Cancel

Open app

Search

Pop-A-Top Tavern Restaurant

4.0 (1 review)

Pop-A-Top Tavern Restaurant Photos

You might also consider

More like Pop-A-Top Tavern Restaurant

Recommended Reviews - Pop-A-Top Tavern Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 372 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Schwartz Family Restaurant

Schwartz Family Restaurant

4.1(95 reviews)
34.6 mi
•$

This is the more authentic Amish restaurant of the two in the area (Stoll's in Loogootee is the…read moreother one). That gives you a very obvious option if you want Amish style food. While this one does offer a buffet option, they don't have enough options to really make that worthwhile. The other place is the buffet place. This is the cafeteria place, but it's not as expensive, and the food is just as good. And you get plenty of it in the meal. I'm a big eater, and I'm always satisfied by the plate lunch. Outside of the building, you can see the farm where a lot of their food is grown. I've been here probably a dozen times, and each time was a treat, with fresh food from their local gardens and farms. Unlike Stoll's, they grow their own foods. Like I said, it's authentic Amish. The cafeteria style tables make for a more pleasant and comfortable atmosphere than Stoll's. Surprisingly, the restrooms here are cleaner than Stoll's, where the restrooms are often out of order. This is a much more pleasant experience at Schwartz's. The servers are very nice and helpful. There is a small area for their Amish store of honey, fresh vegetables, and other delights. Where they excel is their pies. While their competitor uses cheap packet pies, Schwartz's has homemade pies, all fresh. I highly recommend the blueberry cream pie and the peach pie. A nice view of the rural surroundings, even if it is on the highway, but so is the other Amish place. The atmosphere is very nice. There is a lot of good feeling in the air. Sometimes, there are folk style musicians in the adjoining room, if you go for that. This is a customer friendly place, and they care about what they do and about the people they serve.

The food was great. The Help was nice. The place was clean. Bathroom was clean . I paid for the…read morebuffet and one trip was all I could hold. I drove there just to check it out . But too far away to eat there often. I recommend this place.

Photos
Schwartz Family Restaurant - The steam line

The steam line

Schwartz Family Restaurant - Home style buffet. Corn, baked chicken, bbq chicken, chicken quiche, broccoli and cauliflower in cheese sauce and coconut cream pie

Home style buffet. Corn, baked chicken, bbq chicken, chicken quiche, broccoli and cauliflower in cheese sauce and coconut cream pie

Schwartz Family Restaurant - Front entrance

See all

Front entrance

Burton's Farmhouse - Kids waffle

Burton's Farmhouse

4.5(55 reviews)
24.7 mi

Stopped here on a drive to French Lick for the holiday weekend. First visit. This place has some…read moreamazing food! We were seated promptly - it's a large space, would make you think about a barndominium. Staff was friendly, and attentive. Always a plus. I ordered their bone-in pork chops in a brown sugar marinade, with a loaded bake potato, and my wife had their all day breakfast (2 eggs, bacon, toast, hash brown casserole, and a waffle on the side). The pork chops were grilled to perfection and delicious! The baked potato was very good and very large. The star of the whole meal was their hash brown casserole! Do not sleep on this! It's made with (I think) pepper Jack cheese, and it was amazing! If you are in the area, well worth stopping in to check out. Looks like they have a nice outdoor patio, so I'm sure it would be even better in the summer.

We went to Burton's for the first time for my family reunion dinner. We had about 50 people and it…read morewas one of very few places in the area to be able to accommodate all of us. The place is very cute, simple, and kind of out on its own which is nice. Parking is plenty. I booked the place so I went before the time I said we'd be there to make sure everything was in order. When I walked in, everything was set up nicely with menus and ice water. There was plenty of space for everyone to socialize. The staff was patient with everyone getting settled and ordering. They also made sure to put everyone's order in at once so it didn't come out of the kitchen sporadically. Food had mixed reviews from our crew. Those who got the salmon, pork chops, steak, and fish seemed to enjoy their food--especially the salmon. Those who got quesadillas, burgers, sandwiches were less than impressed. My quesadilla has a bag clip fall out of it and the pineapple "salsa" was just pineapple and bell peppers so I was disappointed there. People said the burgers tasted like meat on a bun--no seasoning. Those who got soft drinks didn't get refills and we were disappointed to learn that the bar had closed as it was one of the reasons we chose here. The staff did fairly well for the amount of people we had plus the rest of the restaurant. We managed to get in and out in about 2 hours. I am so-so on choosing to eat here again since some loved it and others were not impressed. For the area, it was pretty good. Definitely had its pros and cons.

Photos
Burton's Farmhouse - We had the whole center area here.

We had the whole center area here.

Burton's Farmhouse - Omelette meal

Omelette meal

Burton's Farmhouse - Pancakes

See all

Pancakes

Pop-A-Top Tavern Restaurant - newamerican - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...