually taste the beef with all the fresh ingredients. Overall the jumbo butter burger is not jumbo at all but it's a decent custard store version burger, definitely not a burger destination place and in now way going to replace anyone's favorite good burger place. read more

See all

This has been a favorite since I was a little girl. Their chocolate flavored custard is amazing and very rich in chocolate flavor. Culver's does not compare. read more

I've been going to Pop's as long as I can remember. They are a family tradition. The new ownership is great. Everything tastes the same. I moved out of state and make sure to visit when I return. My go to order: Jr cheeseburger, fries, cheese sauce for dipping, and chocolate shake. You won't be disappointed! Also, if you're driving by and the sign says black raspberry, you better turn in there for a scoop (or quart)! THE BEST! read more

Pop's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

A must visit Menomonee Falls landmark. Recommended dishes: custard (any flavor) and the infamous jumbo butter burger you can actually taste the butter on! read more

Comparing two totally different places at which we ate this week: Cup of Chili and a Salad at Bavette's and at Pop's. The Chili was $5.00 (Bavette) vs. $2.99 (Pop's). Unfortunately, Pop's had grease floating on top so it didn't look appetizing, although the flavor was decent. The big surprise, however, was the salad ($13.00 at Bavette's and $7.99 at Pop's). Pop's Chef Salad was smashed in a plastic bowl pressed down with a plastic cover. Since I couldn't eat it after the chili I took it home and put it in a large bowl and tossed it with the Rasberry vinaigrette. Was I surprised! When the fine pieces of lettuce (lots of arugula and other things) along with tomatoes, chicken, ham, cucumbers, swiss cheese and chopped cheddar were loosened up, THERE WAS ANOUGH FOR FOUR PEOPLE!! This is a deal. Way better than Bavette's or any other chef's salad I've had in a long time. Great to stop by, pick one up for the family and have enough for four. It's on my list. read more

Best custard in all of Wisconsin. Pops always tries new things when it comes to custard, and I have yet to try a flavor I don't like. I highly recommend. read more

Originally started going here for their custard. The tin roof is delicious. However, I was quite surprised at the quality of their food too. The mushroom and Swiss is the best I have ever had. The mushrooms taste fresh, and the buns have a taste of garlic butter, not your typical fast food burger. Absolutely delicious, highly recommend. read more

My review is based on the custard only. Having been to Culvers, Roberts, Kraverz, Kopps, and Oscars, I had to try it. I had a lemon raspberry torte and it was amazing! Right up there with the rest! read more

Pops has been around since I was a kid and I couldn't imagine NOT going here! The custard is amazing! The food is your typical custard stand style- greasy and delicious! I love that you can either eat inside or outside patio. No drive thru but that's AOK! I appreciate the humble, small town approach they've kept since the early 80s. I now bring my kids here and we're keeping the tradition alive and well! read more

As residents of Menomonee Falls, we go to Pops Custard two or three times a year. The food is pretty tasty... And they employ a lot of the local highschoolers who are trained in courteous customer service, while simultaneously helping them to build a résumé. This would've been five out of five stars but the prices for many items are just a little on the high end for a takeout place, otherwise we would come more often for their burgers and fish sandwiches. read more

I thought places like this were supposed to be good. Anyways, I felt rushed in the line, so I ordered corn dogs and French fries. My fries tasted like they were from yesterday and just put in the microwave to heat up. I might come back for the ice cream but definitely not the fries ‍ read more

A limerick: There once was a place called "Pop's," T'was better than all custard shops. To my folks' house it is near, To my heart, it's quite dear, Only comparable maybe, is Kopp's. --- A haiku: Custard to die for So so much kitsch but it's real Turkey sub for life --- Another haiku: Black cow on the real Burgers and chicken tenders Oh how I love you read more

Been going to Pops for years, best ice cream spot in the Falls. Tried the fish sandwich today and was very impressed. Try this local spot out!! read more

I like Pop's and my preference is to frequent local businesses when I can. However, my visit tonight left me upset. Ordered 2 shakes and handed the younger female cashier a $20. She handed me $1.61 in change. I reminded her that I gave her a $20. She said no it was a $10. I opened my wallet and showed her that all I had were $20's because I just came from the ATM and also showed her the receipt and counted out the money which was $20 less. She turned around and walked away. I will not be back. read more

Oh my goodness I got some ice cream here and I was in love it's a mom and pop place there's no indoor orders due to covid-19 but the food was made with love staff was a little young but they were very professional and I really respected that about that business read more

My boyfriend grew up going here, and decided to take me with. Guess who was not disappointed? The staff was friendly and everything was absolutely delicious. Sorry I don't have any pictures! It was too good not to devour immediately! Definitely a good place to stop for some good food or custard!! read more

Love Pops! The food, the custard, best in town!!!! They have a walk up window which is super helpful! Highly recommend.

I stopped at Pop's today for the first time in several years. I decided to try the special that is advertised on their sign outside - hamburger, fries, and soda for less than $5. My son was with me and when we went to the counter to ask about the special, the lady kept repeating that we could make any sandwich a combo for $2.75. I finally spoke up and asked about the special and was told that it was a SMALL burger. I ordered the jumbo butter burger and my son had the jumbo butter burger combo. The buns were average, the burger patties were thin, and I could have read the paper through the slice of tomato on my burger. The fries were adequate in quantity, and probably the best I've had anywhere. The food was adequate and the bill was under $13.00 Here is the rub - the three senior ladies sitting in the corner talked loudly the entire time. Their conversation was normal though not interesting, so I'll give them a pass. I'm over 80 with good hearing but I realize many seniors aren't so blessed. The irritating problem was the five or six teenagers occupying the booth behind me. They were loud and obnoxious to the point that I actually got a head ache. They did not order anything, but talked incessantly with the volume control stuck on maximum and the management did not ask them to turn it down. I believe management has a responsibility to keep an orderly and reasonably quiet atmosphere for people who are simply there to eat and relax. I probably will not be back. read more

My favorite cheese burger!! My husband knew just what to bring home on my birthday! A cheeseburger and fried mushrooms! Yum! Pops has been a stable since I was in high school. The frozen custard is perfect! I just wish they made the sprecher root beer flavor more often! read more

I am leaving 1 star because I can't leave zero. I took my family to Pop's for some sundaes and the up charges are absolutely ridiculous and petty. My daughter wanted sprinkles and whip cream. I was charged $.79 for the whip cream and another $.79 for less than a teaspoon of sprinkles. What kind of cheapskates are running this place. I was charged almost $14.00 for 3 sundaes that were $2.89 each without all of the up charges. The only up charge I seen as normal was the pecans on my mother's sundae for $1.50 My order was 1small hot fudge sundae with whipped cream 1small hot fudge sundae with whipped cream and sprinkles. 1 small hot fudge sundae with peacans and whipped cream. I am amazed they don't charge for the toilet paper in the bathrooms. I think the owner and buddies must be writing the other reviews as I can't believe most of them from what I saw. The custard was average at best. Inferior to Culver's, Kravers and Robert's in the same area. I have been there 3 times and never fails to disappoint. read more

When we came it was pretty busy. We got our food in less than 10 minutes! Good tastes great. Feels amazing to support a small business!!

I see the discrete (not discreet) merits of Pop's, especially since it serves the good people of Menomonee Falls. p.s. the way to remember how to spell "Menomonee" is to say, "me no monee foh this wonderful custahd", in an Asian accent, and then trick people into buying custard for you. No, you're stupid. Location: 3 out of 5 Not somewhere I would drive to from Milwaukee proper just to get my custard and burger fix, but since I was half coerced into doing some type of Aquathon out at Memonomee Park in late August, Pop's wasn't too far away. It's in the same parking complex as a diving shop, a bar, and maybe another restaurant, so parking is free and ample. They have a cute outdoor seating area as well. Decor/Ambiance: 3.5 out of 5 America, woo hoo! I like the patriotic theme that they had going on during our visit. You know those little spinning decorations that move with the air circulation that you can hang from the ceiling? Yep, they had those. The interior itself is comprised of not so comfortable wooden seats and laquered tables/benches - for those of you with flat booties it may be beneficial to bring along some type of seat cushion if you're going to be there for awhile. (I live for the) ApplauseX2 for the small collection of reading materials and children's toys in the front corner, almost library style. Customer Service: 3.75 out of 5 For being towards the end of the night (I rolled in at around 8:45), all of the workers seemed to be in pretty decent spirits. The gals working the cash registers were friendly in taking our orders, and were polite when asking if I needed extra condiments for my burger. They weren't as in a rush as say, the people that work at any of the Kopp's locations, so I didn't feel like they were trying to herd me in and out ASAP. I'm not such a stickler when it comes to "dirty" looking clothes; working in a custard shop, you have to expect to get some splashback/grease/toppings on you once in awhile, and black shirts tend to hide that well. Selection of Grill Menu Items: 4.5 out of 5 A vast selection when you compare them to a place like Gille's or Kopp's. Sure, they had what you might expect: burgers, hot dogs, chicken sandwich, fish sandwich, fries, o-rings, cheese curds, etc. What they do offer that sets them apart are quasi specialty sandwiches: a giant grilled cheese, pulled pork, pizza burger, pork chop, etc. Taste/Quality of Butter Burger + Cheese and Bacon: 3 out of 5 Ever so slightly below what I have come to expect given my experiences at Kopp's. This is not a knock or an insult, and perhaps my view is based on the fact that I'm a pretty standard person when it comes to ordering: My "go to" is a bacon cheeseburger with whatever toppings are free (expect to pay a bit for lettuce and tomato here, but onions are free), and I opted for the butter burger on the night of my visit. The meat itself wasn't overly greasy, which can be good or bad depending on what your lifestyle is. For example, those familiar with Portillo's will attest that the meat there is VERY "flavorful". The bacon, while tasty, was nothing special. With the way they cut up the strips into halves, it reminded me of what I might find at Burger King. The one thing I remember the most as being a little off was the bread to meat ratio of my burger. While I have no complaints about the size of the meat patty, the size of the bun was slightly overwhelming. However, I imagine that on the double burger, it'd be perfect. Six up, half a dozen down, right? The butter part of the burger was nicely done - the top half of my bun wasn't saturated or swimming in tasty fat, but it was obvious that well, there was butter. Taste/Quality of "plain" Vanilla Custard: 4.5 out of 5 Yeeeeeeeboy, that's some tasty custard. My theory on custard is pretty simple - if they can make the base right (either chocolate or vanilla), they can make any variants well. And this folks - was very very good custard. In my opinion, and mine only - probably a little better than Kopp's. Creamy, rich, sweet, cold (but not brain freeze cold), decadent. All of the above. Value: 4 out of 5 If you happen to have no money (remember, "Me no monee"), you won't be eating here. But, if you have a little bit of cash (and they take credit too, even though the sign on the wall says "We accept cash"), you can eat pretty well. Expect to pay around 10$ a person, which if you do it right, can get you "one scoop" (it's really like 2.5 scoops) of custard, a burger, and probably some fries too. Overall: 4 out of 5 Cute place, delicious custard, extensive menu. Will return if I'm in the area. read more

Pop's Frozen Custard - Ample bacon cheese burger, butter style. Bread to meat ratio on the single patties is a little bread heavy, though. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin

Pop's has hands down the best butter burgers around. Made to order. On top of that I've been working my way down their menu, all I have to say is....I have had no complaints and I will never. The staff is super friendly, the food comes out fast and prompt. This is the place to stop at. read more

Great food, custard, and service. They make things to order, so don't expect fast food.