Came here after having lunch at Shoots, and dammit, I wish I had stumbled upon Pop Pie first. I would have ordered one of every savory pie and a slice of all the sweet pies! But alas, I was only able to get a slice of the key lime pie (DAMN good) and a fruit pie pocket thing (also amazing). Purchased them on Saturday afternoon, and here I am eating it on a Tuesday night and it's SO good. Regerts for not eating same day, b/c I'm pretty sure it would have knocked my socks off. read more

TLDR: food was good, presentation and service could've been better. I like this place. The pies are tasty, baked well, and always taste the same whenever I go. I've never had a bad pie here. The same was true the other day when I stopped by for a meal at 9 o'clock. I got the Aussie pie. I think the Aussie pie can best be described as the flavors of a sloppy Joe in a pot pie. I don't mean that as an insult. I just think it's the best way to describe the flavor of this particular pie. I also got the mashed potatoes and gravy. The gravy is kind of a light brown gravy with a light flavor. The reason why I say presentation could've been better is that even though I was dining in, I was given both the pie and the mashed potatoes in to-go containers, which has never happened to me before. And yes, they knew I was dining in. On to the service. I arrived at 9 o'clock almost on the dot. The restaurant closes at 10 o'clock, but they were clearly preparing for closing. The heated display case that normally has a dozen or so pies displayed had nothing in it. If this was my first time here, I would be very confused. Someone was in front of me and the young man at the counter was finishing their order, and didn't acknowledge my existence for several minutes. If it were me, I would greet any Customer that comes into my store and then let them know that I'll be with them in a minute or something. He then proceeded to interact for a few minutes with the young lady who was working there before finally coming over and asking me what I would like. I then inquired as to the empty display case, and he said that he had just cleaned it out because he wanted to clean it. He said they had all of the usual pies. Overall I just felt like I was an imposition on what they were trying to do, which is to close the restaurant. it seems kind of early to do that since it was one hour before closing. I've worked in restaurants, and I can understand something like shutting down the grill a few minutes before closing, and not taking any new cooking orders. But this place pre-bakes all of the pies and the only thing they have to do is hand you an already-warmed pie. There is absolutely no reason to clear out things that early. I suppose it saves a few minutes of extra time at the end of the shift, but it creates a very bad impression to the customer. read more

See all

Are you one of those people who grew up eating those frozen Swanson's and/or Banquet chicken and beef pies and loved them? Do you go to Costco and buy a large pack of Marie Callendar's pot pies for those times you don't feel like cooking? If so, you will love this place. I haven't found a place that specializes in pot pies since Moffett's in Bellflower closed. I never got to try them and I'm still kicking myself for missing out so I wasn't about to miss out on this opportunity. I ordered the traditional chicken pot pie with a side of creamed corn. The crust was perfectly crispy and the pie was filled with a reasonable quantity of tasty chunks of chicken. The side of creamed corn was quite good as well. I saw they had dessert pies as well and could not leave without adding a slice of caramel crumble apple pie to my order. It was delicious and I definitely could have eaten another slice if I had one. The one bad thing about this location is the lack of parking. People will double park, blocking cars legally parked while they go in to pick up their orders. If you're in a hurry to leave and the counter is busy, you could find yourself inconvenienced by these thoughtless, inconsiderate drivers. Going to one of their other locations might be a better option if you want to avoid this type of problem. read more

See all

I'm extremely disappointed with my experience. I found a hair in my piece of pie, which was absolutely disgusting and completely ruined my appetite. When you order food, you expect it to be prepared and served in a clean and sanitary environment. Finding a hair in your dessert is unacceptable and raises serious concerns about food handling and cleanliness. Unfortunately, this experience left a very bad impression, and I would think twice before returning. I hope management takes this seriously and addresses the issue to prevent it from happening to other customers. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Hair - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

Adorable shop, and who doesn't love a pot pie? So many options an available and plenty of sides and desserts to choose from when planning your next meal. The staff is super friendly and helpful when trying to decided between all of the choices. There's also a freezer for you to pick and choose your favorites to take home for later! I ordered the butter chicken pot pie and it was the perfect size for me. The crust was crispy and flaky, and the filling. So good!! The chicken was tender and there was plenty of sauce to keep it moist on the inside but also to dress the chicken chunks under the crust. I really enjoyed having butter chicken in this particular way vs the usual way with rice. I am looking forward to coming back so I can try more options available read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

This place is outstanding. I had a classic chicken pot pie, which was super delicious. And I thought I'd try the chocolate chip walnut cookie which was equally amazing! I had to go back the next day for a chocolate chip cookie. That's how good it was and I live 30 min away :) read more

Pop Pie Co. - Chocolate chip walnut cookie - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

got delivery it was really delicious! The pie was flaky and delicious. The sides were also really good as well. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

Visited the University Heights location and it always has a welcoming vibe. Love the friendliness of the staff. The food is always a hit! Can't wait til Thanksgiving so I can get a turkey pie! Tried the Salted Apple Caramel pie for the 1st time and it was to die for....especially if it's slightly warmed. Sorry no pics because I ate first lol. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ At my next visit I'll take pictures BEFORE I eat...promise! read more

I have driven by a number of times since they've opened, but I kept forgetting that they were there. I'd go to the one in University Heights, even though I live closer to this one. So one evening.... The inside is warm and inviting! The staff is really friendly too! I ordered a chicken pie which is so good! I love the flaky crust! Of course, I also need the mashed potatoes and gravy. I also ordered the kale salad because, you know, you need to keep it healthy! I love the dressing! Since I had kale, I ordered the delicious key lime pie! So good! I also ordered The Boss for the next day for breakfast! There's a nice little patio in front that's dog friendly. This little corner has become very lively. I will definitely be back since parking is a lot easier around here. Next time, I'll bring Cako! But I'm sure she'll approve! read more

See all

Absolutely phenomenal pie and Ice cream! I can't wait to go back and try the savory pies, the store front is so cute and their stuff is so fresh and delicious. Service was really fast and there was no line today. read more

See all

The savory pies have a flaky, golden crust with hearty fillings, and they rotate seasonal flavors which keeps things interesting. They also have sweet pies -- and those are especially good warmed up with a scoop of ice cream on top. Overall, a comforting little spot when you're craving pie, sweet or savory. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

Heard a lot of hype about this place tried it for the first time but honestly didn't live up to its hype. I had two of their pot pies the steak and their pulled pork and both of them were very dry I also had their sausage hot dog which also the meat was very dry. Was definitely a try would not be returning. Cream corn was good and service was fast so I gave them 2 stars. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

It was my first time here. I got the steak and something pie. I thought it was going to be really good but honestly it was super plain and nothing special. 3 pies for $42 is kind of crazy. Service was fast and the seating area is small. Would I come back? No. But if you're craving a pie then I guess you can stop and try it out! read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

Was craving pie during the holidays so we got a mix and match and a whole pumpkin. As a general tip we recommend buying a whole pie. We noticed the individual slices were more on the dry side whereas the full pie crusts were more flavorful (probably because they were fully intact for longer). Their Apple is such a solid choice but special shout out to the seasonal pumpkin. Will return whenever we are craving a pie but more importantly for the holiday seasonal choices! It's South Park so there is only street parking. It's never been an issue for us but please note finding one directly in front is not always the case. Service was fast and friendly. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

Pie Time! wow first visit love that they have savory and sweet to choose from and the crust I will say its amazing! Just go and experience these delicious pies! You may also purchase frozen pies to take and bake at home. read more

This place felt like a hidden gem. Shocked i am just now discovering it. I am not the pie type, but this place changed my viewpoint. I went in thinking it would be like KFC type of pies, and i was wrong in every way. Soon as i walked in, the vibe was coffee shop cafe mixed with a bakery feel to it. Now on to the food, each pie i tried was unique and delicious. Thankfully the staff was so kind and gave me recommendations. I may have over did it but it was worth it. Even washed everything down with an Ice Chai Latte lol. I am certainly coming back again! read more

See all

My wife is the realest she knows I can't stand for long periods of time and told me you sit this one out champ I'll handle this and handle this she did. I dropped her off and waited for her page to tell me she got the goods I really only wanted two pies from this year's pie day the dfc and the tinola pie but she grabbed the tribute one to round it all off she also got a key lime slice for all her hard work. The dfc was a banger it was cheesy and meaty and out of no where some good spice to kick it off right, but that tinola pie was a work of aft and the calamancy kicked to the next level it put me in a straight food coma and I needed it. When I woke up the next day we tried the tribute and no smut on the tribute pie but you had Mike Tyson and Mayweather vs Ryan Garcia good but those two pies just hit different I can't wait for next year's pie day. read more

See all

I'll start by saying this place is pretty decent flavorful pop pies . Small & quaint kitchen service is pretty ok also The only downside is my chicken pop pie was DRY full of chicken nonetheless But DRY. No rue or W.E they use to put a pie together VERY DISAPPOINTING. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Carry out bag. - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

Pot pies were yummy. They were out of dessert pies since it was Pi day but the ice cream and hand pies were good. It's counter service so not much to report there they took our order correctly and handed us our food so they were good. Mostly like a fast food place but pot pies and coffee. Pretty loud and casual but serves its purpose. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Lemon (D) Lemon Curd & Mixed Berry Hand Pie - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

After dinner, we headed to Stella Jean's for some ice cream. The place was packed, and we thought the line we were in was for ice cream, but it was for Pop Pie. We learned that the same owner owns both. We decided to split up and my wife bought some chicken pies to-go for us to try the next day. After a day, we put the pies in the oven at 350 °C for 20 minutes, and they tasted fresh and were abundant with chicken. The crusts were crispy and buttery. We will definitely come back to get some of their other flavors next time. read more

See all

The first Pop Pie Co. location I tried while in San Diego, located in the South Park neighborhood, and has a Stella Jean's at the same location! The service was fast and the ambiance wasn't bad either. The regular pies were a little disappointing, but the handheld pies were amazing! The guava and cream cheese was my absolute favorite, I wish I had some right now, haha. If you're getting both Stella Jean's and Pop Pie Co., I recommend getting the pies first and the ice cream after (they ice cream is a bit sweeter and the flavors are more bold as well). read more

See all

Such a cute little spot, and there's a Stelle Jeans ice cream inside too! I loved their mashed potatoes with rosemary gravy and thought it really came in clutch after I got my wisdom teeth removed. Their service is really friendly, and it's a cozy spot if you want to come out with a group, share a table, and split a tiny pie. read more

I like this place, the employees are friendly, and the vegan ice cream from Stella is fantastic! Truth be told, I have not tried their vegan lentil pie, but it's definitely on my list. I found that they have Key Lime Pie!!! My husband absolutely loves key lime pie, so I plan on taking him here. Dangerous information: this business is a quarter of a mile away from where I live. :D I absolutely love the location! Excellent customer service, it smells incredible in here, and they have the BEST vegan ice cream in the entire neighborhood. What more would you want? read more

I love their key lime pie! Pop Pie Co offers both dessert pies and savory pies, and everything always looks delicious. I came around 9pm on a Saturday and there was no line. Service was good, and there's both indoor and outdoor seating available. It's also conveniently connected to Stella Jean's Ice Cream, which makes it easy to grab a pie and ice cream in one stop. read more

See all

Been coming here for a few years. Their key lime pie is my favorite followed by the salted apple caramel pie. Some of the breakfast pies are pretty good. They're solid read more

Pop Pie Company of San Diego continues to expand. Now, in the neighborhood of South Part, they continue to offer their terrific savory and sweet pies, not to mention their tasty quiches and sausage rolls. I had the slice of mushroom & leek quiche, which comes with tender roasted oyster mushrooms, citrus leeks, sun-dried tomatoes, farm eggs, and crème fraiche in their signature buttery crust for $8.50. The quiche was well baked and had nice color. The egg mixture with the ingredients was fluffy and soft. They were tasty y but the mixture could of benefited from a little extra seasoning. The crust was good, with a light crisp exterior, but there was a noticeable thin line of rawness in the crust. Whether that was intentional, I am not sure. The crust tasted good. The service was very easy going and friendly. This location offers a very good amount of inside seating and some on the sidewalk. read more

See all

Pop Pie had its official grand opening in South Park/Golden Hill. The shop shares a space with Stella ice cream. Street parking is a challenge. For reference, Pop Pie is sandwiched between Bock and Kindred. Pop Pie Co shops are located at other locations throughout San Diego: University Heights/North Park, Point Loma, Pacific Beach and now here. Currently only indoor seating. The menu offers savory and sweet pies inspired from the country down under, Australia ...specially with the meat pies. I've tried the mushroom and leek quiche and the roasted vegetable curry pie, both delicious in their own way. I prefer less carbs and prefer the quiche. These pies are perfect anytime meal and are quite filling. The shop is new and as expected clean sun organized. You enter and immediately see the display of pies. You order and the pies are heated or not in case you want it togo and heat it yourself at home. Staff were helpful but could have been more cordial and friendly. The South Park area which seems to be developing and growing and Pop Pie Co. shop is a welcomed addition read more

See all

Had the sausage roll and an Arnold Palmer. The sausage roll had okay flavor, but a lot less of the puff pastry than you would expect given the size of the sausage. The Arnold Palmer was given in a 20oz cup filled to the brim with ice, resulting in me getting about 2 sips worth of drink. For $3.50 I expected to actually get a little beverage, so I asked for a refill to which she said "yea we do refills on those," and then rang me up for $1. Not sure what world she's from but I wasn't asking if I could BUY more beverage. I then asked if I could just have more based on how much ice was in it, to which she said they usually just serve 10oz (which this was not) of liquid.... Despite it being marketed on their menu as 20oz. I originally wanted the affogato but was informed they close their coffee machine at 8:30.... It was 8:35. How difficult is it to turn it back on? Wouldn't really recommend just based on the actual food quality and the interactions with staff. Stella Jean is great, just keep your wallet on the right side of the room. read more

OH Crap... where did you guys come from? So, I love food and I have traveled more than most being a 20 yr Navy guy & I've been every where from Australia to Africa. Comfort food is one of those things most people don't twist too much and everyone has their version of meatloaf or POT PIES, but these guys flipped it on their head. No only was the traditional Chicken pot pie worthy of 5 stars, but what in the world are you doing putting Butter Chicken in a pot pie? When people ask what is your favorite all time food you can get lobster, steak or Pizza & mine just happens to be Butter Chicken. And this was Phenominal butter chicken in a flaky crust and makes me want to come back today for another one!!! I was so curious I also bought a Ground beef pie and it is really good, but I need some mashed to go with it. They have mashed and next time i'll certainly try that. I do have 2 minor critical comments. 1. add a little variety (not sure messing with perfection is a good idea, but they have a vege curry pie & if you could ADD Chicken to it I would be all in because 2nd all time favorite food is yellow coconut curry with chicken. or removing peppers from braised pork is a minor suggestion 2. a tick more gravy was my wifes response she loved it, but said she wished it kind of poured out as you cut into it. It wouldve made a tiny bit better. BUT 101% Phenomenal Pies you've got to try them. read more

I am not sure why I did not find out about the South Park location sooner-it's so much easier to find parking! This location is definitely super clean, organized and cute! Service was quick and they're super helpful in talking you through the different pie types that are available. I find that one small pot pie is a sufficient for the savory feeling that you need when you're not feeling so good or just want something warm and cozy. These things are also easy to heat up and the crust is super flaky. Obviously, chicken pot pie is a classic, but surprisingly the curry which is vegetarian is good as well with some sweet potatoes in there. Don't forget the sweet pastries and the sweet pies as well! I always order the apple one for the holiday parties! Can't go wrong with any of the sweet pies here if you're looking to host any events or parties-indulge a little! read more

Come here for key lime pie It's the BEST Everyone super nice take order quickly. Cute little corner ib north park only thing parking can be bit hard If live in area walk over read more

Came here during the holiday week around mid day. I ordered the steak and ale pot pie and wasn't that impressed with it. I can only assume my timing was off and that the pies are fresher in the morning. However, the pie needed more gravy inside. It was too dry and the steak wasn't tender. This was my first time having their pies so I'm not sure if this is standard for them. What I loved about the place is that they have an espresso bar and tea. I ordered an earl grey with milk and it was wonderful. Service was wonderful but as far as the food goes I'm not sure I'll be back. read more

Really good spot in the middle of South Park for a great dish. Had the salted caramel apple crumble and it was delish!!!! Also had the guava cheese hand pie and am looking forward to having both again. Friendly workers and a really nice atmosphere within the restaurant. Definitely a go to spot! read more

Natalie took great care of me this morning! Exceptional service and pleasant ambiance! Highly recommend a visit to Pop Pie Co. when you are in the area! read more

See all

Had their ice cream 1 yr prior while on vacation and loved it!It was so good that we made it a point to come back the next year! We also tried the chicken pot pie and cream corn this time and both were amazing! read more

Got the food delivered while I was visiting SD. I like the packaging the pies came. The pot pie was amazing we both got chicken the dough on the pie was flaky & tasty. The pies were just the right amount of filling. We also got cookies they were just the right amount of sweetness not so overly sweet. read more

As a southern girl, I was SHOCKED by how good these pot pies are. The crust is perfect, they're full of flavor and I have ZERO complaints. The mashed potatoes are great and I love the guava hand pie. read more

A must when in San Diego! Everything here was just superb/chef's kiss! Their chicken pot pie and turkey pop pies are a 10/10. Their key lime pie and pumpkin pie - AMAZING! Tastes fresh! The guava pastry is a must! So good we went back 3 days in a row. read more

The pie is really good and the portions are large. Really, the Big Boss Breakfast Pie is huge. Two eggs, bacon, potatoes, chives, cheddar, and jack plus a side of maple syrup (I used the packets of Tapatio they had instead)! I also recommend the Lemon Curd Mixed Berry Pie. The person that helped me was very kind and turned on Noname. Great vibes. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Big Boss Breakfast Pie, cold brew, lemon curd mixed berry handpie - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California

See all

From the sign outside to the sights and smells upon entering, this is an outstanding place for a sweet treat(s). This is the second time visiting in less than three days....!We came back for a slice of out of this world, strawberry rhubarb crumble pie. Sitting outside and enjoying the afternoon sun was an amazing way to spend our last afternoon in San Diego. read more

Pop Pie Co. - Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble (V) - Slice - Desserts Near Me - San Diego, California